Argument against the Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for saying this. I’ve been accused of uncharity for accusing you of this very thing…I don’t see praying to and worship as the same thing.
Understand that I am not conceding your point by saying that we pray to Mary and the saints. The principle planted in your objection is that we are giving to creatures what is due to God alone. The fact is that we are not, and every orthodox Catholic understands this. But if you see a distinction between prayer and worship, then what is the basis for your continued objection to praying to Mary and the saints?

Asking people on earth for intercessory prayer is precisely the same as asking it of the saints in heaven, whether we use the word “prayer” to describe addressing people on earth or not. The substance of the thing at issue is the same.
 
Which is to say, Catholics infer the IC from Luke 1:28, albeit through the circuitous rout of Tradition…(Are you really saying Luke 1:28 provides no support for the IC and/or that it isn’t one of the usual texts used by Catholic apologists when trying to establish a biblical basis for the IC? I ask, because that’s all I’m saying.)
Obviously I’m not saying that Luke 1:28 provides no support for the Doctrine of the Immaculate Conception. After all, I clearly stated that it does. But when this belief was finally officially defined as doctrine (in Ineffabilis Deus), Luke 1:28 was only one thing that was cited. In the full document we also see evidence from Sacred Tradition, biblical typology, the concept of Sensus Fidei, and so on:

papalencyclicals.net/Pius09/p9ineff.htm

So Luke 1:28 plays it part but, as I said previously, we would still have the Doctrine of the Immaculate Conception even if Luke never wrote it.
To that we can add that it is in the vocative case, which is used in salutations. Greek is a highly inflected language. Cases are used where we might use prepositions in English. We can’t modify our participles the way Greek can, so we have to come up with circumlocutions to get at the meaning. The question is, is how much theological meaning can we invest into the term based on the grammar?
As I pointed out in a previous thread, Luke 1:28 can be validly translated as either “highly favored one” or “full of grace.” I gave an overview of the latter, and you have now given an overview of the former. Neither of us has refuted the other’s translation. Therefore, we have simply demonstrated that there is, indeed, more than one possible interpretation. Because the Catholic concept of the Immaculate Doctrine does not hinge on this, suffice to say further debate on Luke 1:28 may no longer be relevant to the discussion at hand. It is still an interesting discussion, but it may now work better as a thread discussion of its own.
In any event, my only issue in raising this whole business of “full of grace” was to point out that most modern translations, including Catholic ones have chosen “favored one” ore even “highly favored.”
I agree. Looking through my own personal Bible collection, I have one English Bible (the Ignatius Press RSV) and one Spanish Bible that uses “full of grace” (or “llena de gracia”). Most of my other Bibles went with “highly favored one” (or something along those lines). I assume I would see the same in Bibles translated into other languages, but I really don’t know. But I see no reason to dispute the idea that as far as the majority of modern scholars are concerned, of the two possible translations, the “favored one” is, indeed, the favored one. And I believe that they exercised academic integrity and competence in reaching such a postion.
LOL. Those biased translators!
Yeah - LOL - I guess we have to admire the marketing strategy, though.
 
Understand that I am not conceding your point by saying that we pray to Mary and the saints. The principle planted in your objection is that we are giving to creatures what is due to God alone. The fact is that we are not, and every orthodox Catholic understands this. But if you see a distinction between prayer and worship, then what is the basis for your continued objection to praying to Mary and the saints?

Asking people on earth for intercessory prayer is precisely the same as asking it of the saints in heaven, whether we use the word “prayer” to describe addressing people on earth or not. The substance of the thing at issue is the same.
Well after I brought up Joshua he modified his argument to “give to man what is due God alone”, I haven’t gotten a response yet RE Job or my clarification that St. Michael the Archangel is indeed a created being thus no matter how you slice it, Joshua was worshiping a created being who is not God.
 
Further, I submit that once we have clearly explained what we do, and supported it, it is rude for anyone to continue to insist something else just because they have a different belief.
Yep. It’s tough to root out deeply-held prejudices, and tough to have to acknowledge that the trusted spiritual leader who taught them the contrary about the Catholic Church was not altogether honest with them. So the only thing they have left to fall back on, in order to remain true to the prejudices, is to conclude that we must be deluded.

