Argument against the Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have objections to every one of the 15 “promises”, but for the sake of brvevity for now, I’ll talk about just a couple. Every one of the following promises is fraught with false promises and every one of them takes away from the sacrificial work of Jesus Christ my Saviour and Lord:

“5. Those who trust themselves to me through the Rosary will not perish.”

This statement has Mary usurping the saving power of God’s Son, Jesus Christ. The Bible tells us to trust in Him. Doing a word search on “trust” in any version of scripture will yield results that make it ever so clear to trust in God and in Him alone for our salvation.

Because of the nature of this promise, I truly do not believe that Mary who was a godly woman would have it in her to present this to anyone. I do believe that the source of this is the impersonator, the devil, who would most want to have people trusting anyone but Christ for their salvation.
First and foremost, God makes the promise and used Mary as the vehicle through which to commuicate the promise. This is no differenet, in a sense, than Moses communicating the Law (of God) to the Jews.

But, with how this promise is completely scriptual:
Joh 2:5 His mother saith to the waiters: Whatsoever he shall say to you, do ye.
Mary points you towards Jesus always, you’ve errored in your thought that Mary is doing something in her own right, or that “paying attention to Mary takes away from your attention paid to Jesus”. This isn’t possible.
“6. Whoever recites my Rosary devoutly reflecting on the mysteries, shall never be overwhelmed by misfortune. He will not experience the anger of God nor will he perish by an unprovided death. The sinner will be converted; the just will persevere in grace and merit eternal life.”
Not even God will promise us a life without misfortune if we reflect on His mysteries, etc. I’ve run out of time now, but I want to expand on this later.
I’ve bolded the part that has affected my life in particular, my experience with the rosary, indeed has brought me so much further on the path to conversion to Christ than anything else. I say brought me further because, naturally, I still struggle greatly with sin in many ways. But certainly praying the rosary made me listen significantly more sharply to the voice of the Holy Spirit than anything else.

Now, having already established previously that one can not pray to any particular Saint instead of God (rather, to God through the petitions of the Saint) then I would respond to you:
Luk 11:11 And which of you, if he ask his father bread, will he give him a stone? Or a fish, will he for a fish give him a serpent?
Luk 11:12 Or if he shall ask an egg, will he reach him a scorpion?
Luk 11:13 If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father from heaven give the good Spirit to them that ask him?
 
OLD TESTAMENT TIMES

PRIETHOOD - EARTHLY TABERNACLE – Law

Ref.: Incence on Earth Leviticus 2:15-16

Incense offered on the Altar not new:-

Quote: ”and poured a log of oil and an handful of incense upon it, presented it to the priest, who heaving it in the form of a cross, threw as much as he could hold in his hand upon the altar, and kept the rest for himself.” (Haydoc Catholic Old Testament Commentary).
:15 And thou shalt put oil upon it, and lay frankincense thereon: it is a meal-offering. :16 And the priest shall burn the memorial of it, part of the bruised grain thereof, and part of the oil thereof, with all the frankincense thereof: it is an offering made by fire unto Jehovah.
Lev 2:15-16 (American Standard Version).

NEW TESTAMENT TIMES

PRIESTHOOD HEAVENLY TABERNACLE –– Christ Jesus – all things made new.

Ref.: Incence in Heaven - Prayers of Saints; - Revelations.
(Revelations 4:1 – John sees the throne of God in Heaven.
Revelations 5:13 – Whole creation in Heaven and on earth give glory to God simultaneously – (as one voice. No distance).
Rev 5:8 (American Standard Version). And when he had taken the book, the four living creatures and the four and twenty elders fell down before the Lamb, having each one a harp, and golden bowls full of incense, which are the prayers of the saints.
Quote: “Having every one of them harps to celebrate his praise, and golden vials full of odours, which are the prayers of the saints: which shews that the saints in heaven offer up before the throne of the Divine Majesty the prayers of the faithful. Wi. — Harps, &c. These harps are symbols of the praise which good men render to God; and the vials full of odours, represent the prayers of the saints. In conformity with this idea, S. John wishes to represent these four and twenty ancients as so many senators, who present to the Almighty the prayers and homages of good men on earth. Estius. Clemens Alex. — This also is an imitation of what was practised in the temple, in which were always around the altar, in times of sacrifice, Levites with musical instruments, priests with vials to contain the wine and blood, and censers to hold the incense. Calmet. — The prayers of the saints. Here we see that the saints in heaven offer up to Christ the prayers of the faithful upon earth”. Ch (Haydoc Catholic New Testament Commentary).
Rev 7:9-12 (ASV)
Rev 8:1-5 (ASV)
 
First and foremost, God makes the promise and used Mary as the vehicle through which to commuicate the promise. This is no differenet, in a sense, than Moses communicating the Law (of God) to the Jews.
I think that is a core fallacy that needs to be addressed. Once it is established to be a falsehood, all credibility that one might see in the 15 promises will be washed away.

