Atheists unveiling monument by Ten Commandments

  • Thread starter Thread starter GreyRabbit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Are Christians the only citizens who believe in God?
No.
Not privileging Christianity does not mean a complete loss of morality.
What morality is privileged?
Societal moral codes did not begin with Christianity or even Judaism. The Code of Hammurabi, the I Ching, Plato’s Euthyphro – none of these attempts to identify and codify good and bad are based on the Judeo-Christian God.
Are you saying good and bad are based only on the Judeo-Christian God? what do you mean by saying “none of these attempts to identify and codify good and bad”?

Morality - Define
1.Principles concerning the distinction between right and wrong or good and bad behavior.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
And actually…atheists are not miserable at all. Most I know are very happy and relieved and feel freedom and truth in their dis-belief.

.
Dont confuse pleasure for true happiness and freedom.
 
Yes, but you are quoting words from a piece of writing from nearly 2000 years ago that had a specific goal and by which we do not know the author…and many people centuries and centuries later today have found decent reason to question it.
So the quote above does not resonate or ring true for many.

.
I can assure everyone, if they reject God and refuse to seek truth with an open mind a heart, desperation and despair is assured. This is why I am frustrated when people advocate such. The truth is there for those who seek it, don’t ever stop seeking it and I’m tired of ignorant people trying to encourage others not to seek the truth.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Are you saying good and bad are based only on the Judeo-Christian God? what do you mean by saying “none of these attempts to identify and codify good and bad”?
The examples I offered are of moral codes that are *not *based on Judeo-Christian belief. Ergo, the God of Catholicism is not required in order for a community to fashion a moral code for itself that identifies what is good and what is bad. This is a response to your use of Aquinas’ “straight/crooked line” analogy.
 
The examples I offered are of moral codes that are *not *based on Judeo-Christian belief. Ergo, the God of Catholicism is not required in order for a community to fashion a moral code for itself that identifies what is good and what is bad. This is a response to your use of Aquinas’ “straight/crooked line” analogy.
True. Which is exactly my point, why is such a moral code superior to any others?

Why would you as a Catholic advocate that all morality is equivalent?

When a society embraces moral subjectivity, all evil is justified and it ends up destroying all objective morality.

Like I said before, anyone who rejects God and refuses to seek the truth with an open mind and heart is assured of desperation and despair. So why do people advocate and encourage others to follow that exact same destructive path? why do they encourage others not to seek the truth?

I don’t mind atheists who claim they don’t know and are seeking the truth with an open mind and heart, I get frustrated with atheists who claim that there is no truth and don’t even bother to search.

Matthew 4:4
4 Jesus answered, “The Scriptures say: ‘No one can live only on food. People need every word that God has spoken.’”

People who reject God and refuse to search for the truth end up spiritually starving themselves, (In other words, their life began in nothing and will end in nothing, thus making their life and existance meaningless) and than they wonder why or blame others for why they end up in deperation and despair, most of the time they ironically blame God for it.

Jesus Christ is the truth, the way and the life. Those who look for him will eventually find him.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
True. Which is exactly my point, why is such a moral code superior to any others?

Why would you as a Catholic advocate that all morality is equivalent?

When a society embraces moral subjectivity, all evil is justified and it ends up destroying all objective morality.

Like I said before, anyone who rejects God and refuses to seek the truth with an open mind and heart is assured of desperation and despair. So why do people advocate and encourage others to follow that exact same destructive path? why do they encourage others not to seek the truth?

I don’t mind atheists who claim they don’t know and are seeking the truth with an open mind and heart, I get frustrated with atheists who claim that there is no truth and don’t even bother to search.

Matthew 4:4
4 Jesus answered, “The Scriptures say: ‘No one can live only on food. People need every word that God has spoken.’”

People who reject God and refuse to search for the truth end up spiritually starving themselves, (In other words, their life began in nothing and will end in nothing, thus making their life and existance meaningless) and than they wonder why or blame others for why they end up in deperation and despair, most of the time they ironically blame God for it.

Jesus Christ is the truth, the way and the life. Those who look for him will eventually find him.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
So the ancient Babylonians, ancient Chinese, ancient Greeks – their sense of morality was somehow deficient because it didn’t come from God? The successes of their communities indicate otherwise.

