You claim this doctrine comes from Jesus–that he “said so.” How do you know?
Because Christ is the head of the Church, and has given the Church the guidance and authority to interpret the Deposit of Faith.
Why do I have to demonstrate this from the Bible? (I’m not saying I can’t. There is plenty of reason to make God’s written word our theological starting point. But why do you add, “from the Bible” to your challenge to demonstrate the plausibility of sola scriptura?)
I have no problem with starting with a hypothesis, but the conclusion has to be in keeping with the Law of Noncontradition. Truth cannot contain a contradiction, and because God is Truth Itself, this logic can be applied to Christian doctrine.
Sola Scriptura means “Scripture Alone.” The idea is that if a proposed doctrine is not demonstrated in Scripture then it should be rejected. The doctrine of Sola Scriptura fails its own test, because no where does the Bible teach it. Therefore the doctrine of Sola Scriptura contains a contradiction, because if it is true, it teaches us to reject it. To put this another way, it is an extra-biblical teaching that tells us to reject extra-biblical teachings.
Let’s do the math. If there are three “contenders” for being the rule of faith (scripture, tradition and the magisterium) and if two out of three of them have erred by contradicting the third, then 3-2 = 1. The only “contender” still standing is the Bible (and liberals everywhere want to knock that one down too).
I know of no contradictions between Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the official interpretations of the Magisterium regarding them.
I guess that’s why you’re a Catholic.
It would be more accurate to say that this is one of the reasons I became a Catholic. I was very resistant to the idea at first, and in trying to refute Catholic positions I ended up discovering the truths of them.
But I would argue on the basis of how doctrinal issues are debated in scripture for the preeminence of scripture. We all know what is said about scripture’s inspiration.
I agree that Scripture is divinely inspired. I will also point out that a lot of the books that make up the Bible don’t expressly designate themselves to be divinely inspired, leaving the Magisterium the job of determining this. I propose that the Letter of Paul to Philemon is one such example.
Nothing like this is said about the magisterium or tradition.
Sacred Tradition & Magisterium:
St. Paul says that he passes on Christian teaching through a variety of means, including the written word as well as by the spoken word and by his example (2Thess 2:15; Col 4:9). If Sola Scriptura were true, he would have mentioned the written word and stopped there.
St. Paul tells us to accept the traditions passed down by him and the Church (2Thess 3:6; 1Cor 11:2).
There are doctrines and teachings accepted by Protestants that not found in the Bible, such as the Doctrine of the Holy Trinity, and the practice of transferring the observance of the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. These are examples of Sacred Tradition.
St. Paul states the Church to be the pillar and bulark of the truth (1Timothy 3:15). If he were a proponent of Sola Scriptura he would have credited such a profound statement to Scripture, not the Church.
The Canon of Scripture itself was determined by an action of the Magisterium. In antiquity what we think of as the Bible was a collection of scrolls from both the Old Testament era and the New Testament era. Furthermore, there were many religious scrolls that arose from both Jewish and Christian communities that many considered divinely inspired. The Magisterium addressed this situation by determining which scrolls were and were not divinely inspired. This is why, for example, the Gospel of John is in the Bible but the Gospel of Thomas is not.
I can show you from the book of Revelation, for example, that John believes that not only the Lord’s oral word, but also his written word is infallibly true.
I believe this as well. But since you mentioned Revelation, it is worth noting that many ancient Christians did not believe it was truly inspired. Nevertheless, the Magisterium declared it to be so, and therefore it is in the Bible. So in light of this, it is tricky to use the Book of Revelation in a way that reject’s the authority of the Magisterium.
So as a matter of prudence, it’s better to trust what we know to be true than what theoretically might be true.
In Christianity, for 1500 years there was no question that Sacred Tradition was one of the means through which we receive divine revelation. No one ever suggested that it might not be true until the Protestant Reformation. I agree that Catholics and Protestants can have a lot of dialog centered on the Bible for the fact that we all agree that it is divinely inspired. It is an important area of common ground between us. But this does not mean that the validity of Catholic doctrines have to demonstrated according to the rules of Sola Scriptura.
Since all interested parties in this debate accept scripture as authoritative, that’s probably the safest starting point. But that’s really a matter for another thread, don’t you think?
I agree that the concept of Sola Scriptura is more than enough to warrant its own thread. I assume that discussions on it regularly come up in this forum anyway. As for the discussion at hand, I think it is fine if Catholics want to discuss the merits of praying to saints based on Scripture. After all, as you know, I have thrown in my two-cents here and there along these lines. But I think it is also important to note that, for Catholics, Scripture is not the only source for doctrine.