Attending Protestant Services

  • Thread starter Thread starter jbelokur
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One thing I would like to say about your quote. It don’t matter that You and the Catholics both believe in The Eurcharist. To the Catholics, the Bread only changes when a Catholic Priest Consecrates it. So they don’t see you as the same as them. Or they don’t believe your pastor has the ability to cosecrate the wine and bread. I didn’t know if you realized that or not.
Rom 16:17 Now I beseech you, brethren, to mark them who make dissensions and offences contrary to the doctrine which you have learned and avoid them.

1Co 1:10 Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you all speak the same thing and that there be no schisms among you: but that you be perfect in the same mind and in the same judgment.
 
=denwiles;5215052]THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IS NOT YOUR SALVATION-JESUS CHRIST THE SON OF THE LIVING GOD IS, THE MESSIAH, THE ANNOINTED ONE!!!
No need to shout.
Do I need to perfect the sign of the Cross. bow down to statues better, go to mass 7 days a week, go to confession 3 times a day, read through Church doctrines again, and again. I got much of it memorised. Whats good enough for you!!! Oh to be a robot and do and think exactly like you.
Sarcasm and exaggeration do nt prove your pooint. They don’t even well make it.
So lets look at a few things
2. Call no man Father. I know your answer on this, I have studied Catholic Doctrine for over 10 years now. One thing is good about all this many people have truly believed in Jesus because they Have seen His prophesies fullfilled, by you doing what he said not to do.
I grew up in a city with lots of Catholics and Lutherans. Catholics always called my dad “Father” as he was a Lutheran pastor and always wore is clerical collar. He was never offended. When I would meet a Catholic priest, I called him “Father”. The interpretation when applied to priest isn’t sound.
  1. In the Last days they will forebid to marry. Hello!!! Jesus is not rebuking the world. He knows the world sins. He is rebuking an Institution who has a Form of Godliness, but denies the Power, Which is the finished work of the Cross!!! Jesus said it is finished!!! The Bible even says a Bishop is to be the Husband of one wife. Your tradition superseeds the Bible and you blindly except it. Why are their so many Homosexuals and pediphiles? Because those who want to marry go other places and minister, but those who have no interest in marriage in the first place and want great power, so great is the power to them. They go to the Catholic Church. Not all their are some awesome Priest.
You’re right. Not all. There is as much abuse by protestant clergy as Catholic.
  1. All occults Lord over the people. Jesus said the gentiles lord over each other but you are to be each others servent. Only Catholic Priest according to your doctrine. Have the power to Consencrate the sacrifice “Eucharist” You say this is vital and the REAL PRESENCE of Jesus. Now a protestant who has been properly Baptized in Water doesn’t have to be baptized again, but if they commit a mortal sin, according to James if you break one point of the law you transgressed the whole law, truthfully sin is sin, you have to confess to a priest or your sin is not forgiven and you are lost. That my friend is altimate power. Lording over people with fear of Hell at it’s best. The Bible says if you sin Jesus is fathful to forgive you. I am His Child he is my Father, Because of Jesus I can boldly go before the throne of grace and obtain mercy. He is my Father, Jesus is my Savior.
Incorrect. The Catholic Church says any clergy in apostolic succession. That would include Orthodox. I disagree, but at least I disagree with what they actually teach.
And the CC is not a cult.
My heart hurts so bad when I see people so hungry for the Truth, but follow men insted of God. Jesus Christ Loves you so much and wants all of us to really know Him.
I say all this in Love!!! Many would like me kicked off, because they don’t like what I say. Gods will be done!!! I will gladly be kicked off for the truth. Most just don’t want to deal with it. Try to get a Mormon saved!!! They won’t listen. Why because insted of doing what is right they will listen to their teachers until death. You say no to Bible alone and I say that is exactly why we have so many occults. All things are to be tested by the Word of God it is sharper than any two edge sword. ANY!!! ANY other Written word or tradition. So go ahead and follow your phrophets. Me and my Family we will follow the LORD JESUS CHRIST!!!
It isn’t the things you say here, it is the way you’ve said things…

