Are relics Biblical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There were many manuscripts floating around in the 4th century, claiming to be gospels, which did not make it into the Canon. The “Gospel of Thomas” and the “Gospel of Judas,” for example. Why were these not included? Because Catholic* councils found them unBiblical. There is no proof that any of the NT was authorized, at the time of writing, by an Apostle or one of his disciples. Thee was only word of mouth passed down to the members of these councils.

*The Church was first called Catholic sometime before AD 117, by St. Ignatius of Antioch, in his Letter to the Smyrneans (Ch 8), which he wrote on the way to his martyrdom in Rome. He was “very probably” a disciple of John. Sources: newadvent.org/fathers/0109.htm
newadvent.org/cathen/07644a.htm

Perhaps these following thoughts have already been spoken. If so, I’m sorry.

I don’t understand your interpretation of 2 Peter 1:20. “Private interpretation” means to me that I get to read the Bible and interpret it for myself. Isn’t that what you advocate? Isn’t that why there are so many sects of non-Catholic Christians?

One of the things that drove me into the Catholic church was participating in a private Bible study forum with non-Catholic Christians of many stripes. After two years, I realized that each of these groups based their beliefs on certain verses, and ignored any verses to the contrary. It seemed to me that they chopped the Bible up into bits, and kept their favorite bits, and swept the rest away.

That sure sounds like “private interpretation” to me.

I believe the Bible, as the word of God, cannot contradict itself, and that therefore, we must read the whole thing before we decide what the writers meant to tell us. So I did this, looking for meanings that brought “contradictory” verses together. I formed beliefs based on this - and found them codified in the Catholic church.

It has seemed to me for a while now that those who say “The Bible alone” are actually treating the Bible as an idol. It does not contain all that Jesus did and taught (see the last verse of John’s Gospel), or all that His Apostles taught. To find out what the first Christians did and believed, we have to read what they wrote and passed on to their disciples. Again, we have to read all of it, not “cherry-pick” the words that we agree with.

We should also know something about the teaching methods used back then, and Greek idioms, and, and, and…

Your sister in Christ,

Ruthie
If only Mr. Clark would look into history instead of into the “Inspired Table of Contents” that apparently fell from heaven…
 
This is why Protestants unknowingly accept the authority of the Catholic Church for their New Testaments.

Now…back to relics…
This could never be more wrong. We do accept the authority of any church unless that church is biblical. Why? Because the Bible gave birth to the church. 👍
 
This could never be more wrong. We do accept the authority of any church unless that church is biblical. Why? Because the Bible gave birth to the church. 👍
So… was there a Church in 33AD… 34AD …35AD? 👍
 
If something is anointed of God, it doesn’t have an expiration date.

God doesn’t decay. His glory doesn’t decay. and his directives and what they imply
don’t decay.

If His power is at work, why do you question it in such agony over and over?

Is a song only meant to be sung once?
 
This could never be more wrong. We do accept the authority of any church unless that church is biblical. Why? Because the Bible gave birth to the church. 👍
OK, let’s make it REAL simple: How about the Apostles, who had zero NT scripture, but went forward and taught anyway? Were they Church, or were they all condemned because they didn’t have a bible?

Praying for you brother. You have been grossly mislead.
 
I would call it less of an argument than defense of the faith. For if one rejects relics, he will reject the Catholic Church because the Catholic Church recognizes veneration of relics. So as long as one defends charitably, there is nothing wrong with defending the nature of relics and their Scriptural roots.
What Bible verse tells us to use relics. In fact the Bible speaks against their use. Ex 20:4-6
4 " You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. 5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me, 6 but showing lovingkindness to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
NASU

These verses from the10 Commanments tells us not to make cetain things which relics fall into those that we are not to make. The the next portion tells us not worship them. I am wondering if the Catholic church is guilty of both sins? 😦
 
What Bible verse tells us to use relics. In fact the Bible speaks against their use. Ex 20:4-6
4 " You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. 5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me, 6 but showing lovingkindness to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
NASU

