Without the concept of an afterlife, why shouldn’t life take on added import? There’s plenty of moral philosophy by atheists out there – if they truly thought life was meaningless, why wouldn’t they simply commit suicide now instead of crafting moral codes? Why would they form family units, raise children, refrain from murdering one another, etc.?
And of course, back to the topic at hand, my seeing a particular belief system as rational or irrational doesn’t determine its adherents’ right to place a bench next to a monument to my belief system.
Sounds like they are intent on “proving” that you don’t need God. Maybe an ego trip. It may also be a way of carving out a life they can live without guilt for moral wrongs since it is they themselves who determine what is right and what is wrong. I wonder how many are anti-abortion, or anti-contraception, or anti-gay sex? I doubt many. Or maybe, they don’t really believe there is no God? After all, it is self evident.
We studied John Paul Sartre’s Nausea in Theology 101; pretty depressing stuff.
“I felt myself in a solitude so frightful that I contemplated suicide. What held me back was the idea that no one, absolutely no one, would be moved by my death, that I would be even more alone in death than in life.”
“I am going to outlive myself. Eat, sleep, sleep, eat. Exist slowly, softly, like these trees, like a puddle of water, like the red bench in the streetcar.”
“I want to leave, to go somewhere where I should be really in my place, where I would fit in . . . but my place is nowhere; I am unwanted.”
As I have said before, it is an excellent reminder [their monument to “no God”] that there are those in the world who desperately need our prayers. I believe in the power of prayer, especially prayer imploring Our Lady’s intercession. Somehow * the Most Blessed Virgin’s intercession gets God to do what His Infinite Mercy and Justice would not do without her intercession. But that’s another thread.
You know, I don’t think Christians are that much offended by the monument to “no God” so long as it is done with earnestness and good will.
Ah! There’s the rub. It does not seem to pass the smell test for many people.*