Australia flood Brisbane faces surge

  • Thread starter Thread starter Santi2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Santi2

Guest
Thousands of people have been urged to leave parts of Australia’s third largest city, Brisbane, which is facing its worst flooding in decades.
Officials say between 6,500 and 9,000 homes and businesses are set to flood in Queensland’s state capital.
Streets are largely empty and families have moved to refuge centres in some areas, with the peak of the flooding expected on Wednesday and Thursday.
To our Aussie friends here, I pray and hope all be well soon.
 
I read in another post on another thread that this flooding alternates with drought.

Maybe the town leaders need to build some catchment areas upstream to divert or store the water.
 
Maybe the town leaders need to build some catchment areas upstream to divert or store the water.
Its not a topic I am familiar with, and perhaps some of our Aussie friends (or at least those with more knowledge than myself) can weigh in. However, it seems that after the catastrophic flood of 1974, the Wivenhoe Dam was built precisely to prevent a repeat flood.
abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/01/10/3109759.htm

However, weeks of unusually heavy rain due to a La Nina weather pattern similar to 1974, has filled the reservoir forcing the gates to release flood waters in high volume.
 
I read in another post on another thread that this flooding alternates with drought.

Maybe the town leaders need to build some catchment areas upstream to divert or store the water.
My daughter lives in Brisbane. I believe, from what I remember her telling me on my last visit during the drought, that their main catchment area for city water supply is actually on the other side of a range of mountains. At that time homeowners were being urged to install water tanks in their yards for watering their gardens with runoff from their roof.

Of course, now it’s flooding because it’s raining–no way to control that. 😃 She told me a month or so ago that one of the catchments that was for flood control was nearly full at that time.

My daughter works in an office that is located in the 100 year floodplain. First they were moving things up from the ground floor, next the area was evacuated.

She lives uphill from the river on a slope, and said she had enough supplies on hand to wait it out.

I pray for help for those who are less prepared or suddenly find themselves in danger.
 
To our Aussie friends here, I pray and hope all be well soon.
Thankyou everyone for your interest, and prayers.

The floods in Queensland have been catastrophisc, and have caused loss of life.

There is a “but” however! Just two years ago all of Australia was in the most severe drought that we had ever seen. In Queensland, the area which has been most flooded, the dams were at 10%, and the government was trying to sell to the population the idea of recycling sewage water. We were all facing a “dry” and very uncertain future.

I don’t think there is anyone who would want to go back to the drought.

Most of southern and eastern Australia has experienced floods in the last couple of months, and most of it has been beneficial. Probably 80% of Australians have been effected by floods in some way. People have travelled to the rivers and lakes for the once-in-a-lifetime chance to see all this water.

Unfortunately, the recent floods in Queensland have been more severe than the others. We thank you again for your concern and prayers.

~ Edmundus
 
I just heard from my daughter in a Brisbane suburb. She says it’s estimated that 40,000 homes will have flooded by the time this is over. They have a couple that they know who were flooded staying with them until the water recedes.

I always admired the style of the old Queenslander homes–many are built up off the ground with space underneath that provides shade during the hot months. Now I realize that they were probably built that way because of the flood potential, too.

Still praying for relief for these people. The drought was bad enough…
 
Some excerpts from comments section of newspaper:

The Qld government has been repeatedly urged to build more dams as part of a better water management plan in the face of population increase, but has always refused on environmental grounds.

Instead, listening to the global warming fanatics who predicted worsening drought, they sank over $1 billion into a desalination plant.

Desalination plants use alot of energy don’t they? Are they solar powered plants?

The global warmists claimed Queensland’s rains would dry up, which is why the Labor Government built a desalination plant - now mothballed - instead of yet more dams:
(Premier Peter) Beattie said the effects of climate change on our region meant we could no longer rely on past rainfall patterns to help us plan for the future…

“My advice indicates if we continue to experience below average rainfalls it could take several years (anywhere from five to ten years) for our major dam system to climb back up past 40 percent even with purified recycled water, desalination and the other measures we’re taking to supplement our water supplies.