These verses from the10 Commanments tells us not to make cetain things which relics fall into those that we are not to make. The the next portion tells us not worship them. I am wondering if the Catholic church is guilty of both sins? 😦
What are we then to make of Numbers 21:8,9 where it says:
8 The LORD said to Moses, “Make a snake and put it up on a pole; anyone who is bitten can look at it and live.” 9 So Moses made a bronze snake and put it up on a pole. Then when anyone was bitten by a snake and looked at the bronze snake, he lived.
The Israelites realized they had sinned against the Lord, they asked Moses to pray to God for forgiveness and ask God to take the snakes from them. God knew all this yet he still instructed Moses to make the snake and have the Israelites gaze upon it. Why did God do this? Was God violating one of his own commandments? Were the Israelites worshipping this snake?

Catholics would see this bronze snake as a type of relic. The relic has absolutely no power to save or heal apart from the grace that God provides. That’s where many Protestants come off the rails when they criticize Catholics. For veneration of relics to be sinful and for what we do to become idolatry Catholics would have to believe these relics have a power of their own that originates from itself. That is not the case in one bit. You will never find the Church teach anything other than the fact that whatever graces a person gets from venerating a relic only come from God and nowhere else.

All the criticisms of our separated brethern fall flat on their face as they should from the sheer weight of their misunderstandings.

ChadS
 
What Bible verse tells us to use relics. In fact the Bible speaks against their use. Ex 20:4-6
4 " You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. 5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me, 6 but showing lovingkindness to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
NASU

These verses from the10 Commanments tells us not to make cetain things which relics fall into those that we are not to make. The the next portion tells us not worship them. I am wondering if the Catholic church is guilty of both sins? 😦
It is possible to make the bible an idol. In so doing, pitting the bible against the use of
a relic has no relevance. Like looking for a tongue to lick itself.
 
relics matter not. they are absolutely pointless aside from them that can find a temporary use. Just like the executional cross found in so many churches today. if the cross be there or not is of no use. Some people find the image of Christ’s electric chair helps them recal Christs sacrifice; and this is SO important.

For me personally I find these things to be revolting. I hate statues, relics, images of any kind especially the statues of mom.

To each there own. And as long as communion is the real body and real blood of Christ it doesn’t matter. But when the communion becomes symbolic as prophesied then we have something to be concerned about.
 
What Bible verse tells us to use relics. In fact the Bible speaks against their use. Ex 20:4-6
4 " You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. 5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me, 6 but showing lovingkindness to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
NASU

These verses from the10 Commanments tells us not to make cetain things which relics fall into those that we are not to make. The the next portion tells us not worship them. I am wondering if the Catholic church is guilty of both sins? 😦
Relics, as in the remains of Saints bodies, are not graven images made by man. They are ‘graven images made by God’, God takes a person, makes them His, their body is the temple of the Holy Spirit, this is Gods handywork. People do, and always have, from the beginning honoured the relics of the Saints because of what God did for them, their bodies were temples of the Holy Spirit and often they died as martyrs for Christ, with the promise from christ in ther hearts, For whosoever will save his life, shall lose it; for he that shall lose his life for my sake, shall save it. So that we are sure that these martyrs are in heaven and deserve honour.
What is difficult to understand is the mean-spiritedness of this attitude which takes no joy in seeing others succeed and grudges a martyr even a simple show of respect and honour.
 
Dear DL,

It would seem to me that the purpose of your entering into Catholic teachings and practices is to save those in error. It’s either that or you are a masochist.

As one of those who continue to protest against the authority of Christ’s Church, it’s authoritative teachings and it’s Vicar, you must argue from those talking points taught you directly or learned from those in agreement with your positions, whom you have read or listened to by some medium.

What I am about to say is not flattering but I think it can be proven.

Most converts to Protestantism do so because they enjoy a better or greater degree of fellowship. It is more of a " feeling " than an exhaustive thought process. Conversely, most converts from Protestantism to Catholicism do so because it becomes the logical conclusion of a lifetime of attempting to reconcile the passages in the Bible that are in accord with Catholic teaching and opposed to Protestant interpretation.