So let me address this to the non-Catholics who think we’re deluded: quit going to guys like Jimmy Swaggart and Loraine Boettner and Tony Alamo, or their disciples, or disaffected Catholic apostates in your congregation, to find out what Catholics believe. The teachings of the Catholic Church are not secret. Go to the Church to find out the truth.
 
Regardless, Joshua worshiped a created being, not God and you really can’t dance around that one.
That has yet to be established. And if he was worshipping an angel, then you have an even greater theological problem, since you’d have to explain why it’s okay for Joshua to bow down to an angel, but not okay for John in Revelation. That would violate the doctrine of inerrancy, which at least the conservatives in your denomination still uphold.
This is what praying to the saints is, you really can’t argue against this because if you do you directly contradict any idea that you’re allowed to ask others to pray for you, as well as your ability to pray for others.
I’m not buying that asking someone on earth to pray for me is the same as “praying to” someone in heaven in order to ask them to pray for me. If you’re right and I’m wrong, then the worse case scenario is that I’m praying to God alone. No sin in that. But if I’m right, and you’re wrong, the worse case scenario is that you’re committing idolatry of the gravest kind. I don’t think the kinds of circumstantial, leaky-bucket arguments I’m seeing in this thread are good enough justification for me (or anyone else) to risk praying to Mary or the saints. I’m playing it safe.
As we know, neither death, nor principalities or powers can seperate us from the body of Christ.
I think Paul said it this way:
“For I am convinced that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor any other created thing, will be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.” (Romans 8:38-39)
We cannot be separated from the love of God. We can be and in fact are separated temporarily from the faithful departed. But neither they, nor we are separated from God.
If one “dies” a member of Christs body then they are not dead but alive, thus they can pray for you.
Again, this has yet to be established.
 
Still waiting for you, Miguel, to show the consistent Christian teaching, historically, that Christians did not ‘pray to the saints.’
Why do I need to show this? I’m not the one who teaches as a dogma that it is permissible to pray to someone other than God. Nor do I subscribe to the theory that Christians throughout the ages never got it wrong until the 16th century.
Ever seen the inscriptions in the catecombs, Miguel?
In 1986, I took the catacombs tour in Rome. So yes, I’ve seen them. Is it good theology? That’s a better question. You seem to think it’s good simply because it’s old. I have a different criteria for making that determination. (God’s word, which is even older.)
 
That has yet to be established. And if he was worshipping an angel, then you have an even greater theological problem, since you’d have to explain why it’s okay for Joshua to bow down to an angel, but not okay for John in Revelation. That would violate the doctrine of inerrancy, which at least the conservatives in your denomination still uphold.
I have no theological problem, it was perfectly OK for Joshua to do what he did because due to the nature of Man’s fall we were considered inferior to Angles. Thus angels were rightly offered a non-divine worship, exactly how the bible states it in the book of Joshua (I quoted KJV, Douay uses the same language, as does NAB, Darby, ASV, ESV etc). John was asked not to worship in the same manner because due to the nature of the incarnation God evelavated man to the state of adopted sons (commonly referred to as divination). Now, as scripture says, we know things which the angels long to. That said, such elevation does not eliminate our ability to pray for one another, nor would it eliminate the ability of an angel to pray for us. We ask them to do so, by praying to them.
I’m not buying that asking someone on earth to pray for me is the same as “praying to” someone in heaven in order to ask them to pray for me. If you’re right and I’m wrong, then the worse case scenario is that I’m praying to God alone. No sin in that. But if I’m right, and you’re wrong, the worse case scenario is that you’re committing idolatry of the gravest kind. I don’t think the kinds of circumstantial, leaky-bucket arguments I’m seeing in this thread are good enough to risk praying to Mary or the saints. I’m playing it safe.
No sin in that, other than you’re ignoring scripture and the constant teaching of Christianity now going into it’s third milleniam 🙂 What is the consequence of this? The consequence is you’re denying your self aid, look again at Job Migel. God wouldn’t accept the prayers of Eliphaz due to the nature of his sins. Indeed in James it says
Jas 5:16 Confess therefore your sins one to another: and pray one for another, that you may be saved. For the continual prayer of a just man availeth much.
Who is more just I ask, you? Me? Or Gods mother in heaven?
I think Paul said it this way:

We cannot be separated from the love of God. We can and are separated temporarily from the faithful departed. But neither they, nor we are separated from God.

