Argument against the Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Or, a more charitable assumption might be, perhaps I have read the Old Testament and have simply forgotten those passages where people are praying to angels. Do you have any particular texts in mind?

And am I to understand that you would agree that prayer to angels is in fact a kind of worship, albeit of a lesser sort?
One such famous example from the OT,

KJV:
Jos 5:13 And it came to pass, when Joshua was by Jericho, that he lifted up his eyes and looked, and, behold, there stood a man over against him with his sword drawn in his hand: and Joshua went unto him, and said unto him, Art thou for us, or for our adversaries?
Jos 5:14 And he said, Nay; but as captain of the host of the LORD am I now come. And Joshua fell on his face to the earth, and did worship, and said unto him, What saith my lord unto his servant?
Jos 5:15 And the captain of the LORD’S host said unto Joshua, Loose thy shoe from off thy foot; for the place whereon thou standest is holy. And Joshua did so.
 
I scanned this whole thread and so far no one seems to have touched on this point but I think it is important.

The rosary and the promise mentioned are two different things. The rosary predates the promise. In fact in it’s oldest form it consisted of 150 ‘Our Fathers’. It evolved from that, and this is sometimes mentioned in Catholic sources.

The ‘promise’ comes from an apparition, which may or may not have actually happened, and no one is required to believe it. This is not doctrinal Catholicism, it is popular religion. Many Catholics do not believe in the apparition’s promises, and many others are not aware of them. The rosary stands on it’s own with or without them.

The rosary is a chaplet, the most popular by far out of the many choices, it is basically a prayer rule, but not the official prayer rule of the church. That role is taken by the Liturgy of the Hours and the supreme prayer, the Mass.

Any one can create a personal prayer rule of their own, but it will not be encouraged with an indulgence unless some Pope likes it and feels it should be promoted.

The issue then, is over intercessory prayer. Is it efficacious or not? We believe that it generally is (subject ultimately to Our Lord’s will in every case), others do not share this concept. We believe the holy ones who have gone before us are with God, this is the God of the living, they are the communion of saints and they can appeal to God on our behalf.
 
Jesus is not silent on this. Using prayer to seek the intercession of the saints is a Doctrine of the Faith, and therefore has its origins in Jesus. Therefore, we do it because Jesus says we can do it. You are the one who seems to think that Jesus only provides revelation through Sacred Scripture.
Okay, let’s assume that he provides revelation outside of scripture. Then where did he reveal this practice and when?
Throughout this discussion you seem to be judging the concept of praying the Rosary based upon Sola Scriptura, which is not a Catholic doctrine. A Doctrine of the Faith does not have to be demonstrated as a “legitimate development from what is already implicit in Scripture.”
Well I’ll let you debate that point with those in your church who subscribe to the development of doctrine thesis. So what you’re basically saying is that praying to Mary and the saints isn’t based on scripture but extra-biblical revelation, right?
Furthermore, when you use language such as “Scripture seems to explicitly rule out this kind of development” you are simply stating your personal interpretation of Scripture.
Should I substitute someone else’s interpretation for my own? Whose do you have in mind? Yours?
  1. Prayer is the tool of communication given to us by God as a means of communicating within the Body of Christ.
Really? How do you know? Is there an example of this somewhere in scripture? I mean, do you see members of the body of Christ praying to one another? If not, how do you know it is okay to do so?
  1. The letter of James tells us to pray for one another, and to seek out the prayers of the righteous because they are powerful in their effects (James 5:16).
Do you really think James has in mind here the practice of invoking the faithful departed?
We can ask righteous people on earth to pray for us, and we can ask righteous people in heaven to pray for us.
I see Christians soliciting prayers from other living Christian. Are there any examples of them asking the departed to pray for us?
  1. At his Transfiguration, Jesus spoke to Moses & Elijah in full view of Peter, James and John. In the most basic understanding of this event, Jesus was communicating with righteous people who are no longer on this earth.
Was anyone praying to Moses and Elijah in this scene?
  1. It is a historical fact that the ancient Christians prayed to saints in heaven.
The Inquisition is an historical fact. That doesn’t make it right.
When Christians were martyred by the pagan Romans, the Christian community buried the martyrs with the inscription, “Ora Pro Nobis” (“Pray for us”). Many of those tombs are preserved to this day. Therefore, archeology demonstrates that Christians on earth started praying to martyrs at least by the middle of the 1st Century.
Which might only show how early things went wrong. Or possibly the inscription is intended only as prayer for the dead. Thus the “Ora Pro Nobis,” is from the point of view of the dead rather than the living. On this reading the inscription would function as a reminder to the living to keep the dead in mind when they pray. It’s not really evidence that Christians were praying to saints at this point in church history.
To commit the sin of idolatry, one has to have this intention.
The highway to hell is paved with good intentions. (Was it Augstine who said that?) In any event, I think the distinction between formal and material idolatry would be helpful here. If praying to saints is wrong, but you’re not intending to do wrong, then perhaps the idolatry in question is only material, rather than formal. But that’s a side issue. I’m more interested in the Catholic case for the practice.
As far as Catholics are concerned, these doctrines and instructions have their origins in God.
Wow. I find it incredible that God would approve of such a practice and not mention a word about it in scripture. As I said before, this isn’t something like the Trinity that really is a matter trying to make sense of everything scripture says about Father, Son and Holy Spirit. This is a spiritual practice. And yet no one seems to engage in it from Genesis to Revelation. In fact, when people are tempted to bow down/pray to/worship anything other than God, we only see scripture condemning the practice.
 
