Are relics Biblical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well lets look at this a bit.
The Moabite was brought back to life. It was not a matter of his faith but a witness of the power of God. Nor is the passage something to be replicated. A man falling into a grave is a lot different than purposeful grave defilement.
Yes God can perform miracles. I would say the question is whether or not one violates common human decency in purposefully defiling a body to attempt to have God perform a miracle. For that behavior, there is not a biblical precedent.

Once again, I see no problem with the NT passages you mention. I do not believe that is the kind of behavior Catholics have historically attempted to emulate.
As far as the fraud charge, I believe the biblical accounts and yes I do not believe the Catholic Church can prove the bones they use are the actual bones. The real question is what would have possessed the first person to dig Peter or someone up, or to disturb their resting place to take parts of their body off of them. It is very disturbing behavior.
Now look how they treated the bones of Polycarp, it was respectul and there is nothing to indicate that the bones were not put in something that is similiar to a grave and left undisturbed.
Look at this example, because it defends my perspecitve. These early Christians did not devy up his bones. They took them and put them somewhere…a jar…in the ground…we do not know but there is nothing to indicate they would have supported or condoned grave desecration.
As far as your opinion about the canon, that is not what the text says. Scripture is scripture because God makes it so. That it may have taken people longer to recognize it in a few cases of a few books does not mean they created a canon. They recognized what God did…not the other way around.
 
Well lets look at this a bit.
The Moabite was brought back to life. It was not a matter of his faith but a witness of the power of God. Nor is the passage something to be replicated. A man falling into a grave is a lot different than purposeful grave defilement.
Yes God can perform miracles. I would say the question is whether or not one violates common human decency in purposefully defiling a body to attempt to have God perform a miracle. For that behavior, there is not a biblical precedent.

Once again, I see no problem with the NT passages you mention. I do not believe that is the kind of behavior Catholics have historically attempted to emulate.
As far as the fraud charge, I believe the biblical accounts and yes I do not believe the Catholic Church can prove the bones they use are the actual bones. The real question is what would have possessed the first person to dig Peter or someone up, or to disturb their resting place to take parts of their body off of them. It is very disturbing behavior.
Um…is there any example in the OT of the Jews digging up bones and taking them with them when they moved from one place to another?

:yup:
Now look how they treated the bones of Polycarp, it was respectul and there is nothing to indicate that the bones were not put in something that is similiar to a grave and left undisturbed.
Look at this example, because it defends my perspecitve. These early Christians did not devy up his bones. They took them and put them somewhere…a jar…in the ground…we do not know but there is nothing to indicate they would have supported or condoned grave desecration.
Perhaps relics are not to your particular taste, but you cannot actually prove that housing the bones of saints in reliquaries where they are honored is desecration. That is simply a cultural view.
As far as your opinion about the canon, that is not what the text says. Scripture is scripture because God makes it so. That it may have taken people longer to recognize it in a few cases of a few books does not mean they created a canon. They recognized what God did…not the other way around.
No question. Catholics do not believe that it was the canonization itself that made an otherwise unremarkable text suddenly become the inspired word of God. But yes, the Church did create the canon when it collected the inspired books into a single collection. The inspired books existed prior to this, but the Bible as a collection did not.

You have your (slightly truncated) Bible today because the Catholic Church did the heavy lifting long ago. Luther will have to answer for why he subtracted from the Word of God.

Hope this helps. :tiphat:
 
Acknowledging or respecting relics is an holy act that we acknowledge God’s sanctity in them. We believe that matter, when its essence has been co-worked or had done relations in everything that is holy, becomes holy itself. Yes, relics are not the focus of Christian life, for the relics themselves don’t emit their own holiness, but the fact that holiness once touched them, these things we cannot reject in any way.

You, my Protestants brothers, often quote the second letter of Peter, eh? You forget that the same letter gives importance to things or places that were once related to the Holy One, which is Christ himself. Look:

"For we did not follow cleverly devised tales when we made
known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ,
but we were eyewitnesses of His majesty.

For when He received honor and glory from God the Father,
such an utterance as this was made to Him by the
Majestic Glory, “This is My beloved Son with whom I am well-pleased”–

and we ourselves heard this utterance made from heaven
when we were with Him on the holy mountain."
(2 Peter 1:16-18, emphasis mine)

Look on the words “holy mountain” above. We know what Peter is talking about. He’s talking about his one-of-a-kind experience of witnessing Jesus’ transfiguration together with James and John. The question is, why on earth would Peter call Mt. Tabor, “holy”? Mt. Tabor isn’t mentioned nor deemed in the Old Covenant as a holy place

If Peter had no intention to give acknowledgment to the reputation of the mountain, he wouldn’t have call it “holy”. That is blasphemous enough to universal Christians he is writing unto if the mentality of the early Christians is the same with the modern fundamentalists: *Christ alone, you alone are holy, no other holy not even things get holy. *

Just as St. Peter gave significance to that thing (mountain) because it has once been attached to grace, or had its essence touched by holiness, so are we, we deem these things (relics) as holy for they had been once touched by holiness through the saints by the one holy God.


http://i442.photobucket.com/albums/qq143/katolikongtunay/visit.gif
Salamat sa malinaw mong pagpapaliwanag, nawa’y mas marami pa ang makaunawa dahil sa mga paliwanag mong ayon sa Salita ng Panginoon.