“Given the current uncertainty about the likely impact of climate change on rainfall patterns in SEQ over coming years, it is only prudent to assume at this stage that lower than usual rainfalls could eventuate.

But Heather Brown, a Toowoomba resident, says locals made other bad choices in the same mistaken belief that floods would not come:

Tragically, it seems some of the most basic rules of survival - and certainly the most elementary rule of town planning - were forgotten in the case of Toowoomba, a city that is dissected by East Creek and West Creek, two deceptively innocent looking little creeks that seem to run as much water as a decent suburban gutter for most of the year.

Admittedly, Toowoomba - Australia’s Garden City - has been battling drought for almost a decade… Along the way, the creeks have been prettied and preened and slotted into your typical modern urban plan. And the breadth of their flow - and their seminal right to a small flood plain - has been gradually stolen away.

At the intersections of Victoria, Margaret and Russell streets - where the boiling muddy tsunami was its fiercest and most graphically filmed - the city council had embarked on an ambitious beautification plan to turn the creek into a pleasing urban feature, complete with boardwalks, gardens, illumination and seating. Everyone thought it was wonderful, except for cynics such as my husband and me. In fact, every time we drove past the feature we would say to no one in particular: This little creek is going to make them sorry one day. Tragically, we were right.

Early yesterday morning I went back to the bruised and battered Margaret Street to support any local business that still had the heart to open. My coffee shop was handing out free coffees to the battered owners of the local businesses who had lost so much. When I went to buy my newspaper, the newsagent told me he was devastated, not because of what had happened but because the engineer who had worked on the beautification project told him he couldn’t make them listen when he pleaded for bigger pipes - “18-footers” he called them - to let the water through, because it simply didn’t suit the aesthetics of the architects and landscapers.

So that’s what happened to my city, folks, the same as happened to so much of flooded Queensland. We did stupid and really, really dumb things because we thought we could get away with them. We built the wrong sort of houses and the wrong sort of bridges. We built towns and suburbs on flood plains. And we ignored at our peril the forces of nature and the history of the great floods that have shaped this continent for thousands of years.
 
This just in:

Some recent and older history on Australian weather.

Queensland floods: but at least the ‘endangered’ Mary River cod is safe, eh?

By James Delingpole Politics Last updated: January 11th, 2011

This is a guest post from one of our regular commenters, Memory Vault. He’s understandably upset about the Australian floods, which may have claimed more than 70 lives. But what really upsets him is that this disaster could have been prevented. He blames green campaigners so wedded to their ideology they never stop to consider the human consequences. It is to them his bitter letter is addressed.

Andrew Bolt has similarly harsh words for Australia’s eco nuts. Were it not for the actions of Environment Minister Peter Garrett, for example, the Queensland town of Gympie would not now be underwater. Unfortunately, Garrett took it upon himself to block the proposed dam that would have prevented it.

Federal Environment Minister Peter Garrett on Wednesday said he made the interim decision to reject the controversial $1.8 billion plan to dam the Mary River because evidence showed it could kill off endangered species. He made the interim decision to reject the controversial $1.8 billion plan to dam the Mary River because evidence showed it could kill off endangered species

“The project would have serious and irreversible effects on national listed species such as the Australian lungfish, the Mary River turtle and the Mary River cod – both of those endangered.

Here is Memory Vault’s post. It is addressed to the climate trolls who haunt this blog, forever assuring us with their characteristic shrill certainty, that the “science” is now settled and that we sceptics are greedy, selfish fools.

I am sitting here in my home in South East Queensland, watching the news come in about the flooding everywhere. Entire suburbs around Brisbane and several smaller towns are either isolated by flood-waters or have been evacuated. Highways are cut everywhere.

People have been dying. So far about 20 people have died in the past week – nine just this morning when a deluge went through the Lockyer Valley. Most of them children. Another 70 are missing. One could put it all down to “just” weather.

Except EXACTLY the same floods occurred in EXACTLY the same places back in 1974, with much the same tragic loss of life and destruction of property.