Jon
 
THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IS NOT YOUR SALVATION-JESUS CHRIST THE SON OF THE LIVING GOD IS, THE MESSIAH, THE ANNOINTED ONE!!!
No one said the Church was the salvation for Catholics.
The people that have given their lives to God through Jesus is the Church!!! Work on what? You said I need to be more Catholic. Do I need to perfect the sign of the Cross. bow down to statues better, go to mass 7 days a week, go to confession 3 times a day, read through Church doctrines again, and again. I got much of it memorised. Whats good enough for you!!! Oh to be a robot and do and think exactly like you. No thanks my friend. Their is a world out their that needs Jesus and I’m going to do it.
Look Satan is a Master at deception. The Father of Lies. Deception is strange because to be truly decieved you don’t know it or it’s not deception. I want you to wake up!!! I don’t want to get into another subject, but ***faith in God comes by hearing the word of God. Romans 10. ***Paul said the Beareans were more noble than any other, because they studied the scriptures. So you believe in tradition and works. After all Paul said to work out your salvation with fear and trembling. Do you fear and tremble to make sure you are right??? The Holy Spirit wrote the Bible and he said to do this!!! Paul was not speaking of working as in deeds as most of you would say, but make sure your doctrine is correct.
So lets look at a few things
  1. Every Mary apperance, Study them for your self, Points to Mary as Hope-
  2. Call no man Father.
  3. In the Last days they will forebid to marry.
  4. All occults Lord over the people. Jesus said the gentiles lord over each other but you are to be each others servent.
  5. Why a Statue?
(SNIPPED TO FIT A RESPONSE)
Your laundry list of objections has nothing to do with the topic of the thread. In most instances when a Protestant throws such a list out, it’s because they have no desire to discuss each subject rationally. It’s an obvious attempt to throw out a smoke screen to continue on with their own agenda.

In fact this poster has been refuted on other threads and leaves them to go on another thread to spew the same anti-Catholic misconceptions.
My heart hurts so bad when I see people so hungry for the Truth, but follow men insted of God. Jesus Christ Loves you so much and wants all of us to really know Him.
I say all this in Love!!! Many would like me kicked off, because they don’t like what I say. Gods will be done!!! I will gladly be kicked off for the truth. Most just don’t want to deal with it. Try to get a Mormon saved!!! They won’t listen. Why because insted of doing what is right they will listen to their teachers until death. You say no to Bible alone and I say that is exactly why we have so many occults. All things are to be tested by the Word of God it is sharper than any two edge sword. ANY!!! ANY other Written word or tradition. So go ahead and follow your phrophets. Me and my Family we will follow the LORD JESUS CHRIST!!!
Bible alone, that’s sola scriptura isn’t it? Please show us where that is written in scriptures. I honestly believe that is a man-made tradition.

Someone has already pointed out the thousands of denominations, due to private interpretation of scripture, how can you prove your authority and that you have correctly interpreted scriptures? What makes your Church right over all the thousands of other Churches?

Lastly, point blank, do you think Catholics have no hope of salvation in the Catholic Church?
 
No need to shout.

Sarcasm and exaggeration do nt prove your pooint. They don’t even well make it.

I grew up in a city with lots of Catholics and Lutherans. Catholics always called my dad “Father” as he was a Lutheran pastor and always wore is clerical collar. He was never offended. When I would meet a Catholic priest, I called him “Father”. The interpretation when applied to priest isn’t sound.

You’re right. Not all. There is as much abuse by protestant clergy as Catholic.

Incorrect. The Catholic Church says any clergy in apostolic succession. That would include Orthodox. I disagree, but at least I disagree with what they actually teach.
And the CC is not a cult.

It isn’t the things you say here, it is the way you’ve said things…

Jon
Jon I think I will wait for you to respond to post like that before I do from now on. You seem to be better at it then me.