One such famous example from the OT,

KJV: Jos 5:13 And it came to pass, when Joshua was by Jericho, that he lifted up his eyes and looked, and, behold, there stood a man over against him with his sword drawn in his hand: and Joshua went unto him, and said unto him, Art thou for us, or for our adversaries?
Jos 5:14 And he said, Nay; but as captain of the host of the LORD am I now come. And Joshua fell on his face to the earth, and did worship, and said unto him, What saith my lord unto his servant?
Jos 5:15 And the captain of the LORD’S host said unto Joshua, Loose thy shoe from off thy foot; for the place whereon thou standest is holy. And Joshua did so.
I’m still not seeing Joshua praying to the man. In fact, this probably was the angel whom the Lord promised to send before Israel (see Exodus 23:20-33). While it does say that Joshua “bowed down” or “worshiped,” it does not say that Joshua bowed down “to him” or that Joshua worshipped “him.” The object of Joshua’s worship/bowing down isn’t clear, but three possibilities come to mind:
  1. Joshua bowed down/worshipped the man (who was really an angel.)
  2. Joshua bowed down/worshipped in the presence of the angel.
  3. Joshua bowed down/worshipped the angel (who was really the Lord himself.)
We can rule out 1 as plausible by appealing to Revelation 19:10:
Then I fell down at his feet to worship him, but he said to me, “You must not do that! I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold to the testimony of Jesus. Worship God.”
If the angel is an angel, and if Joshua is bowing down/worshipping an angel, then why wasn’t he rebuked as was John?

Further, there is no reason to suppose that the word for “bowing down/worship” is a “lesser form” of worship. That’s a Catholic contrivance based on distinction between latria and dulia which was foreign to the Hebrew mind.

Option 2 is possible since we’re never told the object of Joshua’s worship/bowing down. Presumably Joshua was worshipping God alone, which would be consistent with everything else we know about Joshua.

Option 3 is also possible, since the “angel of the Lord” seems to be a circumlocution for God himself in many passages. Since the angel goes on to say, “Take off your sandals from your feet, for the place where you are standing is holy,” (v. 15), and since this is a near verbatim quotation of Exodus 3:5, it may very well be that the “commander of the Lord’s army” is the Lord himself. This wouldn’t be the first time God appeared to people incognito (see Genesis 18:1).

It seems to me that you’re arguing for option 1. If so, how do you avoid setting up a contradiction in scripture?
 
Catholics do NOT pray to Mary in the sense suggested. It doesn’t matter how many times this false accusation is made, it will never be true.
 
