Assault-weapons ban no guarantee mass shootings would decrease, data shows

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cavman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Cavman

Guest
Congress is poised to launch into a contentious debate next year over reinstating the assault-weapons ban.

In the wake of the Connecticut elementary school massacre, Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., already has vowed to introduce such a bill at the start of the session. President Obama is voicing support.

But crime trends over the past few decades offer a mixed verdict on whether renewing the ban would reduce the kinds of mass shootings that have spurred calls for its re-enactment in the first place.

Data published earlier this year showed that while the ban was in place, from 1994 to 2004, the number of mass shootings actually rose slightly during that period…
Read more: foxnews.com/politics/2012/12/24/history-gives-mixed-grade-to-impact-assault-weapons-ban/#ixzz2G02IVSS8
 
decodedscience.com/new-assault-weapons-ban-no-gun-seizure/22871

Like the previous assault weapons ban passed in 1994, Feinstein’s bill will contain a grandfather clause. Gun owners who are in legal possession of a weapon when the new law comes into effect will be allowed to continue to own and use that firearm despite the fact the legislation will make that weapon illegal to buy or possess. And it is the firearm that is grandfathered, not the owner’s right to have an assault weapon. Owners will be free to transfer their grandfathered guns to someone else

There is quote that says, repeating the same mistake twice means you failed to learn the lesson

Read the study on the ban commissioned by the National Insitute of Jusice and done by the University of PA

Assault weapon ban which also banned manufacture of magazines with capacity of ammunition of 10 or more rounds did not lower the homicide rate in the years it was law, so why this focus on this law again when it did not work before
 
Dianne Feinstein’s bill allows people to keep the semi automatic or automatic rifles they have. If that bill is enacted into law there will still be many semi and automatic rifles in circulation so what is the point?

There is quote that says, repeating the same mistake twice means you failed to learn the lesson

Assault weapon ban which also banned manufacture of magazines with capacity of ammunition of 10 or more rounds did not lower the homicide rate in the years it was law, so why all this focus on this law again when it did not work the first time
It makes them feel good and provides opportunity for face time on TV.
 
decodedscience.com/new-assault-weapons-ban-no-gun-seizure/22871

Like the previous assault weapons ban passed in 1994, Feinstein’s bill will contain a grandfather clause. Gun owners who are in legal possession of a weapon when the new law comes into effect will be allowed to continue to own and use that firearm despite the fact the legislation will make that weapon illegal to buy or possess. And it is the firearm that is grandfathered, not the owner’s right to have an assault weapon. Owners will be free to transfer their grandfathered guns to someone else

There is quote that says, repeating the same mistake twice means you failed to learn the lesson

Read the study on the ban commissioned by the National Insitute of Jusice and done by the University of PA

Assault weapon ban which also banned manufacture of magazines with capacity of ammunition of 10 or more rounds did not lower the homicide rate in the years it was law, so why this focus on this law again when it did not work the first time
 
Like the previous assault weapons ban passed in 1994, Feinstein’s bill will contain a grandfather clause. Gun owners who are in legal possession of a weapon when the new law comes into effect will be allowed to continue to own and use that firearm despite the fact the legislation will make that weapon illegal to buy or possess. And it is the firearm that is grandfathered, not the owner’s right to have an assault weapon. Owners will be free to transfer their grandfathered guns to someone else
With Diane Feinstein (D) being known to carry a gun, I would not be surprised if she owns an assault weapon.
 
No need for data. Gun bans can’t be effective (or even constitutional) so long as the Second Amendment is effective.
 
No need for data. Gun bans can’t be effective (or even constitutional) so long as the Second Amendment is effective.
Seriously your posts on these gun control threads have gone from semi-uneducated opinions to what I would consider lazy (lazy because no apparent thought has gone into them to provide a logical argument; the above is a prime example as it ignores the fact that the restrictions on private ownership of automatic weapons invalidates it) attempts to provoke conflict based on outlandish rationalizations (like the NRA somehow being responsible for the number of privately owned firearms in the US).
 