Again, this has yet to be established.
What you say here makes aboslutly no sense what so ever… If the “dead” don’t know what is going on here, then either they aren’t members of the Body of Christ or we aren’t. Which of those do you prefer to believe? What about

“There will be more rejoicing in heaven over the repentance of one sinner than for 100 richous men”? How will there be much rejoincing in heaven of the Saints and Angels have no clue what is going on? What exactly do you do with the Parable of Lazerous?
 
My the way Miguel, consider this:

If you’re wrong not only do you personally believe error, but you’re actually teaching error to fellow believers and evangalizing non-believers to believe an erroneous teaching. How does that usually stack up in the many thousands of years of judeo Christian tradition? I believe St. Paul said:
1Co 15:17 And if Christ be not risen again, your faith is vain: for you are yet in your sins.
1Co 15:18 Then they also that are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.
This is a man who knows full well, and isn’t afraid to discuss the consequences of getting it wrong.
 
What you say here makes aboslutly no sense what so ever… If the “dead” don’t know what is going on here, then either they aren’t members of the Body of Christ or we aren’t. Which of those do you prefer to believe?
That makes no sense. We don’t know what’s going on in heaven. By your logic, we’d have to conclude that we’re not in the body of Christ. Further, I am not saying that the faithful departed do not know what is going on here. They might, they might not. I’m not sure exactly. But whether they do know or not, what does that have to do with being in the body of Christ? I don’t know what Christians are doing all over the world right now. My limitations in awareness and knowledge do not thereby exclude me from the body of Christ, or them. You’re making no sense here.
 
Why do I need to show this? I’m not the one who teaches as a dogma that it is permissible to pray to someone other than God. Nor do I subscribe to the theory that Christians throughout the ages never got it wrong until the 16th century.

In 1986, I took the catacombs tour in Rome. So yes, I’ve seen them. Is it good theology? That’s a better question. You seem to think it’s good simply because it’s old. I have a different criteria for making that determination. (God’s word, which is even older.)
If you are a Christian, then you SHOULD be teaching as a revealed Christian truth that it is permissible to pray (which means ASK, not WORSHIP) to any person. I pray you, will you say a prayer for me? And of course, if you think Christians ‘got it wrong’ before the 16th century–you’re right in one sense and wrong in another. Certainly any individual Christians ‘could and did get it wrong’ at times. But the Church never got any of its teachings on faith and morals wrong. Ever. St. Paul had to admonish the ones who made errors to ‘take it to the Church’ to get a definitive answer. And the gnostics and Arians and Pelagians and Monophytes and Iconoclasts (as we now call them) all THOUGHT that ‘they’ were ‘interpreting right’–until The Church proved them wrong.

So if the prayers to people (saints) in the catacombs would be ‘bad theology’ (and I am NOT thinking it is good simply because it is old, you just put words in my mouth there), where exactly is the ‘good theology’ that gives the consistent apostolic teaching that St. Paul and the others never prayed to saints? Never taught it was permitted to pray (ask, not worship) saints? You won’t find it because St. Paul never spoke ‘against’ it, never taught against it, it is a chimera made up by some (not all) Protestants because of their mistaken private interpretation of cherry picked Scripture which they were told by their own ‘leaders’ and chose to accept in SPITE of the clear consistent Christian teaching otherwise.

Because if you ever did acknowledge that early Christians ‘did’ what Catholics now do, and which you reject. . .then you’d have a big problem. Because how would you justify that you’re acting ‘differently’ from the gospel that St. Paul taught? Trying to make it appear that St. Paul actually taught what you teach doesn’t work when we have no instances until AD 1500 of anybody teaching what you teach on prayer, but rather of teaching the CATHOLIC position all those years.

It may take a little longer (but then as Psalm 90 tells us, A thousand years in God’s sight are as yesterday’) but The Catholic Church will prevail. It always has. It always will. That’s GOD’s promise to us, and I do believe in His word. I’ll trust Him and the Church He established to guide and protect us with the Holy Spirit over the teachings of men.
 
That makes no sense. We don’t know what’s going on in heaven. By your logic, we’d have to conclude that we’re not in the body of Christ. Further, I am not saying that the faithful departed do not know what is going on here. They might, they might not. I’m not sure exactly. But whether they do know or not, what does that have to do with being in the body of Christ? I don’t know what Christians are doing all over the world right now. My limitations in awareness and knowledge do not thereby exclude me from the body of Christ, or them. You’re making no sense here.
By our own right, no we don’t know what is going on in heaven. But do you deny that God gave us a glimps of what is going on in heaven? I would find that eye opening… God was expliciate, and the constant tradition of Christianity has been to pray to our “fallen bretheren”.

