Are relics Biblical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Relics, where do you find a command in the Bible telling us to use relics?🤷
Acts 19:11-12
11
God did extraordinary miracles through Paul, 12so that even handkerchiefs and aprons that had touched him were taken to the sick, and their illnesses were cured and the evil spirits left them.

Paul’s handkerchiefs and aprons were examples of second-class relics. Here is the classification system:

First-Class Relics
Items directly associated with the events of Christ’s life (manger, cross, etc.), or the physical remains of a saint (a bone, a hair, a limb, etc.). Traditionally, a martyr’s relics are often more prized than the relics of other saints. Also, some saints’ relics are known for their extraordinary incorruptibility (Human remains do not deteriorate as would normally be expected. For instance a 500 year old body that appears as though it is still in wake) and so would have high regard. It is important to note that parts of the saint that were significant to that saint’s life are more prized relics. For instance, King St. Stephen of Hungary’s right forearm is especially important because of his status as a ruler. A famous theologian’s head may be his most important relic. (The head of St. Thomas Aquinas was removed by the monks at the Cistercian abbey at Fossanova where he died). If a saint did a lot of travelling then the bones of his feet may be prized. Current Catholic teaching prohibits relics to be divided up into small, unrecognizable parts if they are to be used in liturgy (i.e, as in an altar; see the rubrics listed in Rite Of Dedication of a Church and an Altar).

Second-Class Relics An item that the saint wore (a shirt, a glove, etc.) Also included is an item that the saint owned or frequently used, for example, a crucifix, book etc. Again, an item more important in the saint’s life is thus a more important relic.

Third-Class Relics Any object that is touched to a first class relic.[7] The sale of relics is strictly forbidden by the Church. The Code of Canon Law states:[8]

§1190 §1 - “It is absolutely forbidden to sell sacred relics.”
§1190 §2 - “Relics of great significance and other relics honored with great reverence by the people cannot be alienated validly in any manner or transferred permanently without the permission of the Apostolic See.”
 
I see that you have logged on and ignored

Post #119
Post #120
Post #139
Give it up, Randy. Unless you can point to a specific verse in Scripture that states, “Verily, verily, thou shalt use relics” (or words to that effect), DLC isn’t going to listen to you. :rolleyes: :banghead:
 
Relics, where do you find a command in the Bible telling us to use relics?🤷
Once again DL, we do not worship the Bible as many Protestants do, we do not find it necessary to find a proof text comanding us to do a thing, or it is forbidden.

That is called “Regulative Worship” that goes all the way back to Jean Cauvin (Calvin in English) and was also reiterrated by the so called “churches of Christ”.

We do not accept either of those concepts, and we will not acces to your command “where is that commanded in the Bible”? Or the “church of Christ” version “where does God command that” the Bible is not God, nor was written by God, or dictated by God.

Most of the people here are Catholics by birth, but I am not. I was converted out of the “churches of Christ”, I see exactly where you are going from long years of painful experience. In another thread I have been going around and around with one of your fellow cofcers, who does not even have the courtesy of telling us what denomination he belongs to, just calls himself “christian”, but it is obivous what denomination he belongs to just by the rhetoric he uses.
 
DL Clark is a woman.

7th Day Adventist, maybe? Or maybe a follower of Tony Alamo? (That is a problem.)

Lives at the Indianapolis 500 Track?

Doesn’t trust Catholics? Cuz they don’t read their Bible?

Loves this thread because it has become about them, oops, her?
 
The point is that the Bible is to be primary in all thing in the christian life in order to know God and live a life pleasing to Him, 2 tim 3:16.
(3:16) All scripture, inspired of God, is profitable to teach, to reprove, to correct, to instruct in justice,

This does not say that the Bible is primary, only that it is useful, inerrant and needed.
 
Where in the bible does it support your idea that relics are a sign of the Holiness of
christ? How do you know that your relic accurately portrays the Holiness of Christ? The 2 Peter passage, if you carefully read it, will show us that the Bible is all we need. Peter, James and John were on the Mt. of transfiguration and saw Christ in all His glory. Yet Peter says in 2 Peter that the Word of God is more important than that or any experience we may have. The point is that the Bible is to be primary in all thing in the christian life in order to know God and live a life pleasing to Him, 2 tim 3:16.
dlclark,
The problem with your exegesis is it contains anti-biblical assumptions that you seem to be unaware of. Many assume that “Word of God” and “Scripture” and interchangeable terms. This is not always the case. In fact, in the New Testament Scriptures, the term ‘Word of God’, when not referring to Christ Himself, almost always refers to the Gospel as orally proclaimed by Christ and the Church.

(1:16) For we have not by following artificial fables, made known to you the power, and presence of our Lord Jesus Christ; but we were eyewitnesses of his greatness. (1:17) For he received from God the Father, honour and glory: this voice coming down to him from the excellent glory: This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased; hear ye him. (1:18) And this voice we heard brought from heaven, when we were with him in the holy mount. (1:19) And we have the more firm prophetical word: whereunto you do well to attend, as to a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day star arise in your hearts: (1:20) Understanding this first, that no prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation. (1:21) For prophecy came not by the will of man at any time: but the holy men of God spoke, inspired by the Holy Ghost.
 
