Armed task force to patrol streets

  • Thread starter Thread starter Seamus_L
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The proposal is generating a lot of controversy in town. The police had scheduled four town hall meetings to discuss crime. But after the proposal was unveiled at the second meeting, the next two meetings were canceled.
In the statement released Monday, the department sites the strong feelings for and against the Street Crimes Unit and the town hall meetings as cause of the cancellation.
Part of the statement by police reads:
“We feel that with the strong feelings on both sides of the Street Crimes Unit issue, a safe and productive meeting would not be the probable outcome.”
kait8.com/story/20317507/paragould-focuses-on-safety-through-town-hall-meetings

Paragould is a small city (26,000 population) located in the northeast corner of Arkansas. Its violent crime rate is lower than the state average, but it has a high rate of property crime (nearly double the state average)
cityrating.com/crime-statistics/arkansas/paragould.html

Both types of crimes surged around 2005 and have stayed at historically high levels since then.
 
Yeah, I don’t think this will survive for long. I mean walking patrols to try to fight crime - fine. That may even be a good idea. But stopping everyone and demanding proof that they are not engaged in criminal activity with no reason to suspect that particular person of anything? Not cool. I imagine a court will smack that down fairly quickly.
 
Im ok with this. The area has a very high crime rate and these patrols will hopfully cut down on crime
 
I’m having trouble reading the article in its entirety as the page keeps flipping up and down on me. But from what I read, its a step up from normal, “cop on the beat” protocol, which is to be friendly, engage everyone you run across with a smile, conversation, small talk, and be a known presence on the street. It is amazing how cops on a beat, even in big cities like Manhattan, can know so many people and get a feel for when something isn’t right. Beat cops in small places like this town can be even more effective.

Sounds like they are backing off the ID thing, and the dress-up idea carrying assault weapons does sound a bit over-dramatic.

We used to travel to Mexico a lot many years ago, and having the police and military patrol in military uniform with assault weapons always gave us a chill and never made us feel any safer. Others may feel differently.
 
How is it giving up liberty? They only ask you for ID and where you are going? What is so wrong with that?🤷
Actually, if you read the article, they stop you, take your name and address and record it. Which means, now, not only would I have to “carry papers.” I also have to have my movements monitored.

Sorry, where I go and whom I am with, it not the police’s business, unless I am doing something illegal. Since going for a walk is not illegal, there is no reason to stop me.
 
Actually, if you read the article, they stop you, take your name and address and record it. Which means, now, not only would I have to “carry papers.” I also have to have my movements monitored.

Sorry, where I go and whom I am with, it not the police’s business, unless I am doing something illegal. Since going for a walk is not illegal, there is no reason to stop me.
I actually read a different article and that article did not mention about them recording all that stuff. Cops do have a right to stop anyone and ask for Ids Im still ok with that just not the recording as you mention
 
Once an area has been identified as a high crime neighborhood, the select group of officers will saturate the area in an attempt to curb the criminal behavior that is plaguing that particular neighborhood. Officers will accomplish this in a variety of different methods. Officers will be working to identify residents in the affected area so that we can better serve our affected neighborhoods. Most often, this identification process will be nothing more than making contact with a subject, handing them a business card, and asking if they live in the area and if there’s anything we can do for them. During hours in which crime seems to be more prevalent (i.e. between the hours of 11pm and 5 am), our process will become more stringent. We will be asking for picture identification. We will be ascertaining where the subject lives and what they are doing in the area. We will be keeping a record of those we contact.
From another source:
theblaze.com/stories/why-is-an-arkansas-city-deploying-police-with-ar-15s-demand-citizens-show-i-d-on-the-streets/

So they will stop you, take your information, record it and save it in case they need it for questioning later.
 
I have little respect for the ACLU but I hope they lay the hammer down in the courts over this.
 
How is it giving up liberty? They only ask you for ID and where you are going? What is so wrong with that?🤷
It’s none of there business, or anybody’s business, unless I am doing something illegal. They are not my mother; I do not have to report to them just to walk around. You do realize that if you tell them it is none of their business, or you lie, you will be in trouble with these gestapo, right? And I use the word gestapo because this smacks of armed gestapo or communist ‘police’ who always ask people walking outside for their ‘papers’. No wonder the town meetings started to go ballistic - they should.
Hitler always used the excuse of ‘it is for your improved security’ as he took away Germans’ rights day by day and spread his armed goons throughout the cities. Wake up. And read some history.

God bless you.
 
I actually read a different article and that article did not mention about them recording all that stuff. Cops do have a right to stop anyone and ask for Ids Im still ok with that just not the recording as you mention
While driving since a driver must be licensed, but not while walking - we are not required in this country to carry ‘papers’ at all times, nor produce id. If you travel and read guidelines before going to another nation, you will find that in many other nations you are expected by law to carry some type of ‘papers’ with you at all times, and to present these when asked to do so by police or other authorities.