In fact if you visit Saints Peter and Pauls tomb in Rome (original) you will still see scrawled in latin on the walls (several thousands years old) “St. Peter, St. Paul Pray for us”. If you read the writings of the early Christians going back to the very begining you will see exortation to pray to the saints. If you read scripture, you will see constant exortation to do exactly this (unless of course your faith tradition disallows you to believe it).
 
Saints in Heaven are Aware of What Takes Place on Earth:

For the sake of this discussion, I would like to point out that there is scriptural evidence that the saints in heaven are aware of what is happening on earth, and that they ask God to do things to people on earth as a result. This comes from John’s vision of the martyrs in heaven:

“I saw underneath the altar the souls of those who had been slaughtered because of the witness they bore to the word of God. They cried out in a loud voice, ‘How long will it be, holy and true master, before you sit in judgment and avenge our blood on the inhabitants of the earth?’” (Revelation 6:9-10)

These martyrs are aware that those who persecuted them during their earthly lives have not yet been brought to justice. Therefore, at least in this regard, the martyrs are aware of what is happening on earth.

Saints in Heaven Pray to God to Do Things to People on Earth:

In the above example, the martyrs pray that God enacts divine justice on their persecutors. Admittedly, for the discussion at hand, I would like to have found an image of a saint in heaven asking God to heal the illness of someone on earth, or to restore a lost puppy, or something like that. But even though the martyrs are asking God to avenge them, the essence is that they are asking God to do something to people on earth.

This opens up the possibility that in addition to asking God to send divine justice upon evil people on earth, the martyrs could likewise ask God to send blessings upon the good (especially in light of the fact that if we continue the reading from Revelation 6, we see that the martyrs are informed that even more people on earth will have to suffer for the Faith, so they are aware of this as well). I admit, however, that this is speculation based on the text, and therefore the text itself does not clearly show such a thing. I also admit that this biblical passage does not demonstrate a person on earth praying to these martyrs, but such a thing is not the intention of this particular post. Rather, my position here is that saints in heaven are aware of what happens to people on earth, and ask God to do things to people on earth accordingly. The above quote from Revelations shows that this happens at least on some level.
 
Saints in Heaven are Aware of What Takes Place on Earth:

For the sake of this discussion, I would like to point out that there is scriptural evidence that the saints in heaven are aware of what is happening on earth, and that they pray on behalf of people on earth as a result. This comes from John’s vision of the martyrs in heaven:

“I saw underneath the altar the souls of those who had been slaughtered because of the witness they bore to the word of God. They cried out in a loud voice, ‘How long will it be, holy and true master, before you sit in judgment and avenge our blood on the inhabitants of the earth?’” (Revelation 6:9-10)
I had this passage in mind too, which is why I said in the previous post that I wasn’t sure if the saints in heaven have an awareness of things on earth or not. But I think you’d have to agree that this passage still isn’t decisive. They could be referring to a memory of their own martyrdom rather than presently viewing earth from heaven. As for taking this as evidence for intercessory prayer, you’re reading far too much into this text. There is no evidence that they are praying on behalf of their fellow martyrs. In fact, you could read them as only concerned for their own blood. “How long before you avenge our blood?” I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt and suppose that “our” refers to both those on heaven and those about to be martyred on earth. But we’re still a Looooooong way from asking saints to pray for us, since it’s not at all clear that they’re interceding for the other saints. They’re asking a question: “How long?” Notice also that there is no evidence here that the saints on earth are invoking the saints in heaven.
I admit, however, that this is speculation based on the text, and therefore the text itself does not clearly show such a thing.
That is the safe way to play it. It strikes me that most of your arguments along these lines, while well reasoned, still suffer plausibility problems. Too many things have to fall into place in precisely the way you suggest (when there may be far more likely scenarios in mind). It seems that so much energy is spent showing how it could be this, if only x, and then with the passage of time, y, and so on so that you can finally conclude: “While I haven’t proven X from scripture, I’ve at least shown how it might be logically inferred from scripture and at the very minimum that it doesn’t contradict scripture.” Compare that to Jesus: “You err because you do not know the scriptures” (Matthew 22:29). (There’s a little more teeth in Jesus’ statement.)
 
