Atheists unveiling monument by Ten Commandments

  • Thread starter Thread starter GreyRabbit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This just seems plain old immature to me. “If you put up a monument we’re putting up one too…SO There!”
How ridiculous.
 
I am not a Christian, but the 10 Commandments is something people whether Christian or non-Christian should live by. There’s no reason why non-Christians or Atheists who don’t believe in God should be offended by the 10 Commandments. There’s no reason why Atheists should be offended by Merry Christmas-Christmas anyhow has been secularized. During Christmas, I would rather people say to me Merry Christmas than be politically safe. In mostly non-Christian nations such as India, most people don’t get offended by Merry Christmas. Want to let Catholics know to know that not all non-Christians agree with putting Atheist monuments next to 10 Commandments and there are Atheists who are against what these Atheists are doing.
 
I am not a Christian, but the 10 Commandments is something people whether Christian or non-Christian should live by. There’s no reason why non-Christians or Atheists who don’t believe in God should be offended by the 10 Commandments. There’s no reason why Atheists should be offended by Merry Christmas-Christmas anyhow has been secularized. During Christmas, I would rather people say to me Merry Christmas than be politically safe. In mostly non-Christian nations such as India, most people don’t get offended by Merry Christmas. Want to let Catholics know to know that not all non-Christians agree with putting Atheist monuments next to 10 Commandments and there are Atheists who are against what these Atheists are doing.
It’s their attitude of “screw you God, we’re better than you”. For Biblical examples see Adam/Eve, the tower of Babel, etc, etc. These people PRIDE themselves as if they are they highest order of creation. Nothing new, been happening since sin ever came into the world. I laugh at their unbelief just as they laugh at my belief.
 
Not necessarily.
An atheist might also want to put something next to other religious monuments as a way to make onlookers or passersby aware that there is another option other than believing in a religion. They may do something like this as a symbolic gesture or as a way to start conversation or get people thinking about the religion question.

.
Perhaps. But for me it recalls the saying, “Misery seeks companionship.”

Atheism is more an arrogant position that represents those who do not believe in fairy tales, religious myths, fables, and an old man with a beard hiding in the clouds. The Christian position, by contrast, is not arrogant, as it accepts its truth as revealed by Jesus Christ and is willing to risk the ridicule and scorn of the world for its foolish belief in a God-man crucified for their sins. As we can see, the more the world grows in “wisdom,” the more the Church is under attack. But there is hope even for the short run-- God can turn it around on a dime! Keep praying those foolish prayer beads. 😉
 
“It is an attack, but it’s an attack on Christian privilege, not an attack on Christians themselves, and not so much an attack on Christianity.”
Your attitude gracepoole is extremely frustrating.

“It’s an attack, but it’s an attack on Christian privilege.” I say damn straight we should have Christian privilege.

It’s like Abortion, the common response is “well you believe that it’s wrong, however I don’t believe it’s wrong and since I respect your beliefs you should respect mine, why does your morality receive privilege above mine”?

This is just madness. Those who buy into such arguments frustrate the hell outta me, because without God there is no morality (accept subjective morality) and morality is not subjective, thus not all morality should be treated or received equally, to treat all morality as equal and subjective is madness.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Many non-religious groups have organized and are now putting money toward charity work etc. They obviously cannot compare yet to thousands of years – but in time, their influence will grow in these areas and, of course, donating money to charities and hospitals, etc, is a good thing.
Matthew 4:4
4 Jesus answered, “The Scriptures say: ‘No one can live only on food. People need every word that God has spoken.’”

The idea that man should live without God or that man lives better without God, is the ultimate form of arrogance and with arrogance, condemnation and destruction is assured. This is why it’s frustrating when people advocate such.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Your attitude gracepoole is extremely frustrating.

“It’s an attack, but it’s an attack on Christian privilege.” I say damn straight we should have Christian privilege.

It’s like Abortion, the common response is “well you believe that it’s wrong, however I don’t believe it’s wrong and since I respect your beliefs you should respect mine, why does your morality receive privilege above mine”?

This is just madness. Those who buy into such arguments frustrate the hell outta me, because without God there is no morality (accept subjective morality) and morality is not subjective, thus not all morality should be treated or received equally, to treat all morality as equal and subjective is madness.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
If my attitude is “extremely frustrating,” Josh, I can think of some countries that base their system of government on Sharia law that might be more suited to your taste. Many faiths are practiced in the United States – none should have privilege over another.

People on this thread who have so far characterized atheists as arrogant relativists should probably spend a bit more time reading philosophy – there’s a centuries-long tradition of moral coding that rejects the relativism and the self-centeredness that seem to get ascribed to anyone who isn’t an adherent Catholic.

What “frustrates the hell outta me” is a straw man.
 
They could have saved themselves money by just putting a fence around an empty space since they don’t believe in anything.
 
:idea::idea:
Ahh…someone should sue them since they trying to promote the state establishment of the religion of non religion LOL
:idea::idea:
 
In “The Last Superstition”, Edward Fesser claims that New Atheism forms a sort of anti-religion and embodies that which it claims to despise. He also claims that New Atheism is an essentially negative movement; outside of its criticism of religion it is nothing. I’m inclined to agree with both of his statements and this monument has done nothing to change my mind.

I also find the quote rather funny. Putting aside the contribution of religious schools, hospitals and charity I find it ironic that they proclaim all of money goes towards practical, humanitarian ends on a monument costing however many thousands of dollars.
 