For God be the honor and glory in Jesus mighty name!👍
 
What Bible verse tells us to use relics. In fact the Bible speaks against their use. Ex 20:4-6
4 " You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. 5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me, 6 but showing lovingkindness to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
NASU

These verses from the10 Commanments tells us not to make cetain things which relics fall into those that we are not to make. The the next portion tells us not worship them. I am wondering if the Catholic church is guilty of both sins? 😦
Surely you jest?

For one thing relics are not idols and they are not worshiped, I really do not see how you manage to conflate the two.

Apparently you don’t even seem to know what a relic is, did you know that in many cases it is God who is actually the relic maker and not we humans?

In many cases relics are the uncorrupted bodies of Saints, people whose bodies continue to exist without decay for centuries. These Saints were not preserved by human effort, or embalming, they were preserved by God himself in defiance of all the laws of nature.

The tilma that belonged to Jaun Diego is another relic created by God, and not by humanity. That tilma was just a simple peasant’s cloak nothing special until Juan Diego was told to gather roses in January, long past the time for roses to bloom, but God provided the roses which JD gathered in his cloak. When JD opened his cloak to reveal the roses in it. Their suddenly appeared the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe, instantly.
that tilma had been examined by scientist throughout the centuries and cannot be explained scientifically. According to nature that tilma would have rotted away a long time ago, but it is seen by millions each year it a church in Mexic City.

I really can not think of a single relic anywhere that humans have created, not one.
 
"As they were burying a man, behold, they saw a
marauding band; and they cast the man into the
grave of Elisha. And when the man touched the
bones of Elisha he revived and stood up on his feet.

(2 Kings 13:21, emphasis mine)
DLClark, just like the above poster showed, through the bones of a holy person someone was brought back to life.

I do not think it is important to look for a specific verses that tells us to continue to use relics. Rather what is truly important is showing that relic EXISTED. By showing that relics existed it indicates that God does in fact use materials to heal people. By continually asking for a verse that says specifically “use relics” you are creating a circular argument. Obviously as you and everyone else clearly sees, relics existed in the old and new testament. So since you cannot argue against your existence you argue against their continued use. But if you want to nit pick at verses, then I could easily say to you “where in the bible is the word trinity ever used?” in this case i know there is sufficient evidence to prove that Jesus is God, but now i create a circular argument by asking for a specific word that may or may not have been used during the time of Christ. If you find the word “trinity” I would then ask you what the word in the original Greek was. I start to focus more on words then on context, until finally the verse will mean what I want it to mean.

Be careful you do not follow down this path, don’t back yourself into a corner where you can shield yourself with stubbornness.

What do we know from here? We know and can both agree that relics existed in the past. We know that there were both present in the old and new testament. So, if God used relics then, why would he not use them today? If God healed people in the past, why would he not do it again? If God cast out demons then, why would he not continue to do so today? Relics existed, and therefore COULD exist today. You may not agree, but it is a possibility. There is no need to find a verse where God says he will use relics or we should, as God never told the Israelites to use relics but to their suprise the bones of a prophet brought someone back from the dead. God needs not tell us his plan.
 
Re: Polycarp’s bones

Actually, there’s everything to tell us that the early Christians took his bones to “where it was suitable” (not wanting to disclose the location of this tomb in a public letter) and immediately started saying Mass on top of his bones, at least on the anniversary of his martyrdom. “Thus we, having afterwards taken up his bones, more valuable than precious stones, laid them where it was suitable. There, so far as is allowed us, when we are gathered together in exultation and joy, the Lord will enable us to celebrate the birthday of the martyrs, both for the memory of those who have contended, and for the exercise and preparation of those to come.” (Hoole’s translation)

This custom of using martyrs’ tombs as altars for Mass also shows up in the Book of Revelation, where the martyrs are underneath the altar of God Himself.
 
Yes, exactly. God’s power can really work through matter. He even raised a dead man to life through the bones of prophet Elisha:

"As they were burying a man, behold, they saw a
marauding band; and they cast the man into the
grave of Elisha. And when the man touched the
bones of Elisha he revived and stood up on his feet.

(2 Kings 13:21, emphasis mine)
i know this is a little off topic but whats the story about elisha?
 
Jesus was not addressing the desciple but the people in general. Read the verses I sent showing the context in which the statement was given.
61 Many therefore of his disciples, hearing it, said: This saying is hard, and who can hear it? 62 But Jesus, knowing in himself, that his disciples murmured at this, said to them: Doth this scandalize you?
You are claiming that Jesus asked His disciples simply to believe in Him, but His disciples said ‘This saying is too hard’

67 After this many of his disciples went back; and walked no more with him. Jesus’ disciples already believed in Him, thats why they were disciples. Jesus challenged them to eat His flesh, if they wanted Life, and it was that which was too hard for His disciples, it scandalized them.