God Bless brother
 
It is interesting that you say this because there are now somewhere between 25-30K different protestant denominations that all say yes to the Bible alone, yet all teach different doctrines and dogmas.
wrong!!! All essiential Doctrines are the same!
  1. All believe Jesus is God
  2. All believe Bible alone
  3. All believe in the Death and Ressurection of Jesus
  4. All believe in the Virgin Birth
  5. All believe in the Trinity
  6. All believe in Salvation alone is found in Christ
    I could go on and on
    Now non essentials Doctrines, yes! their is a diffrence. JUST AS IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
    Speaking in Tongues. Many Charismatic Catholics speake in tongues and many don’t believe in it. Does that divide the church? NO of course not. Same as in the Protestant Churches
 
No one said the Church was the salvation for Catholics.

Your laundry list of objections has nothing to do with the topic of the thread. In most instances when a Protestant throws such a list out, it’s because they have no desire to discuss each subject rationally. It’s an obvious attempt to throw out a smoke screen to continue on with their own agenda.

In fact this poster has been refuted on other threads and leaves them to go on another thread to spew the same anti-Catholic misconceptions.

Bible alone, that’s sola scriptura isn’t it? Please show us where that is written in scriptures. I honestly believe that is a man-made tradition.

Someone has already pointed out the thousands of denominations, due to private interpretation of scripture, how can you prove your authority and that you have correctly interpreted scriptures? What makes your Church right over all the thousands of other Churches?

Lastly, point blank, do you think Catholics have no hope of salvation in the Catholic Church?
That is one Doctrine I would honestly take a bullet for. Sola Scriptura!! Satan in these last days is doing all he can to attack the Word of God. It is sharper than any two edge sword. All things must be tested by the Word of God or else cults arise. All Protestant Churches believe in all essential Doctrines. I have listed some of them on another post. But When you are in a group that contridicts Scripture, such as the Mormons, then you have to teach against it. Bible says “Jesus is God” They say no, but He became a God Just as all Mormons believe they can. Acts 10 Paul said the Bereans were more nobel than any other because they examined the Scriptures, to make sure Paul was right. Now the Holy Spirit wrote the Bible so God is the one who really said it.
Since you are so good at claiming Protestants are Apostate. Tell me then by what Power do they Preach??? Satan! No Sir!!! Satan don’t preach Christ!!! And you tell me how are they so divided? They believe Jesus is God and worship God alone and make Jesus their Savior!!! That is not Satan. Satan can’t cast out Satan or he would be divided and His Kingdom would Fall…How can ya’ll just change things and call it tradition? Jesus Rebuked the Pharises for THE EXACT SAME THING. Their traditions went beyond what was written and Jesus said No. Read about the Disciples not washing their hands. Paul said Let NO MAN Judge you on Sabbaths and Holy Days, but yet you say we must hold to the Holy Days of Obligation. Thats just one of Many. Please Just Pray and Study, Study, Study. I Love all of you on this site. I really do and I wish I could give my soul for yours, but you must come to know. For each mans soul will be Judged on it’s own. I want all my Brothers and Sisters in our Lord Jesus to come together and stop Lording over each other. The Eurcharist is for all the Children of God not Just Catholics.
 
Prodical Son
I never said the Catholics have no Hope, I said the Roman Catholic Church can’t save you, only Christ can. In Christ we all have hope. When the Rich man left and the Disciples said who can be saved? Jesus said with man this is impossible! We are the Church “man” and it is impossible for us to be saved by a man. Then Jesus said with God all things are possible.
Now what give me authorithy? Thats my point we don’t Lord over each other with authority! Ok so don’t take me wrong I know you’ll say Peter was given the Keys. Yes and so was all who God places in Charge, but not to Lord over, but to LEAD as an Example. So the final authority is the Word of God.
 
