Are We Better than the Saints?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Soulstorm
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Soulstorm

Guest
If you asked any Priest nowadays if it’s ok to kill a heretic they’d probably be aghast and quickly tell you that it is not ok.

Yet some of our greatest Saints such as Thomas More have mentioned it is right to kill a heretic if they do not recant. To add to this probably most clergy of the Middle Ages would have agreed that a heretic who did not recant could only deserve death.

So what does that mean? That from the Renaissance and down all of the Christians of the time period are most likely in Hell for approving of killing heretics? If this was a Church approved stance then that means it was teaching falsehoods so then why should we believe that presently its a trust worthy organization?

I hear constantly the proud claim that the Church has not changed since its creation 2000 years ago. Yet we do not hold the beliefs of the Medieval Church, meaning that it changed.

Edit: When people tell you that we can’t judge people and their morality from other time periods with our own morality it usually implies that our current system of Morality is still better than those of the past (Ex. Our current morality claims its not moral to wipe out an entire race of people simply because they don’t believe in God. Even though apparently all morals come from God and he was alright with endorsing Genocide thousands of years ago)
 
First, it is best to note the source for your quote so that it may be verifired. Church teaching has not changed. Church behavior has. We cannot judge past times through today’s glasses, as we did not walk in their shoes. I think that you might be conflating Church behavior with Church teaching. The teaching has deepened in many areas, but has not changed in substance. We should aspite to be as the Saints in all holiness - after all, in the long run, we are either Saints or burning in hell. You choose.
 
They are Saints and we are not.
I give you my example again. Thomas More and Aquinas, here is a quote from Aquinas.
With regard to heretics two points must be observed: one, on their own side; the other, on the side of the Church. On their own side there is the sin, whereby they deserve not only to be separated from the Church by excommunication, but also to be severed from the world by death. For it is a much graver matter to corrupt the faith which quickens the soul, than to forge money, which supports temporal life. Wherefore if forgers of money and other evil-doers are forthwith condemned to death by the secular authority, much more reason is there for heretics, as soon as they are convicted of heresy, to be not only excommunicated but even put to death.
Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
 
No, we’re not better than the saints, but we all are called to become saints. Read the Catechism. It will help you understand the Catholic Church’s teachings and traditions. We are all sinners, but with grace we can grow in holiness.
 
I give you my example again. Thomas More and Aquinas, here is a quote from Aquinas.

Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
I think you mis-percieve Aquinas’ words. He does not say that those “will be” killed, or “must be” killed, or even that it will occur at the hands of man at all, only that they deserve, by their own actions, to be taken from this earth. He did not say by what means or authority this would or should occur, but it is clearly implied that God would judge.

As to morality of our culture, it is the most blood-thirsty that has ever exited, introducing, supporting and promoting the industrialized killing of targeted innocents in the womb - for the sake of convenience.
 
I give you my example again. Thomas More and Aquinas, here is a quote from Aquinas.

Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
Simple. St. Thomas Aquinas was a better man than us overall. But he was - no matter how holy he was - just a man bound in a certain time period. So we can easily say he was wrong on that, didn’t realize he was wrong, and thus isn’t as culpable in the eyes of God for it because of his ignorance in the matter.

So, on this we’re better, on most other things he’s better.
 
Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
Because you aren’t living in medieval times and therefor know better. If you know better you’re held way more culpable.
 
Because you aren’t living in medieval times and therefor know better. If you know better you’re held way more culpable.
By that logic there are people in heaven who support genocide over the issue of religion?

Also then what authority does the Catholic Church has if in one millennium it enforced murder of heretics (Papal Bull: Vergentis in senium, it would treat heresy the same as treason) and the next millennium it calls for all people to have Freedom of Religion?

God doesn’t change his mind, so why is the Church who bases their morality on God constantly change with variables found from the earthly world.
 
By that logic there are people in heaven who support genocide over the issue of religion?

Also then what authority does the Catholic Church has if in one millennium it enforced murder of heretics (Papal Bull: Vergentis in senium, it would treat heresy the same as treason) and the next millennium it calls for all people to have Freedom of Religion?

