Argument against the Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Part of understanding the Communion of Saints, is that we ask for those living and dead to intercede or carry our prayers to Jesus.
In other words, your pray to someone other than God. In the history of the people of God from Genesis to Revelation, is there anyone who ever prays to a departed believer? I ask, because it seems to me that whenever Israel was tempted to adopt the religion of its neighbors, which would include “praying to” someone other than the God of Israel, well, I think you know what happened.
Mary is a part of this Communion of Saints. She is in a very real sense, our mystical connection to the spiritual Church.
That you believe this is “mystical” to me. How do you go from “blessed among woman” to “mystical connection to the spiritual Church”? I don’t get it.
How do we understand this? In Gen. 3:15 we see from the very beginning that God gives Mary a unique role in salvation history. God says “I will put enmity between you and the woman, between your seed and her seed.”
Yes, the protoevengelium. I’m on board with this…
The phrase “her seed” is not seen elsewhere in Scripture. The Scriptures begin and end with the woman battling Satan.
As I read Genesis 3:15, it says “he will bruise your head.” It sounds like the battle is between Mary’s offspring (Jesus) and the devil, not Mary and the devil. Also, it isn’t clear that Mary is the primary referent of “woman” in Revelation 12. But even if she is, where is she “battling” Satan? If Mary is foremost in mind, which has to be argued rather than assumed, where is she going “mano a mano” with the dragon?
 
In other words, your pray to someone other than God. In the history of the people of God from Genesis to Revelation, is there anyone who ever prays to a departed believer? I ask, because it seems to me that whenever Israel was tempted to adopt the religion of its neighbors, which would include “praying to” someone other than the God of Israel, well, I think you know what happened.
As was mentioned earlier in this thread, praying is not the same as worship. It can be, but it can also mean “to ask”. When I “pray to Mary” or “pray to the saints”, I am asking them to pray for me.

Your analogy of Israel adopting the religion of its neighbors couldn’t be farther from what Catholics do when they pray to the saints / Mary. Never once have I ever been told to put someone or something equal to or higher than God. Which is what the Israelites did.
 
The rosary is really meant to be a meditative prayer – we are to be meditating on the particular decade mystery while praying the 10 Hail Mary’s of that decade. The Hail Mary’s then serve as kind of a holy timer for that particular meditation! 🙂
When prayed this way, as it is meant to be prayed, it soon becomes obvious how Christ centered the rosary is.

But, I had a very difficult time praying the rosary in this manner - meditating on the mystery rather than the actual words. Don’t know why, since my mind had no problem taking off on tangents and thinking about cooking supper, cleaning, you name it, while I was praying the Hail Mary’s!:confused: Always very annoying when that type of thing happens.
Anyway, I was introduced to the Scriptural rosary - where a different line from Scripture, relating to the particular mystery, is recited/read before each Hail Mary of the decade. This was a big aid. And then, a few years later, as my father was dying and I was in the hospital praying, all of a sudden it just happened. I became totally absorbed in meditation of the mystery (without the aid of my scriptural rosary booklet) as I silently prayed the Hail Mary’s. A breakthrough I guess, because after that it was no longer a problem. And the insights as I’ve prayed the rosary have been wonderful. I really think the practice of using the Scriptural rosary booklet prepared the way for me to be able to meditate now without the use of the booklet.

Has anyone else had particular aids that have helped them in mediation on the mysteries?
 
If “objective” means “formal equivalence,” then there is no way to get “full of grace” out of
κεχαριτωμένη. In other words, if you want to have an accurate rendering of the Greek, then “full of grace,” isn’t a good choice. The Bible does say “full of grace” or πλήρης χάριτος (John 1:14, and Acts 6:8), so if that’s what Luke/Gabriel intended to say about Mary, why not use πλήρης χάριτος as in Acts 6:8 (also written by Luke)? Further, since Catholics infer that Mary was conceived without sin on the basis of Luke 1:28 (which doesn’t actually say, “full of grace,”) could we also infer that Stephen was immaculately conceived since the text (Acts 6:8) actually does say “full of grace?”
Catholics do not infer the Immaculate Conception of Mary based on Luke 1:28. All Luke 1:28 acts to do is provide scriptural support for Sacred Tradition. A literal examination of the Greek text shows that it is indeed expressing the language of being highly favored but there is a lot more going on here. The problem is that kecharitomene is a perfect past participle, meaning “you who are already favored/graced.” The grammar implies something that has reached its completion (i.e., “full”, “finished”, etc.). Whatever it is cannot be in conjunction with her motherhood, because her motherhood has not yet been mentioned, nor has she consented yet to be the mother of the Messiah.