Back then we weren’t nearly as clever and learned as you think yourselves to be today. Back then we had this silly notion that climate was cyclical, and if we didn’t prepare for it, we would have a repeat of the same tragedies to deal with in “about thirty years”. That was the thinking of the scientists back then – that climate went in roughly thirty year cycles.

Flood mitigation programs were planned. A series of levee banks and diversionary dams would be built. Brisbane and SE QLD would NEVER suffer such devastation again. After all, we had thirty years to plan and build and improve.

And that’s what we did – or at least started. Wivenhoe Dam got built as the first step, but by the time it was finished clever people like you lot who “knew” that such things were never going to happen again had taken over. CO2 AGW madness had already taken hold.

Instead we had “post modern” minds like Tim Flannery “advising” the government that because of Anthropogenic Global Warming, SE QLD would be perpetually in drought from then on. “Forget dams and flood mitigation programs”, intoned the wise Dr Tim – “build desalination plants instead”.

So that’s what our government did. And that is why thirty five years later, we are once again suffering exactly the SAME tragic loss of life and destruction of property, pretty-much exactly where, and when, and how, those stupid scientists who foolishly believed climate was cyclical had predicted.

Meanwhile our billion dollar desalination plant is quietly being mothballed, and emergency crews are frantically trying to work out how they might be able to save nineteen thousand homes from destruction in the next couple of days, as the Lockyer deluge hits Brisbane. Wise Dr Tim Flannery has been made ‘Australian of the Year” for his contributions.

I google on the internet for climate extremes and climate-related disasters in the 1972 – 1979 period – the period of the last transition in the natural weather cycle, and I find that it wasn’t a good period in many places around the world. Record and near record high – and low temperatures, record and near-record precipitation, and so on. Floods and droughts pretty-much mimicking what is happening now, and in pretty-much the same places.

I also noted that the indicators of the “silly” theory of the cyclical nature , ocean and atmospheric, are pretty much exactly as they are now.
 
[a small amount had to be cut for length]

I have to admit it could all get a bit depressing. But then I remember that the world is in the capable hands of much cleverer people than those silly scientists back in the Seventies who believed climate was cyclical. Now the decisions are being made by clever people like Dr Tim Flannery

– and you.

That is when I weep for my fellow Man.

2011-1973 = 38 = 2 x 19yr eclipse cycle
SouthWEST Queensland to be hit by floods end Jan

As the BBC reports on the massive floods now - 11 Jan - hitting Brisbane you can almost feel them wailing about the “almost unprecedented wall of water…” - with all its Global warming CO2 extremes innuendo - except locals in a matter-of-fact manner ruin the show by saying it is unprecedented since 1974. Or if you look at more details unprecedented since the years of floods centred around 1973-74**.

As shown in WA2011NewsNo1* Queensland & Australian floods show a very strong tendency to occur at a certain phase of the 19yr eclipse cycle. The delusional Australian politicians who want to blame CO2, and the warmist cult propagandists of the BBC need to be reminded of simple sums:

2011-1973 = 38 = 2 x 19yr eclipse cycle

So the floods are nothing to do with CO2!

Piers Corbyn, astrophysicist of Weatheraction.com says these floods are caused by ‘stuck’ jet stream situations which depend on certain phases of the eclipse cycle and will continue through January.
 
So the floods are nothing to do with CO2!

Piers Corbyn, astrophysicist of Weatheraction.com says these floods are caused by ‘stuck’ jet stream situations which depend on certain phases of the eclipse cycle and will continue through January.
I’m reminded of a Larry Niven short story (can’t remember which) where, because of global cooling, they had to artificially restart the jet stream. It was the 60s, you know, they thought it was global cooling, then—and amazingly, all the same environmental policies were called for!

If you go to a guy because it’s too hot, or too cold, or you’re impotent, or you have too much libido, and his answer to all of them is, “Repent! Woe unto all ye sinners!”…

…that guy is not a scientist, he is a preacher-man. Nothing against preachers, but let’s have some consistent labeling.
 
I’ve posted a prayer request for the Queensland floods under another forum, mainly focussing on Brisbane.

