"Are you done having kids yet?!"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cathmomof6
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My Mum thought she was ‘done having kids’ when she was 40… My little sister was born when she was 42!!

I’m hoping and praying that kind of thing is in my genes because I have only one son and I’m 38. God bless you, your husband and your lovely big family. I’m not jealous… much. 😉
Both my grandmothers had their last baby at age 50.

No, they did not have fertility treatments, just being open to life and being faithful Catholics. Each of them had 8 children.
 
When my husband and I were in our early 20s, we always said we would be done having kids at 35. However, now that we are past that and have more fully embraced our faith, we don’t really have a “cut-off” number anymore!! But I do have some reservations. My experience with this last pregnancy was eye-opening. At 19 weeks I was told our baby had a high likelihood of trisomy 18. We were sent to see a maternal fetal specialist and genetic counselors, who kept repeating the statistics of my “advanced maternal age” and increased risk of genetic abnormalities!! This all put in me almost a feeling of shame and irresponsibility, like we would have caused our baby to have a lifetime of difficulty! However, my pregnancy went smoothly and we had our very healthy baby boy 2 weeks ago! I bled a lot immediately after birth - looked like a horror movie - and was given a shot to stop the bleeding! Again I was told this was probably because of all the babies I’ve had. I really don’t know exactly the risks of postpartum hemmorhaging and maternal death, but this concerns me with a future pregnancy too. Obviously, I NEED to stick around here to raise these little ones I already have!!! So we are currently “discerning” if these are serious reasons to “be done”!! Any thoughts???
You have legitimate concerns for your health and that of any future children, so I’d say that not having any more would be the prudent thing to do. God and the Church do not demand that we pop out as many children as our bodies can possibly produce to the detriment of our health and the welfare of our families. Seven children may be your limit, if so that’s fine. It’s a matter of prudential judgment not of sin if you decide that you are done having children for the reasons you’ve cited. :yup:
 
A man in our parish with a large family claims his answer to the “Don’t you know what causes that?” question was: “Yes we do, and so do our neighbors.” Ha.
 
In the past, the easiest way to answer this question, has been “yes, we’re done” just to get them off the subject. My parents have made numerous comments about this being my “last baby”. …

If I say we would welcome more or are not sure, I always get this look like I am some completely insane individual and I get dragged into a conversation where I get defensive and feel I need to defend myself. I don’t want to be rude as I understand, for the most part, people are really just being curious, and I don’t want to sound like some “religious freak” (not to offend anyone, but I definitely know this is some people’s perception of us).

I sometimes think I would like “just one more baby” (been saying that since #4:D!!), but maybe we are getting too old? I just don’t know, but to say we are 100% done is hard too since we struggle with NFP and complete abstinence does not seem necessary either. I also had some postpartum hemmorrhaging with last baby, which I guess is somewhat common after 7 babies!

I know I do not have to completely decide this now but everyone else seems to think I should have a definitive answer!!!
With 9 children, I’ve had my share of that in the past. I just smile and say, with this many kids, one or two more hardly makes any difference. Or, “Who knows.” Also with a smile. It seems to deflect a lot, and give them the idea that I’m quite happy with the way I live my life and my choices (probably because it’s true.) Maybe it dispels their concerns for me, to see I myself am not worried over it.

I don’t worry in the least about being too old. Of course, now that I’m divorced and in my 40s, it’s highly unlikely there will be more children, but if I got married tomorrow, I still wouldn’t worry. My kids would be thrilled with a new sibling, and I have absolutely no concerns about my ability to care for another baby.
 
God and the Church do not demand that we pop out as many children as our bodies can possibly produce…
I doubt anyone actually believes God and/or the church require this. I’ve always found it pretty offensive when people helpfully clue me in that God and the Church don’t require this of me. It really suggests that I’m not too bright, not too thoughtful, that somehow I’ve never actually stopped to think this through. Moreover, people who have said this to me have never actually taken the time to learn what I really do think or know on the subject. They’ve just made this highly offensive assumption that I couldn’t possibly be a thinking person and have this many kids.
 
