There were many manuscripts floating around in the 4th century, claiming to be gospels, which did not make it into the Canon. The “Gospel of Thomas” and the “Gospel of Judas,” for example. Why were these not included? Because Catholic* councils found them unBiblical. There is no proof that any of the NT was authorized, at the time of writing, by an Apostle or one of his disciples. Thee was only word of mouth passed down to the members of these councils.
*The Church was first called Catholic sometime before AD 117, by St. Ignatius of Antioch, in his Letter to the Smyrneans (Ch 8), which he wrote on the way to his martyrdom in Rome. He was “very probably” a disciple of John. Sources:
newadvent.org/fathers/0109.htm
newadvent.org/cathen/07644a.htm
Perhaps these following thoughts have already been spoken. If so, I’m sorry.
I don’t understand your interpretation of 2 Peter 1:20. “Private interpretation” means to me that I get to read the Bible and interpret it for myself. Isn’t that what you advocate? Isn’t that why there are so many sects of non-Catholic Christians?
One of the things that drove me into the Catholic church was participating in a private Bible study forum with non-Catholic Christians of many stripes. After two years, I realized that each of these groups based their beliefs on certain verses, and ignored any verses to the contrary. It seemed to me that they chopped the Bible up into bits, and kept their favorite bits, and swept the rest away.
That sure sounds like “private interpretation” to me.
I believe the Bible, as the word of God, cannot contradict itself, and that therefore, we must read the whole thing before we decide what the writers meant to tell us. So I did this, looking for meanings that brought “contradictory” verses together. I formed beliefs based on this - and found them codified in the Catholic church.
It has seemed to me for a while now that those who say “The Bible alone” are actually treating the Bible as an idol. It does not contain all that Jesus did and taught (see the last verse of John’s Gospel), or all that His Apostles taught. To find out what the first Christians did and believed, we have to read what they wrote and passed on to their disciples. Again, we have to read all of it, not “cherry-pick” the words that we agree with.
We should also know something about the teaching methods used back then, and Greek idioms, and, and, and…
Your sister in Christ,
Ruthie