If we assume that she is favored because God has sent an angel to her with an invitation, then it is notable that this happens frequently in the Bible but no one else is greeted with “kecharitomene.” Plus, such an interpretation does not take into account the perfect past participle nature of the statement. In other words, is the archangel really saying something along the lines of, “Rejoice you who have been completely favored by God in the past”? That seems highly unlikely. The traditional Catholic interpretation is that Mary is favored because she already experiences, in its completion, the fruits of the salvation that God will offer to all (the salvation being the grace/favor).

Although Luke describes Stephen as being “full of grace” in Acts 6:8, the grace he experienced was a gift that came upon him at that moment. Therefore, the Greek in Acts 6:8 does not say that Stephen was “already filled with grace” which is why there is a difference in the Greek Luke selected between Luke 1:28 and Acts 6:8.

But people can interpret this anyway they want. God has revealed that Mary is the Immaculate Conception, so this would be true even if Luke had never written his gospel.
And in the opinion of most translators, Jerome made a mistake. Or do you subscribe to the infallibility of Jerome?
I do not subscribe to the infallibility of Jerome. I do, however, subscribe to the infallibility of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church through whom there is a guaranteed guidance in the correct interpretation of Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. And it is one thing for a translator to disagree with St. Jerome’s choice of words (and therefore use the “favored one” expression), but quite another thing for one to say that he “made a mistake.” I don’t think there are any Scripture scholars out there who go that far. If you disagree then I’ll ask you for a quote.
I wonder what version of the RSV you’re reading, because mine says “highly favored” (Luke 1:28, RSV). You might want to double-check this.
Ok, I double-checked. The Ignatius Press RSV says “full of grace” and the New Oxford RSV says “O favored one.” So one version for the Catholics and another version for the Protestants. Go figure.
“Some scholars?” Just “some”? How about almost “all” of them, Protestant and Catholic?
As I stated above, they are preferring to go with a stricter literal translation, but notice they also felt the need to switch the tense to make it sound smoother in English (i.e, they took it out of the perfect past participle, and therefore the implications of the perfect past participle are lost). So even the stricter literal translation does not capture all that is actually being expressed. Plus, there are also scholars who agree with the “favored one” translation and yet also agree that it has a greater significance than a simple greeting. For example, whatever it is, it is being used by Gabriel as a title, and this is the only time in the Bible an angel greets someone with a title rather than a personal name. All this is just the sort of thing a Greek scholar has to grapple with. St. Jerome’s term “full of grace” allows for taking all the various considerations into account, which is why he chose it. As a side note, let me go ahead and state for the record that I’m not pretending to be a Greek scholar, or even a Greek amateur.
And how does one begin to verify who the greatest Greek scholar “the world has ever known” is or may have been? What criteria does one use to make such a judgment? Really, I’d like to know.
St. Jerome was the first person commissioned to translate the Old and New Testament into Latin, which became the exclusive Bible used by all of Western Christendom for 1000 years, and is still used today. And the exact term I used was “arguably the greatest.” I challenge you to find a single credible Greek scholar who would disagree with that statement. They may disagree with some of his translations of a word here and there, but it seems like you are trying to downplay his significance simply because you don’t like what he did with one verse. Are you suggesting that the Latin Vulgate, as a whole, is not a work of brilliance with immeasurable historical impact?
 
