Baby Found in Trash

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
estesbob:
How did “If you want to celebrate…” become “I celebrate” ? I’m done with you. We all agree that this is an unspeakable tragedy ( what thread title refers to, so no-one misinterprets), and I’ll just leave it at that.
 
So rather than help people and pray for their recovery, we should hope they die from their abuse? Nice.

You’d be shocked how many perfectly happy and well-adjusted people have had abuse in their past. No one escapes unscathed - but to wish for their death? I can’t tell you how distasteful this is.
I fully agree with you. There is absolutely no rationalizing the wishful thinking that any life be distinguished. It is NOT for us, as imperfect people, to decide what would be best in such a situation. That is for God to decide and we must pray and trust in Him, and through His grace, perhaps those who are abused can overcome. We have fallen so far from our trust in God. The baby survived, given the circumstance, that would be God’s Will. God has a plan, and for us to presume we know better is folly.
 
In my opinion he/she’d be much better off dead. I don’t hope or wish he/she had died as I don’t want to be another person in the list of people who’ve done him/her harm. To me beatific vision and perfect happiness is a better lot than a (shadow of a) life of hardship, suffering and emotional misery (as post-traumatic lives usually are), that’s a no-brainer to me. If you want to celebrate knowing what lies ahead for the baby, suit yourself.
By all that, you mean suffering as Christ did? Not all of us will face the same hardships, and not all of us will carry such burdens, and still for others, burdens will be much heavier. It is for God to decide, we must pray that His will be done, and that if the baby survived, it is part of God’s plan.
 
In my opinion he/she’d be much better off dead. I don’t hope or wish he/she had died as I don’t want to be another person in the list of people who’ve done him/her harm. To me beatific vision and perfect happiness is a better lot than a (shadow of a) life of hardship, suffering and emotional misery (as post-traumatic lives usually are), that’s a no-brainer to me. If you want to celebrate knowing what lies ahead for the baby, suit yourself.
Sad to see someone with such a limited scope of life.
 
I am losing faith in humanity. This is where a society goes when we want instant answers to problems.

Regarding the microwave link: We want our food heated up in less than a minute. We want our problems to go away by taking a pill or having some surgery. Is it no surprise someone has combined the two?

When we start accepting this kind of thing as, well, the baby is better off dead than having to grow up in that home, we minimalist the value of human life. The devalue of life perpetuates today’s culture of death. Where will it all end?

On the bright side, I am seeing some youths turn to God for answers. I watched a survivor episode where they had a group prayer. I have seen young people join church choirs and get married in the Catholic Church. The top contestant in American Idol where’s a cross, and you can tell by the way he acts he is a Christian. Maybe we aren’t so totally lost.
 
In my opinion he/she’d be much better off dead. I don’t hope or wish he/she had died as I don’t want to be another person in the list of people who’ve done him/her harm. To me beatific vision and perfect happiness is a better lot than a (shadow of a) life of hardship, suffering and emotional misery (as post-traumatic lives usually are), that’s a no-brainer to me. If you want to celebrate knowing what lies ahead for the baby, suit yourself.
Aren’t you forgetting that God, as the Author of Life, also has sovereignty regarding Death? (Altho we’ve tried to usurp Him in this regard with abortion and other moral evils.) This baby will not be without God’s grace to grow into his full potential.
 
Sad to see someone with such a limited scope of life.
Expose your extended scope of life so I can learn from you. Does your moral superiority allow you to use “you” when referring to me or you’re going to find creative ways to circumvent it? Quite frankly, you have no idea what you’re talking about. Now Jesus, there’s this presomptuous guy who thinks he’s a moral reference because he read the Bible and the CC from cover to cover and he’s condemning me for thinking the baby would be better off with you, all that on a Catholic forum, of all places. You know heaven, the prize, what we keep our gaze on everyday to keep going, running the race to the finish, the “finish” being perfect union with you. He insists that the mere thought of it is reprehensible and that thinking anything other than this “valley of tears” is morally contemptible? Shall I pray for him or discard him as a hopeless case as far as logic goes?
 
Expose your extended scope of life so I can learn from you. Does your moral superiority allow you to use “you” when referring to me or you’re going to find creative ways to circumvent it? Quite frankly, you have no idea what you’re talking about. Now Jesus, there’s this presomptuous guy who thinks he’s a moral reference because he read the Bible and the CC from cover to cover and he’s condemning me for thinking the baby would be better off with you, all that on a Catholic forum, of all places. You know heaven, the prize, what we keep our gaze on everyday to keep going, running the race to the finish, the “finish” being perfect union with you. He insists that the mere thought of it is reprehensible and that thinking anything other than this “valley of tears” is morally contemptible? Shall I pray for him or discard him as a hopeless case as far as logic goes?
By your rationale we should kill all children at birth so they can be with the Father and not have to worry about ever suffering. Again there is no basis in Church teaching that supports your contention that the child woud be better off dead. Perhaps you should read the CC and Bible cover to cover.
 
. Does your moral superiority allow you to use “you” when referring to me or you’re going to find creative ways to circumvent it?
Who said anything about morality? I was commenting on your obviously limited experiences in life.

To think that a child or infant can not go on to have a happy life despite tragic or humble origins is just sad. Not ever seeing such an occurrence indicates a life that has been extremely limited in both human contact and general life experiences.
 
Who said anything about morality? I was commenting on your obviously limited experiences in life.

To think that a child or infant can not go on to have a happy life despite tragic or humble origins is just sad. Not ever seeing such an occurrence indicates a life that has been extremely limited in both human contact and general life experiences.
Please don’t use the term “humble origins” in a thread about a “Baby Found in Trash”.

This thread is starting to be too much about me and not enough about the baby. I ask God to find a loving and Christian family and Mary to open his heart and mind to her maternal love and to the love of God also. I pray God that he/she may not be acquainted with grief, sorrow, rejection but that he/she may have a fulfilling life. Amen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top