It’s a bench. Which is very appropriate. It would make me very happy to have my rear-end make contact with their “monument” 😃 I get all goose-pimply just thinking about it! :egyptian:
 
What bothered me about the whole farce was not because the monument itseld was supposedly dedicated by atheists for atheists but the intent; really, old testament punishments, what are they trying to say here, that being atheist supposedly makes you a better person than a Christian? Because secularists and atheists haven’t accepted things like the death penalty before or engaged in war.

I’m also baffled at the sheer paranoia of who thought this up, as if Christians are really against science or really want to kill people who happen to be atheist instead of you know, praying for them to convert. “We’re not going to let them do it without a counterpoint,” said David Silverman, the group’s president. “If we do it without a counterpoint it’s going to appear very strongly that the government actually endorses one religion over another, or - I should say - religion in general over non-religion.” Wow, so we need a paranoid agent to enlighten us that that the government is non religious? As if the past hundreds of years of seperating Church and state and as if people immigrating to America for more religious freedom weren’t proof enough that the government already does this.

Not only that but instead of helping atheists, this monument EMBARRASSES the living hell out of any normal atheist as they don’t need much less WANT some jackass who disrespectfully stands on the ten commandments as he’s all high and mighty to and declares that he’s representing them. Lighten up people: most Christians don’t want to kill atheists and most atheists don’t want to stamp out religion. Only militant nutters like this guy do. The great secular leaders: George Washington, Napoleon Bonaparte, John Locke, Victor Emmenual, a no name leader of a bunch of fanatics.

Oh well:

http://www.google.com.mt/imgres?img...1qzQUYOxDoSo4gTiw4HgAg&ved=0CDIQ9QEwAQ&dur=33
 
Not necessarily.
An atheist might also want to put something next to other religious monuments as a way to make onlookers or passersby aware that there is another option other than believing in a religion. They may do something like this as a symbolic gesture or as a way to start conversation or get people thinking about the religion question.

.
Why would anyone want to convert a Christian into an atheist? I can understand wanting to change their mind about evolution, about some moral philosophies and this coming form a Christian, I can understand other religious people be they Protestant fundamentalists or Muslims wanting to convert me into their religion because they think my religion is the wrong one and that they are right; I have the same belief that my religion is right and every other religion is wrong but I don’t go around telling people that they’re going to hell if they don’t convert and I understand that if I keep on insisting instead of discussing religion with them they’re going to feel FLIPPING RIGHTFULLY hurt. Who wants a friend who thinks your morally inferior because you have a different religion? On that same note, who wants a friend who wants to deconvert you as if there is something wrong with being religious? Somebody who looks down upon as being less intelligent somehow?

And I don’t meant to aim this on you at all daddygirl as if you are at fault here but in my case nobody tries converting me or any friend I may make for a stupid reason like God not existing or religion being evil because I did my homework on religion and I know that it’s not evil. So if any self righteous jerk wants to split hairs about religion with me, I’ll buzz off and let them stew in their own made up world of hatred and pride.
 
If my attitude is “extremely frustrating,” Josh, I can think of some countries that base their system of government on Sharia law that might be more suited to your taste. Many faiths are practiced in the United States – none should have privilege over another.
One nation under god - Abraham Lincoln

So I guess he should have said “One nation under man” because no relgion should recieve privilege right?

When no morality recieves privilege, we end up with no morality.
People on this thread who have so far characterized atheists as arrogant relativists
Only those who claim man should live without God or that man lives better without God.
should probably spend a bit more time reading philosophy – there’s a centuries-long tradition of moral coding that rejects the relativism and the self-centeredness that seem to get ascribed to anyone who isn’t an adherent Catholic.
Tell me, without God, what makes an Atheist subject to any kind of objective morality? How can an Atheist call a line crooked unless they have some idea of what a straight line is? God is that straight line, if there is no God, than there is no line to compare in order to call this or that one crooked, thus there is no morality without God.
What “frustrates the hell outta me” is a straw man.
What frustrates me is when Catholics could even play into the idea that man could be better off without God, you seem to view man’s morality equivalent to God’s for some reason. Man is not the highest authority and there is nothing but destruction and despair that is reaped and sowed from those who live as if it is.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
One nation under god - Abraham Lincoln

So I guess he should have said “One nation under man” because no relgion should recieve privilege right?
Are Christians the only citizens who believe in God?
When no morality recieves privilege, we end up with no morality.
Tell me, without God, what makes an Atheist subject to any kind of objective morality? How can an Atheist call a line crooked unless they have some idea of what a straight line is? God is that straight line, if there is no God, than there is no line to compare in order to call this or that one crooked, thus there is no morality without God.
Not privileging Christianity does not mean a complete loss of morality. Societal moral codes did not begin with Christianity or even Judaism. The Code of Hammurabi, the I Ching, Plato’s Euthyphro – none of these attempts to identify and codify good and bad are based on the Judeo-Christian God.
 
http://newsbcpcol.stb.s-msn.com/amn...fb2f4c7a9958739f/_h0_w628_m6_otrue_lfalse.jpg

?? Shouldn’t it be something LESS tangible? And what’s with the morality?
Are these bench people the Atheists’ starting lineup?

I “don’t believe” this is REAL Atheism … what’s more I “don’t believe” this bench
is a randomly configured accident of science at all. A roomful of dense fog would be more representative (if harder to photograph).
Is this for real???

The first quote on the monument reads, “An atheist believes that a hospital should be built instead of a church.”

Who do they think built the first hospitals?

I believe it was the Catholic Church. Amen to that!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top