If “objective” means “formal equivalence,” then there is no way to get “full of grace” out of
κεχαριτωμένη. In other words, if you want to have an accurate rendering of the Greek, then “full of grace,” isn’t a good choice. The Bible does say “full of grace” or πλήρης χάριτος (John 1:14, and Acts 6:8), so if that’s what Luke/Gabriel intended to say about Mary, why not use πλήρης χάριτος as in Acts 6:8 (also written by Luke)? Further, since Catholics infer that Mary was conceived without sin on the basis of Luke 1:28 (which doesn’t actually say, “full of grace,”) could we also infer that Stephen was immaculately conceived since the text (Acts 6:8) actually does say “full of grace?”
This sounds exactly like an article at carm and last I read that article, I noticed a very distinct word missing from it - the Greek root of “grace”, which is also missing from your explanation. The Greek for grace is “charis”.

The interesting thing is that a form of charis is found in κεχαριτωμένη, or, keCHARItomene, and is not found in πλήρης χάριτος, which is the exact opposite of what you just tried to tell us. I hate to say it, but where ever you got that from - they lied to you.
 
The rosary is really meant to be a meditative prayer – we are to be meditating on the particular decade mystery while praying the 10 Hail Mary’s of that decade. The Hail Mary’s then serve as kind of a holy timer for that particular meditation! 🙂
When prayed this way, as it is meant to be prayed, it soon becomes obvious how Christ centered the rosary is.

Has anyone else had particular aids that have helped them in mediation on the mysteries?
Hi Nita, Virtual Rosary 5.2 from Softpedea downloadable for Windows, Mac, Linux or Mobile, etc. etc. is a great way to pray the scriptural Rosary - Another helpful Rosary prayer book for meditation is; “From Genesis to Revelation” Seven Scriptural Rosaries by Christine Haapala, Illustrations by Christine Parson.Web address: www.sufferingservant.com This is a handy ‘travel’ book for meditation to carry with you when away from your mobile or PC.🙂
 
Hi,

I’d like to respectfully give my dissenting opinion on the Rosary.
  1. The first problem I have is that it seems like it is first and foremost a prayer to Mary.
  2. It seems to me that Catholics “say,” rather than “pray” the Rosary.
    3a. Can we simply string together texts of scripture and turn them into prayers?
    3b. “Hail Mary full of grace,”
  3. I’m not going to mention the “babbling” or “vain repetition”
  4. Lastly, the one time the disciples asked Jesus to teach them to pray (Luke 11:1), he gave them a prayer to say, but also a model for praying. What Jesus gave them is so unlike the Rosary, that it seems dubious to me that he could ever have imagined us praying to anyone else but the Father. How could the addition of the “Hail Mary’s” and the “Salve Regina” ever be an answer to the request, “Lord teach us to pray,” given what Jesus actually taught them in Luke 11?
One last comment/question. I wonder how often people pray the Rosary with the superstitious idea that by doing so their prayer is more “efficacious” than it otherwise would be if they had just prayed informally? Is there a belief that in praying the Rosary, God is somehow more favorably disposed/likely to answer the prayer?

Anyway, my basic issue is that I simply reject the idea that one grows closer to God by going through Mary. This, in my view, is where Catholicism has departed from the gospel by introducing another mediator and quite possibly another redeemer.

Solus Christus,

Miguel Sastre
Dear Miguel, may I explain how the Rosary draws me closer to God? Every time I SAY or READ the Rosary I confirm to myself the Apostles Creed and what I personally believe, Not only do I see or hear the words, but I see in picture form in my mind what I CONFESS. 🙂
I WORSHIP God with the words: Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit - It gives me pleasure to say those powerful words. :dancing:
Each time I repeat the Our Father, I focus on a new line of PRAYER i.e. “give us this day our daily bread” - Jesus Christ has become our daily bread.😃
I ask Jesus to forgive our sins (in my minds eye I see myself and the world needing forgiveness and with every reiteration I focus on different aspects of sin i.e. small sins, large sins, discord, abortion, pornography etc.) :gopray:
Repeating the Scripture words in the Holy Mary recitation, a supernatural event is reaffirmed with awsome wonder - the reality of our Lord being born a human being, a tiny babe dependant on human parents. May we all become obedient and trusting as Mary.
Meditating on the Sorrowful Mysteries for example, the scripture verses jumps out at me - when having moved from “Hail Mary full of grace” that is to say, the words leading up to the conception of our Lord (a happy event) to the 10 scripture verses accompanying each Hail Mary, (a different scripture of that particular Mystery), x 5 decades, my heart aches for my Lord’s suffering -
DECLARING the Rosary by meditating on the scripture accompanying each meditation decade makes the fact of His birth, presentation, finding in the temple, baptism, temptation, the wedding, the proclamation of the Kingdom of God, the transfiguration, betrayal, Scourging, carrying the cross, last moments on the cross, resurrection and ascension of Jesus Christ and all the in between, very real to me.
Ending the meditation with the words of prayer; …(that) we may imitate what they contain and obtain what they promise, through the same Christ our Lord, - reafirms the sense of free will to follow or withdraw - to commit :signofcross: or fall away :(. and is a confort to me in the knowledge that I may depend on the grace of God in a childlike way.
“I can guarantee this truth: Unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. 4 Whoever becomes like this little child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven. 5 And whoever welcomes a child like this in my name welcomes me.
Matt 18:3-5 (GW)
 