Let me also note this. An atheist may claim that she doesn’t need God to know right from wrong because her developed conscience provides this knowledge for her. And even if the conscience comes from God, it’s still not necessary to believe in and worship God in order for her conscience to work properly.
 
Is this for real???

The first quote on the monument reads, “An atheist believes that a hospital should be built instead of a church.”

Who do they think built the first hospitals?

I believe it was the Catholic Church. Amen to that!
While it’s nice to find out that “An atheist” “believes” (something)

… the words “should be built instead of” stand out. Said atheist is building neither …

but BELIEVES (whoever it is that will be doing the building) should do (a) “instead of” (b).

They don’t produce much (:eek:*** - darn, have I fallen into the class warfare I try to avoid?)*** – though I must admit, they have managed a snarkily marked BENCH to celebrate their “superiority” at least.

Catholics (and others) have built both Hospitals AND Churches … and believe in things higher than either of those temporary structures … which nonetheless care for bodies and souls of people who are eternally loved by the bountiful Lord who made them (to enjoy eternal happiness*** with ***Him)!

Did they really “unveil” THIS? :doh2: :dancing: *** WHY?*** Pray tell. (uh … tell).

Ohhhh. Nice BENCH! Really. One of your best efforts maybe. 🤷
Even the “writing” is better than the usual (for all its deficiency).

If any atheist be offended … sorry. You are cordially invited to challenge your philosophy with people who consider you an eternal being created deliberately by a loving all-powerful God (and more potential benefits than your current philosophy can enumerate).

Hope to see you in heaven! < Proof that I’m not a hater … not of people anyway. Things that harm people I rather hate, but mostly those things don’t know I hate them. So no harm no foul.

And hey. Build that hospital if you will. Hospitals are good. Sing as you build it (if you do) rather than grumble about Churches with every placement of brick and mortar. You’ll be happier. And maybe even get to hear “I was sick and you cared for me …” to your happy surprise one day … instead of … something else … and a horrible surprise.

(PLUS … in the light, the colors are more inspiring than just shades of black and grey). :yup:

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQyFgVAYx5ZF_xoMFB2aiMu1ooHnsm636yGsqW0DkPtx4MH_wi3

Per the THIS vs. THAT dilemma: If you find you
cannot be BOTH of these … be HAPPY !

Details provided throughout this site! :getholy: :love:
 
I have seen many, many unhappy people who believe in God. Many of them write very desperate, pleading posts on this forum. So for many, they have not found true happiness and freedom even though they are theists.
And honestly, I know many who are truly happy who are a-theists.
This.
 
I don’t care about the specific monuments one way or another.

But what I love is the concept of the public ground being a free speech zone where any group can fund a monument to their beliefs or philosophy. That’s just very, very cool and something that I hope takes off. Government grounds should either stay neutral and not risk appearing to endorse anything, or they should be open for any American to display their beliefs. Most places have the former system, but it’s nice to see that the latter can work too.

It’s nice to show the diversity of Americans on land that is owned essentially by all citizens.

10 commandments, benches, and whatever else is eventually constructed aside this system is fantastic and I love it!
 
Well, one hopes that it’s just an exercise in free speech. Still, atheists can sometimes be worrisome. Atheism because official French government policy in 1792 with the establishment of the “Cult of Reason,” during the French revolution. Church property was seized, crosses were removed from cemeteries, priests removed from their posts, and Notre Dame Cathedral was forcibly converted into a Temple of Reason. Then the guillotines came out.
 
Well, one hopes that it’s just an exercise in free speech. Still, atheists can sometimes be worrisome. Atheism because official French government policy in 1792 with the establishment of the “Cult of Reason,” during the French revolution. Church property was seized, crosses were removed from cemeteries, priests removed from their posts, and Notre Dame Cathedral was forcibly converted into a Temple of Reason. Then the guillotines came out.
…this is a bench. The 10 commandments are not the crusades and a bench is not a guillotine.
 
But perhaps other religions think the Christian position is more arrogant, to believe it is the correct truth. Just as Christians may also think other religions are the more arrogant, thinking they have The Truth. Those religions are also “willing to risk the ridicule and scorn of the world for its foolish beliefs.”
Any group that claims they are the right truth will most likely be looked upon as somewhat arrogant by each other group.
This is no different.

And actually…atheists are not miserable at all. Most I know are very happy and relieved and feel freedom and truth in their dis-belief.