Prodical Son
I never said the Catholics have no Hope, I said the Roman Catholic Church can’t save you, only Christ can. In Christ we all have hope. When the Rich man left and the Disciples said who can be saved? Jesus said with man this is impossible! We are the Church “man” and it is impossible for us to be saved by a man. Then Jesus said with God all things are possible.
Now what give me authorithy? Thats my point we don’t Lord over each other with authority! Ok so don’t take me wrong I know you’ll say Peter was given the Keys. Yes and so was all who God places in Charge, but not to Lord over, but to LEAD as an Example. So the final authority is the Word of God.
No one is saying that anyone is “lording” over anyone else. YOU are saying.

However, Christ DID establish the Catholic Church, from which she has authority and teaching.

Really, Dennis, you sound more protestant than Catholic. No one is saying that protestants are bad people. Many of them are very good people. However, they are in apostasy to the Catholic church. For now, we can only hope and pray that they’ll be saved. But there is no guarantee that just because you believe in Christ you’re saved.
 
wrong!!! All essiential Doctrines are the same!
  1. All believe Jesus is God
  2. All believe Bible alone
  3. All believe in the Death and Ressurection of Jesus
  4. All believe in the Virgin Birth
  5. All believe in the Trinity
  6. All believe in Salvation alone is found in Christ
    I could go on and on
    Now non essentials Doctrines, yes! their is a diffrence. JUST AS IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
    Speaking in Tongues. Many Charismatic Catholics speake in tongues and many don’t believe in it. Does that divide the church? NO of course not. Same as in the Protestant Churches
Then why so many other denominations denwiles? unfortunately not all protestants believe the list you provided above, not all believe that jesus is god, not all believe in the trinity. I know this because i have spoken to many non-catholic people who have explained to me why their denomination does not believe in the things i mentioned above.

And also speaking in tongues is not a doctrine, and there no such thing as a “non-essential doctrines”, any defined doctrine in the catholic church is essential otherwise it would not be defined as doctrine!

And if different protestant denominations have different “non-essential doctrines” then explain how you would convince someone about your faith if there are different ideas and interpretations being floated around? at least the Catholic church can say that all it’s teachings are and have been consistent for 2000 years going back to Christ himself!
 
Prodical Son
I never said the Catholics have no Hope, I said the Roman Catholic Church can’t save you, only Christ can. In Christ we all have hope. When the Rich man left and the Disciples said who can be saved? Jesus said with man this is impossible! We are the Church “man” and it is impossible for us to be saved by a man. Then Jesus said with God all things are possible.
Now what give me authorithy? Thats my point we don’t Lord over each other with authority! Ok so don’t take me wrong I know you’ll say Peter was given the Keys. Yes and so was all who God places in Charge, but not to Lord over, but to LEAD as an Example. So the final authority is the Word of God.
All who god places in charge? Yes that is correct! Jesus put Peter in charge of his church(catholic) here on earth to lead as an example for the rest of the world! How can protestants believe they are the true church if they all teach differently from one another? is god trying to confuse everyone? did god wait 1500 years before finally revealing his true church? ofcoursenot!!!, the catholic church has 2000 years, hundreds of church fathers and saints who give testimony that the catholic church is god’s church!

Denwiles, the Catholic church has never said that we are saved by man…where did you get this idea from? we do not worship the pope or anyone other than Jesus Christ himself! This is Catholic doctrine, if anyone has told you otherwise then they are mistaken…BIGTIME! We only worship god and god alone, you will not find anywhere in catholic doctrine that we are saved by man, only through Christ Jesus.
 
No need to shout.

Sarcasm and exaggeration do nt prove your pooint. They don’t even well make it.

I grew up in a city with lots of Catholics and Lutherans. Catholics always called my dad “Father” as he was a Lutheran pastor and always wore is clerical collar. He was never offended. When I would meet a Catholic priest, I called him “Father”. The interpretation when applied to priest isn’t sound.

You’re right. Not all. There is as much abuse by protestant clergy as Catholic.

Incorrect. The Catholic Church says any clergy in apostolic succession. That would include Orthodox. I disagree, but at least I disagree with what they actually teach.
And the CC is not a cult.