Watch EWTN, The Journey Home program and witness some of the greatest contemporary lay Biblical minds, converts, who have come to the conclusion, after many years of hard work and prayer, that the greatest amount of Truth is contained within the deposit of faith, possessed and protected by the Church founded by our Lord at the Last Supper. The Apostolic Church that went forth filled with the Holy Spirit, from Pentecost.

If you haven’t already done so, observe the celebration of the Mass, ideally more than once, and listen intently to the prayers and consider just how biblical this form of worship is. Then consider the ramifications of what it might mean if God actually participates in this worship of Him and makes it possible to fulfill Christ’s admonitions in John ch 6 as regards the eating of His Flesh.

Rather than trying to reject Catholicism based on a perceived error of a practice barely used by modern Catholics, look into the lifeblood of the Church, the worship of God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit in the sacrifice of the Mass. If you can reject this worship after praying to the Holy Spirit for guidance and our Lord Jesus for His Presence, then you can reject the Catholic Church because your faith doesn’t permit you to believe.
In that case, I would trust that you are where you are meant to be. This cannot be a cursory effort but must involve hard work and perseverance. I would suggest starting from the position of believing that God participates in and adores this worship above all others and then find concrete proof to the contrary.

If you find that the Church is right about this, then you will need to disprove other teachings, one at a time.

Eventually, you might come to the conclusion that relics are but one of the many perks our Lord has given His Church for the great benefit of His Church militant. I’m a fond proponent of the thinking that I’ll take all the help I can get.

If you haven’t already come to the realization that you are dealing with people armed with ample knowledge and Truth, you should know that the likelihood of your being converted into the Catholic Church is far more likely than converting a knowledgeable and practicing Catholic.

May the Peace of Christ be with you always,

JT
 
To JT,

This is a fine post indeed. Thinking right outside the box. Original, original, original.
And rather friendly.

The church is alive.
 
Sauce,

Thanks,

And to think that those ideas sprang forth from the mind of a former prolific sinner in the mold of the pre conversion St. Augustine and a right wing, conservative nut.

The church is alive and well and fighting the good fight.

JT
 
It is possible to make the bible an idol. In so doing, pitting the bible against the use of
a relic has no relevance. Like looking for a tongue to lick itself.
How do make the Bible an idol? The only way we can truely worship God is through the Wrod of God the Bible. To make anything more important than the author of the Bible and His Word violates the 10 commanments. God tells us to worship Him in truth and thy Word is truth.
 
Anything- anything can become an idol if you let it. Even though most benign of things
You say the Bible says-this or that- how can you possibly understand and be certain of what the Bible truly says if everyone interprets it his own way.?One pastor say this another that.I’ve heard preachers on TBN take the same scripture verse and come out with stuff diametrically opposed to one another.Just as in Judaism Tradition has helped us through all.What has passed orally is just as important.Orally tradition was how the world worked for thousands of years before thing could be written down.OT was passed for hundreds maybe thousands of years before it hit paper.So are we not to trust the OT because it was passed verbally first!?NT was passed verbally first-Oral Tradition held it together- are we not to trust it because it was oral Tradition first.?
Many people seem to ignorant of the fact that the Bible didn’t fall from the sky full formed. That the things we see as basic to beliefs in Christianity didn’t not enter into this world full formed. They were argued over debated, fought over- . what criteria did they use to guide them- that pesky dirty word Tradition.Unfortunately what is believed as Trinity-hypostatic union and many other basic stuff was not as self evident as you would like to believe.It came out of discerning,praying,blood sweat and tears- not just scripture by itself.
 
Anything- anything can become an idol if you let it. Even though most benign of things
You say the Bible says-this or that- how can you possibly understand and be certain of what the Bible truly says if everyone interprets it his own way.?One pastor say this another that.I’ve heard preachers on TBN take the same scripture verse and come out with stuff diametrically opposed to one another.Just as in Judaism Tradition has helped us through all.What has passed orally is just as important.Oral tradition was how the world worked for thousands of years before thing could be written down.OT was passed for hundreds maybe thousands of years before it hit paper.So are we not to trust the OT because it was passed verbally first!?NT was passed verbally first-Oral Tradition held it together- are we not to trust it because it was oral Tradition first.?
Many people seem to ignorant of the fact that the Bible didn’t fall from the sky full formed. That the things we see as basic to beliefs in Christianity didn’t not enter into this world full formed. They were argued over debated, fought over- . what criteria did they use to guide them- that pesky dirty word Tradition.Unfortunately what is believed as Trinity-hypostatic union and many other basic stuff was not as self evident as you would like to believe.It came out of discerning,praying,blood sweat and tears- not just scripture by itself.
 
