Attending a protestant church is a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter maxm2820
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No one is worthy except through Jesus Christ…

We have a different point of view and I came here to discuss in brotherly love. I believe that Catholics love Jesus Christ. I think you are all faithful to God and are all fruitful in His works. We have a different approach and I am blunt at times, I am here to learn a little and to teach a little. ** I would not enter an orthodox area and speak my mind for I respect the sanctity of what you believe.** This area appears to be more of an open market place and I feel that a difference in opinion should promote growth in your personal faith journeys by giving you an opportunity to see how other Christian faiths worship and relate to our Lord.

If I am mistaken and this is not such a place, let me know… I will apologize for entering your hallowed halls and depart.

B
And yet that is just what you have done. The topic in this thread is about the obligations of a **Catholic **(the OP). Sure, you can have a different point of view but to force a Protestant interpretation into a discussion of Catholicism is not very respectful. What other faiths teach about their own churches or even what they teach about Communion is not relevant to this discussion. It only confuses when the idea is to find clarity regarding Church teaching.

Your desire for discourse on other faiths might be better served in the Apologetics subform or in thread in the non-Catholic Religions sub forum that deal with non-Catholic teaching.
 
When I arrived at this forum, I looked for places marked as apparently unorthodox (open-discussion). A forum heading marked “Non-Catholic Religions” is misleading.

I am sorry if I hurt anyone’s feelings. I do not think we can grow in our faith without solid discussion. I was working on answers to some of the questions and counter questions asked in the spirit of brotherly love and Christian learning.

Now that I know that this is a closed area, I will refrain from posting in this part of the forum in the future.

B
 
When I arrived at this forum, I looked for places marked as apparently unorthodox (open-discussion). A forum heading marked “Non-Catholic Religions” is misleading.

I am sorry if I hurt anyone’s feelings. I do not think we can grow in our faith without solid discussion. I was working on answers to some of the questions and counter questions asked in the spirit of brotherly love and Christian learning.

Now that I know that this is a closed area, I will refrain from posting in this part of the forum in the future.

B
It is fine to discuss differences in beliefs and to offer your perspective; however, your initial posts in this thread as well as others came across to me, and apparently to other posters as well, as dismissive and insulting of Catholic beliefs. That is where the issue lies. It appears that you did not intend for that to happen, but that is how it was received by some. If you will consider softening your tone in your future posts, I think you will find the discussion to be more fruitful.
 
No one is worthy except through Jesus Christ…
Amen! Christ is King; and we are all as ants to a bull by comparison. Any and everything that we achieve and are is by His Grace.
We have a different point of view and I came here to discuss in brotherly love.
Then do so and not dismiss our dogmas and theology as man-made “tradition”. We get them from the Bible. Browse the Apologetics Forum and see for yourself, sir. You don’t see us dismissing Methodism as a concoction of John Wesley; do you? You say you want to discuss in brotherly love? Then do it. I have two brothers myself and neither one of them talk to me the way you have spoken to us.
I believe that Catholics love Jesus Christ. I think you are all faithful to God and are all fruitful in His works.
Thanks for giving us that much credit.
We have a different approach and I am blunt at times, I am here to learn a little and to teach a little.
We certainly do have a different approach, don’t we? I can be blunt myself, so I get it. Most Protestant Forums don’t usually allow Catholic members; and when they do, the Catholics are given a pretty bad time. As someone who has experienced this first-hand, you’ll have to forgive me for being guarded when someone shows up here belittling our Faith and our Church.

Also, what do you expect to teach us, Mr. Methodist Minister? I am VERY curious about that.
I would not enter an orthodox area and speak my mind for I respect the sanctity of what you believe. This area appears to be more of an open market place and I feel that a difference in opinion should promote growth in your personal faith journeys by giving you an opportunity to see how other Christian faiths worship and relate to our Lord.
If I am mistaken and this is not such a place, let me know… I will apologize for entering your hallowed halls and depart.
The only mistake you have made is to think that the rules of charitibility and respect don’t apply here as opposed to the rest of the Forum.

Yes, we discuss others faiths here. But whether they be Jews, Orthodox, Protestant, or anything else; we MUST respect them and their beliefs. If we do not, we get suspended or banned. Even if we’re Catholic.