I had this passage in mind too, which is why I said in the previous post that I wasn’t sure if the saints in heaven have an awareness of things on earth or not. But I think you’d have to agree that this passage still isn’t decisive. They could be referring to a memory of their own martyrdom rather than presently viewing earth from heaven. As for taking this as evidence for intercessory prayer, you’re reading far too much into this text. There is no evidence that they are praying on behalf of their fellow martyrs. In fact, you could read them as only concerned for their own blood. “How long before you avenge our blood?” I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt and suppose that “our” refers to both those on heaven and those about to be martyred on earth. But we’re still a Looooooong way from asking saints to pray for us, since it’s not at all clear that they’re interceding for the other saints. They’re asking a question: “How long?” Notice also that there is no evidence here that the saints on earth are invoking the saints in heaven.

That is the safe way to play it. It strikes me that most of your arguments along these lines, while well reasoned, still suffer plausibility problems. Too many things have to fall into place in precisely the way you suggest (when there may be far more likely scenarios in mind). It seems that so much energy is spent showing how it could be this, if only x, and then with the passage of time, y, and so on so that you can finally conclude: “While I haven’t proven X from scripture, I’ve at least shown how it might be logically inferred from scripture and at the very minimum that it doesn’t contradict scripture.” Compare that to Jesus: “You err because you do not know the scriptures” (Matthew 22:29). (There’s a little more teeth in Jesus’ statement.)
This raises another question. Which Saints in Heaven do you recognize and why?
 
As for taking this as evidence for intercessory prayer, you’re reading far too much into this text. There is no evidence that they are praying on behalf of their fellow martyrs.
And I admited as much when I posted it.
In fact, you could read them as only concerned for their own blood. “How long before you avenge our blood?”
It does not matter who the word “our” refers to. My point is that a saint in heaven is asking God to do something to someone who is still on earth. In this case, it is enacting divine retribution on evil people.
I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt and suppose that “our” refers to both those on heaven and those about to be martyred on earth. But we’re still a Looooooong way from asking saints to pray for us, since it’s not at all clear that they’re interceding for the other saints.
I tried to be very clear that I was not presenting that particular quote as evidence of intercessory prayer. There has been some recent discussion in this thread as to whether or not saints in heaven are aware of events happening on earth, and whether they feel compelled to do something about it. The quote from Revelation clearly shows this that they are aware and that they are doing something about it. As with any passage from Scripture, the human imagination can come up with other interpretations, but the plain words of the passage in question throw a lot of weight into my interpretation.
They’re asking a question: “How long?” Notice also that there is no evidence here that the saints on earth are invoking the saints in heaven.
I admitted as much. You’re looking at my last post as a suggested proof of intercessory prayer. I clearly stated what my last post was for, and what I think it accomplished.
That is the safe way to play it. It strikes me that most of your arguments along these lines, while well reasoned, still suffer plausibility problems. Too many things have to fall into place in precisely the way you suggest (when there may be far more likely scenarios in mind). It seems that so much energy is spent showing how it could be this, if only x, and then with the passage of time, y, and so on so that you can finally conclude: “While I haven’t proven X from scripture, I’ve at least shown how it might be logically inferred from scripture and at the very minimum that it doesn’t contradict scripture.” Compare that to Jesus: “You err because you do not know the scriptures” (Matthew 22:29). (There’s a little more teeth in Jesus’ statement.)
From a Catholic perspective there is no plausibility problem. As I have repeatedly said, praying to the saints is a Doctrine of the Faith, and therefore has its origins in God. Simply put, we pray to the saints because Jesus said we can.

And speaking of translations, I will take your critique from the above quote and paraphrase it to show what is really going on here:

Miguel to Catholics in this Forum: “Defend the Catholic doctrine of praying to saints using the Protestant doctrine of Sola Scriptura.” Even though you have not used the exact term “Sola Scriptura”, you are using the language of it, and expect Catholics to prove our case according to its rules. When I say that you are using the language of Sola Scriptura, I offer the following quotes you made as evidence of that:

Post #48: “…(praying to saints) doesn’t seem to be the kind of thing that we can explain as a legitimate “development” from what is already “implicit” in Scripture.”