Where in the bible does it support your idea that relics are a sign of the Holiness of
christ? How do you know that your relic accurately portrays the Holiness of Christ? The 2 Peter passage, if you carefully read it, will show us that the Bible is all we need. Peter, James and John were on the Mt. of transfiguration and saw Christ in all His glory. Yet Peter says in 2 Peter that the Word of God is more important than that or any experience we may have. The point is that the Bible is to be primary in all thing in the christian life in order to know God and live a life pleasing to Him, 2 tim 3:16.
DLClark

Your first misunderstanding is your assumption that everything ‘pleasing to God’ must be Biblical. Where did you get the ‘idea’ that only something ‘Biblically supported’ is authentic and true and pleasing to God? How did you come to believe so assuredly, that the Bible is the only source for ‘what is and what isn’t’? It certainly was not FROM the Bible. It doesn’t say, ‘whatever is in this BOOK is the only true Christian teaching’. I think you go off base looking to slice and dice the Bible for the minutiae to support your ideas when the true answer is that it is *irrelevant *whether it is clearly stated in the Bible or not. I believe it to be. But Even if it is not according to ‘your’ interpretation, history has proved it to be ‘pleasing to God’. So has the Church. Study that.
 
Relics, as in the remains of Saints bodies, are not graven images made by man. They are ‘graven images made by God’, God takes a person, makes them His, their body is the temple of the Holy Spirit, this is Gods handywork. People do, and always have, from the beginning honoured the relics of the Saints because of what God did for them, their bodies were temples of the Holy Spirit and often they died as martyrs for Christ, with the promise from christ in ther hearts, For whosoever will save his life, shall lose it; for he that shall lose his life for my sake, shall save it. So that we are sure that these martyrs are in heaven and deserve honour.
What is difficult to understand is the mean-spiritedness of this attitude which takes no joy in seeing others succeed and grudges a martyr even a simple show of respect and honour.
If they are not graven images made by man then who maks them, God? How does God make them? The Bible tells us not to make graven images in Ex. 20. If you want to violate the Word of God go ahead. It is between you and God. What Bible verse says that we are to keep, use, and have relics?
 
If they are not graven images made by man then who maks them, God? How does God make them? The Bible tells us not to make graven images in Ex. 20. If you want to violate the Word of God go ahead. It is between you and God. What Bible verse says that we are to keep, use, and have relics?
Again, you assume incorrectly. Graven images, or carved images, was a command by God in response to the unfaithfulness of the tribes of Israel, and a warning against the damaging effects of the Egyptian and Canaanite religions. Graven images are as god. Relics are not graven images, or not thought of as god, but as touchstones from the lives of great men and women, human beings who have gone before us… who served as an inspiration to us, also lives that we believe deemed ‘pleasing to God’ and to whom special favor has been granted. You may reject THAT notion, but the notion that the relics of Saints are graven images, is totally in error. That is not to say, that people in history have not abused those practices or have exaggerated the understanding of relics. But the true understanding of the meaning of relics is not as you assume. Nor does it SAY in the BIBLE not to have relics. Historically, from the very beginning, venerating the tombs of the Patriarchs was known. The bones of Joseph were venerated with such high regard as to be carefully preserved, and eventually taken back to the promised land. Veneration of Apostolic tombs was also known from the first century. You need to broaden your understanding beyond your limiting the Bible to a ‘closed end book’. It was ‘the Church’ that gave you that book in the first place, whether you want to except THAT or not. Don’t assume that the Church does not understand the meaning of "The Word’ or some how is missing an important point that you see so clearly. You really don’t see it as clearly as you think.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top