Ask a Muslim

  • Thread starter Thread starter arab
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
proudcatholic2 said:
My account was suspended 3 times (Now they blocked my IP, so I can’t even access this site, Why all this?) because Catholics hate me for saying that there is such a thing as a Catholic (Christian) Terrorist. Some hate me because I am a Muslim (remember Jesus Loves us All). To those who are angry with me I say that I am very sorry, but I had to tell the truth, and believe me I feel your pain (It hurts). For those who say there is no such a thing as a Catholic (Christian) terrorist I have no apology at all.

You must face it, Catholic (Christian) terrorist exist…and here we go again, very sad news:

Thursday, 8 September 2005
Rwanda
Several Rwandan priests (Catholic Terrorists) and nuns have been convicted of participating in the killing of some 800,000 minority Tutsis and moderate Hutus.
For details, please visit: news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/africa/4225366.stm

Feel free to email me your questions: proudcatholic@minister.com

Seek the truth, tell it but do not hide it. I Share You Decide
Click to expand...
Decide what? Read my post,…if you think because an individual ‘ACT’ in opposition to clear Church teaching, that some how proves a point, please tell me what point you are trying to make. I totally don’t believe you are kept off this site because you only want to ‘share the truth’. That’s ridiculous. Are you trying to tell me that people *on this web *site DENY that a Catholic, (in name only) has NEVER done anything wrong? How stupid. The Catholic Church IS FULL of illicit history, evil ‘men’ doing ’ THEIR OWN WILL’, not Gods, but how does this compare to what the Church, *actually *preaches and teaches, compared to what Islam preaches and teaches. Muslims are free to believe what they want, it is their right as Americans, and I respect that, but don’t try to put up some evil Priest as a representation of Christianity, when you know it isn’t. Please tell me what Islam really teaches, that is the TRUE essence of the difference. These priests and nuns, do these things of their OWN accord, not with the blessings of the Church, and NOT IN ANY CONTEXT OF THE NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES, so again, what’s your point here?
 
meedo said:
In all sincerity, muslims should suppoort Justice against evil, regardless of faith.

Muslims do decry against evil and against injsutice. But it is not their job alone to stop evil and injustice.

salam
Click to expand...
If you read my previous posts you would see that I said we Christians must also do what can be done to stop evil, whether done by non-Christians or Christians.
My question is still out there I think.
Does the Quran instruct Muslims not to defend non-Muslims against other Muslims even if those Muslims are doing evil to the non-Muslims?
Example:
A Muslim man murders a Jewish child. He is witnessed by fellow Muslims. Do the witnesses have an moral obligation to report what they witnessed? Or are they instructed by the Quran not to intercede for the Jewish victim because the assailant is Muslim?
As a Christian, should it be reversed, I would be morally obligated to report what I had witnessed. This example would be that a Christian man murders a Muslim child. For which he should be arrested, prosecuted and sentenced to a term of prison.
Could someone who is familiar with the Quran please answer?
 
slyboots said:
If you read my previous posts you would see that I said we Christians must also do what can be done to stop evil, whether done by non-Christians or Christians.
My question is still out there I think.
Does the Quran instruct Muslims not to defend non-Muslims against other Muslims even if those Muslims are doing evil to the non-Muslims?
Example:
A Muslim man murders a Jewish child. He is witnessed by fellow Muslims. Do the witnesses have an moral obligation to report what they witnessed? Or are they instructed by the Quran not to intercede for the Jewish victim because the assailant is Muslim?
As a Christian, should it be reversed, I would be morally obligated to report what I had witnessed. This example would be that a Christian man murders a Muslim child. For which he should be arrested, prosecuted and sentenced to a term of prison.
Could someone who is familiar with the Quran please answer?
Click to expand...
I know. As always, the question is dodged.
 
Odd they bring up Hitler. He is very popular in Muslim countries. Mein Kampf was a best seller at the Cairo bookfair this year. They seem to think he is a hero.
 
cestusdei said:
Odd they bring up Hitler. He is very popular in Muslim countries. Mein Kampf was a best seller at the Cairo bookfair this year. They seem to think he is a hero.
Click to expand...
Well said! The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was prepared to hand over the Jews to the Germans - has the allies lost in the battle for north Africa.