It isn’t the things you say here, it is the way you’ve said things…

Jon
Brother my heart is so full of Love for all. I wasn’t being sarcastic, but trying to prove a point. Anyway I hope the Lord will show you truth. Your group is the reason we don’t get along. Martin Luther. You should be Catholic, that is not a cut down. I don’t know how many times I have to say it I am not a Protestant. I hate the fact that people don’t want the truth. I have had these exact same talks to the Mormons, Muslims, and many other groups> I have traveled all over the US defending Christian Doctrine. People will die for lies, because that is what they were taught. God Uses me to Provoke thought. Why do you believe what you believe? That is what My job is to do. To get you to think and defend the Truth other wise scientiest will try to make athiest out of us all. Christians when challenged don’t have an answer, because they don’t know what to say. Anyway God Bless you and May Jesus Love as it already does continue to flow through you.
 
wrong!!! All essiential Doctrines are the same!
  1. All believe Jesus is God
  2. All believe Bible alone
  3. All believe in the Death and Ressurection of Jesus
  4. All believe in the Virgin Birth
  5. All believe in the Trinity
  6. All believe in Salvation alone is found in Christ
    I could go on and on
    Now non essentials Doctrines, yes! their is a diffrence. JUST AS IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
    Speaking in Tongues. Many Charismatic Catholics speake in tongues and many don’t believe in it. Does that divide the church? NO of course not. Same as in the Protestant Churches
This isn’t true. My father in law claims to be a Christian and denies the Trinity. He says that it is a non-essential. Who are you to tell him differently? Since your “essential/non-essential” list is subjective and not based off the Bible, by what authority would you tell someone like that, a fellow “bible alone” Christian that it is an essential?

By the way, read about Luther and Zwingli’s meeting and find out just how “non-essential” the real presence was to Luther.

God bless
 
That is one Doctrine I would honestly take a bullet for. Sola Scriptura!! Satan in these last days is doing all he can to attack the Word of God. It is sharper than any two edge sword. All things must be tested by the Word of God or else cults arise. All Protestant Churches believe in all essential Doctrines. I have listed some of them on another post. But When you are in a group that contridicts Scripture, such as the Mormons, then you have to teach against it. Bible says “Jesus is God” They say no, but He became a God Just as all Mormons believe they can. Acts 10 Paul said the Bereans were more nobel than any other because they examined the Scriptures, to make sure Paul was right. Now the Holy Spirit wrote the Bible so God is the one who really said it.
Acts 17:10 - 12
10 Then the brethren immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea. When they arrived, they went into the synagogue of the Jews. 11 These were more fair-minded than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness, and searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so. 12 Therefore many of them believed, and also not a few of the Greeks, prominent women as well as men. (KJV)


After searching the Scripture, MANY of them believed. That implies that MANY of them did not. They searched the same Scriptures, and yet disagreed. And, we can assume that the Greeks probably did not search the Scriptures at all, yet a “number of them” believed.

Those that believed, especially the Greek women and men, believed because Paul taught with authority.
Since you are so good at claiming Protestants are Apostate. Tell me then by what Power do they Preach??? Satan! No Sir!!! Satan don’t preach Christ!!! And you tell me how are they so divided? They believe Jesus is God and worship God alone and make Jesus their Savior!!! That is not Satan. Satan can’t cast out Satan or he would be divided and His Kingdom would Fall…How can ya’ll just change things and call it tradition? Jesus Rebuked the Pharises for THE EXACT SAME THING. Their traditions went beyond what was written and Jesus said No. Read about the Disciples not washing their hands. Paul said Let NO MAN Judge you on Sabbaths and Holy Days, but yet you say we must hold to the Holy Days of Obligation. Thats just one of Many. Please Just Pray and Study, Study, Study. I Love all of you on this site. I really do and I wish I could give my soul for yours, but you must come to know. For each mans soul will be Judged on it’s own. I want all my Brothers and Sisters in our Lord Jesus to come together and stop Lording over each other. The Eurcharist is for all the Children of God not Just Catholics.
I am not claiming Protestants are apostate. I am also not the one on these forums spreading dissension or division, by pointing out differences when it appears two from different Churches are in agreement.