God doesn’t change his mind, so why is the Church who bases their morality on God constantly change with variables found from the earthly world.
Slow down! First, we have an out of context quote of Aquinas. That is a major problem. Consider: Saint Paul says “For, we are saved by hope” (Romans 8:24). OK, so, is this all we have to do to enter heaven? Sounds like it, huh? But No!

All comments, and all scripture must be taken within the context in which they were spoken or written.

To consider ourselves as even equal with the Saints is utter conceit.
 
I think it is really important to note two things in this discussion.
  1. The words “by the secular authority” in the original quote.
  2. The fact that “heresy” does not constitute “non-Catholic thought” but rather “presenting non-Catholic thought as official Catholic thought.”
It’s kind of more along the lines as someone going around changing all of the official laws of our country into other laws without anyone’s knowledge or approval, so no one knew what to follow anymore, which presents a very real danger, and is quite different from someone who seeks to change the laws, or thinks the laws are unjust, or takes issue with the laws.
 
Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
would you call me a sinner for advocating that the pagans should be put to death because they are sinners and may lead others to idolatry?
I am believing the exact thing that moses and maybe God believed in the OT so why would they be in heaven and i in hell for advocating the murder of pagans? Thomas is right It does deserve death but the judgment is for God, besides both catholics and protestants killed those they regarded as heritics and i assure you they would say their conscience was clear they did nothing wrong they thought they were doing God a favour and applying biblical principles. Who is wrong??? All we can do is sit and try to judge what happened centuries ago i don’t think we would have done better given the circumstance. With a ‘clear conscience’ it would be hard to convict them and moses of mortal sin. But Thomas said they deserved death which they do but you are saying should be put to death, there is a difference.
Peace
 
With a ‘clear conscience’ it would be hard to convict them and moses of mortal sin. But Thomas said they deserved death which they do but you are saying should be put to death, there is a difference.
The only difference I see is one is a demand, and the other is a wink wink nudge to the government on what actions they should take.
 
By that logic there are people in heaven who support genocide over the issue of religion?

Also then what authority does the Catholic Church has if in one millennium it enforced murder of heretics (Papal Bull: Vergentis in senium, it would treat heresy the same as treason) and the next millennium it calls for all people to have Freedom of Religion?

God doesn’t change his mind, so why is the Church who bases their morality on God constantly change with variables found from the earthly world.
Innocent III’s papal bull didn’t say that heretics have to be killed if they are seen on sight street, it only said that heresy should be treated the same as treason as heresy truly is treason against God. In fact, I’ve spent the last hour researching it and though I didn’t find the full english text, this book says that Innocent III didn’t stipulate the death penalty for heresy in page 191: books.google.com.mt/books?id=jY4Ow07bwyYC&pg=PA191&lpg=PA191&dq=innocent+iii+vergentis+in+senium&source=bl&ots=_QzMzZ_xpM&sig=0XFQw34gjRdIBJWrpNd0u1RnjyA&hl=mt&ei=S-_jTuWmHsbk4QSrw_y_BQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CEoQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=innocent%20iii%20vergentis%20in%20senium&f=false It even provides a footnote where the line in the original text can be found.

This book also says that though Innocent III didn’t legistlate that heretics should be killed and that they can be given over to secular authorithies, he didn’t go against it, as seen on page 108: books.google.com.mt/books?id=lG-a_RBO8VgC&pg=PA108&lpg=PA108&dq=vergentis+in+senium+death+penalty&source=bl&ots=aEFQTCgqv-&sig=QlJ4GRAfYeShX9ryaCuEW0ZdO7g&hl=mt&ei=zvHjTs-YLMiK4gSav-SyBQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CBgQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=vergentis%20in%20senium%20death%20penalty&f=false