Not so in the US, which sets us apart. I wouldn’t be surprised if this is some type of ‘trial balloon’ to see just how far ‘they’ can go before people rise up against it. I remember a few years ago when a governor of a state out of the limelight ‘suggested’ we should postpone the national election since things were ‘too chaotic at the moment’. That too was a trial balloon, and fortunately the people went ballistic and the governor said ‘just kidding!’

God bless you.
 
How is it giving up liberty? They only ask you for ID and where you are going? What is so wrong with that?🤷
Because the chief said that if you did not cooperate you would be arrested for obstructing a government operation. This rather ignorant police chief will soon find out that he can not re-write the Constitution to meet his needs. I predict that if this city does not stop this before it is started, they will be paying through the nose for wrongful arrest suits.

Yes, police have the right to stop and ask anyone anything. However, they have no right to arrest because the person does not have ID, or does not want to tell them their business out. Worse yet, because this is now in the news, I look for some to go there just to walk the streets and antagonize the heck out of these police.
 
Hard to read the article. It’s unstable or something.

But what I could read without going blind entirely made me wonder how this is a whole lot different from the old fashioned “cop on the beat”. Those guys most definitely kept track of the people in the neighborhood. I think it’s reasonable to believe these cops will very quickly learn who belongs in a neighborhood and who is new to it. I feel pretty confident they will get to personally know most residents.

I recall a few years ago when there was a lot of property crime in a particular neighborhood in my town. So, the city administration sent a bunch of cops to “pound the beat”, walk the sidewalks, alleys, and so on. If they encountered anybody that didn’t look right, they asked for ID and what the person was doing. They quickly learned who lived in the neighborhood and gave the known peaceful citizens no hassle at all.

The cops really hated it because it’s a lot more comfortable to ride around in a cruiser. The property crime really did drop off though, and eventually the city quit doing it. But it did serve its purpose, and had a lasting effect because the bad guys couldn’t be sure they wouldn’t suddenly start doing it again. If you’re thinking of crawling into somebody’s back window or breaking into somebody’s car and don’t know if a cop will see or hear you doing it, you will think long and hard before making the decision.
 
Hard to read the article. It’s unstable or something.

But what I could read without going blind entirely made me wonder how this is a whole lot different from the old fashioned “cop on the beat”. Those guys most definitely kept track of the people in the neighborhood. I think it’s reasonable to believe these cops will very quickly learn who belongs in a neighborhood and who is new to it. I feel pretty confident they will get to personally know most residents.

I recall a few years ago when there was a lot of property crime in a particular neighborhood in my town. So, the city administration sent a bunch of cops to “pound the beat”, walk the sidewalks, alleys, and so on. If they encountered anybody that didn’t look right, they asked for ID and what the person was doing. They quickly learned who lived in the neighborhood and gave the known peaceful citizens no hassle at all.

The cops really hated it because it’s a lot more comfortable to ride around in a cruiser. The property crime really did drop off though, and eventually the city quit doing it. But it did serve its purpose, and had a lasting effect because the bad guys couldn’t be sure they wouldn’t suddenly start doing it again. If you’re thinking of crawling into somebody’s back window or breaking into somebody’s car and don’t know if a cop will see or hear you doing it, you will think long and hard before making the decision.
The article made it sound more invasive than asking a few questions. I don’t think most of us have a problem with cops walking around and just talking to people who are out. But the wording the mayor used in the article made it sound more like the cops would treat anyone they see as a potential criminal and aggressively interrogate them as to their purpose (requiring proof of innocence to allow the person to move on).

I think there is a perfectly good thing that the city could do that is pretty close to what they’re talking about doing, and I hope they do it.
 
Best advice that any smart lawyer will tell you if you are questioned by police, is to be calm and polite, and to tell them you are choosing to remain silent. Then you alternately ask them “Am I being detained” and "“Am I free to go”. Answering questions regarding why you are in an area, how often you go there, what times a day, are definite no no’s.
 
Best advice that any smart lawyer will tell you if you are questioned by police, is to be calm and polite, and to tell them you are choosing to remain silent. Then you alternately ask them “Am I being detained” and "“Am I free to go”. Answering questions regarding why you are in an area, how often you go there, what times a day, are definite no no’s.
If the police are following the law, they will have to end it there, if it is just a routine stop and check. However, there is nothing to prohibit them from keeping a picture of people that refuse in case criminal activitiy arises. Then they can question people with opportunity as potential witnesses.

We must remember that police also have a right and a duty to investigate crime. If these questions are asked in an investigateion of a crime, they do have the right to detain you, if you refuse to answer, for identification purposes. This however only is when a crime is being investigated and they have some probable cause that the person they detain may be involved either as an actor as a witness. So saying nothing doesn’t always fly, even though it is perfectly legal for the type of stops in this article.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top