I doubt anyone actually believes God and/or the church require this. I’ve always found it pretty offensive when people helpfully clue me in that God and the Church don’t require this of me. It really suggests that I’m not too bright, not too thoughtful, that somehow I’ve never actually stopped to think this through. Moreover, people who have said this to me have never actually taken the time to learn what I really do think or know on the subject. They’ve just made this highly offensive assumption that I couldn’t possibly be a thinking person and have this many kids.
Anyone who assumes to tell you this is rude, insensitive and a bore, I agree. I merely wanted to remind us of this fact in case our lurkers and seekers have the mistaken idea that Catholic women are looked upon as mere “breeders” of children–a disgusting term, don’t you think? We are mothers (those of us with children) and how many children we have is entirely up to us. I absolutely agree with that. :tiphat:
 
With 9 children, I’ve had my share of that in the past. I just smile and say, with this many kids, one or two more hardly makes any difference. Or, “Who knows.” Also with a smile. It seems to deflect a lot, and give them the idea that I’m quite happy with the way I live my life and my choices (probably because it’s true.) Maybe it dispels their concerns for me, to see I myself am not worried over it.

I don’t worry in the least about being too old. Of course, now that I’m divorced and in my 40s, it’s highly unlikely there will be more children, but if I got married tomorrow, I still wouldn’t worry. My kids would be thrilled with a new sibling, and I have absolutely no concerns about my ability to care for another baby.
How old were you when you had your last baby? And did you have any issues with postpartum hemmorhaging after having that many kids? These are really my only two reservations about having more kids. I know the Church does not want me to have as many babies as physically possible. I am not stupid, and I find this a little offensive, too. My problem is that when I look at my precious newborn, it breaks my heart to think we won’t have anymore!! Now that might make me slightly crazy, but it is true:shrug:. I don’t know why I feel this way when others can be so sure they are done. I seem to always feel like I want just one more, and my 5 year old and 3 year old really want twins yet:).

I kind of feel like if we are still able to conceive at our age then it must be ok, but my whole experience with this last pregnancy and the suspected genetic defect makes me more concerned. I truly was made to feel like we were being irresponsible having a baby at our age. I would hate to cause our child a lifetime of difficulty!!!
 
A man in our parish with a large family claims his answer to the “Don’t you know what causes that?” question was: “Yes we do, and so do our neighbors.” Ha.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
How old were you when you had your last baby? And did you have any issues with postpartum hemmorhaging after having that many kids? These are really my only two reservations about having more kids. I know the Church does not want me to have as many babies as physically possible. I am not stupid, and I find this a little offensive, too. My problem is that when I look at my precious newborn, it breaks my heart to think we won’t have anymore!! Now that might make me slightly crazy, but it is true:shrug:. I don’t know why I feel this way when others can be so sure they are done. I seem to always feel like I want just one more, and my 5 year old and 3 year old really want twins yet:).

I kind of feel like if we are still able to conceive at our age then it must be ok, but my whole experience with this last pregnancy and the suspected genetic defect makes me more concerned. I truly was made to feel like we were being irresponsible having a baby at our age. I would hate to cause our child a lifetime of difficulty!!!
If anything I wrote offended, I apologize. Of course you know you are not required to have as many children as possible, but I wanted to reassure you of this fact so that in making your decisions with your husband, you would have every reassurance that not having more is just as fine as having more children. Does that make sense? I’m afraid I’m expressing myself badly here. 😊

In any case, many people find having a talk with their priest about it gives them direction/confidence in their decisions about such important matters. You and your husband may want to talk to him about it, if you haven’t already done so. Just now you are in the full flush of happiness with your newborn. This might be influencing the euphoria you are feeling. Anyway, all the best to you and your family. 🙂
 
How old were you when you had your last baby? And did you have any issues with postpartum hemmorhaging after having that many kids? These are really my only two reservations about having more kids. I know the Church does not want me to have as many babies as physically possible. I am not stupid, and I find this a little offensive, too. My problem is that when I look at my precious newborn, it breaks my heart to think we won’t have anymore!! Now that might make me slightly crazy, but it is true:shrug:. I don’t know why I feel this way when others can be so sure they are done. I seem to always feel like I want just one more, and my 5 year old and 3 year old really want twins yet:). I left the hospital as normal with no need for blood transfusions…my bleeding was just heavy in comparisons to less “experienced mothers.”