We don’t get many Methodists here, so to me you’re kind of a curiosity. I live in an area that is overwhelmingly Catholic. Most of my interaction with our separated Protestant brethren actually happens here at CAF or other corners of the internet.

I have an idea for you… instead of telling US about Catholicism and what you think of it; why not tell us about Methodism? Let US tell YOU about Catholicism. That would be a great way to get off on the right foot with most of us, I think.
I am sorry you are confusing the difference between personal opinion and insult.
You have gotten the point across of what your opinion of Catholic theology is. There are MANY Protestant regulars here who are VERY respected, have made their opinions known, and are dear “friends” to many of us here.

They are true to their Reformed theology, we agree to disagree, but there’s always respect.
Since I also belong to Christ’s Church and this church cannot be claimed by either Protestant or Catholic, I know that I have made no such insult by raising points that can make others think about their own faith journey…
Are you trying to lead Catholics away from the Church? (I think this is a valid question that deserves an answer, sir.)
When I arrived at this forum, I looked for places marked as apparently unorthodox (open-discussion). A forum heading marked “Non-Catholic Religions” is misleading.
As I said before… we do discuss non-Catholic religions here. With respect towards their practices and dogmas. Even if we STRENUOUSLY disagree with them.
I am sorry if I hurt anyone’s feelings.
Thanks.

(continued…)
 
I do not think we can grow in our faith without solid discussion. I was working on answers to some of the questions and counter questions asked in the spirit of brotherly love and Christian learning.
Are THESE statements made in brotherly love???
but your obligation is to God, not any particular church denomination. If you feel like you are being called by God to go elsewhere, go. Who do you serve? God or man?
We know our obligation is to God. To tell us that we think otherwise is by worshiping in HIS Church that CHRIST founded is offensive.
If you feel like you are being called by God to go elsewhere, go. Who do you serve? God or man?
We ALL serve God, here. YOU, however, seem to want to encourage people to leave Christ’s Church. Proselytizing is NOT allowed here.
Communion is another point that you do not have to fear burning in Hell about. I know that tradition and ritual has made this into a gigantic deal in the Catholic church.
More brotherly love? That communion you speak of is actually the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Christ. It is NOT “tradition”. It is NOT “ritual”. It IS the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Christ. Respect it.
1 Corinthians 11:27-29 ~ Therefore whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgment on himself.
St. Paul thought the Eucharist was a big deal, sir. It seems we SHOULD fear buring in hell for partaking of the Body unworthily, no? A lesson to be learned here…
It is so big that to tell you that you cannot participate in a set Lord’s Table being offered to you by someone that has been called by God to serve as a minister and ordained or appointed to administer such sacraments is where the sin actually lies.
Wow. You accuse us of sinning by NOT participating in an IMITATION of our Holy Sacrament? Christ is not present in the Protestants’ bread and grape juice. For us to knowingly imitate the Eucharist is a grave sin. Sorry, but that’s the truth.
How will God contend with this I wonder when all is said and done and we stand before Him and He asks why we keep people from entering His banquet? Just some thoughts for you to think about before you choose to miss an opportunity to worship God because men told you ‘no.’
As I said before… MEN do not prevent us from participating. God does. That is NOT the Eucharist. Protestant ministers do not posess Apostolic Succession. They do not have the 2,000 year old Sacrament of Holy Orders. They do not have the authority Catholic priests do (given by Christ). They can not change bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ.
Now that I know that this is a closed area, I will refrain from posting in this part of the forum in the future.
 
When I arrived at this forum, I looked for places marked as apparently unorthodox (open-discussion). A forum heading marked “Non-Catholic Religions” is misleading.

I am sorry if I hurt anyone’s feelings. I do not think we can grow in our faith without solid discussion. I was working on answers to some of the questions and counter questions asked in the spirit of brotherly love and Christian learning.

Now that I know that this is a closed area, I will refrain from posting in this part of the forum in the future.

B
Personally, I wasn’t offended. I understand that some communions feel differently regarding communion. You gave your opinion, I gave mine. No reason for tears or hurt feelings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top