I’m going to expand where I left off in my last post which was dealing with the first sentence in promise number 6 - “Whoever recites my Rosary devoutly reflecting on the mysteries, shall never be overwhelmed by misfortune.” As I stated in my last post, God doesn’t even offer us a promise like that. In fact, Jesus said the opposite in John 16:32 - "In the world you will have tribulation; but be of good cheer, I have overcome the world.” It is God who is with us as believers in time of trouble and while He will not always take away our afflictions and woes, He is with us and we can count on Him to be there for us. He is our shelter in the storm and He cares for us like no other.

Psalm 46:
" 1 God is our refuge and strength,
A very present help in trouble.
2 Therefore we will not fear,
Even though the earth be removed,
And though the mountains be carried into the midst of the sea;
3 Though its waters roar and be troubled,
Though the mountains shake with its swelling. Selah"

Amen and amen! Let us always look to God alone in the spiritual realm as our refuge and strength and as our help. There is no other!
But, with how this promise is completely scriptual:
Mary points you towards Jesus always, you’ve errored in your thought that Mary is doing something in her own right, or that “paying attention to Mary takes away from your attention paid to Jesus”. This isn’t possible.
Have you noticed in the 15 promises of the rosary, that not once does Mary’s imposter point to Jesus Christ? The imposter points to Mary and to the rosary. There is mention of the name of Jesus once in promise 13, but the main focus is on Mary (or her impersonator).
I’ve bolded the part that has affected my life in particular, my experience with the rosary, indeed has brought me so much further on the path to conversion to Christ than anything else. I say brought me further because, naturally, I still struggle greatly with sin in many ways. But certainly praying the rosary made me listen significantly more sharply to the voice of the Holy Spirit than anything else.
We need to always go to God’s Word for what is truth. There isn’t even a hint in scripture that the rosary should be a part of the Christian’s life and the 15 promises argue against what God did give us in scripture.
 
Everything everyone says on this matter is just creating conjecture or reciting conjecture created by others.

The Bible says we must go through Jesus to get to the Father. Nowhere does it suggest that we can or should go to Mary to get to Jesus. After his baptism, Jesus addressed Mary as “women” not even “mother”.

An interesting point to this is Joh 2:1-4. This expression was common in the bible, and meant - “what is there in common between me and you?”

See (Jos 22:24; Jg 11:12; 2Sa 16:10; 19:22; 1Ki 17:18; 2Ki 3:13; 2Ch 35:21; Ho 14:8) and six times in the Greek Scriptures: (Mt 8:29; Mr 1:24; 5:7; Lu 4:34; 8:28; Joh 2:4)

Jesus NEVER assigns Mary any position of authority, nor is there good biblical reference for how Catholic’s view Mary. Tradition is all Catholics have to support this doctrine - and yes, it is a doctrine.
 
(Edited)

Catholics can (and should) go through Jesus to the Father. However, doesn’t Paul tell us to pray for each other? That is what we are doing. For example, in the Hail Mary, we ask Mary to pray for us. Now, if you have objections to asking people in heaven to pray for us, that is another thread… I just wanted to make sure you know it isn’t and either / or situation. We can ask Mary to pray for us and we can pray directly to Jesus.

About the term woman, I believe it means the exact opposite of what you are implying. The term woman is used to connect Mary to Eve (Mary is the new Eve) and to the woman in Revelation. This article goes into detail on what I mean:

See the section:
II. The Mother of Jesus
A. Scolding Mary?

salvationhistory.com/studies/lesson/queen_wedding_at_cana_garden_in_eden
 
Catholics can (and should) go through Jesus to the Father. However, doesn’t Paul tell us to pray for each other? That is what we are doing. For example, in the Hail Mary, we ask Mary to pray for us. Now, if you have objections to asking people in heaven to pray for us, that is another thread… I just wanted to make sure you know it isn’t and either / or situation. We can ask Mary to pray for us and we can pray directly to Jesus.
I agree with this. Therefore, there is nothing wrong with praying the Hail Mary prayer, or a number of them in combination with other prayers/meditations/exercises/fasts.

The issue is these alleged ‘promises’.