Secondly, the decretal was written for the town of Viterbo and the clergy there which had joined with Church enemies who to my knowledge were Cathars. And though the Pope didn’t legistlate the death penalty, he did say that the property of heretics should be confiscated and that they should be isolated so as to protect the faith of the people. He goes further than that, as he even orders that the inheritance of even orthodox catholic children should be confiscated. It may have been harsh especially in regards the children, but the Pope didn’t decree that they should be killed. In fact, not all the supporters of the heretics had the same fate happen to them:

There was a Bishop who suspected that two Priests were guilty of ehresy and asked the Pope for help. The Pope concluded that they would have to show and declare their orthodoxy if they had a chance at freedom. This proves that though the Church is vehemently and rightfully against heresy, it didn’t kill everybody that was simply rumored to be a heretic. The same for the Inquisition which I consider an otherwise great organization. The Inquisition as David Goldstein said, is as guilty of murder as a jury is to sending a man to the electric chair. It did order penances for repantant heretics but it never issued the death penalty (except for the Roman Inquisition but even then, though it was the Pope who signed the permission to execute the person, it was done non-infallibly). It was the state that carried out the execution of heretics, some of whom deserved it, others who didn’t, but these were actions carried not by the Catholic faith or by the Pope ex cathedra but by simple, non-infallible human beings.

Oh, and if the links aren’t working, copy and paste them (with the [ bits of course) on the adress bar, it worked for me.]( bits of course) on the adress bar, it worked for me.)
 
@MrSylvester

This is good to hear, however the main point is that the Catholic Church does not keep to one policy on how to deal with people and in fact is swayed by the power of earthly things.

For example if the Church suddenly gained the Italian Peninsula entirely as their secular domain they would not reinstate Jewish Ghettos because past history has made Antisemitism something that the Secular world abhors.

I’m simply having trouble seeing how if the Church is apparently the highest morality and how God will punish someone by the notions of his time instead of a absolute morality. I mean does that mean if someone hated the Jews in the Medieval ages they could still attain Heaven because that was just the norm of the time period?
 
@MrSylvester

This is good to hear, however the main point is that the Catholic Church does not keep to one policy on how to deal with people and in fact is swayed by the power of earthly things.
I doubt it ALOT. You must note that the reinstanation of the Jewish ghettos was a response to certain things in the times. The Church always condemend Judaism and rightfull so
 
As wikipedia showed, the Popes condemend the error that Jews practiced ritual murder and in another article, it said that: The Jews of Fulda, Germany were accused of ritual murder. To investigate the blood libel, Emperor Frederick II held a special conference of Jewish converts to Christianity at which the converts were questioned about Jewish ritual practice. Letters inviting prominent individuals to the conference still survive. At the conference, the converts stated unequivocally that Jews do not harm Christian children or require blood for any rituals. In 1236 the Emperor published these findings and in 1247 Pope Innocent IV, the Emperor’s enemy, also denounced accusations of the ritual murder of Christian children by Jews. In 1272, the papal repudiation of the blood libel was repeated by Pope Gregory X, who also ruled that thereafter any such testimony of a Christian against a Jew could not be accepted unless it is confirmed by another Jew. Unfortunately, these proclamations from the highest sources were not effective in altering the beliefs of the Christian majority and the libels continued.

True the Church canonized Saint Simon of Trent and High of Saint Lincoln but these accusations were thoroughly investigated and indeed, a child really was murdered brutally, and Saint Simon was murdered well after the Pope’s laws on blood libel testimony were done. However, it is possible that a small, Jewish sect mixed in satanism with their religion, similiar to how Nazis mixed in vague Christian elements to their satanic religion and only practiced ritual murder just for the lulz. It doesn’t mean that Judaism practices this unequivocally. Recently, a book was released by a Jewish historian that showed some cases of ritual murder however, thats all I’ll say. I haven’t read the book to judge it.

