Asked to Get Slim, Cheese Resists

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
NY Times:
Asked to Get Slim, Cheese Resists
MILWAUKEE — In the centuries that Americans have been making cheese, they have gotten very good at it, producing world-class Cheddars and chèvres, to name just two varieties. But more recently, cheese making has been something of a struggle. Under pressure to reduce sodium and saturated fats in American diets — especially those of children — the cheese industry has tried to make products with less salt or fat that consumers will like.
It has not had great success.
“We’ve made some progress in that arena,” said Gregory D. Miller, president of the Dairy Research Institute. “But we have not been able to crack the code.”
Dr. Miller, whose group is financed by the dairy industry, was referring to efforts to reduce salt, but he had a similar appraisal of the challenges of low-fat cheese. “When you take a lot of the fat out, essentially cheese will turn into an eraser,” he said.
The trouble with cheese is that salt and fat are critical components, responsible for far more of its character than consumers might think.
Salt helps control moisture content and bacterial activity — the starter culture that is added to the milk and naturally occurring strains. All of them can flavor the cheese, for better or worse, as it ages.
“Salt serves as a preservative, as a director of flavor development,” said Mark Johnson, senior scientist with the Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. “If I remove it, my flavor goes in a different direction.”
Fat affects moisture levels, too — less fat generally means more water, which can speed spoilage — and helps govern texture, balancing out proteins so a cheese slices properly and feels right when chewed.
Because salt and fat both affect moisture, it is particularly difficult to make a product that is low in both.
Gee, I could have saved them all the fancy explanations; fat + salt = flavor, no way around it.
Enjoy your cheese, cut down on fats elsewhere.
 
Well, I recall this study article about eating diary products, with a mention about cheese, and loosing body fat. I guess personally if i was looking to drop a few pounds, I’d be more concerned about eating sugar, wheat and other grain products as they tend to put the weight on me I’ve noticed in the past.

“Dairy products can assist weight loss”

drbriffa.com/2011/07/26/dairy-products-can-assist-weight-loss/

snippet:
…There is considerable evidence linking higher intakes of calcium and dairy products with reduced body fatness [2]. It has been suggested that not just calcium, but other chemical constituents in dairy products somehow assist fat loss. There is evidence that supplementing the diet with dairy products (yoghurt) can enhance fat loss, including abdominal fat [3,4].
In light of this, I was interested to read a recently published study in which diets containing different amounts of protein and dairy products were tested in a group of overweight and obese women [5]. All women engaged in aerobic and/or resistance exercise, and ate a diet reduced in calories. The women were randomised to eat one of three diets:
  1. High protein, high dairy (30 per cent of calories from protein, 15 per cent from dairy)
  1. Adequate protein, medium dairy (15 per cent of calories from protein, 7.5 per cent from dairy)
  1. Adequate protein, low dairy (15 per cent of calories from protein, < 2 per cent from dairy)
The trial lasted a total of 16 weeks.
All groups lost weight and body fat, but there were differences between the groups. Here are the highlights:
Fat loss was greater with diet 1 than diets 2 and 3.
Those eating diet 1 saw an increase in lean mass (e.g. muscle), while those eating diet 2 maintained lean mass and those eating diet 3 lost lean mass.
Those eating diet 1 lost more ‘visceral’ fat than those eating diet 2 (visceral fat is fat found in and around the abdominal organs and is particularly strongly linked with ill-health).
Loss of visceral fat was correlated with calcium and protein intakes – in other words, higher intakes of calcium and/or protein were associated with greater losses of visceral fat.
The authors of the study concluded that:
“Therefore, diet- and exercise-induced weight loss with higher protein and increased dairy product intakes promotes more favorable body composition changes in women characterized by greater total and visceral fat loss and lean mass gain.”
One of the major downsides to dairy, on the other hand, is that it’s a quite-common cause of food sensitivity reactions. My experience in practice is that pasteurised milk is the worse offender here, and I advocate raw dairy products (where available) if at all possible as these do seem to be much better tolerated…
 
👍 As a Wisconsinite, I advocate the eating of any type of cheese. No cheese prejudice here.

Personally, I’d cut back on other things before I’d cut out my cheese. :rolleyes:
 
“Poets have been mysteriously silent on the subject of cheese.”
― G.K. Chesterton, Alarms and Discursions
 
NY Times:

Gee, I could have saved them all the fancy explanations; fat + salt = flavor, no way around it.
Enjoy your cheese, cut down on fats elsewhere.
I remember a study down several years ago that revealed the fat in cheese is not metabolized the same way as the fat in milk and other saturated fats. The Italians, French, and Greeks instinctively knew this for decades as cheese is a healthy staple in the Mediterranean diet. Eating the fat in cheese, as well as foods containing monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, does not make people fat; it’s excessive sugar consumption and artificial sweeteners that make people fat.
 
News flash! Cheddar Cheese is not orange!!!

At least not in Cheddar England.
 
Cheese bigots!!! 😃
True!

If you want to hear a bunch of whiners talk to some British Expats about Cheese in North America.

Utter bigotry!

BTW Pete_29 - you say you are getting better, but then your location has you down as “so ill”! Which is it?😛
 
There is no food better than cheese. I eat great quantities of it on everything. I will never give it up. Yum yum yum!!!😃
 
I do miss Stilton!

Don’t get me started!

And I miss Cheshire and Lancashire and Wensleydale, and Red Leicester,

withdraws in order to mourn privately!:bighanky:
 
Reduce wheat! (Except for communion; it’s the only concession I make). Other than that, I love my fats (all kinds, except vegetable oils [processed seed oils]), meat, veggies, and fruit (occasional). Primal/Paleo, the way nature/God intended 😃
 
I say three cheers for cheese. I follow a carb-control Aitkens maintenance diet to control my weight, and that allows for the cheese I crave.
 
reduced fat cheese is so . . . . . . eeeewww. . . .

If folks don’t want to get fat then just don’t eat so MUCH cheese. Dont settle for gross cheese.

I mean Jeez. . . . . cheese. . . . . . please. . . .
 
reduced fat cheese is so . . . . . . eeeewww. . . .

If folks don’t want to get fat then just don’t eat so MUCH cheese. Dont settle for gross cheese.

I mean Jeez. . . . . cheese. . . . . . please. . . .
👍 When it comes to cheese I want the real thing.
 
There is a great show on one of my cable channels called Cheese Slices. It goes around the world checking out varieties of cheese and how its made, from the cow/goat/sheep to the finished product.

mmmmm cheese

👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top