Attack on the vatican

  • Thread starter Thread starter flaneur
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, I guess if one were to express an honest response, one would have to concede that, while the article does contain the usual inaccuracies that are typically found in the media, it also contains more than a little truth. To call this article “defamatory” is going just a bit overboard.

In addition to being the spiritual leaders of the Church, high level Vatican officials (eg. the Pope, the College of Cardinals, etc.) are also politicians. As in any political organization, those who rise to the top levels often get there not because of their leadership abilities but because of their political skill and their ability to forge alliances and make deals. As a result, by the time they reach very high levels of leadership, they have often been compromised and occasionally even corrupted. I have absolutely no doubt that the halls of the Vatican are rife with political rivalry and intrigue.

As a young priest, our pastor spent spent a few years working and studying in the Vatican. I think he was only half kidding when he expressed the opinion that God has never set foot in the place.
 
It’s all but inevitable that the Vatican have this type atmosphere. It’s a political place. Always has been. Probably always will be. You can’t have that level of power in any one place and expect otherwise.
 
BettyBoop416
…As a young priest, our pastor spent spent a few years working and studying in the Vatican. I think he was only half kidding when he expressed the opinion that God has never set foot in the place.
Let me guess…your pastor is from the “Class of 1968”…Right. ?

Pax Christi
 
Well, that’s a reief. The thread title had me thinking that there was a terrorist attack! :eek:
 
Defamatory… Do you honestly think that all the Vatileaks scandal is based on pure fiction, that Pope Benedict never had any reason to wish for a reform of the Vatican bureaucracy (or that he was genuinely helped by many others in reforming this network of secular power)? Or that such complains are mere lies?
 
Secular people and even some catholics consistently mess up when observing priests, bishops and popes. There is this common misconception that the doctrinal purity and sacramental validity of the catholic faith depend on the sanctity of the clergy. LOL, if that were the case, catholicism would have been wiped out 1,900 years ago for sure!

Anyplace that involves groups of humans working together towards shared goals (and not a few diverging visions on how to get there) there will be politics, rivalries, backstabbing and, well, sin. Duh, the church exists in the first place precisly because all humanity needed a Savior. We got one, and he established and still guards his one, holy, catholic and apostolic church.

Most “jounalistic” account like this one should honestly be titled this way:

Breaking News: Vatican hierarchy populated entirely by flesh and blood human beings!

But that doesn’t sell many newspapers, does it?
 
CNN is also reporting trouble at the Vatican, so it’s not just the Washington Post.

I am praying for the Holy Father, the Church, and for the Cardinals as they choose a new pope.
 
Secular people and even some catholics consistently mess up when observing priests, bishops and popes. There is this common misconception that the doctrinal purity and sacramental validity of the catholic faith depend on the sanctity of the clergy. LOL, if that were the case, catholicism would have been wiped out 1,900 years ago for sure!

Anyplace that involves groups of humans working together towards shared goals (and not a few diverging visions on how to get there) there will be politics, rivalries, backstabbing and, well, sin. Duh, the church exists in the first place precisly because all humanity needed a Savior. We got one, and he established and still guards his one, holy, catholic and apostolic church.

Most “jounalistic” account like this one should honestly be titled this way:

Breaking News: Vatican hierarchy populated entirely by flesh and blood human beings!

But that doesn’t sell many newspapers, does it?
I tend to agree. It helps for both Catholics and non-Catholics to remember that the Church does not transform our leaders into supra-human beings - not while on earth at least. Any sort of scandal, real or imagined, involves the fact of our common humanity - nothing to do with the validity or relevance of our faith.
 
There is a thread on the Catholic Living/Spirituality forum by Melissa called looking for 118 companions. She is looking for one person to pray for each of the 118 cardinals who are going to choose a new pope. I adopted a cardinal and am praying for him. There are still 60 cardinals who need to be adopted.
 
Fr Lombardi
“There is no lack, in fact, of those who seek to profit from the moment of surprise and disorientation of the spiritually naive to sow confusion and to discredit the Church and its governance, making recourse to old tools, such as gossip, misinformation and sometimes slander, or exercising unacceptable pressures to condition the exercise of the voting duty on the part of one or another member of the College of Cardinals, who they consider to be objectionable for one reason or another.”
te-deum.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/holy-see-takes-aim-at-reports-often.html
 
The 6:30 pm CBS News horrendously attacked the Vatican as well as the entire Catholic Church. I almost threw up. :mad:
 
The 6:30 pm CBS News horrendously attacked the Vatican as well as the entire Catholic Church. I almost threw up. :mad:
i purposefully avoid CBS news as well as CNN and MSNBC.

i think this is very sad that the last days of office held by Pope Benedict XVI we have to have further scandal generated by this italian newspaper. they are always looking for ways to attack the Church.
i pray fervently that our new Pope will have the strength to stand up to these attacks from journalists as well to the attacks within the Vatican. i am a relatively new Catholic - 5 years this summer so i guess i can be considered naive when it comes to what goes on inside the Vatican. i agree there are probably power struggles. i just hope the new Pope will be following the same path as Pope Benedicts XVI took.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top