Atheists unveiling monument by Ten Commandments

  • Thread starter Thread starter GreyRabbit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Proselytizing by atheists seems almost a contradiction. They wish to fervently spread the gospel of no God?
 
What gets me about this unveiling of an 'atheist monument" is that atheism is not a belief, it’s an un-belief. I can see allowing someone to erect a monument to something positive, such as, a monument to mankind, or a monument to human reason, but to “not believing in something?” That doesn’t make much sense to me. It should not be allowed.
This is from Merriam-Webster:

a : a disbelief in the existence of deity
b : the doctrine that there is no deity

Sounds like a belief, if you accept that definition.
 
**And hey. Build that hospital if you will. Hospitals are good. Sing as you build it (**if you do) rather than grumble about Churches with every placement of brick and mortar. You’ll be happier. And maybe even get to hear **“I was sick and you cared for me **…” to your happy surprise one day … instead of … something else … and a horrible surprise.
I was healed in a hospital both physically and spiritually! Amen to that!
 
The monument’s inscription stresses action instead of words for man’s future prosperity. It makes sense.
 
Is this for real???

The first quote on the monument reads, “An atheist believes that a hospital should be built instead of a church.”

Who do they think built the first hospitals?

I believe it was the Catholic Church. Amen to that!
We’ll have to go back quite a bit further – like to the ancient Egyptians.
Well than perhaps the Egyptians didn’t build very good ones because when Jesus was alive, the really sick like those with leprosy were usually found on the outskirts of towns on the side of streets begging for mercy. And it was Jesus who came to their aid and healed them and taught His disciples how to care for the sick as well. I am not disclaiming the Egyptians if they hold claim to building the first hospitals but if all the sick were found on the sides of roads, apparently the Egyptian hospitals were not full of sick people or maybe they were full of sick people who were rich and the poor were left to fend for themselves until Jesus came to heal?
 
This is from Merriam-Webster:

a : a disbelief in the existence of deity
b : the doctrine that there is no deity

Sounds like a belief, if you accept that definition.
Hmmm… but the first definition is a “disbelief.” which sounds like an unbelief to me. Atheism falis to say what it does believe in, only what it does not believe in. Now if a person is a rationalist, and by the way, an atheist, then we know more about what he does believe. I think I’ll stick with what I said for now. 🙂
 
Game, set and match! Post #66’s analysis by Tom Hoopes is a withering indictment of the group that disingenuously posted ironic hypocrisies all over their own monument (albeit it’s a very unimportant thing - if we think of just the bench).

The most enjoyable irony in the article, I thought, was:
  1. It’s awkward that at the dedication, a preacher used the monument to preach Christ, and the free thinkers got mad at his free thinking.
:doh2: :rotfl: :doh2: . . . :whistle:

Thanks Abyssinia. 👍
 
Quite frankly, I could care less about the atheist bench. Atheists can do whatever they want under the law. I disagree with their viewpoint, but they’re entitled to express their views through legal means. If atheists are wrong in their beliefs, they face a bigger problem than mere disdain for a simple bench.
 
I was healed in a hospital both physically and spiritually! Amen to that!
And it wasn’t an atheist who came to pray with me for healing in the name of Jesus - it was a Catholic priest! Amen.
 
if the Christians should stop building monuments and Churches and build hospitals or donate to them,why on earth dont they do it?

i mean they are asking people to stop building religious monuments and then go and build one them selves next to a religious monument.

are they scared of Christians/theists ?

are they scared of God?

why cant they have a monument away from what they dont believe in?

and last but not least why cant they just grow up?
 
So, there are the ten commandments, there’s the atheist bench. Now, if someone would put up a crucifix…
 
gracepoole, why do you believe in God?
Why are my reasons for belief relevant?
That’s obviously not true, if the conscience is from God, how can the rejection of God allow a conscience to flourish? How does what you have said work?
The conscience is not developed by faith alone. I’m not sure if in saying that, you see me as some sort of radical – but basic psychology and sociology have quite a bit to say about the creation and development of one’s conscience.
To be honest, Atheists worry me, for precisely the reason of depciting man as the highest authority (e.g. depicting themselves as God by distinguishing between right and wrong as they themselves please or see fit), for precisely the reason of no moral absolutes.
Yes, the world is a frightening place. I’m not an atheist, but I’m personally far more frightened of religious fanaticism.
Well than perhaps the Egyptians didn’t build very good ones because when Jesus was alive, the really sick like those with leprosy were usually found on the outskirts of towns on the side of streets begging for mercy. And it was Jesus who came to their aid and healed them and taught His disciples how to care for the sick as well. I am not disclaiming the Egyptians if they hold claim to building the first hospitals but if all the sick were found on the sides of roads, apparently the Egyptian hospitals were not full of sick people or maybe they were full of sick people who were rich and the poor were left to fend for themselves until Jesus came to heal?
Are you really sticking to the claim that Catholics are responsible for the first competent hospitals?
 
So, there are the ten commandments, there’s the atheist bench. Now, if someone would put up a crucifix…
Yes, ramp it up a few centuries

And dial it back a few centuries

Either way, the cross touches eternity.

Who knows maybe that will bring the atheists back? This whole thing may redound to their benefit. They get exposed to the commandments, even on their “own” monument (which recounts the punishments for breaking the commandments - the earthly ones).