As was mentioned earlier in this thread, praying is not the same as worship. It can be, but it can also mean “to ask”. When I “pray to Mary” or “pray to the saints”, I am asking them to pray for me.
It was also mentioned that “pray” simply means “ask,” and that children “pray” to their parents all the time. (This definition of “pray” seems like something out of Shakespeare). If “pray” is simply a pious synonym for “ask,” then would you agree that the following situations can be classified as “prayer”?:
  1. You’re at the drive-thru and say, “I’d like to pray for a Big Mac with fries.” (Here, “pray” is what we normally mean by “order.”)
  2. You’re moving a couch that is too heavy and call and friend and say, “I have a favor to pray to you for.” (Here prayer seems to mean “ask for”).
Are situations 1 and 2 above examples of “prayer” as the Bible uses the term? Or am I simply substituting an archaic English definition of the word for what today would mean “to ask for”? What’s your opinion?

Also, I never said prayer = worship, so I am not going to defend this view.
Your analogy of Israel adopting the religion of its neighbors couldn’t be farther from what Catholics do when they pray to the saints / Mary.
I disagree. Israel often prayed to and worshiped foreign gods in addition to Yahweh, only usually they thought of Yahweh as being higher than the foreign gods. So the idea of “lesser divinities” along side Yahweh wasn’t unknown to them. Of course, this isn’t the point I was raising at all. I only wished to say that in the history of the Bible, you don’t find an endorsement for praying to anyone other than God. When Israel prays to someone other than Yahweh, this practice is denounced by the prophets. It matters not if these other entities are “lesser gods” or no gods at all. The principle is the same. The people of God pray to no one else but God. Anything less than God (Mary, the saints, Baal, Astarte, whoever) is simply a no-no.

Does the silence of Jesus and the rest of the New Testament about praying to saints bother you in the least? I ask, because this (praying to saints) doesn’t seem to be the kind of thing that we can explain as a legitimate “development” from what is already “implicit” in Scripture. Scripture seems to explicitly rule out this kind of development as a legitimate spiritual practice.
Never once have I ever been told to put someone or something equal to or higher than God. Which is what the Israelites did.
I’m sure no one in Rome thinks they’re committing idolatry by praying to saints. I suspect that over the course of time, many in Israel thought much the same thing with respect to their own spiritual practice of invoking foreign gods in addition to Yahweh. So long as they thought of Yahweh as the highest God, what harm could there be in having some lesser gods? (Much harm.)
 
It was also mentioned that “pray” simply means “ask,” and that children “pray” to their parents all the time. (This definition of “pray” seems like something out of Shakespeare). If “pray” is simply a pious synonym for “ask,” then would you agree that the following situations can be classified as “prayer”?:
  1. You’re at the drive-thru and say, “I’d like to pray for a Big Mac with fries.” (Here, “pray” is what we normally mean by “order.”)
  2. You’re moving a couch that is too heavy and call and friend and say, “I have a favor to pray to you for.” (Here prayer seems to mean “ask for”).
Are situations 1 and 2 above examples of “prayer” as the Bible uses the term? Or am I simply substituting an archaic English definition of the word for what today would mean “to ask for”? What’s your opinion?
Language changes over time. Just because a word’s usage changes over time, that doesn’t mean the definition changes. For example, if I read a book written in the 1800’s and it said Jim was gay, it probably meant Jim was happy. If I read a book written today that said Jim is gay, it probably means Jim is a homosexual. But, it could still mean Jim is happy Both are correct. You have to look at the context to determine which meaning is being used.