Catholics do not pray TO Mary. We ask her to pray FOR us. You have been told this several times, and yet you continue to say Catholics pray TO Mary.
Respectfully, I’d ask you to read all the posts in this thread. Many Catholics here are perfectly comfortable with the language of “praying to” Mary. Also, in my original post in this thread, I explicitly acknowledge the distinction between “praying to” and “praying through” Mary, which is what I think you’re saying here.
Have you ever asked a friend to pray on your behalf about something important?
Yes. The crucial difference is that I can actually talk to them and they can talk back because they’re “in the body” rather than “at home with the Lord,” to use Paul’s terminology. In order for you to ask a saint or Mary to pray for you, you have to “pray to” them. There’s no getting around that fact. Your fellow Catholics in this thread, by and large, have no trouble admitting that. Why do you?
 
Respectfully, I’d ask you to read all the posts in this thread. Many Catholics here are perfectly comfortable with the language of “praying to” Mary. Also, in my original post in this thread, I explicitly acknowledge the distinction between “praying to” and “praying through” Mary, which is what I think you’re saying here.

Yes. The crucial difference is that I can actually talk to them and they can talk back because they’re “in the body” rather than “at home with the Lord,” to use Paul’s terminology. In order for you to ask a saint or Mary to pray for you, you have to “pray to” them. There’s no getting around that fact. Your fellow Catholics in this thread, by and large, have no trouble admitting that. Why do you?
I have read the other posts. You have no reason to suggest otherwise.

I am not disagreeing with the other Catholics that have posted to this thread, I am stating, repeatedly since you continue to repeat a false accusation, that your characterization of the prayer of the Rosary, and other intercessory prayer, is inaccurate.

For you to continue to maintain your position, in the face of repeated demonstrations that it is inaccurate, is offensive. You have been told what the Catholic position is. For you to continue to assert it is something else is simply wrong, and, I submit, uncharitable.
 
Okay, let’s assume that he provides revelation outside of scripture. Then where did he reveal this practice and when?
The Rosary involves reciting the Apostles’ Creed, the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and meditating upon gospel events and God’s plan of salvation for the human race. None of this is objectively contrary to Scripture, and certainly has a scriptrual basis.

The practice of praying to the saints is an element of Sensus Fidei. As such it was revealed by the Holy Spirit to the hearts and minds of the ancient Christians, and is therefore part of the Deposit of the Faith.
Well I’ll let you debate that point with those in your church who subscribe to the development of doctrine thesis.
There would be no debate. Our doctrines are rooted in the Deposit of Faith. Our understanding of doctrinal matters can improve over time. This is all that the concept of the development of doctrine entails.
So what you’re basically saying is that praying to Mary and the saints isn’t based on scripture but extra-biblical revelation, right?
It does not contradict Scripture and can be implied from it (which I did in my last post). The same can be said of the Doctrine of the Trinity and switching the observance of the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday.
Should I substitute someone else’s interpretation for my own? Whose do you have in mind? Yours?
My point is that Catholic devotional practices do not contradict Scripture, only your interpretation of Scripture.
Really? How do you know? Is there an example of this somewhere in scripture? I mean, do you see members of the body of Christ praying to one another? If not, how do you know it is okay to do so?
As I have stated, prayer is a tool of supernatural communication. If I ask someone on earth to pray for me, I use the spoken or written word. If I ask someone in heaven, the spoken word becomes a prayer. In terms of how I know it is okay to do so is because it is a Doctrine of the Faith, as I have repeatedly pointed out.
Do you really think James has in mind here the practice of invoking the faithful departed?
I believe he has in mind here both asking the righteous on earth and the righteous in heaven for their prayers.
I see Christians soliciting prayers from other living Christian. Are there any examples of them asking the departed to pray for us?
There are no concrete examples of this in the New Testament that I know of, nor are there instructions not to do so. I do, however, see it implied in the Letter of James, which I have already covered. Because I do not believe in Sola Scriptura, the lack of any concrete examples is not problematic.
Was anyone praying to Moses and Elijah in this scene?
You are intentionally avoiding the concept I used demonstrating prayer as communication. Jesus communicated with Elijah through the spoken word. If I want to do the same then my spoken word to Elijah becomes a prayer because he is back in heaven.
The Inquisition is an historical fact. That doesn’t make it right.
Any harmful practices conducted by Church members during the Inquisition do not represent Doctrines of the Faith.

But to use your same argument, the Protestant Reformation is a historic fact, but that doesn’t make it right either.