And really, how long can you commit to nothing without your guardian angel tapping you on the shoulder or whispering of better things in your ear? 🙂

Atheism is sort of like being at the South Pole. Every step you take is closer to the truth.
(Not to recommend the trip there). :winter::snowing: < Spiritual winter 😦
 
I’m guessing that the atheists will not be adding a copy of “The Black Book of Communism,” to their bench as a tribute to the accomplishments of atheism.
 
A picture is TRULY worth a thousand words! :yup:

And because I think it’s really worth seeing, I’m posting your montage again, sized a bit larger for ease of viewing:



Thanks again for this terrific juxtaposition, Dave! 👍
 
RE: ATHEIST MONUMENT RECOMMENDS BUILDING HOSPITALS*** (instead of Churches)*
**
newadvent.org/cathen/07480a.htm

The idea of who built the first hospitals was intriguing. From antiquity, this site lists …
***the IRISH! *** :coolinoff: < Fighting off a flood of ethnic pride now, as if I had anything to do with this!
Pagan antiquity
While among savage tribes, e.g. the ancient Germans, the sick and feeble were often put to death, more humane practices are found among civilized peoples. One of the earliest hospitals on record was founded in Ireland, 300 B. C., by Princess Macha. It was called “Broin Bearg” (house of sorrow), and was used by the Red Branch Knights and served as the royal residence in Ulster until its destruction in A.D. 332 (“Seanchus Mór”, 123; cf. Sir W. Wilde, “Notes on Ancient Ireland”, pt. III).
I think this means the Germanic tribes were (per mercy’s standards, “savage”; while the Irish were “civilized” by comparison, during the 300 BC period). Some historians categorize the beginnings of a “modern hospital” thus:

THE EVOLUTION OF HOSPITALS FROM ANTIQUITY TO THE …
www.ajol.info/index.php/actat/article/download/52575/41180‎ < pdf download
It is to the Christians that one must turn for the origin of the modern hospital. Hospices, originally called xenodochia, initially built to shelter pilgrims and messengers between various bishops, were under Christian control developed into hospitals in the modern sense of the word. In Rome itself, the first hospital was built in the 4th century AD by a wealthy penitent widow, Fabiola. In the early Middle Ages (6th to 10th century), under the influence of the Benedictine Order, an infirmary became an established part of every monastery
As the OT Bible mentions certain medical things (not hospitals but some treatments etc. even dating to the time of the Exodus from Egypt) – and some Irish histories claim a relation to the 10 lost tribes of Israel - this makes for an interesting info-quest.

ensignmessage.com/archives/commonalities.html < Celtic, Israelite commonalities. Lost tribes. Language. Priestly practice. Agriculture. Alphabet. By
Yaacov Levi


Pre-Christian Irish seemed to have a druidic priesthood (so was not atheistic) and the term Pagan can be as broad as non-Jewish/non-Christian when applying the term to those on the island in 300 BC. :hmmm:

From the beginning of Christianity, the apostles and their successors made house calls with anointing and healing. Buildings? Well, they were hiding from the Pagan Romans and a big hospital would be a dead giveaway.
There was thus from the earliest times a well organized system of providing for the various forms of suffering; but it was necessarily limited and dependent on private endeavour so long as the Christians were under the ban of a hostile State. Until persecution ceased, an institution of a public character such as our modern hospital was out of the question. it is certain that after the conversion of Constantine, the Christians profited by their larger liberty to provide for the sick by means of hospitals.
Someone named “Ratzinger” suggested that Constantinople had (one of?) the earliest hospitals.
When and where the first hospital was established is a matter of dispute. According to some authorities (e.g. Ratzinger, p. 141), St. Zoticus built one at Constantinople during the reign of Constantine, but this has been denied (cf. Uhlhorn, I, 319). But that the Christians in the East had founded hospitals before Julian the Apostate came to the throne (361) is evident from the letter which that emperor sent to Arsacius, high-priest of Galatia, directing him to establish a xenodochium in each city to be supported out of the public revenues (Soxomen, V, 16).
Of course the Christians built Churches TOO! 🙂



Mural in Rome. Hospital? “Medicine” anyway.
Depicts the treating of a wound. And … anesthesia? :eek:
 
Why are my reasons for belief relevant?
Well, your not an atheist, so the reason for that could help those on here who are Atheists.

Instead it feels as if you are trying to embrace atheism with your arguments.
The conscience is not developed by faith alone. I’m not sure if in saying that, you see me as some sort of radical – but basic psychology and sociology have quite a bit to say about the creation and development of one’s conscience.
Okay. I don’t see you as some kind of radical, it just feels as if your arguments are in favor of the opposition rather than your own faith.
Yes, the world is a frightening place. I’m not an atheist, but I’m personally far more frightened of religious fanaticism.
So you think us as a society would be better off with more atheists? you’d rather more atheists? how is that loving your neighbor by guiding them away from the truth?

So the main question would be, if your more worried about religious people, than why are you yourself religious?

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
I do like the idea that wherever there is a monument to atheism, there is a monument to God or Christianity. As the former draws atheists to see their handiwork, the latter, which they cannot help but see when they visit, might be just the spark needed to begin them on the road to a saving belief in Almighty God. And I like the fact that Christians and other God-fearing people visiting their own monuments, will be reminded that there are those in the world who need their prayers. In this context, I can’t think of a better pairing of monuments, can you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top