Today most people think prayer is only something done in a religion context, ie, praying to God. While this is certainly true, it doesn’t mean the other definitions of the word is not valid.
I disagree. Israel often prayed to and worshiped foreign gods in addition to Yahweh, only usually they thought of Yahweh as being higher than the foreign gods. So the idea of “lesser divinities” along side Yahweh wasn’t unknown to them. Of course, this isn’t the point I was raising at all. I only wished to say that in the history of the Bible, you don’t find an endorsement for praying to anyone other than God. When Israel prays to someone other than Yahweh, this practice is denounced by the prophets. It matters not if these other entities are “lesser gods” or no gods at all. The principle is the same. The people of God pray to no one else but God. Anything less than God (Mary, the saints, Baal, Astarte, whoever) is simply a no-no.

Does the silence of Jesus and the rest of the New Testament about praying to saints bother you in the least? I ask, because this (praying to saints) doesn’t seem to be the kind of thing that we can explain as a legitimate “development” from what is already “implicit” in Scripture. Scripture seems to explicitly rule out this kind of development as a legitimate spiritual practice.

I’m sure no one in Rome thinks they’re committing idolatry by praying to saints. I suspect that over the course of time, many in Israel thought much the same thing with respect to their own spiritual practice of invoking foreign gods in addition to Yahweh. So long as they thought of Yahweh as the highest God, what harm could there be in having some lesser gods? (Much harm.)
Your whole premise is that Catholics things Mary / the saints are sort sort of God. That simple is not the case. There is one God. We worship the one God. We ask our brothers and sisters (those on earth and in heaven) to pray for us.
 
Your whole premise is that Catholics things Mary / the saints are sort sort of God.
That is so NOT my premise. I never said you think of Mary or the saints as divinities. I said you pray to them. The issue isn’t whether the saints and Mary are divine. The issues is whether or not it is permissible to pray to anyone who is NOT God.
 
That is so NOT my premise. I never said you think of Mary or the saints as divinities. I said you pray to them. The issue isn’t whether the saints and Mary are divine. The issues is whether or not it is permissible to pray to anyone who is NOT God.
And on what basis do you make any claim that it would not be permissable to petition Mary and the Saints through prayer?
 
That is so NOT my premise. I never said you think of Mary or the saints as divinities. I said you pray to them. The issue isn’t whether the saints and Mary are divine. The issues is whether or not it is permissible to pray to anyone who is NOT God.
As I have explained, we do not worship Mary / the saints. We ask them to pray for us. We worship God. This has some very good info on the subject:

scripturecatholic.com/saints.html
 
That is so NOT my premise. I never said you think of Mary or the saints as divinities. I said you pray to them. The issue isn’t whether the saints and Mary are divine. The issues is whether or not it is permissible to pray to anyone who is NOT God.
Catholics do not pray TO Mary. We ask her to pray FOR us. You have been told this several times, and yet you continue to say Catholics pray TO Mary. Now that you have been provided repeatedly with the correct information, please do us Catholics the courtesy of dropping your inaccurate characterization of the Rosary.

Have you ever asked a friend to pray on your behalf about something important? Perhaps you haven’t, but many Christians do ask for the prayers of others. The Rosary is analogous to that. If you had a child who was in the hospital and you asked your friend to pray for that child’s speedy recovery, I submit you would not describe that request as praying to your child.

Praying the Rosary, a meditative prayer, is praying the Gospel. It is Gospel-focused and much the Hail Mary prayer itself is word-for-word from the Gospel. It is not a prayer TO Mary, it is a prayer asking for Mary’s prayers on our behalf. If this issue is, as you have stated, whether or not it is “it is permissible to pray to anyone who is NOT God”, then your argument fails, because Catholics do not pray TO Mary in the sense that you have repeatedly, and incorrectly, described.
 
And on what basis do you make any claim that it would not be permissable to petition Mary and the Saints through prayer?
On the basis of thousands of years of recorded history from Genesis to Revelation. You just don’t find the people of God praying to anyone else but God and not getting in deep trouble for it.