Post #54: “In order to ask departed saints to pray for us, you have to pray to them. There’s no Biblical example of anyone doing this. I’m going to play at safe and assume that since only prayer to God is sanctioned, that’s the only kind of prayer that is legitimate.”

Post #57: “Where do you find prayer to anyone but God as legitimate in scripture? And if there is no example, then are there at least biblical principles from which we could deduce/infer that the development of such a practice is in fact legitimate?”

Post #63: “Is there an example of this somewhere in scripture?”
And…
“Wow. I find it incredible that God would approve of such a practice and not mention a word about it in scripture.”
And…
“This is a spiritual practice. And yet no one seems to engage in it from Genesis to Revelation.”

You have stated that my defense of the practice of praying to the saints lacks plausibility based on what is being inferred from Scripture. Maybe that’s true. But if plausibility is so important to determining what ought to be and what ought not be a Christian practice then I challenge you to demonstrate the plausibility of Sola Scriptura from the Bible. As far as I am concerned, Catholics have more of a scriptural basis for believing in the concept of praying to the saints than Protestants have for believing in Sola Scriptura.
 
Which might only show how early things went wrong.
I’m curious. When, according to you, were things “right” after the death of the Apostle John and prior to the Reformation? In other words, can you point to a time in the early Church and cite historical/patristic evidence that the Church - as a whole - at one time adhered to your theology?
 
From a Catholic perspective there is no plausibility problem. As I have repeatedly said, praying to the saints is a Doctrine of the Faith, and therefore has its origins in God. Simply put, we pray to the saints because Jesus said we can.
How do you know Jesus said so? This is really the crux of the issue. You claim this doctrine comes from Jesus–that he “said so.” How do you know?
You have stated that my defense of the practice of praying to the saints lacks plausibility based on what is being inferred from Scripture. Maybe that’s true. But if plausibility is so important to determining what ought to be and what ought not be a Christian practice then I challenge you to demonstrate the plausibility of Sola Scriptura from the Bible.
Why do I have to demonstrate this from the Bible? (I’m not saying I can’t. There is plenty of reason to make God’s written word our theological starting point. But why do you add, “from the Bible” to your challenge to demonstrate the plausibility of sola scriptura?) I ask because I suspect that you think that, by hypothesis, I have to. But that’s not true once you understand what an axiom or starting point is.

For example, if we claim to know a proposition, P, then do we first have to know that we know P? And if we have to know that we know P, then do we have to know that we know that we know? What I am getting at is this. We cannot posit an infinite regress of requirements in order to have knowledge (at least in our every day truth claims regarding propositions.)

Sola scriptura is an axiom or theological starting point. As such it cannot be demonstrated since whatever one would appeal to derive it, would then be logically prior to it. (It’s kind of like asking, “Who created God?” God is the beginning. Once you understand what “God” means, the question can’t arise in the first place.) No one can prove a principle. All that you can do is give plausible reasons for why your principle is a better starting point than some other. To that end, I think I have good reasons for sola scriptura. Let’s do the math. If there are three “contenders” for being the rule of faith (scripture, tradition and the magisterium) and if two out of three of them have erred by contradicting the third, then 3-2 = 1. The only “contender” still standing is the Bible (and liberals everywhere want to knock that one down too).
As far as I am concerned, Catholics have more of a scriptural basis for believing in the concept of praying to the saints than Protestants have for believing in Sola Scriptura.
I guess that’s why you’re a Catholic. But I would argue on the basis of how doctrinal issues are debated in scripture for the preeminence of scripture. We all know what is said about scripture’s inspiration. Nothing like this is said about the magisterium or tradition. I can show you from the book of Revelation, for example, that John believes that not only the Lord’s oral word, but also his written word is infallibly true. John makes this argument on the basis of God’s character, the “faithful and true Amen.” I’d even concede that perhaps scripture doesn’t close the door on other sources of revelation or infallible authority. But I just don’t see it positively teaching this about anything else. So as a matter of prudence, it’s better to trust what we know to be true than what theoretically might be true. Since all interested parties in this debate accept scripture as authoritative, that’s probably the safest starting point. But that’s really a matter for another thread, don’t you think?
 
Tradition precedes a lot of scripture, in time. Particularly the New Testament.