Believing in Jesus, as they did, did not scandalize them.
 
i know this is a little off topic but whats the story about elisha?
Elisha was the apprentice of Elijah. He took over as a great prophet after Elijah was taken into heaven. Elisha performed a number of miracles, like raising people from the dead. Elisha was picked by God to take Elijah’s place.
 
Elisha was the apprentice of Elijah. He took over as a great prophet after Elijah was taken into heaven. Elisha performed a number of miracles, like raising people from the dead. Elisha was picked by God to take Elijah’s place.
ok that makes sense that elisha’s bone would bring people to life. thanks for the info!
 
Relics are a form of idol worship which the Bible condems, Ex. 20.
No one worships relics.

Please do not resort to blanket statements and taking verses out of context. To say Relics are a form of idol worship is an insult to God, who worked through the bones of Elisha and all other Relics, including the bronze serpent of Moses.
 
Surely you jest?

For one thing relics are not idols and they are not worshiped, I really do not see how you manage to conflate the two.

Apparently you don’t even seem to know what a relic is, did you know that in many cases it is God who is actually the relic maker and not we humans?

In many cases relics are the uncorrupted bodies of Saints, people whose bodies continue to exist without decay for centuries. These Saints were not preserved by human effort, or embalming, they were preserved by God himself in defiance of all the laws of nature.

The tilma that belonged to Jaun Diego is another relic created by God, and not by humanity. That tilma was just a simple peasant’s cloak nothing special until Juan Diego was told to gather roses in January, long past the time for roses to bloom, but God provided the roses which JD gathered in his cloak. When JD opened his cloak to reveal the roses in it. Their suddenly appeared the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe, instantly.
that tilma had been examined by scientist throughout the centuries and cannot be explained scientifically. According to nature that tilma would have rotted away a long time ago, but it is seen by millions each year it a church in Mexic City.

I really can not think of a single relic anywhere that humans have created, not one.
Where does the Bible say to use relics? I know the Bible and do not know of one verse telling us that it is ok to use a relic. Relics are a form of idolatry.
 
Where does the Bible say to use relics? I know the Bible and do not know of one verse telling us that it is ok to use a relic. Relics are a form of idolatry.
Please tell me just how a relic can possibly be an “idol”? We have already reasured you repeatedly, over and over that we do not worship them. An idol is defined as an object or idea that is worshiped in the place of God. In exactly the same way that a lot of Protestants worship the Bible instead of God. And a lot of Americans worship football and idolise the players.

No the bible does not specifficaly state that me must use relics, but it does not forbid their use either. Their are scripture verses that describe relics and their use as far back as the Old Testament. I will not identify them for you since they also have been related, over and over in this same thread. Reread them for yourself.

BTW before I became Catholic, I too belonged to a Protestant church that had to get permission from the Bible to do anything, or to use your words 'I DO not know of one verse telling us it is ok to use a relic". My response to that is Big Deal, I, We, do not believe it is needed to get an “OK” from the bible for everything we do.
 
I’m gonna take pipper’s example too. DLClark is clearly trying to create a cyclical argument. As we have shown that relics and their use is not only Church tradition (apealling to a Catholic stance), but ALSO scriptural (thus as a protestant he was beaten) he now asks for us to show him that scripture asks for the continued use of relics, thus setting the bar higher. Even if scripture said this he would continue to do this until he could find some way to make them sound unscriptural, even though we had initially proven to them that they are.

Right now, since we have shown him that relics are scriptural, he is beaten, but still continues to argue out of pride. If we continue to prove him wrong he will set his requirements for “proof” higher and higher until, like the “proof” he asks for now, they are set at unrealistic heights.
 
Threads like these are one of the reasons I haven’t been on the forum for a while.You have folks like DLC (who apparently are here only here to show us poor benighted Catholics “Bible truth”) who come and attack Catholic beliefs. Catholics use Scripture to point out the validity of our beliefs, but the “Bible Christians” will harp on one or two verses that “prove” their point. Round and round it goes- it can get very aggravating.
BTW, in addition to the bronze serpent in showing that God can and does allow the use of images in worship, don’t forget the cherubim on the ark of the covenant (Exodus 18:20), the cherubim in the Holy of Holies of the temple as well as carved on the temple walls and doors (1 Kings 6:23-35), the twelve oxen holding the tank of water for purification 1 Kings 7:24).
 
Where does the Bible say to use relics? I know the Bible and do not know of one verse telling us that it is ok to use a relic.
I already provided a biblical basis for this in post #119. You either missed or ignored that.
Relics are a form of idolatry.
Since you have already been told repeatedly that Catholics do not worship relics thereby committing the sin of idolatry, your repeated assertions to the contrary are themselves sinful - a violation of the commandent not to bear false witness against your Catholic brothers and sisters in Christ.

Confession and repentence are in order, and we await your apology.
 
Since you have already been told repeatedly that Catholics do not worship relics thereby committing the sin of idolatry, your repeated assertions to the contrary are themselves sinful - a violation of the commandent not to bear false witness against your Catholic brothers and sisters in Christ.

Confession and repentence are in order, and we await your apology.
I wouldn’t hold your breath… :whistle:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top