England vs USA
Gun control myths
Thomas Sowell
November 26, 2002

Professor Joyce Lee Malcolm of Bentley College deserves some sort of special prize for taking on the thankless task of talking sense on a subject where nonsense is deeply entrenched and fiercely dogmatic. In her recently published book, “Guns and Violence,” Professor Malcolm examines the history of firearms, gun control laws and violent crime in England. What makes this more than an exercise in history is its relevance to current controversies over gun control in America.

Gun control zealots love to make highly selective international comparisons of gun ownership and murder rates. But Joyce Lee Malcolm points out some of the pitfalls in that approach. For example, the murder rate in New York City has been more than five times that of London for two centuries – and during most of that time neither city had any gun control laws.

In 1911, New York state instituted one of the most severe gun control laws in the United States, while serious gun control laws did not begin in England until nearly a decade later. But New York City still continued to have far higher murder rates than London.
If we are serious about the role of guns and gun control as factors in differing rates of violence between countries, then we need to do what history professor Joyce Lee Malcolm does – examine the history of guns and violence. In England, as she points out, over the centuries “violent crime continued to decline markedly at the very time that guns were becoming increasingly available.”

England’s Bill of Rights in 1688 was quite unambiguous that the right of a private individual to be armed was an individual right, independently of any collective right of militias. Guns were as freely available to Englishmen as to Americans, on into the early 20th century.
Nor was gun control in England a response to any firearms murder crisis. Over a period of three years near the end of the 19th century, “there were only 59 fatalities from handguns in a population of nearly 30 million people,” according to Professor Malcolm. “Of these, 19 were accidents, 35 were suicides and only three were homicides – an average of one a year.”

The rise of the interventionist state in early 20th century England included efforts to restrict ownership of guns. After the First World War, gun control laws began restricting the possession of firearms. Then, after the Second World War, these restrictions grew more severe, eventually disarming the civilian population of England – or at least the law-abiding part of it.

It was during this period of severe restrictions on owning firearms that crime rates in general, and the murder rate in particular, began to rise in England. “As the number of legal firearms have dwindled, the numbers of armed crimes have risen,” Professor Malcolm points out.

In 1954, there were only a dozen armed robberies in London but, by the 1990s, there were more than a hundred times as many. In England, as in the United States, drastic crackdowns on gun ownership by law-abiding citizens were accompanied by ever greater leniency to criminals. In both countries, this turned out to be a formula for disaster.
While England has not yet reached the American level of murders, it has already surpassed the United States in rates of robbery and burglary. Moreover, in recent years the murder rate in England has been going up under still more severe gun control laws, while the murder rate in the United States has been going down as more and more states have allowed private citizens to carry concealed weapons – and have begun locking up more criminals.

In both countries, facts have no effect whatever on the dogmas of gun control zealots. The fact that most guns used to murder people in England were not legally purchased has no effect on their faith in gun control laws there, any more than faith in such laws here is affected by the fact that the gun used by the recent Beltway snipers was not purchased legally either.

In England as in America, sensational gun crimes have been seized upon and used politically to promote crackdowns on gun ownership by law-abiding citizens, while doing nothing about criminals. American zealots for the Brady bill say nothing about the fact that the man who shot James Brady and tried to assassinate President Reagan has been out walking the streets on furlough.
 
Thank you.Kept me from researching it again.

The AWB is not about lowering crime, it is a governmental power grab. If you research the statistics (2011 FBI) you’ll see there were about 250 homicides in which rifles were used. Not “Assault Rifles” but rifles. Even if a ban on all rifles reduced that to 0, the over rate would be affected by a couple percent.

If you read the Declaration of Independence and Constitution, you’ll see the 2nd amendment is a check and balance for the people against the government.

This is all you need to know about disarming the US Population.
The Communist Party of China demands the U.S. should disarm. According to Chinese officials, the recent school massacre gave all to understand that one should not wait any longer. The country’s leaders believe that the brutality of the Connecticut shooter will ensure the widest public support for arms reduction, Infowars.com reports with reference to China’s news agency Xinhua.english.pravda.ru/news/world/21-12-2012/123268-china_usa-0/
 
If you read the Declaration of Independence and Constitution, you’ll see the 2nd amendment is a check and balance for the people against the government.
The second amendment was intended to provide for national defense in lieu of a standing army not as a loophole through which the people can threaten the security of the State. Frankly, I’d be more concerned about a mob of gun toting extremists than an army of bureaucrats. Delusions of revolutionary grandeur are just that.
 