.
Actually, I believe atheists derive their arrogance from believing they alone have been able to reason that there is no God and to reject the fables and superstitions of religious people. If faith is a gift, how can anyone be arrogant or take pride in his receiving it?

As for misery, it’s a subjective judgment. I am not saying they admit to it, but I believe they are miserable deep down. Life without meaning is miserable IMO. If I’m wrong, then hell may not be such a bad place.
 
As for misery, it’s a subjective judgment. I am not saying they admit to it, but I believe they are miserable deep down. Life without meaning is miserable IMO. If I’m wrong, then hell may not be such a bad place.
I agree, If life began with nothing and life ends in nothing, than that follows that life is meaningless and with that false realisation for atheists, it leads to only one logical outcome which is desperation and despair.
So the ancient Babylonians, ancient Chinese, ancient Greeks – their sense of morality was somehow deficient because it didn’t come from God? The successes of their communities indicate otherwise.
gracepoole, why do you believe in God?
Let me also note this. An atheist may claim that she doesn’t need God to know right from wrong because her developed conscience provides this knowledge for her. And even if the conscience comes from God, it’s still not necessary to believe in and worship God in order for her conscience to work properly.
That’s obviously not true, if the conscience is from God, how can the rejection of God allow a conscience to flourish? How does what you have said work?

To be honest, Atheists worry me, for precisely the reason of depciting man as the highest authority (e.g. depicting themselves as God by distinguishing between right and wrong as they themselves please or see fit), for precisely the reason of no moral absolutes. Anything is possible for an atheist, because they don’t believe in nothing, instead they believe in anything and often believe in far more dangerous ideologies.
The atheists I know have sought truth with an open heart and mind…and continue to do so…but in doing so, they do not find a God.
I don’t think Atheists try to encourage people not to seek the truth. Quite the opposite. They encourage people to question and look for answers until they find them.
The only difference is, they find a different truth than you do.
What’s that? there is no truth? is that the truth they arrive to? lol gimmie a break.
Most atheists have indeed investigated and immersed themselves in one or more religions and have often studied religions more intensely than their fellow theists, trying to make themselves believe. Many atheists have been priests or pastors or ministers for many years. And this is the reason why they end up not believing…it is because of what they find.

They would, of course, say that you would be encouraging others not to seek the truth.
By telling someone to stick with one specific belief system, that it is the only truth, and to dare not venture out to investigate other religions/non-religion…would be seen by many as someone who is hindering their exploration of the truth with “an open mind and heart”.
I’m happy to look into atheism, only problem is that there is nothing to look into 😛

Okay, why do you not believe in God? I encourage anyone on this thread to answer the same question. 🙂

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Top 10 Awkward Facts About the Atheist Monument
Atheists unveiled a monument next to a Ten Commandments monument in Florida.
  1. A quote on it says: “An atheist believes that a hospital should be built instead of a church.” Which is awkward, because we really haven’t seen all those hospitals the atheists were going to build …
  1. The hospital quote is also awkward because it clearly should have said: “An atheist believes that $22,000 monuments to atheism should be built in all 50 states instead of a hospital.”
  1. A quote on the monument says atheists “Want war eliminated.” Which is awkward because warriors like Stalin and Lenin and Mao and Hoxha and Ceaușescu – were all atheists.
  1. The monument also mocks the punishments threatened in the Old Testament. Awkward: Far worse brutality was actually committed by the atheist warriors listed above – in our lifetime.
  1. The “We want war eliminated” quote is also awkward because all of the other atheists quoted on the monument are Founding Fathers known for starting a war with England.
  1. It’s awkward that at the dedication, a preacher used the monument to preach Christ, and the free thinkers got mad at his free thinking.
  1. It’s awkward that the monument has what looks like a biohazard symbol on it.
  1. But the symbol actually shows an atom. J.J. Thomson won the 1906 Nobel Prize in Physics for discovering the electron. He was a churchgoer who read the Bible every night. Which is awkward for atheists.
  1. A quote on the monument says “An atheist strives for involvement in life and not escape into death.” Awkward: atheists Jack Kevorkian (Dr. Death) and Derek Humphry (founder of the Hemlock Society) would disagree.
  1. A New Jersey-based group went to Florida to build an atheist monument. That sounds kind of … missionary and proselytizing. Which is awkward for people who are against that kind of thing …
 
