R
Rightlydivide
Guest
Well lets look at this a bit.
The Moabite was brought back to life. It was not a matter of his faith but a witness of the power of God. Nor is the passage something to be replicated. A man falling into a grave is a lot different than purposeful grave defilement.
Yes God can perform miracles. I would say the question is whether or not one violates common human decency in purposefully defiling a body to attempt to have God perform a miracle. For that behavior, there is not a biblical precedent.
Once again, I see no problem with the NT passages you mention. I do not believe that is the kind of behavior Catholics have historically attempted to emulate.
As far as the fraud charge, I believe the biblical accounts and yes I do not believe the Catholic Church can prove the bones they use are the actual bones. The real question is what would have possessed the first person to dig Peter or someone up, or to disturb their resting place to take parts of their body off of them. It is very disturbing behavior.
Now look how they treated the bones of Polycarp, it was respectul and there is nothing to indicate that the bones were not put in something that is similiar to a grave and left undisturbed.
Look at this example, because it defends my perspecitve. These early Christians did not devy up his bones. They took them and put them somewhere…a jar…in the ground…we do not know but there is nothing to indicate they would have supported or condoned grave desecration.
As far as your opinion about the canon, that is not what the text says. Scripture is scripture because God makes it so. That it may have taken people longer to recognize it in a few cases of a few books does not mean they created a canon. They recognized what God did…not the other way around.
The Moabite was brought back to life. It was not a matter of his faith but a witness of the power of God. Nor is the passage something to be replicated. A man falling into a grave is a lot different than purposeful grave defilement.
Yes God can perform miracles. I would say the question is whether or not one violates common human decency in purposefully defiling a body to attempt to have God perform a miracle. For that behavior, there is not a biblical precedent.
Once again, I see no problem with the NT passages you mention. I do not believe that is the kind of behavior Catholics have historically attempted to emulate.
As far as the fraud charge, I believe the biblical accounts and yes I do not believe the Catholic Church can prove the bones they use are the actual bones. The real question is what would have possessed the first person to dig Peter or someone up, or to disturb their resting place to take parts of their body off of them. It is very disturbing behavior.
Now look how they treated the bones of Polycarp, it was respectul and there is nothing to indicate that the bones were not put in something that is similiar to a grave and left undisturbed.
Look at this example, because it defends my perspecitve. These early Christians did not devy up his bones. They took them and put them somewhere…a jar…in the ground…we do not know but there is nothing to indicate they would have supported or condoned grave desecration.
As far as your opinion about the canon, that is not what the text says. Scripture is scripture because God makes it so. That it may have taken people longer to recognize it in a few cases of a few books does not mean they created a canon. They recognized what God did…not the other way around.