In order to ask departed saints to pray for us, you have to pray to them. There’s no Biblical example of anyone doing this. I’m going to play at safe and assume that since only prayer to God is sanctioned, that’s the only kind of prayer that is legitimate. On what basis do you think it is permissible to pray to them?
 
On the basis of thousands of years of recorded history from Genesis to Revelation. You just don’t find the people of God praying to anyone else but God and not getting in deep trouble for it.

In order to ask departed saints to pray for us, you have to pray to them. There’s no Biblical example of anyone doing this. I’m going to play at safe and assume that since only prayer to God is sanctioned, that’s the only kind of prayer that is legitimate. On what basis do you think it is permissible to pray to them?
You obviously haven’t read the Old Testament, or you would have known that on many occations worship was offered to angels rather than to God. This of course was an appropriate lesser worship.
 
It was also mentioned that “pray” simply means “ask,” and that children “pray” to their parents all the time. (This definition of “pray” seems like something out of Shakespeare). If “pray” is simply a pious synonym for “ask,” then would you agree that the following situations can be classified as “prayer”?:
  1. You’re at the drive-thru and say, “I’d like to pray for a Big Mac with fries.” (Here, “pray” is what we normally mean by “order.”)
  2. You’re moving a couch that is too heavy and call and friend and say, “I have a favor to pray to you for.” (Here prayer seems to mean “ask for”).
Are situations 1 and 2 above examples of “prayer” as the Bible uses the term? Or am I simply substituting an archaic English definition of the word for what today would mean “to ask for”? What’s your opinion?
The modern English word for “prayer” comes from the older English word “prithee”, which, in turn, was a combination of “pray thee”. Basically, it meant “please” in the context of asking for something. To use your example, you would go through the drive thru and say something along the lines of, “Prithee, I would like one Big Mac and fries.”

If I pray to a saint because I want to be healed, the actual intention I am expressing is “Please ask God to heal me.” I do not believe that the saint has the power to heal me on his own. Any help he can give me is as an intercessor with God, and God can use that saint to channel of his healing grace into my life. If I can go to a faith healer for this on earth, I can go to a saint in heaven for the same thing.

Although Catholics typically use the term “praying to a saint”, the actual idea (i.e., the intention) is that we are contacting a saint to pray to God on our behalf, and the mode of contact with the saint is likewise prayer.

(continued in my next post)
 
As I have explained, we do not worship Mary / the saints. We ask them to pray for us.
I know. So back to the question. Where do you find prayer to anyone but God as legitimate in scripture? And if there is no example, then are there at least biblical principles from which we could deduce/infer that the development of such a practice is in fact legitimate? Or de we have to simply base the entire legitimacy of the practice on Rome’s alleged infallibility?

You keep attributing to me positions I do not hold. As I said before, I’m not accusing you of worshiping the Mary or the saints, nor of believing that they are divine. I’m accusing you of praying to them. I am accusing you of praying to people who are not God.
 
Does the silence of Jesus and the rest of the New Testament about praying to saints bother you in the least?
Jesus is not silent on this. Using prayer to seek the intercession of the saints is a Doctrine of the Faith, and therefore has its origins in Jesus. Therefore, we do it because Jesus says we can do it. You are the one who seems to think that Jesus only provides revelation through Sacred Scripture.
I ask, because this (praying to saints) doesn’t seem to be the kind of thing that we can explain as a legitimate “development” from what is already “implicit” in Scripture. Scripture seems to explicitly rule out this kind of development as a legitimate spiritual practice.
Throughout this discussion you seem to be judging the concept of praying the Rosary based upon Sola Scriptura, which is not a Catholic doctrine. A Doctrine of the Faith does not have to be demonstrated as a “legitimate development from what is already implicit in Scripture.” Furthermore, when you use language such as “Scripture seems to explicitly rule out this kind of development” you are simply stating your personal interpretation of Scripture.