The original post is in a sense mistermed, because an argument against the promises is not an argument against the rosary, and it should be pointed out that the Catholic church is not making this promise, an apparition of uncertain origin is making the promise. The church has never adopted the promise as a teaching, and does not stand behind it, because it allows any Catholic to disbelieve it in good Faith. So an argument against the promises is not an argument against the Catholic church.

The promise could be utter trash, and it would not be a reflection upon the rosary as a prayer rule whatever.

Now there may be different arguments about which prayers are better or more efficacious or more important to say, but that is an internal matter within the churches. The Catholic church has already come squarely down in favor of the very ancient Liturgy of the Hours as the official and preferred prayer of the entire church. That makes the rosary a popular private devotion (of later origin).
 
To get to the point of honoring Mary the way Catholics do, you need to create some additional words - like they did. Since the bible doesn’t assign any particular word apart from “blessed” (or other words for blessed) to Mary, Catholics needed to create dulia, hyperdulia, and latria. By this way alone can you begin to give Mary honor the way Catholics do. The problem being, you just created words to fit your intentions.

The fact is that people don’t simply “ask” Mary to pray for them like I might of another brother - they pray to Mary to pray for them. When Paul was talking about having brothers pray for one another, it simply meant pray for the benefit of each other. He was NOT saying pray to your brother, so then he may pray to you. The difference is “for” and “to”. Catholic’s pray TO Mary. Also, if you want to view Paul’s counsel that way, could I then create a statue of my brother in my home and pray to it??? Its a perversion of what was said.
 
By the way everyone - take a look at Mt. 6:7 and tell me how reciting the same sorts of prayers are ok.
 
By the way everyone - take a look at Mt. 6:7 and tell me how reciting the same sorts of prayers are ok.
That verse does not mean repeating prayer is bad. It says" In praying, do not babble like the pagans, who think that they will be heard because of their many words." When saying the rosary, you aren’t just saying the words over and over. You are mediating on the, death and resurrection of Christ.

When Jesus was praying before his passion, He went and “said the same thing” 3 times. That is repeating. Look at Psalms 136. In Revelation the four living creatures repeat the same thing over and over (Rev 4:8). So just the act of repeating something isn’t in itself bad.

The four living creatures, each of them with six wings, were covered with eyes inside and out. Day and night they do not stop exclaiming: “Holy, holy, holy is the Lord God almighty, who was, and who is, and who is to come.”
 
To get to the point of honoring Mary the way Catholics do, you need to create some additional words - like they did. Since the bible doesn’t assign any particular word apart from “blessed” (or other words for blessed) to Mary, Catholics needed to create dulia, hyperdulia, and latria. By this way alone can you begin to give Mary honor the way Catholics do. The problem being, you just created words to fit your intentions.

The fact is that people don’t simply “ask” Mary to pray for them like I might of another brother - they pray to Mary to pray for them. When Paul was talking about having brothers pray for one another, it simply meant pray for the benefit of each other. He was NOT saying pray to your brother, so then he may pray to you. The difference is “for” and “to”. Catholic’s pray TO Mary. Also, if you want to view Paul’s counsel that way, could I then create a statue of my brother in my home and pray to it??? Its a perversion of what was said.
To pray means the same as to ask. The man in hell in Jesus’ parables talked to Abraham and asked him to have Lazarus give him some water, if that’s not a prayer to someone on heaven who is not God, I don’t know what is.

And while having a statue of your brother probably isn’t common simply because isn’t a tasteful decoration, would you not have a picture of your brother? Where is Paul’s distinction between pictures and statues? By the way, we don’t pray TO the statues, we simply have them as a reminder of those who have gone on.
 
Regression:

You may want to look at another bible translation. Here is the King James

Mt 6:7 But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking.

I would say vain repetitions is exactly what is bad. Catholic prayers are very repetitious. You believe it matters how many times you can say the same thing over and over. That is the reality of it…it’s undeniable.
 
Regression:

You may want to look at another bible translation. Here is the King James

Mt 6:7 But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking.

I would say vain repetitions is exactly what is bad. Catholic prayers are very repetitious. You believe it matters how many times you can say the same thing over and over. That is the reality of it…it’s undeniable.
No, it is not undeniable, dear. I deny it. And I challenge you to prove that for Catholics it 'matters how many times you say the same thing over and over." So, where exactly in the Catechism does it mention this ‘opinion’ of yours? What exactly does it ‘matter’? What is going on while Catholics say the ‘same thing over and over?’
 
