Hi,
I’d like to respectfully give my dissenting opinion on the Rosary.
- The first problem I have is that it seems like it is first and foremost a prayer to Mary.
- It seems to me that Catholics “say,” rather than “pray” the Rosary.
3a. Can we simply string together texts of scripture and turn them into prayers?
3b. “Hail Mary full of grace,”
- I’m not going to mention the “babbling” or “vain repetition”
- Lastly, the one time the disciples asked Jesus to teach them to pray (Luke 11:1), he gave them a prayer to say, but also a model for praying. What Jesus gave them is so unlike the Rosary, that it seems dubious to me that he could ever have imagined us praying to anyone else but the Father. How could the addition of the “Hail Mary’s” and the “Salve Regina” ever be an answer to the request, “Lord teach us to pray,” given what Jesus actually taught them in Luke 11?
One last comment/question. I wonder how often people pray the Rosary with the superstitious idea that by doing so their prayer is more “efficacious” than it otherwise would be if they had just prayed informally? Is there a belief that in praying the Rosary, God is somehow more favorably disposed/likely to answer the prayer?
Anyway, my basic issue is that I simply reject the idea that one grows closer to God by going through Mary. This, in my view, is where Catholicism has departed from the gospel by introducing another mediator and quite possibly another redeemer.
Solus Christus,
Miguel Sastre
Dear Miguel, may I explain how the Rosary draws me closer to God? Every time I SAY or READ the Rosary I confirm to myself the Apostles Creed and what I personally believe, Not only do I see or hear the words, but I see in picture form in my mind what I CONFESS.

I WORSHIP God with the words: Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit - It gives me pleasure to say those powerful words. :dancing:
Each time I repeat the Our Father, I focus on a new line of PRAYER i.e. “give us this day our daily bread” - Jesus Christ has become our daily bread.

I ask Jesus to forgive our sins (in my minds eye I see myself and the world needing forgiveness and with every reiteration I focus on different aspects of sin i.e. small sins, large sins, discord, abortion, pornography etc.)

Repeating the Scripture words in the Holy Mary recitation, a supernatural event is reaffirmed with awsome wonder - the reality of our Lord being born a human being, a tiny babe dependant on human parents. May we all become obedient and trusting as Mary.
Meditating on the Sorrowful Mysteries for example, the scripture verses jumps out at me - when having moved from “Hail Mary full of grace” that is to say, the words leading up to the conception of our Lord (a happy event) to the 10 scripture verses accompanying each Hail Mary, (a different scripture of
that particular Mystery), x 5 decades, my heart aches for my Lord’s suffering -
DECLARING the Rosary by meditating on the scripture accompanying each meditation decade makes the fact of His birth, presentation, finding in the temple, baptism, temptation, the wedding, the proclamation of the Kingdom of God, the transfiguration, betrayal, Scourging, carrying the cross, last moments on the cross, resurrection and ascension of Jesus Christ and all the in between, very real to me.
Ending the meditation with the words of prayer; …(that) we may imitate what they contain and obtain what they promise, through the same Christ our Lord, - reafirms the sense of free will to follow or withdraw - to commit

or fall away

. and is a confort to me in the knowledge that I may depend on the grace of God in a childlike way.
“I can guarantee this truth: Unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. 4 Whoever becomes like this little child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven. 5 And whoever welcomes a child like this in my name welcomes me.
Matt 18:3-5 (GW)