*(continued in my next post) *
 
I’m still not seeing Joshua praying to the man. In fact, this probably was the angel whom the Lord promised to send before Israel (see Exodus 23:20-33). While it does say that Joshua “bowed down” or “worshiped,” it does not say that Joshua bowed down “to him” or that Joshua worshipped “him.” The object of Joshua’s worship/bowing down isn’t clear, but three possibilities come to mind:
  1. Joshua bowed down/worshipped the man (who was really an angel.)
  2. Joshua bowed down/worshipped in the presence of the angel.
  3. Joshua bowed down/worshipped the angel (who was really the Lord himself.)
We can rule out 1 as plausible by appealing to Revelation 19:10:

If the angel is an angel, and if Joshua is bowing down/worshipping an angel, then why wasn’t he rebuked as was John?

Further, there is no reason to suppose that the word for “bowing down/worship” is a “lesser form” of worship. That’s a Catholic contrivance based on distinction between latria and dulia which was foreign to the Hebrew mind.

Option 2 is possible since we’re never told the object of Joshua’s worship/bowing down. Presumably Joshua was worshipping God alone, which would be consistent with everything else we know about Joshua.

Option 3 is also possible, since the “angel of the Lord” seems to be a circumlocution for God himself in many passages. Since the angel goes on to say, “Take off your sandals from your feet, for the place where you are standing is holy,” (v. 15), and since this is a near verbatim quotation of Exodus 3:5, it may very well be that the “commander of the Lord’s army” is the Lord himself. This wouldn’t be the first time God appeared to people incognito (see Genesis 18:1).

It seems to me that you’re arguing for option 1. If so, how do you avoid setting up a contradiction in scripture?
No, what I’m telling you is that praying to i.e. petitioning the Saints (which include angels) is something which has happened since the times of the Old Testament, here you’re trying to split hairs with your argument about St. Michael being an angel. Regardless, Joshua worshiped a created being, not God and you really can’t dance around that one. In the case of Christians today, we venerate the Saints, and seek their intercession exactly like we seek eachother’s intercession when we ask others to pray for us. You can also see this in the story of Job,

KJV:
Job 42:7 And it was so, that after the LORD had spoken these words unto Job, the LORD said to Eliphaz the Temanite, My wrath is kindled against thee, and against thy two friends: for ye have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job hath.
Job 42:8 Therefore take unto you now seven bullocks and seven rams, and go to my servant Job, and offer up for yourselves a burnt offering; and my servant Job shall pray for you: for him will I accept: lest I deal with you after your folly, in that ye have not spoken of me the thing which is right, like my servant Job.
Job 42:9 So Eliphaz the Temanite and Bildad the Shuhite and Zophar the Naamathite went, and did according as the LORD commanded them: the LORD also accepted Job.
  1. Eliphaz is not what we Catholics would call, in a state of grace
  2. Thus God will not hear his prayer, for he is far from being Ritcheous (quite the contrary)
  3. Because of this, if he wants to live he needs an intercessor to pray for him
  4. God (in this case) instructs him to use Job as his intercessor
  5. God accepts the prayer of the intercessor.
This is what praying to the saints is, you really can’t argue against this because if you do you directly contradict any idea that you’re allowed to ask others to pray for you, as well as your ability to pray for others. As we know, neither death, nor principalities or powers can seperate us from the body of Christ. If one “dies” a member of Christs body then they are not dead but alive, thus they can pray for you.
 
Respectfully, I’d ask you to read all the posts in this thread. Many Catholics here are perfectly comfortable with the language of “praying to” Mary. Also, in my original post in this thread, I explicitly acknowledge the distinction between “praying to” and “praying through” Mary, which is what I think you’re saying here.

Pray means ask. The newfangled concept that attempts to restrict prayer solely to ‘communication with God alone’ is not what the apostles or early Christians or indeed most current Christians understood prayer to be. They knew that prayer could be directed to one’s fellows.