Duffyk4:

The Hebrew scriptures are filled with explicit warnings against any form of statue in our worship to God. The Isrealites tried making a statue of a calf ONLY to assign God’s name to an image. That, like countless other examples, did not go well for those who incorporated statues or images into worship - whether to a false god or the true God.

Paul warns us over and over again to also not use any images in worship. You will say he was only talking about false gods, but he never makes that delineation. This was a big issue for the church, and many Christians broke away from the church due to it’s stance. This debate has been well played out over the years, and ends like most issues do with the church, in that authority to make such decisions emboldens Catholics to incorporate statues into their worship.

If God felt that such use of statues and images where acceptable, why didn’t he allow Isreal to use statues of Moses, Abraham, etc etc…? Remember how Satan and Michael fought over Moses body…? Satan wanted to use Moses body to skew worship that rightly only belongs to God.
 
Duffyk4:

The Hebrew scriptures are filled with explicit warnings against any form of statue in our worship to God. The Isrealites tried making a statue of a calf ONLY to assign God’s name to an image. That, like countless other examples, did not go well for those who incorporated statues or images into worship - whether to a false god or the true God.

Paul warns us over and over again to also not use any images in worship. You will say he was only talking about false gods, but he never makes that delineation. This was a big issue for the church, and many Christians broke away from the church due to it’s stance. This debate has been well played out over the years, and ends like most issues do with the church, in that authority to make such decisions emboldens Catholics to incorporate statues into their worship.
Please demonstrate the that the proper translation of the Hebrew sciptures is “statue” rather than “idol”.
 
Duffyk4:

The Hebrew scriptures are filled with explicit warnings against any form of statue in our worship to God. The Isrealites tried making a statue of a calf ONLY to assign God’s name to an image. That, like countless other examples, did not go well for those who incorporated statues or images into worship - whether to a false god or the true God.

Paul warns us over and over again to also not use any images in worship. You will say he was only talking about false gods, but he never makes that delineation. This was a big issue for the church, and many Christians broke away from the church due to it’s stance. This debate has been well played out over the years, and ends like most issues do with the church, in that authority to make such decisions emboldens Catholics to incorporate statues into their worship.
Iconclastisicism was declared a heresy in the 8th century. You have read about it, correct? Interestingly enough, the Eastern Church --which was particularly affected by those who fell victim to the heresy-- to this day has no problem with icons. If this is such a big deal, then why do both the Eastern and Western Christian Churches have no problem with it? IOW, the Christian Church (Catholic/Orthodox) was beset by heresy over 1000 years ago and both ‘lungs’ have come to the same conclusion and found images to be acceptable in worship. . .but the Johnny-come-latelys have revised the prohibition. . .and not all at that.

What is your opinion, Johnny, on your fellow Protestants. . .the Episcopalians, the Lutherans, the Methodists. . .who have statues in their churches and acknowledge saints in their church names? Who have candles on the altar and stained glass windows? How come they —among the first to ‘protest’ Catholic teaching–accept statutes etc. as perfectly reasonable?
 
Regression:

You may want to look at another bible translation. Here is the King James

Mt 6:7 But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking.

I would say vain repetitions is exactly what is bad. Catholic prayers are very repetitious. You believe it matters how many times you can say the same thing over and over. That is the reality of it…it’s undeniable.
It is very deniable. I do not believe God has a clipboard and is counting how many times I pray a specific prayer when praying the rosary. As I said before, the rosary is a mediation on the life, death and resurrection of Christ. Each decade’s Hail Mary’s are like a “timer” so to speak. IE, I spend time time it takes to say 10 Hail Mary’s to think about, pray about and appreciate the different aspects of Christ’s life and what He did for us.
 
+AJPM+
By the way everyone - take a look at Mt. 6:7 and tell me how reciting the same sorts of prayers are ok.
Oh? Like “For His steadfast love endures forever”? (Psalm 136)

Or how about “Holy, Holy, Holy is the Lord God Almighty”? (Rev. 4:8)

So if the tax collector in Jesus’ parable (Luke 18:13) prayed “God, be merciful to me a sinner!” more than once that time it is not pleasing to God anymore?

:confused::confused::confused:
 
David,

Would you rather i use the term molten image? Several instances occur where the bible writer used a few terms to clarify ANY image…however it was created.
 
David,

Would you rather i use the term molten image? Several instances occur where the bible writer used a few terms to clarify ANY image…however it was created.
What do you think about Nativity scenes? When I was a protestant, there was always one in the sanctuary (right up front) during the entire month of December.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top