So, if everything hinges on Scripture, and then, at some point, “it” went wrong (and if Evangelicals assert this, then they agree with Mormons, which is an interesting pairing!) then Miguel needs to tell us when, where and how it went wrong. Please provide names and dates as well as documentation.

I second RBK’s request ~ “When, according to you, were things “right” after the death of the Apostle John and prior to the Reformation? In other words, can you point to a time in the early Church and cite historical/patristic evidence that the Church - as a whole - at one time adhered to your theology?”

Let’s see the evidence. Or is it just your opinion?
 
You claim this doctrine comes from Jesus–that he “said so.” How do you know?
Because Christ is the head of the Church, and has given the Church the guidance and authority to interpret the Deposit of Faith.
Why do I have to demonstrate this from the Bible? (I’m not saying I can’t. There is plenty of reason to make God’s written word our theological starting point. But why do you add, “from the Bible” to your challenge to demonstrate the plausibility of sola scriptura?)
I have no problem with starting with a hypothesis, but the conclusion has to be in keeping with the Law of Noncontradition. Truth cannot contain a contradiction, and because God is Truth Itself, this logic can be applied to Christian doctrine.

Sola Scriptura means “Scripture Alone.” The idea is that if a proposed doctrine is not demonstrated in Scripture then it should be rejected. The doctrine of Sola Scriptura fails its own test, because no where does the Bible teach it. Therefore the doctrine of Sola Scriptura contains a contradiction, because if it is true, it teaches us to reject it. To put this another way, it is an extra-biblical teaching that tells us to reject extra-biblical teachings.
Let’s do the math. If there are three “contenders” for being the rule of faith (scripture, tradition and the magisterium) and if two out of three of them have erred by contradicting the third, then 3-2 = 1. The only “contender” still standing is the Bible (and liberals everywhere want to knock that one down too).
I know of no contradictions between Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the official interpretations of the Magisterium regarding them.
I guess that’s why you’re a Catholic.
It would be more accurate to say that this is one of the reasons I became a Catholic. I was very resistant to the idea at first, and in trying to refute Catholic positions I ended up discovering the truths of them.
But I would argue on the basis of how doctrinal issues are debated in scripture for the preeminence of scripture. We all know what is said about scripture’s inspiration.
I agree that Scripture is divinely inspired. I will also point out that a lot of the books that make up the Bible don’t expressly designate themselves to be divinely inspired, leaving the Magisterium the job of determining this. I propose that the Letter of Paul to Philemon is one such example.
Nothing like this is said about the magisterium or tradition.
Sacred Tradition & Magisterium:

St. Paul says that he passes on Christian teaching through a variety of means, including the written word as well as by the spoken word and by his example (2Thess 2:15; Col 4:9). If Sola Scriptura were true, he would have mentioned the written word and stopped there.

St. Paul tells us to accept the traditions passed down by him and the Church (2Thess 3:6; 1Cor 11:2).

There are doctrines and teachings accepted by Protestants that not found in the Bible, such as the Doctrine of the Holy Trinity, and the practice of transferring the observance of the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. These are examples of Sacred Tradition.

St. Paul states the Church to be the pillar and bulark of the truth (1Timothy 3:15). If he were a proponent of Sola Scriptura he would have credited such a profound statement to Scripture, not the Church.

The Canon of Scripture itself was determined by an action of the Magisterium. In antiquity what we think of as the Bible was a collection of scrolls from both the Old Testament era and the New Testament era. Furthermore, there were many religious scrolls that arose from both Jewish and Christian communities that many considered divinely inspired. The Magisterium addressed this situation by determining which scrolls were and were not divinely inspired. This is why, for example, the Gospel of John is in the Bible but the Gospel of Thomas is not.
I can show you from the book of Revelation, for example, that John believes that not only the Lord’s oral word, but also his written word is infallibly true.
I believe this as well. But since you mentioned Revelation, it is worth noting that many ancient Christians did not believe it was truly inspired. Nevertheless, the Magisterium declared it to be so, and therefore it is in the Bible. So in light of this, it is tricky to use the Book of Revelation in a way that reject’s the authority of the Magisterium.
So as a matter of prudence, it’s better to trust what we know to be true than what theoretically might be true.
In Christianity, for 1500 years there was no question that Sacred Tradition was one of the means through which we receive divine revelation. No one ever suggested that it might not be true until the Protestant Reformation. I agree that Catholics and Protestants can have a lot of dialog centered on the Bible for the fact that we all agree that it is divinely inspired. It is an important area of common ground between us. But this does not mean that the validity of Catholic doctrines have to demonstrated according to the rules of Sola Scriptura.
Since all interested parties in this debate accept scripture as authoritative, that’s probably the safest starting point. But that’s really a matter for another thread, don’t you think?
I agree that the concept of Sola Scriptura is more than enough to warrant its own thread. I assume that discussions on it regularly come up in this forum anyway. As for the discussion at hand, I think it is fine if Catholics want to discuss the merits of praying to saints based on Scripture. After all, as you know, I have thrown in my two-cents here and there along these lines. But I think it is also important to note that, for Catholics, Scripture is not the only source for doctrine.
 