I live about 30kms from the Brisbane CBD, and have lived in Queensland most of my life, so I’ve got some local knowledge. I also lived through the 1974 floods and we had about two or three feet of water under the house which was high-set. As far as I know 1974 was the worst flood for Brisbane to date. The difference between it and this one is that it happened almost overnight when a rain depression from a cyclone dumped about 18 inches of rain overnight on Brisbane, and this, coupled with a king tide, flooded those parts of Brisbane which were not far from the river and / or low lying.

I’m not affected directly by the floods myself this time. Where I live in Logan you’d hardly know there was a flood, if it weren’t for the 24/7 flood coverage on the television. On my way home people were mowing their yards, just like any other summer afternoon (a lot of them are off work due to the flood affecting their workplaces, so they’ve got the time at the moment).

Wivenhoe Dam was built following the 74 flood to safeguard against a similar event occurring again. Some other steps were taken such as widening local creeks, although since then the mangroves have grown back again. However the creeks haven’t caused the real damage.

Now just over 2 years ago, following a prolonged drought, the Wivenhoe Dam was down to about 16% capacity or less and the government was very concerned about water supply. There was a real risk the city would run out of water.

Fortunately (not long after the then Premier requested a day of prayer for rain), enough rain fell over a period to gradually fill the dam, and even go overfill it, in the sense that 100% is water supply and excess is flood control.

in 2010 we had one of our wettest years, so that not only were the dams overfilled, but the ground became saturated and therefore any further rain had to be run-off.

I have a few comments to make.

First if enough rain is dumped in an area for long enough, the most dedicated flood controls are not going to stop flooding.

Second I think the Traveston Dam should have gone ahead, not so much for flood control (it wouldn’t have made one iota of difference for Brisbane as the Mary River is a completely different catchment. It might have helped Gympie and Maryborough for a short while, but I still think they’d have flooded). I’m cynical about federal politicians weighing in with arguments that a bunch of lung fish are more important than the water needs of 2 million or more people. And what really annoyed me was that the state government had already spent 2 billion dollars on research and buying up land before the then environment minister stuck his oar in.

That’s our money he was playing fast and loose with.

Third Australia does not have a lot of places where dams can easily be built. We’re the lowest lying continent, and consequently we don’t have the mountains and valleys to be easily dammed. Lake Eyre , which is completely dry most of time, and only fills up following floods in the north, is below sea level.

Third we tend to have floods interspersed with drought. We’ll get several years of drought, and then get hit with a rain depression from a cyclone. Someone on another forum roughly calculated that a billon tons of water (at least) was dumped on Queensland during the floods.

So there’s only so much any government can do. There has been some colossal wastage of resources eg. the Traveston Dam bungle, and that’s what gets my goat more than anything else. We pay for all this stupidity.

Finally I happen to believe in global warming. I remember my old pastor making the comment “I think He’s (God’s) doing something to the sun”. And he used to be very accurate. For whatever reason, I think global warming is a fact. And as the lowest lying continent, with a lot of our most productive farmland being flat and not much above sea level, Australia as a whole would more badly affected than just about any other continent.
 
Thanks to our Aussie friends and to the rest who contributed posts offering updates and background. It helps greatly when one is limited to query of the “hows” and “whys” sort over a calamity of this scale. In the meantime, one continues to pray for what is paramount i.e. the safety of those caught up in the floods. One also offers prayers to those who have perished.

Bob, you’re not too far from the affected areas and I pray that all continue to be well with you, as well as with AnotherMary’s daughter. We have family friends in Brisbane and we do not know what the situation is with them. Since we also have immediate family in Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra who will step in for just-in-cases, we have taken to the “no news is good news” and carry on with prayers.
 
This is an excerpt from the most recent email from my daughter. Their house is not in danger of flooding (at least from the river). I thought readers might be interested in a personal and local perspective–as I have been with what previous posters have shared.
Theamount or rainfall is amazing.Twelve inches ofrain fell over Wivenhoe Dam on Tuesday in just anine hour period. The volume of water the dam was receiving each daywasmore than twice that of*Sydney Harbour. It’s a lot of water! They had to release water from the dam in order to safely absorb all the water flowing in from Toowoomba and the Lockyer Valley.
*
People have been fantastic. Everyone is helping everyone else and not dwelling on what has been lost. We will be helping our friends clean up their houses. We know a few people who were flooded.
**
Keep those prayers coming because there are a lot of people needing all the help they can get.
*
I have to admire the Aussie spirit.
 