If Paul said, “let no mand judge you on Sabbaths and Holy Days”, why are you continually judging Catholic doctrines and traditions? We know who the only judge is, but you keep telling us how you view what is wrong with Catholicism? When we offer explanations, you move to another thread and repeat the same things, ignoring any explanation?

The Eucharist is for all that believe it is what the Lord said it is.
 
Prodical Son
I never said the Catholics have no Hope, I said the Roman Catholic Church can’t save you, only Christ can. In Christ we all have hope. When the Rich man left and the Disciples said who can be saved? Jesus said with man this is impossible! We are the Church “man” and it is impossible for us to be saved by a man. Then Jesus said with God all things are possible.
Now what give me authorithy? Thats my point we don’t Lord over each other with authority! Ok so don’t take me wrong I know you’ll say Peter was given the Keys. Yes and so was all who God places in Charge, but not to Lord over, but to LEAD as an Example. So the final authority is the Word of God.
I asked once and will try again. Who said the Catholic Church saves without Christ? You are the only one making the insinuation.

Christ ordained the Apostles and the Apostles ordained with the imposition of hands. That’s how Apostolic succession works. One doesn’t just decide they have authority and start a new Church, to make improvements in what Christ built through the Apostles.

If the final authority is the word of God, yes we’re back to sola scriptura, please show us the scriptures that say that, or it’s a man made tradition.

Why does the inspired word of God say the Church of the living God is the pillar and ground of truth, instead of scriptures?

Why does the inspired word of God say that the manifold wisdom of God may be made known through the Church, instead of scriptures?

Why does the inspired word of God say for offenses to be taken to the Church, instead of scriptures?

Why do scriptures tell us that people can wrest scriptures, even to their own destruction, if scriptures are the sole authority?

**1Ti 3:15 But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.

Eph 3:10 That the manifold wisdom of God may be made known to the principalities and powers in heavenly places through the church

Mat 18:17 And if he will not hear them: tell the church. And if he will not hear the church, let him be to thee as the heathen and publican.

2Pe 3:16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are certain things hard to be understood, which the unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, to their own destruction.**

Why did the people of the Old Testament need an authority to explain scriptures to them if it was meant for all to interpret them for themselves?

**Nehemiah 8

1And all the people gathered themselves together as one man into the street that was before the water gate; and they spake unto Ezra the scribe to bring the book of the law of Moses, which the LORD had commanded to Israel.

2And Ezra the priest brought the law before the congregation both of men and women, and all that could hear with understanding, upon the first day of the seventh month.

3And he read therein before the street that was before the water gate from the morning until midday, before the men and the women, and those that could understand; and the ears of all the people were attentive unto the book of the law.

4And Ezra the scribe stood upon a pulpit of wood, which they had made for the purpose; and beside him stood Mattithiah, and Shema, and Anaiah, and Urijah, and Hilkiah, and Maaseiah, on his right hand; and on his left hand, Pedaiah, and Mishael, and Malchiah, and Hashum, and Hashbadana, Zechariah, and Meshullam.

5And Ezra opened the book in the sight of all the people; (for he was above all the people) and when he opened it, all the people stood up:

6And Ezra blessed the LORD, the great God. And all the people answered, Amen, Amen, with lifting up their hands: and they bowed their heads, and worshipped the LORD with their faces to the ground.

7Also Jeshua, and Bani, and Sherebiah, Jamin, Akkub, Shabbethai, Hodijah, Maaseiah, Kelita, Azariah, Jozabad, Hanan, Pelaiah, and the Levites, caused the people to understand the law: and the people stood in their place.

8So they read in the book in the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to understand the reading**.

Why did the Ethiopian eunuch need someone to preach to him to understand what he was reading in scriptures, if the scriptures was the sole authority?

As I’ve asked several times, please provide the scriptures that say that scriptures are the sole authority. Also, take time to address the scriptures and examples I have provided.
 