There is another thing I must mention, and that is the case of Saint Vincent Ferrer (or Vicente Ferrer). Though his preaching agaisnt Jews and their heresy and the corruption found in the richest ones did soemtimes lead to bad consequences, he condemned violence against them and not as wikipedia tells you. For more on this subject, read ‘Vicente Ferrer and the King’s Jews’. The book isn’t very long, jsut 48 pages although it is well wrth the read: emory.academia.edu/MikeHatch/Papers/966117/Vicente_Ferrer_and_the_Kings_Jews_Reassessing_the_Modern_Image_of_a_Medieval_Dominican

The point of all this? The Popes and the Church weren’t anti-semitic, they were anti-Judaism. It didn’t have a problem with the Jewish race as a race because there were many saints who were Jewish, such as Teresa of Avila, John of the Cross, Father Avila and of coruse, Jesus and Mary themselves. Well duh! Only people who believe Muslims worship Apollyon (as seen in the song of Roland) or that the Church invented communism beleive Jesus wasn’t Jewish. Some Catholics, like Maximilian Maria Kolbe did believe in the Protocols but in his case, he just genuinely beleived that they were true. He wasn’t anti-semitic as proven by the many article he wrote agaisnt Nazism, the fact that he sheltered Jews and that during his life he converted many Jews to the faith. One story had him converting a Jewish boy on his deathbed. When his mother came and saw a miraculous medal on her boy, she became so angry Max was kicked out! Plus, Maximilian himself may have been Jewish; Kolbe is similiar to the Jewish surname Caleb, only polonized. And I’m going out of track here.

The thing is in this case, this ‘anti-something’ was taken too far. It didn’t encourage the killing of Jews at all but it didn’t treat them too well… actually, wait. Compared to the Church’s treatment and condemnation of Protestantism and other heresies and how these weren’t allowed to practice their religon in public, how much did the Church take things too far against the Jews? Their property was only sold by the Church when they were expelled and at that time, it wasn’t very possible to give them back their money and (and note I don’t support the explusion of any people… except green ones and orcs, I hate those!) since they were expelled out of the country, not allowed to return, there wasn’t much else to do with their former homes. So if one must blame the Church for supposedly being ‘anti-semitic’ blame it for being anti-protestantism (which itself was anti-catholic), anti-atheism, anti-liberal, anti-modernist, anti-vegan (just kidding!), etc… these were all heresies that threathened the Catholic Faith. Because people of other religions couldn’t hold political offices doesn’t mean the Church was unjust, it only did it to protect the purity of faith and in its eyes to rpotect justice and its people against possible rebellion form within. Its not wrong for the Church to have its own theocracy for reasons that’d take too long to mention here, but today, neither heretics nor Jews would be put into ghettos.

I said Pius IX abolished Jewish ghettos: long before him, in the late 17th century, the Popes stopped killing heretics for the crime of heresy and the only people they allowed to be sentenced to death were for normal crimes. Not only that, but today, no heretic would be killed for heresy because the secular authorities don’t count heresy as a crminal offense. Not even Franco killed heretics, he just let the Church deal with them and it certainly didn’t kill them. As I said, the Inquisition’s as guilty of murder as a jury is to sending a man to the electric chair. It determiend who was a heretic and only handed the ehretics over to the secular authorithies, thats it.
 
The point of all this shows that God does indeed punish evil by absolute morality so if you were anti-semitic, you deserved to go to hell whether in the middle ages or not as the Churhc condemend hurting them for this purpose. However, one mustn’t think that because Catholic had more rights in the Papal States than Protestants and Jews than that meant it was bad. Sorry for the repetition but the Church made such restrictions simply to protect the purity of faith. They over stepped their bounds sometimes, such as this clothing rubbish on Jews but the intention, even if it was extreme was always there.
 
I give you my example again. Thomas More and Aquinas, here is a quote from Aquinas.

Would you all call me a sinner for believing that all heretics should be put to death because they can lead others to heresy? I’m believing the exact thing Thomas Aquinas did, so why would he be in Heaven while I’d be in Hell for advocating the murder of heretics?
Did not Christ say it would be better if a millstone was hung on one’s and that person be cast in the sea if they led others to error?
He did not say to do this but it certainly seems suggestive.
Why would it be better for this person to be cast into the sea?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top