Yes. The crucial difference is that I can actually talk to them and they can talk back because they’re “in the body” rather than “at home with the Lord,” to use Paul’s terminology. In order for you to ask a saint or Mary to pray for you, you have to “pray to” them. There’s no getting around that fact. Your fellow Catholics in this thread, by and large, have no trouble admitting that. Why do you?
Why do you think that those ‘at home with the Lord’ have ‘less’ capacity to interact with fellow Christians (living or dead) than we do? If they are in Heaven, and part of Christ’s Body (which itself is glorified), do you think that they are ‘asleep’? Unaware? They are totally 'one with Christ", they ‘see’ as He does, and yet miraculously CHRIST is aware of us and everybody who is perfectly united and conformed to Him is 'blacked out?"
 
Catholics do not pray TO Mary. We ask her to pray FOR us.
We do pray to Mary, and to the saints. This is perfectly fine. The reason Miguel has a problem with it is because, having rejected the priesthood and therefore true worship in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, he has no choice but to equate prayer and worship. He therefore thinks that we are offering to creatures the worship that is due to God alone. He is going to continue to think that no matter how many times we deny it, until he is granted light to see the truth for himself. But there is no need to concede his premise, because it is erroneous.

By the way, Miguel, St. Paul in his Epistles asks the members of the churches he writes to to pray for him. That is precisely what we do when we pray to Mary and the saints. Being in heaven, before God’s throne, there is no one in a better position than they to engage in intercessory prayer of the same sort we ask from each other.
 
We do pray to Mary, and to the saints. This is perfectly fine. The reason Miguel has a problem with it is because, having rejected the priesthood and therefore true worship in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, he has no choice but to equate prayer and worship.

By the way, St. Paul in his Epistles asks the members of the churches he writes to to pray for him. That is precisely what we do when we pray to Mary and the saints. Being in heaven, before God’s throne, there is no one in a better position than they to engage in intercessory prayer of the same sort we ask from each other.
We do not pray to Mary in the sense asserted by Miguel. That is my point.

It is offensive to me that someone would continue to assert something false when that person has been repeatedly shown that their assertion is untrue.

As a different example, I could assert that someone prays to and worships the Moon. The first time I made this assertion, I might be forgiven by that person, since I may have made it in ignorance. Once I have been given the correct information, for me to continue to make the same assertion is something else. And I submit it is uncharitable.
 
Catholics do not infer the Immaculate Conception of Mary based on Luke 1:28. All Luke 1:28 acts to do is provide scriptural support for Sacred Tradition.
Which is to say, Catholics infer the IC from Luke 1:28, albeit through the circuitous rout of Tradition…(Are you really saying Luke 1:28 provides no support for the IC and/or that it isn’t one of the usual texts used by Catholic apologists when trying to establish a biblical basis for the IC? I ask, because that’s all I’m saying.)
A literal examination of the Greek text shows that it is indeed expressing the language of being highly favored but there is a lot more going on here. The problem is that kecharitomene is a perfect past participle, meaning “you who are already favored/graced.”
To that we can add that it is in the vocative case, which is used in salutations. Greek is a highly inflected language. Cases are used where we might use prepositions in English. We can’t modify our participles the way Greek can, so we have to come up with circumlocutions to get at the meaning. The question is, is how much theological meaning can we invest into the term based on the grammar?
The grammar implies something that has reached its completion (i.e., “full”, “finished”, etc.). Whatever it is cannot be in conjunction with her motherhood, because her motherhood has not yet been mentioned, nor has she consented yet to be the mother of the Messiah.
Participles are very tricky in Greek, which is why you almost always need context to determine their meaning, and often there are several plausible interpretations. In this case, the Angel gives us a clue. “You have found favor with God.” (v. 30). And the next verse probably determines the nature of that divine favor: “You will conceive in your womb and bear a son.” So when the Angel addresses Mary as the kecheritoomene, this participle is most likely explained in terms of her future maternity rather than her own past conception. Just because the participle is past does not mean the reason for her favor lies in the past. Participles can and often do have a future force. So what we might say is this. In the past (eternity past), Mary was chosen to be the mother of the Messiah. That would explain the angel’s use of the past tense, and his greeting to her would explain why it’s in the vocative. But the meaning of the greeting is what troubles Mary. She doesn’t get it until the angel explains that she has been favored for having been chosen to give birth to the Messiah.