Thanks to our Aussie friends and to the rest who contributed posts offering updates and background. It helps greatly when one is limited to query of the “hows” and “whys” sort over a calamity of this scale. In the meantime, one continues to pray for what is paramount i.e. the safety of those caught up in the floods. One also offers prayers to those who have perished.

Bob, you’re not too far from the affected areas and I pray that all continue to be well with you, as well as with AnotherMary’s daughter. We have family friends in Brisbane and we do not know what the situation is with them. Since we also have immediate family in Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra who will step in for just-in-cases, we have taken to the “no news is good news” and carry on with prayers.
The chances are your family friends are quite OK in the health sense, since nearly all the recent deaths and missing are centred on the Toowoomba and Lockyer Valley flash flooding. I think there’s only been one death in Brisbane from flooding, and that was a young bloke who got sucked into storm water drainage which he probably couldn’t see when he was wading through water.

If you know what suburb they’re in, I could probably tell you if there’s a possibility of their being hit by the flood or not.
 
Los Angeles, the City of Angels, used to have terrible floods, but they designed and built an elaborate system of drainage canals. Not easy or cheap, but it worked.

Brisbane can do something similar, along with raising up the places where they build buildings using fill dirt from where they excavate reservoirs, detention ponds, retention ponds and canals.
 
Los Angeles, the City of Angels, used to have terrible floods, but they designed and built an elaborate system of drainage canals. Not easy or cheap, but it worked.

Brisbane can do something similar, along with raising up the places where they build buildings using fill dirt from where they excavate reservoirs, detention ponds, retention ponds and canals.
I think there’ll be some soul searching after these floods. It would be stupid if the authorities did nothing, as similar situations will happen again sooner or later.

The river this time reached 4.45 metres against the standard height. The floods in 1893 reached 8.35 metres. However Brisbane was a lot smaller back then so property damage was far less.

A bit of local history just for interest’s sake. You’ll note the reference to our convict origins.

"In 1824, the first convict colony was established at Redcliffe Point under Lieutenant Miller. Meanwhile, Oxley and Allan Cunningham explored further up the Brisbane River in search of water, landing at the present location of North Quay. Only one year later, in 1825, the colony was moved south from Redcliffe to a peninsula on the Brisbane River, site of the present Central Business District, called “Mean-jin” by the local Turrbul inhabitants.

The settlement was named “Edenglassie” (in honour of Edinburgh and Glasgow, Scotland) by British pioneers but was subsequently renamed to match the river. The official population of Brisbane at the end of 1825 was “45 males and 2 females”.

The colony was originally established as a “prison within a prison” - a settlement, deliberately distant from Sydney, to which convicts who reoffended while serving their sentences could be sent as punishment. It soon garnered a reputation, along with Norfolk Island, as being one of the harshest penal settlements in all of New South Wales.

Over twenty years, thousands of convicts passed through the penal colony. Hundreds of these fled the stern conditions and escaped into the bush. Although most escapes were unsuccessful or resulted in the escapees perishing in the bush, some (e.g. James Davies) succeeded in living as “wild white men” amongst the Aboriginal people.

During these decades, the local Aboriginal people tried to ‘starve out’ the settlement by destroying its crops - most notably at the “corn fields” - today’s South Bank. In retaliation, guards shot and killed Aboriginal people entering the corn fields."
 
Thanks for your posts Bob Crowley.

I was always interested in Australia…and then my daughter moved there! I think I read too much travel literature when I was pregnant.

I got to wondering about the underground inner city bypass that I had seen under construction on my last visit to Brisbane. A quick google brought up this YouTube video. I guess the Brekky Creek survived. Look at the hotel website–they are already planning a fundraiser.

So many people are pitching in to help clean things up. Good on ya!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top