No one is saying that anyone is “lording” over anyone else. YOU are saying.

However, Christ DID establish the Catholic Church, from which she has authority and teaching.

Really, Dennis, you sound more protestant than Catholic. No one is saying that protestants are bad people. Many of them are very good people. However, they are in apostasy to the Catholic church. For now, we can only hope and pray that they’ll be saved. But there is no guarantee that just because you believe in Christ you’re saved.
He is a Protestant who uses “Catholic” in the universal sense. From the things he’s written, I’d guess he’s with the Assembly of God Pentecostal Church.
 
wrong!!! All essiential Doctrines are the same!
  1. All believe Jesus is God
  2. All believe Bible alone
  3. All believe in the Death and Ressurection of Jesus
  4. All believe in the Virgin Birth
  5. All believe in the Trinity
  6. All believe in Salvation alone is found in Christ
    I could go on and on
    Now non essentials Doctrines, yes! their is a diffrence. JUST AS IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
    Speaking in Tongues. Many Charismatic Catholics speake in tongues and many don’t believe in it. Does that divide the church? NO of course not. Same as in the Protestant Churches
Would you please show me in Sacred Scripture where it says that some doctrines are essential and some are not?

Contrary to what you believe, Does doctrine matter:
a) 1 Timothy 1:3 As I urged you when I was going to Macedonia, remain at Ephesus that you may charge certain persons not to teach any different doctrine

b) 1 Timothy 4:1 Now the Spirit expressly says that in later times some will depart from the faith by giving heed to deceitful spirits and doctrines of demons

c) Titus 1:9 (speaking of a bishop) he must hold firm to the sure word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to confute those who contradict it

We can’t divide doctrine into essential and non-essential:
a) Matthew 4:4 But he answered, "It is written, `Man shall not live by bread alone,
but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God

b) Matthew 5:18-19 For truly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, not an iota, not a dot, will pass from the law until all is accomplished.
[19] Whoever then relaxes one of the least of these commandments and teaches men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but he who does them and teaches them shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven

And conflicting, contradictory doctrine are not okay:
a) John 14:26 But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things, and bring to your remembrance **all **that I have said to you

b) John 16:13 When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth; for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come

c) Malachi 3:6 For I the LORD do not change
 
:)Hi There; Well…I go to a protestant church. It’s called The Circle Church. It’s a Christian Church(Disiples Of Christ) cogregation. I am Greek Orthodox but right now i’m a protestant worshiping in a Bible church.
I believe that it’s fine if you, take communion in a protestant church as long as they are a trinity loving church.
I belive that the body of christ is one as long as we keep the lord jesus christ as the focus of our doctrine.
I believe that we are one body in jesus christ.I feel that it’s OK for Catholics and Protestants to share with each other and sometimes even The table of the lord. Yes, sometimes holy communion. That’s hard for me, to say as a Greek Orthodox Christian, but I do believe that we can sometimes do it by Economy. I hope that you, can write me, and sure your thoughts.
Blessings to you.
Sincerely,
Gregory.
Hello,
My wife and I were confirmed into the HCC during the Easter vigil mass of '07. My parents both pastor at a protestant Church. My dad is the “music minister” and my mother is the pastor of outreach and evangelism. Is it acceptable for me to attend their services? My dad likes for me to attend when he preaches. Which is about once a month. Obviously, I don’t recieve communion because we are not in communion. I want to show him my love and respect, though I don’t want any mixed messages to be sent to the other members who attend there that we approve of Protestantism in general by my presence. What are your thoughts?
 