In any event, my only issue in raising this whole business of “full of grace” was to point out that most modern translations, including Catholic ones have chosen “favored one” ore even “highly favored.” This seems to be the case for both formal and dynamic equivalent versions.
Although Luke describes Stephen as being “full of grace” in Acts 6:8, the grace he experienced was a gift that came upon him at that moment. Therefore, the Greek in Acts 6:8 does not say that Stephen was “already filled with grace” which is why there is a difference in the Greek Luke selected between Luke 1:28 and Acts 6:8.
Yes, I’m not actually arguing that Stephen was immaculately conceived just because he is “full of grace.” I’m just saying that if "full of grace’ (gratia plena) can be used as the basis for the IC, then how much more a text that actually says “full of grace”?
And it is one thing for a translator to disagree with St. Jerome’s choice of words (and therefore use the “favored one” expression), but quite another thing for one to say that he “made a mistake.” I don’t think there are any Scripture scholars out there who go that far. If you disagree then I’ll ask you for a quote.
Maybe not a “mistake” in any egregious sense of the word. But the fact that everyone is opting for “favored one,” or something close to that, suggests, at the very least, that they think they’ve improved up Jerome’s “full of grace.”
Ok, I double-checked. The Ignatius Press RSV says “full of grace” and the New Oxford RSV says “O favored one.” So one version for the Catholics and another version for the Protestants. Go figure.
LOL. Those biased translators!
Are you suggesting that the Latin Vulgate, as a whole, is not a work of brilliance with immeasurable historical impact?
Far be it from me to “dis” the Vulgate. It really was an accomplishment. Kudos to Jerome.
 
Which might only show how early things went wrong.
Here are some early Church writings on the topic:

Hermas

“[The Shepherd said:] ‘But those who are weak and slothful in prayer, hesitate to ask anything from the Lord; but the Lord is full of compassion, and gives without fail to all who ask him. But you, [Hermas,] having been strengthened by the holy angel [you saw], and having obtained from him such intercession, and not being slothful, why do not you ask of the Lord understanding, and receive it from him?’” (The Shepherd 3:5:4 [A.D. **80]).

Clement of Alexandria

“In this way is he [the true Christian] always pure for prayer. He also prays in the society of angels, as being already of angelic rank, and he is never out of their holy keeping; and though he pray alone, he has the choir of the saints standing with him [in prayer]” (Miscellanies 7:12 [A.D. **208]).

Origen

“But not the high priest [Christ] alone prays for those who pray sincerely, but also the angels . . . as also the souls of the saints who have already fallen asleep” (Prayer 11 [A.D. **233]).

Cyprian of Carthage

“Let us remember one another in concord and unanimity. Let us on both sides [of death] always pray for one another. Let us relieve burdens and afflictions by mutual love, that if one of us, by the swiftness of divine condescension, shall go hence first, our love may continue in the presence of the Lord, and our prayers for our brethren and sisters not cease in the presence of the Father’s mercy” (Letters 56[60]:5 [A.D. **253]).

Anonymous

“Atticus, sleep in peace, secure in your safety, and pray anxiously for our sins” (funerary inscription near St. Sabina’s in Rome [A.D.** 300]).

“Pray for your parents, Matronata Matrona. She lived one year, fifty-two days” (ibid.).

Methodius

“Hail to you for ever, Virgin Mother of God, our unceasing joy, for to you do I turn again. You are the beginning of our feast; you are its middle and end; the pearl of great price that belongs to the kingdom; the fat of every victim, the living altar of the Bread of Life [Jesus]. Hail, you treasure of the love of God. Hail, you fount of the Son’s love for man. . . . You gleamed, sweet gift-bestowing Mother, with the light of the sun; you gleamed with the insupportable fires of a most fervent charity, bringing forth in the end that which was conceived of you . . . making manifest the mystery hidden and unspeakable, the invisible Son of the Father—the Prince of Peace, who in a marvelous manner showed himself as less than all littleness” (Oration on Simeon and Anna 14 [A.D. **305]).

“Therefore, we pray [ask] you, the most excellent among women, who glories in the confidence of your maternal honors, that you would unceasingly keep us in remembrance. O holy Mother of God, remember us, I say, who make our boast in you, and who in august hymns celebrate the memory, which will ever live, and never fade away” (ibid.).