I kind of feel like if we are still able to conceive at our age then it must be ok, but my whole experience with this last pregnancy and the suspected genetic defect makes me more concerned. I truly was made to feel like we were being irresponsible having a baby at our age. I would hate to cause our child a lifetime of difficulty!!!
Just thought I’d pop in and give you my experience. I’ve had 5 children over the age of 35, two of whom were born after the age of 40. Yes, hemorrhaging is a risk factor for women who are mulitpara. They always left a IV line in for about 12-24 hours depending on how things went after birth. Thankfully I did not have any troubles. I did have quite a lot of bleeding with my last pregnancy that ended with a D&C (the baby failed to develop,) but again, no big troubles, and it was expected (due to my mulitpara status and how far along the pregnancy was when I had the D&C.)

I do have a friend that had to spend a day in ICU due to hemorrhaging. He doctor induced her and she knew this was going to be her last baby due to complications. I don’t know what her complications were (she didn’t divulge) but she and her doctor were well aware of the possibility. And I would like to emphasize that this was ONE person out of about 20-30 women that I’ve known that have given birth over the age of35.

I would trust your doctor if you feel he/she can be honest with you about your risk, without the contraceptive bias that can cloud some physicians opinions.
 
Just thought I’d pop in and give you my experience. I’ve had 5 children over the age of 35, two of whom were born after the age of 40. Yes, hemorrhaging is a risk factor for women who are mulitpara. They always left a IV line in for about 12-24 hours depending on how things went after birth. Thankfully I did not have any troubles. I did have quite a lot of bleeding with my last pregnancy that ended with a D&C (the baby failed to develop,) but again, no big troubles, and it was expected (due to my mulitpara status and how far along the pregnancy was when I had the D&C.)

I do have a friend that had to spend a day in ICU due to hemorrhaging. He doctor induced her and she knew this was going to be her last baby due to complications. I don’t know what her complications were (she didn’t divulge) but she and her doctor were well aware of the possibility. And I would like to emphasize that this was ONE person out of about 20-30 women that I’ve known that have given birth over the age of35.

I would trust your doctor if you feel he/she can be honest with you about your risk, without the contraceptive bias that can cloud some physicians opinions.
Thank you for sharing your experience. I need a “mentor” of sorts right now. This is kind of a tricky time of life to navigate. Everyone around our age considers themselves “done” and many are having vasectomies or tubal ligations to ensure it! Although we have always been open to life, I even kind of assumed we would go that route when we hit 35 or so!

Thankfully, we now understand and agree with what the Church teaches on that, but to think of possibly 10 more years of fertility is scary too. We could never sell NFP to anyone as we stink at it. Either we end up with a “what the heck” baby or, as with our last baby, we do something wrong. We were using Marquette and on my first cycle postpartum we used day 4 post peak and still wound up pregnant. ( according to their website, we should have been safe)

And then I go back and forth between I would love another baby but we really shouldn’t - too risky??!! So, as I said, it is nice to come across someone in a similar situation!!! Unfortunately, the midwife who delivered my last 3 babies moved to a different hospital in the middle of my last pregnancy! So they moved me to a new OB in the same practice. She doesn’t really know me yet, and I am not sure her views on contraception, but I am sure I will soon find out. My first postpartum appt is April 22 and this is always the one that the ABC subject comes up. I would love a prolife doctor but don’t know of any in this area:confused:
 
I don’t have any specific advice, but wanted to tell you that my mother had 4 children after 37. And a lot more before that! 😃
 
My favorite reply to “Don’t you know what causes that?” is “YES, and we’re really good at it!” People suddenly realize they are asking about my sex life and they stop asking any questions.

For “are you done yet?” I just say “I don’t know” and don’t say anything else. I haven’t yet had anyone persist, but maybe that’s because we only have four.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top