No aim taken, Mr. A.
I don’t think atheists try to “convert” someone in the same way that someone from a religion may try to convert someone. As I was saying in my other post, I think they try to present what they think is the real truth because so many people who have been brought up within a religion never even consider the idea that they do not have to believe in a religion if they don’t feel it is right.
Many who go along with the religion they are brought up with don’t believe anyway, but they don’t know that they are “allowed” to say they do not believe.
I don’t understand what you mean here. It is true that many cafeteria catholics might as well drop their religion because they don’t care about it and in fact are harming it by tarnishing it’s name but it doesn’t mean that they don’t believe in God; they’re just indifferent. Many atheists try to find the truth, they try to discuss religious topics with people who have religion if not to convert to discover more about it but you must draw a distinction between those who are actually trying to find healthy discussion and the bullies who only want to belittle you for having faith. Nobody like a fundamentalist Christian and nobody likes a fundamentalsit atheist. The former think you’re going to hell for everything you do, the latter look down upon you with contempt.
Just as Catholics feel they have “the full truth” so do atheists. Well, actually, most atheists won’t say that. They will say they are still open to hearing new evidence and new ideas as we find out more about the past, the present, and the world.
And in the same way that you would want to tell people about the truth if you’ve got…so do atheists.
I was once ‘debating’ (for lack of a better word) this atheist who casually told me she deconverted quite a few Christians in her life time and that frankly made me furious. Why? Because she had absolutely no reason to deconvert someone from being Christian; what is it going to accomplish for that person’s mental health? How are you helping him telling him a bunch of rubbish about how God could not exist, about how religion is evil without giving him the chance to search out his religion for himself? This is the reason I absolutely despise books by that **** Hitchens and Dawkins; they present a mountain of ‘evidence’ that is riddled with historical and logical innacuracies to present a picture of religion as being evil yet when it is all said and done, what have they truly accomplished? N devout Christian in his right mind would read that load of rubbish because they know how biased the authors are against religion and they have other more secular sources nowadays like wikipedia and history books to search out whether their claims are true. No atheist with his mind in his place is going to read their books because being an atheist doesn’t mean you hate religion, it means you have your own reasons in not believing in deities. So why on earth would they read the stuff coughed out by a rabid atheist to draw their own conclusions? Why can’t they do the research for themselves?

Oh, I’ve been there by the way; I’ve had lack of belief in God’s mercy, I doubted the sanctity of the Church seeing all it’s corruption throughout the ages but finally, I concluded that despite the corruption, it wasn’t all bad as the Church still did a ton of spiritual and material good and that in the end I was right, militant atheists are full of themselves and rubbish.
And for similar reasons.
Atheists do truly believe religion is harmful, and they have valid reasons to think so. Many people’s research on religion has show something different to them than what your research has shown to you.
So an atheist, just as anyone evangelizes their own religion, does believe that by explaining to others what they think… they are making the world a better, more real, more honest place.
That’s false dude, not all atheists believe religion is harmful as many of them do think that religion has done good for valid reasons. My religion at least founded universities, it influenced western civilization with it’s teachings, it spread art, it spoke against moral evils (though not all of them) when they emerged etc… Secularism also did a ton of good, no denying that but it also did a ton of evil like using war to take countries to it’s idealogy like Napoleon and the Risorgimento did, using murder to stamp out opposition like in the reign of terror, and even today we see how evil moral lapses like acceptance of promiscuity, abortion, indifference to religion etc… bring. Does that make secularism logically bad or evil? NO! But it makes me conclude that neither religion nor secularism/humanism are the problem but individuals themselves.
I’m so glad you don’t go around telling people to convert to your religion or they will go to hell (although, I have seen many people on this forum say this).
I agree with you. I sure wouldn’t want a friend who was constantly trying to convert me. But you can find this kind of “friend” in all religions, too.
Not all people in the forums are absolute saints, least of all myself who rarely prays and who is always giving in to temptation. But you must remember, does that really make them evil people? I’m not saying you are calling them that as you said nothing bad but many atheists instead of wanting to enter discussion at this point would go around demonizing these Christians for being ‘intolerant’ when the correct course of action would be to help them become better Christians. Just remember: trying to change their mindset on abortion and gay marriage, on how their religion is or isn’t the true one, how organized religion is not good etc… will NOT do any good. Helping them get their priorities straight is what we, as Christians should do. It’s not a job for any atheist no matter how nice they are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top