“Mohammad Amin al-Husayni (ca. 1895 - July 4, 1974, أمين الحسيني, alternatively spelt al-Husseini), the Mufti of Jerusalem, was a Palestinian Arab nationalist and a Muslim religious leader. Known for his anti-Zionism, al-Husayni fought against the establishment of a Jewish state in the territory of the British Mandate of Palestine. To this end, Husayni collaborated with Nazi Germany during World War II and helped recruit Muslims for the Waffen-SS.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Amin_al-Husayni

There was some suggestion that ultra-rightist Timothy McVeigh had some financial aid from the Saudis. The commonality is their feeling about Jews
 
slyboots said:
My question is still out there I think.
Does the Quran instruct Muslims not to defend non-Muslims against other Muslims even if those Muslims are doing evil to the non-Muslims?
Click to expand...
No the Quran doesnt say so .
slyboots said:
Example:
A Muslim man murders a Jewish child. He is witnessed by fellow Muslims. Do the witnesses have an moral obligation to report what they witnessed? Or are they instructed by the Quran not to intercede for the Jewish victim because the assailant is Muslim?
Click to expand...
First the Muslim should stop the other Muslim from commiting the murder by force if possible, if he cant then he should report him and he must testify with all what he saw in court in full truth. Even if the other muslim is his very close relative . It doesnt matter who the victim is or what they beleiev. and it doesnt matter who the injustice doer is and what they believe.
slyboots said:
As a Christian, should it be reversed, I would be morally obligated to report what I had witnessed. This example would be that a Christian man murders a Muslim child. For which he should be arrested, prosecuted and sentenced to a term of prison.
Could someone who is familiar with the Quran please answer?
Click to expand...
Same in Islam . I am a muslim who is familiar with the Quran.

salam
 
I have been thinking hard but I can’t remember a recent instance of Muslims killing other Muslims to defend Jews.
 
meedo said:
First the Muslim should stop the other Muslim from commiting the murder by force if possible, if he cant then he should report him and he must testify with all what he saw in court in full truth. Even if the other muslim is his very close relative . It doesnt matter who the victim is or what they beleiev. and it doesnt matter who the injustice doer is and what they believe.
Click to expand...
Where in the Koran does it say so?
 
Montalban said:
Moslems and Mormons are so sure that the Bible just must have been corrupted.😉
Click to expand...
Thier ‘restoration’ doctrines depend on this idea. Where there is no corruption, there is no apostacy. Where there is no apostacy, there’s no need for a restoration. Where would that lead their respective ‘prophets’?
 
Chris_LaRock said:
Thier ‘restoration’ doctrines depend on this idea. Where there is no corruption, there is no apostacy. Where there is no apostacy, there’s no need for a restoration. Where would that lead their respective ‘prophets’?
Click to expand...
Indeed! The problem is when they also want to pretend to respect the *previous *message(s).

Ask them to list all that’s wrong and they come unstuck
 
Montalban said:
Indeed! The problem is when they also want to pretend to respect the *previous *message(s).

Ask them to list all that’s wrong and they come unstuck
Click to expand...
They just point to the passages that disagree with thier theology and say that those were the corrupted parts.
 
Chris_LaRock said:
They just point to the passages that disagree with their theology and say that those were the corrupted parts.
Click to expand...
An interesting thing about Islam is that they believe Jesus was a Moslem.

They believe that he (as a prophet) brought the same message of their god to the people, only that the followers of Jesus messed up the message.

An important development of this is where Moslem apologists want to present Islam in a better light by saying that they too believe in Jesus and Moses et al. Well, they do, but a different concept of Jesus than what we have.

Not just that Jesus is the Son of God, but the actual message Jesus brought.
 
Their idea of peace is world where everyone different than them is either coverted or killed.
 
kindlylight said:
The position re tolerance in Islam is correctly expressed by Arab. Robert Spencer who wrote the excellent book “The Truth about Muhammad” now lives according to the book cover in a secure but secret location, so be careful what you say as bodyguards don’t come cheap,;).
Click to expand...
Just wondering…

Did Dan Brown have to hire bodyguards to protect him from Catholics?😉

My experiences with Muslims is limited, but they don’t seem very friendly.
 
Marrying a muslim is frought with danger.

My experience has taught me that muslims can be friendly so long as you accept dhimmitude and submit to them. But if you insist that you are equal to them or dare to disagree with their religion suddenly they are unfriendly and may try to hurt you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top