Average tax refund down 8% so far this season

  • Thread starter Thread starter ThinkingSapien
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

ThinkingSapien

Guest

Tax season is off to a slower start this year, with early filers seeing smaller average refunds.

The average refund is down about 8% under the first full year of the overhauled tax code, according to data released by the IRS on Friday. Refunds averaged $1,865 compared to $2,035 for tax year 2017.

The total number of returns received also dipped during the first week of the season ending February 1, down from about 18 million to some 16 million so far in 2019.

This season will be watched closely to gauge the real impact of the Republican-led tax overhaul in 2017 that ushered in the most sweeping changes to the tax code in 30 years.
 
Soooo…people didn’t get overtaxed and have to get their money back…
 
Seems so. In the other thread, a person who actually knows something about taxes said those now complaining either:

-Did not adjust their withholding so as to give the government more of their money to refund to them.
-Are in a high tax state and are losing the state tax deduction, but didn’t adjust for it.

In other words, these people are still paying less tax, they just loaned the government less of their income. Nobody is even claiming they’re paying more in taxes.
 
Last edited:
Nobody is even claiming they’re paying more in taxes.
Nobody? Apart from the obvious, there have been numerous people who have inidcated that their total tax remittances are since deductions have been curtailed.
 
And then there’s the ongoing question as to why would an observant Christian take a position of supporting that tax plan that will hurt the poor and many of the elderly through significant cuts to Medicaid and the elimination of the CHIP program that had given children from poor families at least some health-care insurance? The bishops have criticized these cuts but it appears that some Catholics prefer not to listen to them.
 
The bishops
Oh? Perhaps you’ll tell us which bishops they are and quote them from a reliable source.

CHIP still exists. Medicaid still exists. Medicare still exists. What has become virtually non-existent is “child only” health insurance that single parents primarily used to buy. The Obamacare mandates made it too expensive.
 
Did not adjust their withholding so as to give the government more of their money to refund to them.
I would bet many if not most people don’t change their withholding exemptions from year to year.

Paul Ryan celebrated less withholding from everyone’s paycheck and thus more spending money IMMEDIATELY after the tax reform was passed. It appears this was part of the tax act. How many Republicans warned the tax payers to adjust their withholding amounts in early 2018? Close to none since they wanted people to actually believe it was a larger tax cut than it was. IOW it was designed to deceive.

Hope everyone learned his/her lesson and adjusted the W4 for 2019.
 
Last edited:
I certainly remember reading that one ought to adjust his withholding if he wanted his refund to remain at the same level. But I guess a lot of people don’t realize the refund is their own money they loaned to the government at no interest.
 
I certainly remember reading that one ought to adjust his withholding if he wanted his refund to remain at the same level. But I guess a lot of people don’t realize the refund is their own money they loaned to the government at no interest.
Although the refund is what is being reported here, the real question is was it a tax cut? To answer that one must do the taxes and then see if the total tax went down or up. If it was a tax cut, the only way the refund could go down would be if the sum of all the paycheck amounts during the year went up more than the refund went down. That question is still open.
 
The article only mentions inadequate withholding and elimination of some deductions as the cause of lower refunds, but acknowledges that the rates are lower.

So there’s really no mystery about it. Individual rates are lower. Some people will lose some deductions. But that’s not due to tax rates.
 
will it hurt the poor or did it make jobs available to them?
The job market has been gradually improving since 2010 in an almost straight line progression, and both Obama and Trump deserve some credit for that.

However, the tax cuts are viewed in economics as sorta being like a “sugar high” because there are repercussion from such actions that tend to catch up with us, and this is already happening with increases in the prime interest rate and also the prediction that we are likely to be seeing a gradual move towards recession possibly as early as later this year but almost guaranteed in 2020 based on economic models. Time will tell.
 
You’re right, if they get sizesble refunds it is bad tax planning but if it’s the best way to pay for their vacations and such, it’s their choice. At least they don’t go further in debt.
 
Last edited:
No few people use refunds as a sort of “forced savings plan”. I never saw the sense of it myself.
 
With the low interest rates it’s not going to make that much of a difference. When CDs were paying 12% one would want as much money upfront as possible.
 
Last edited:
With the low interest rates it’s not going to make that much of a difference.
No. But for some there’s “opportunity loss”, i.e., what productive thing could I have done with the money?
 
Buy cattle futures at margin? 🙂
Ha! Risky unless the fix is in. I actually had occasion to meet a man who was on the other side of Hillary’s cattle futures adventures. Lost his shirt using the same broker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top