…The 2 Peter passage, if you carefully read it, will show us that the Bible is all we need. Peter, James and John were on the Mt. of transfiguration and saw Christ in all His glory. Yet Peter says in 2 Peter that the Word of God is more important than that or any experience we may have. The point is that the Bible is to be primary in all thing in the christian life in order to know God and live a life pleasing to Him
You also assume that “prophecy of scripture” means “Bible” but the meaning of the words negates this assumption. Scripture = that which is written but prophecy = that which is spoken out loud. What Peter is saying is that the Church’s oral proclamation based on the OT scriptures is infallible.
 
Of course relics are Biblical. St. Elisha’s bones, the Ark of the Covenant, the hankerchiefs from St. Paul-- do they ring a bell?
 
Where dose the Bible say that we are to use relics today? If the Bible is silent on this subject we must be too or else have do we know we are pleasing to God by having them. I am refering to religious thing not secular here.

.
Where does it say we are not? You are putting your own spin on this…
 
On relics when we attach these supernatural powers as attributes it is clearly idolatry, which opposes the word of God.
 
Taken from another thread where it was getting off topic.The above poster defended John MacArthur’s condemnation of relics by arguing that the passages above do not confirm or deny the goodness of relics. Neither MacArthur nor the above poster provided Scripture condemning this concept. The above poster argued that we are not told if the action of bringing these relics to the sick were “right or wrong.” But what does Acts 19:12 say? It says that the delivery of Paul’s relics defeated “evil spirits.” The above poster is arguing that evil was used to defeat evil, a concept specifically condemned by Christ.

It is also worth noting the above poster said that the continuation of what we see in the Old and New Testaments to bring about healing and cast out evil is a “pagan idea.”

Answer: Newman to the rescue 😃 - he thought such things were bits of Christianity in paganism. A brilliant insight, from a brilliant, & holy, Christian thinker.​

Evil can’t be used to defeat evil - for this makes satan the enemy of satan. Why would the devil work wickedly through the wicked relics of all those wicked Saints he (presumably) hated so much & wanted to damn, if the cost of so working was the undoing of his own power, & so, of his power to harm ? That’s like cutting off one’s nose to smell a flower better.
Other responses welcome.

Relics are not only Biblical - they fit into a pattern that the Bible exemplifies, though it does not exhaust it. Relics are “Christ-ian”, therefore, they are Biblical - the Bible is “smaller” than Christ, less adequate as a revelation of God. He is “bigger” - so He, not the Bible, not any creature, has the primacy.​

They fit this pattern because they mediate the grace of Christ the Saviour, provided always that He works through them. They are material, because He mediates His grace through matter: IOW, through sacraments, the Bible, sacramentals, other Christians. Saints do this, the Eucharist does it, all creatures do it according as He sees fit to use them in His service. If He can use inanimate things to do His work - what excludes the mortal remains of His Saints 🤷 ? A relic of St. Therese of Lisieux is as much His as the print & paper of a Bible - these are His by right of creation & of conquest: nobody else’s. So if He can enliven the materials out of which a Bible is made - why can He not use the bones of a Catholic in whom He was present in grace & power & fruitfulness during her life on earth ?

Relics are a reminder that He renews nature - they are “green shoots” of the coming of His Kingdom, where death will be “swallowed up for ever”. They are not the Resurrection of the blessed dead - but they are glimmers of it, reminders that it will come, & cannot be hindered. IOW, they matter.

Just my 2d.
 
On relics when we attach these supernatural powers as attributes it is clearly idolatry, which opposes the word of God.
Wrong! Catholics do not worship relics nor do we regard them as magical. We know that they have no intrinsic power in and of themselves. However, we acknowledge that God’s power can and does work through them, as the Biblical quotes previously supplied clearly show.
 
I think the main reason that Protestants have such a problem with relics (as well as sacred art and liturgy) is that Protestantism (particularly the Calvinistic forms, less so groups like the Lutherans and Episcopalians) has an almost Docetic hatred of the physical world. Yes, the world was marred by sin, but it is still good- God created it. Furthermore, Jesus took on our flesh in the Incarnation to redeem not just our souls but our bodies as well.
 
SNIP> we acknowledge that God’s power can and does work through them, as the Biblical quotes previously supplied clearly show.<SNIP
You “conveniently” failed to mention that the serpent was eventually destroyed because the nation of Israel began worshipping it. The “relic” was not intended to be an object of worship and adoration. Those who were bit by the snakes looked to the pole out of obedience to God’s promise to heal those who did.
It wasn’t the relic that saved, it was a faith in God’s promise of deliverance. Interestly enough, it is only be faith and repentence in God’s promise of deliverance through Jesus Christ which saves.

Furthermore, the signs and miracles accompanying the apostles were clearly affirmative instances verifying the authority and authenticity of the apostolic message of the Gospel. Since then, the revelatory Word of God has been made complete. Those signs are not needed. Not only are they not needed, but being that they were for that age and time (see 1 Cor 13), any claim of authority of the objects is indeed blasphemous compared to the complete, perfect, innerrant, and infallible revelatory Word of God.

The ongoing worship of these so-called “relics” amounts to idolatry. People placing their faith in these objects, are, in affect, saying that the completed work of God’s revelation and the completed work of Christ as declared in the revelation is not sufficient.
 
The serpent doesn’t even qualify and a relic. :rolleyes:

However, here’s a good example of one and God’s use of them.
2nd Kings 13:20] So Eli’sha died, and they buried him. Now bands of Moabites used to invade the land in the spring of the year.
21] And as a man was being buried, lo, a marauding band was seen and the man was cast into the grave of Eli’sha; and as soon as the man touched the bones of Eli’sha, he revived, and stood on his feet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top