:)Hi There; Well…I go to a protestant church. It’s called The Circle Church. It’s a Christian Church(Disciples Of Christ) congregation. I am Greek Orthodox but right now I’m a protestant worshiping in a Bible church.
I believe that it’s fine if you, take communion in a protestant church as long as they are a trinity loving church.
I believe that the body of Christ is one as long as we keep the lord Jesus Christ as the focus of our doctrine.
I believe that we are one body in Jesus Christ.I feel that it’s OK for Catholics and Protestants to share with each other and sometimes even The table of the lord. Yes, sometimes holy communion. That’s hard for me, to say as a Greek Orthodox Christian, but I do believe that we can sometimes do it by Economy. I hope that you, can write me, and sure your thoughts.
Blessings to you.
Sincerely,
Gregory.
Gregory,
Thank you for your post, though I think that you might have missed the point. I too am worshiping at a bible church, the original Bible Church 🙂 (since it is through the Catholic Church God gave us the sacred texts). My original post was not so much about whether or not I should receive communion at when I visit my parents protestant congregation, but whether as a Catholic I should be visiting at all, and how attending or not attending might affect my witness to my parents and their congregation.

I believe that when Christ prayed His High Priestly prayer in John 17 that we all might be one just as He and the Father are one, and that through the witness of our unity the world would know Him (paraphrase of course) He meant it. While I affirm whole heartedly that what connects us is our rootedness(not a word) in Christ, I also affirm that Christ established Here on earth a visible means for us to know and share with the world the fullness of who He is and all of the incredible gifts He has given. That is the Catholic Church. I truly desire to be the best witness to that Truth as I can in every circumstance especially when they are uncomfortable.

As for receiving Holy Communion outside of the Catholic Church. I think that it is fitting that we refer to it as Communion. For it is, as the Catechism of the Catholic Church says, “the source and summit of the life and mission of the Church”. Protestant denominations are not in communion with each other nor are they in communion with the Catholic Church. If, therefore, I believe that the Eucharist is source and summit of life, how can I go outside my Church receive communion with people who do not believe what the Church teaches? Especially its teachings on the very meal we would be sharing? Either Holy Communion is what it is or I am a grave idolater. So if we are not in communion why would we share this table. I gladly share the table of the Lord with those who share the whole Truth Christ gave us, not some of it, or the bits and pieces that they choose to believe.

Again thanks for your post, it was getting a bit off track!
 
Hi There; I’m a protestant christian who attends The Circle Church A Christian Church(Disiples Of Christ) Congregation.
I’m am Greek Orhodox but right now I’m a Protestant Bible Believing Christian. I do believe that it’s OK to worship in protestant churches.
Well…Because we All worship our Lord Jesus Christ. I even believe that sometimes we can share at The Lord’s Table together. In the Greek Orthodox Church this is called Economy. Economy is a special gift of The Orthodox Church were a non-orthodox can recieve Holy Communion under Special Extenuating Circumstances.
Well…In The Christian Church(Disiples Of Christ) All are invited to The Lord’s Banqueting Table. His Banner over me is love! Jesus in his great love has invited us ALL to his Banqueting Table of Love.
I believe that we are saved by Grace. We are not saved by works. We don’t have to earn his love. He loves us All Unconditionally.
He invites us All to his Holy Table.
We are saved by Grace thourgh Faith. We are saved by Jesus. I’m hoping for more love and unity among Catholics and Protestants. I’m hoping for Bridges of Hope and Unity. I want to Extend The Healing love of Jesus among Christians.
Jesus is so much in love with people. He wants to heal people and families.Man o Man, He loves us with such a Stubborn Love! He loves us so much.
It’s my hope to share Jesus love with Catholics and Protestants and Eastern Orthodox Christians.
Jesus has saved us by his Grace. He has saved us by Faith in Him.
I want protestants and catholics to love each other. This will make Jesus very Happy. I’m praying for Bridges Of Hope and love Among Christians. I hope that we can Build a Beautiful Love among Christians that won’t divide us.
Please feel welcome to write this Christian, I would love to hear your thoughts.
God bless you.
Sincerely,
Gregory.
 
Protestant denominations are not in communion with each other nor are they in communion with the Catholic Church.
Actually, that’s not entirely true. The United Methodist Church, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, and the Episcopal Church are in communion/eucharistic sharing agreements with each other, and pastors may concelebrate with each other, as you can read here and here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top