“And you also, O honored and venerable Simeon, you earliest host of our holy religion, and teacher of the resurrection of the faithful, do be our patron and advocate with that Savior God, whom you were deemed worthy to receive into your arms. We, together with you, sing our praises to Christ, who has the power of life and death, saying, ‘You are the true Light, proceeding from the true Light; the true God, begotten of the true God’” (ibid.).

**“Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses…” Heb. 12:1
**
May I ask, how early did “things go wrong?” Was it in 80 AD with Hermas, in 208 AD with Clement, in 253 AD with Cyprian, or in 305 AD with Methodius? And if your answer is 80 AD with Hermas, then what kind of promise was “the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church” if apostasy crept in immediately? How is it that the Apostles were so incapable of handing on the faith “once for all?”

All of these quotes were well before the councils met to determine the New Testament. Given their total inability to interpret Scripture on this matter and others (according to many Protestants), how is it that this Church could be trusted to decide which NT books were inspired? Would your argument be that an apostate church (guided by the Holy Spirit) gave us the NT canon, and was incapable both before, and after, of interpreting it? If yes, then how do you know that you are interpreting it correctly?
 
(continued from my last post)
Which might only show how early things went wrong.
The ancient Christians who were suffering persecution prayed to those among them who were executed. So those suffering persecution were praying to the martyrs in the middle of the 1st Century before the New Testament was completed. In Revelation, the letters to the various churches included Jesus’ criticism of many of their un-Christian practices. Likewise, Revelation states that those who commit idolatry will be condemned to hell. Furthermore, the primary target audience of Revelation were Christians suffering persecution (to bolster their faith in such a frightening time). In light of all this, if praying to martyrs was a problem, Revelation would have been the perfect place to specifically address it.

And keep in mind that the ancient Christians had a very keen sense of what idolatry was and was not. After all, they were being tortured and brutally executed for not commiting idolatry. It is hard to imagine that they were willing to die for not committing idolatry, only to practice idolatry while burying their dead.
Or possibly the inscription is intended only as prayer for the dead. Thus the “Ora Pro Nobis,” is from the point of view of the dead rather than the living. On this reading the inscription would function as a reminder to the living to keep the dead in mind when they pray. It’s not really evidence that Christians were praying to saints at this point in church history.
This interpretation of “Ora Pro Nobis” was not a possibility for the ancient Christians concerning the martyrs. They believed that a person who endured persecution and then died rather than renounce Christ was automatically brought into heaven. To their mindset, the martyrs had no need of anyone’s prayers.

Furthermore, the Catholic Church is not acting in this matter like a historical agency that suddenly came across these ancient tombs inscribed with “Ora Pro Nobis”, and then tried to determine the significance of the words. These tombs and the significance of the inscriptions have always been known, being handed down from generation to generation. It is part of the living history of the Church.
The highway to hell is paved with good intentions. (Was it Augstine who said that?) In any event, I think the distinction between formal and material idolatry would be helpful here. If praying to saints is wrong, but you’re not intending to do wrong, then perhaps the idolatry in question is only material, rather than formal. But that’s a side issue. I’m more interested in the Catholic case for the practice.
I gave you the Catholic case already. In light of what I previously stated, a Catholic who prays to the saints according to the guidelines of the Church cannot commit idolatry with such an action.
Wow. I find it incredible that God would approve of such a practice and not mention a word about it in scripture.
I already gave scriptural support for this practice in Post 58. It can be inferred from Scripture, even though that is not needed for belief. And I likewise find it incredible how anyone could approve of the doctrine of Sola Scriptura which cannot be demonstrated from Scripture in any form or fashion.
As I said before, this isn’t something like the Trinity that really is a matter trying to make sense of everything scripture says about Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
If you think that you can conclusively demonstrate the Doctrine of the Holy Trinity exclusively from Scripture then I invite you to go to a Seventh Day Adventist forum and test that theory. They reject the Doctrine of the Holy Trinity on the sole basis that it cannot clearly be proven from Scripture. At best you can infer it and make logical deductions from Scripture, as I did in Post #58 with the concept of praying to the saints.
This is a spiritual practice. And yet no one seems to engage in it from Genesis to Revelation. In fact, when people are tempted to bow down/pray to/worship anything other than God, we only see scripture condemning the practice.
The ancient Jews initially thought that when people died, they simply became shadows in the netherworld (the good and bad alike), with no ability to even praise God. Praying to such a person would have been pointless. It was not until the later Old Testament period that the Jews developed the concept of Limbo, where the afterlife was more than simply being a shadow. But even then, they saw the righteous departed enjoying one another’s company, but were still not in heaven, and therefore not in the presence of God. The Jews on earth would not have had the concept of a departed person being able to act as an intercessor.