Sola Scriptura means “Scripture Alone.” The idea is that if a proposed doctrine is not demonstrated in Scripture then it should be rejected. The doctrine of Sola Scriptura fails its own test, because no where does the Bible teach it. Therefore the doctrine of Sola Scriptura contains a contradiction, because if it is true, it teaches us to reject it. To put this another way, it is an extra-biblical teaching that tells us to reject extra-biblical teachings.
“Sola scriptura” does mean scripture alone. But I think what stands behind it is far more than these two words. It began as a slogan and then was later articulated as a principle or starting point. Loosely speaking, we can call it a doctrine. But in fact I think it’s more correct to call it a presupposition form which doctrine is derived. Functionally, it is a shorthand expression for the sufficiency of scripture in matters of faith and morals. For it to be true, it does not have to teach its own sufficiency (even though it does). We do not derive the sufficiency, we presuppose it. Similarly, Catholics begin with the Church as their starting point. It would be silly for me to require of you to prove the Church is infallible by asking you to derive this from the Church itself. Consider this statement: “I believe the Catholic Church is infallible because the infallible Catholic Church tells me so.” That’s tautologous. Even if I were to show you where the Bible points to the sufficiency of scripture, the very process I used would be tautologous, since I would have to assume the truth of the principle (which I do) in order to demonstrate the truth of the principle (which I knew all along).

Your argument above is based on a misconception of what stands behind sola scriptura and fails to distinguish between first principles and truths derived form first principles. Imagine, for example, that we found a clear, unequivocal statement in scripture that all parties would agree as claim for sola scriptura. Something like, “All books that are scripture are not only inspired, but also sufficient for determining matters of doctrine and nothing else such as tradition or the magisterium is of equal authority.” Before I could appeal to this verse to demonstrate/prove/establish sola scriptura, I’d have to already know this verse is authoritative. But how would I know that? If I appeal to the Bible, then I argue in a circle.

Catholics, of course, are in the same boat with respect to their starting point. Any attempt to prove one’s principle by using the very components of one’s principle to do so, is circular reasoning. I’ve seen Catholics, for example, show how the fathers quote earlier fathers to prove tradition. That’s all well and good for those who already take the fathers as authoritative. So any argument that reduces to, “We know that the rule of faith is Scripture + Tradition + Magisterium because any combination of Scripture, Tradition and the Magisterium says so,” is also at the end of the day, circular.

What we can do is argue for why one theological starting point is better than the other. But proving those starting points by assuming those starting points, isn’t really “proof.”

I would say that if one were to read the Bible skeptically (i.e., without assuming its divine inspiration and authority), one could still arrive at the idea that scripture is the final court of appeal just by reading it to see how the people within its pages established doctrines. That is, one could derive sola scriptura from the Bible alone. But that still wouldn’t prove it. Because I’d still need to know that my authority was itself authoritative. The fact, for example, that 2 Timothy 3:16 says “all scripture” is inspired means nothing unless I already believe 2 Timothy is scripture. But how do we know this?

You say, “because the Catholic Church tells me so.” But how do you know that the Catholic Church is correct? At this point in the argument, you can’t assume the Catholic Church just has it right. Nor can you appeal to scripture and say, “I believe the Catholic Church is right in claiming 2 Timothy to be inspired because the Bible tells me that the Catholic Church has the authority to tell me what books go in the Bible.” (This is likewise circular.)

What you can do is advance an argument for why it is better to start with Scripture + Tradition + the Magisterium. But do be careful not to beg the question.

Am I making any sense?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top