As a Catholic I can say that Scripture does not explicitly rule out this kind of development. For example:
  1. The Bible teaches we are one in the Body of Christ, and therefore Christians on earth are already joined to the Christians in heaven.
  2. The idea of Christian fellowship indicates social interaction. Such an interaction cannot take place without some form of communication. In this type of fellowship, by asking someone to pray for me, I exercise the virtue of humility. If that person prays on my behalf, he exercises the virtue of charity. The Bible teaches the importance of virtuous living, and this is one way to do it.
  3. Prayer is the tool of communication given to us by God as a means of communicating within the Body of Christ. Prayer has different forms, of which worship/adoration is one. Prayers of worship/adoration are to be given to God alone. Those are not the prayers we give to the saints.
  4. The letter of James tells us to pray for one another, and to seek out the prayers of the righteous because they are powerful in their effects (James 5:16). We can ask righteous people on earth to pray for us, and we can ask righteous people in heaven to pray for us. People in heaven are obviously more righteous than people on earth, and their prayers on our behalf would be considerably powerful in their effects.
  5. At his Transfiguration, Jesus spoke to Moses & Elijah in full view of Peter, James and John. In the most basic understanding of this event, Jesus was communicating with righteous people who are no longer on this earth.
  6. It is a historical fact that the ancient Christians prayed to saints in heaven. When Christians were martyred by the pagan Romans, the Christian community buried the martyrs with the inscription, “Ora Pro Nobis” (“Pray for us”). Many of those tombs are preserved to this day. Therefore, archeology demonstrates that Christians on earth started praying to martyrs at least by the middle of the 1st Century.
I’m sure no one in Rome thinks they’re committing idolatry by praying to saints. I suspect that over the course of time, many in Israel thought much the same thing with respect to their own spiritual practice of invoking foreign gods in addition to Yahweh. So long as they thought of Yahweh as the highest God, what harm could there be in having some lesser gods? (Much harm.)
To commit the sin of idolatry, one has to have this intention. Just because a person’s actions appear to be idolatrous to another, that does not make it so. I saw Yul Brynner standing in front of a statue of a pagan Egyptian god and praying to that god. It looked like he was committing idolatry. Obviously, he was not, because he was acting the role of Pharaoh in the movie “The Ten Commandments”, and therefore had no actual idolatrous intentions.

The Catholic Church approves praying to saints as an official teaching of a matter pertaining to faith and morals (i.e., it is a Doctrine of the Faith). The Catholic Church also condemns idolatry as a sin. The Catholic Church gives guidelines as to the proper way to pray to saints. As far as Catholics are concerned, these doctrines and instructions have their origins in God. So we pray to saints with God’s approval, and he demonstrates his approval by blessing us and spiritually enriching our lives through these actions of Christian fellowship.
 
You obviously haven’t read the Old Testament, or you would have known that on many occations worship was offered to angels rather than to God. This of course was an appropriate lesser worship.
Or, a more charitable assumption might be, perhaps I have read the Old Testament and have simply forgotten those passages where people are praying to angels. Do you have any particular texts in mind?

And am I to understand that you would agree that prayer to angels is in fact a kind of worship, albeit of a lesser sort?
 
I know. So back to the question. Where do you find prayer to anyone but God as legitimate in scripture? And if there is no example, then are there at least biblical principles from which we could deduce/infer that the development of such a practice is in fact legitimate? Or de we have to simply base the entire legitimacy of the practice on Rome’s alleged infallibility?

You keep attributing to me positions I do not hold. As I said before, I’m not accusing you of worshiping the Mary or the saints, nor of believing that they are divine. I’m accusing you of praying to them. I am accusing you of praying to people who are not God.
I guess we should define the word prayer. What is your definition? I will use the definition from Merriam Webster:

merriam-webster.com/dictionary/prayer

1 a (1) : an address (as a petition) to God or a god in word or thought (2) : a set order of words used in praying b : an earnest request or wish
2 : the act or practice of praying to God or a god
3 : a religious service consisting chiefly of prayers —often used in plural
4 : something prayed for
5 : a slight chance <haven’t got a prayer>


When I saw I pray to Mary / saints, I am using the definition “an earnest request or wish”. I request their prayers for me. You will find this (asking one another to prayer for each other) mentioned in the bible. See here:

scripturecatholic.com/saints.html

The Israelites worshiping other gods. This is what got them in trouble.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top