But for the ancient Christians, the idea is that a person specifically in heaven is a very powerful intercessor due to that closeness to God. No one could enter heaven until the sacrifice of Christ opened the gates. Therefore, in terms of praying to the saints, we are talking about a practice that began and gradually caught on during the 1st Century, but from a theological perspective there is no reason to think that the concept would even show up prior to the New Testament, or even as part of the gospels. Acts would be an applicable location to find it, or as part of an epistle. But there are many other Christian concepts not addressed in Acts or the Epistles either. And, as I mentioned earlier, if this practice was problematic, one would reasonably expect to find it specifically condemned in Revelation.
 
We do pray to Mary, and to the saints.
Thank you for saying this. I’ve been accused of uncharity for accusing you of this very thing.
The reason Miguel has a problem with it is because, having rejected the priesthood and therefore true worship in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, he has no choice but to equate prayer and worship.
I don’t know about that. I don’t see praying to and worship as the same thing. But I think the two practices often come together. I wouldn’t want to say, for example, that when the Israelites “bowed down” to the Baals, they were worshipping them but NOT praying to them. So while conceptually I can see a difference between the two, in practice I wonder if they are conjoined (at least in the case of ancient Israel).
By the way, Miguel, St. Paul in his Epistles asks the members of the churches he writes to to pray for him. That is precisely what we do when we pray to Mary and the saints. Being in heaven, before God’s throne, there is no one in a better position than they to engage in intercessory prayer of the same sort we ask from each other.
The crucial difference, of course, is that you have to “pray to” Mary and the saints in order to ask them to “pray for” you. Paul, however, was still “in the body” and addressed his prayer requests to others still in the body. By “in the body,” I mean still living on earth rather than living in heaven. Another difference, it seems to me, is that in asking the Ephesians to pray for him, the Ephesians could write back and say, “You’ve got.” In other words, the communication between Paul and the Ephesians is interpersonal, whereas the communication between a Catholic and Mary or a saint is intrapersonal. To me, that’s all the difference in the world.
 
Still waiting for you, Miguel, to show the consistent Christian teaching, historically, that Christians did not ‘pray to the saints.’

Ever seen the inscriptions in the catecombs, Miguel? Are you aware that there are prayers inscribed to those who have died for the faith? Chiseled in the rock? So where is the Christian teaching prior to AD 1500 that ‘only those in the body’ are ‘able’ to speak or hear prayer and that prayer is ‘attached’ to only worship and nothing else?
 
Still waiting for you, Miguel, to show the consistent Christian teaching, historically, that Christians did not ‘pray to the saints.’

Ever seen the inscriptions in the catecombs, Miguel? Are you aware that there are prayers inscribed to those who have died for the faith? Chiseled in the rock? So where is the Christian teaching prior to AD 1500 that ‘only those in the body’ are ‘able’ to speak or hear prayer and that prayer is ‘attached’ to only worship and nothing else?
I realize he is probably busy, but I’m also awaiting his answer to my scriptual responses as well as to his interpretations of certain passages. God bless,
 
We do not pray to Mary in the sense asserted by Miguel. That is my point.
I was trying to make the same point. 🙂 I just didn’t want to deny that we pray to Mary and the saints, because we do. The trouble is that we are dealing with somebody who does not mean the same thing we mean by “pray.”

By the way, I meant to address my second paragraph in that post to Miguel explicitly, but forgot to do so.
 
I was trying to make the same point. 🙂 I just didn’t want to deny that we pray to Mary and the saints, because we do. The trouble is that we are dealing with somebody who does not mean the same thing we mean by “pray.”
I thought so, but I wanted to make that clear to anyone who did not understand that.

Further, I submit that once we have clearly explained what we do, and supported it, it is rude for anyone to continue to insist something else just because they have a different belief.

The question in the opening post has been asked and answered. That should be the end of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top