I think this assault weapons scare is a way to stimulate the economy. I wouldn’t give it much thought.
 
The second amendment was intended to provide for national defense in lieu of a standing army not as a loophole through which the people can threaten the security of the State. Frankly, I’d be more concerned about a mob of gun toting extremists than an army of bureaucrats. Delusions of revolutionary grandeur are just that.
Wrong.
 
How can a “militia” be well regulated without regulation?
You do understand what “well-regulated” means in terms of how that term is used in the 18th century lexicon, right? A “well-regulated” militia is one that is properly trained and equipped, in other words, “well-regulated” is one that is able to do the function for which it is designed. It has nothing to do with “controlled by federal statutes and legal codes”. A more accurate modern reading of “well-regulated” would be “well-organized”.
 
The second amendment was intended to provide for national defense in lieu of a standing army not as a loophole through which the people can threaten the security of the State. Frankly, I’d be more concerned about a mob of gun toting extremists than an army of bureaucrats. Delusions of revolutionary grandeur are just that.
“Laws that forbid the carrying of arms . . . disarm only those who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes . . . Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants; they serve rather to encourage than to prevent homicides, for an unarmed man may be attacked with greater confidence than an armed man.”

Thomas Jefferson in 1764

"For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well-organized and armed militia is their best security. " Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson understood very well that the easiest way to make slaves out of citizens is to take away their ability to resist tyranny.
 
“Laws that forbid the carrying of arms . . . disarm only those who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes . . . Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants; they serve rather to encourage than to prevent homicides, for an unarmed man may be attacked with greater confidence than an armed man.”

Thomas Jefferson in 1764

"For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well-organized and armed militia is their best security. " Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson understood very well that the easiest way to make slaves out of citizens is to take away their ability to resist tyranny.
HOOAH! 👍
 
Jefferson understood very well that the easiest way to make slaves out of citizens is to take away their ability to resist tyranny.
Jefferson’s philosophy in such matters was a radical product, even then, of a revolutionary age but the true purpose of second amendment cannot be ignored. It was only intended to provide for a means of defense in lieu of a standing army and, as Madison noted, a militia for, organized by, and at the command of each State in the event that the Federal Government formed its own standing army.

The idea that the people have a right to be a unique and unregulated defense force unto themselves is wrong and not supported by the historical stated intent of the founders. Furthermore; the current state of things would render such a position moot. The Federal Government does have a standing army solely at its command and the States do have their own militias solely at their command (the National Guard). The intended need for the second amendment no longer exists.

We don’t need unregulated Billy Joe Bob to pop out of a swamp with a musket to defend the nation or the States. Besides, the States lost that war and Congress made it clear that its not afraid of 100,000 gun-toting Tea Party activists milling around the Mall or their “second amendment solutions.” 😉
 
Jefferson’s philosophy in such matters was a radical product, even then, of a revolutionary age but the true purpose of second amendment cannot be ignored. It was only intended to provide for a means of defense in lieu of a standing army and, as Madison noted, a militia for, organized by, and at the command of each State in the event that the Federal Government formed its own standing army.

The idea that the people have a right to be a unique and unregulated defense force unto themselves is wrong and not supported by the historical stated intent of the founders. Furthermore; the current state of things would render such a position moot. The Federal Government does have a standing army solely at its command and the States do have their own militias solely at their command (the National Guard). The intended need for the second amendment no longer exists.

We don’t need unregulated Billy Joe Bob to pop out of a swamp with a musket to defend the nation or the States. Besides, the States lost that war and Congress made it clear that its not afraid of 100,000 gun-toting Tea Party activists milling around the Mall or their “second amendment solutions.” 😉
When the government does not fear the people it is supposed to represent, it usually bodes poorly for the people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top