Bachmann cites Canada as economic role model

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pax_et_Bonum
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Pax_et_Bonum

Guest
Bachmann cites Canada as economic role model

by Seth McLaughl(name removed by moderator)ublished on June 21, 2011
RECENT ENTRIES

Rep. Michele Bachmann apparently is turning north for economic inspiration to that great land of freedom — Canada.

In a Twitter posting Monday, the outspoken Minnesota Republican and presidential hopeful suggested the United States could learn a lot from the economic policies of its neighbor to the north.

“Lesson in economic recovery: Consider Canada. No stimulus & unemployment is 20% lower than US,” the Bachmann camp wrote, taking a swipe at the $830 billion stimulus package that the Democratic-controlled Congress passed and President Obama signed into law in 2009. Canadian officials did try to stimulate the economy, but at a far lower level than that tried by the Obama administration.

The tweet directs viewers to a chart on a June 16 post from John Lott, where the economist and conservative political commentator compared the Canadian and U.S. unemployment rates during the recession and recovery.

Mr. Lott also points out that the president’s stimulus package was three times bigger than Canada’s on a per capita basis and that “Obama raised marginal income tax rates while Canada has cut marginal tax rates.”

washingtontimes.com/blog/inside-politics/2011/jun/21/bachmann-cites-canada-economic-role-model/
 
I can point out 2 out-front reasons.

One, we regulate our banks better. That doesn’t actually mean more regulation because we actually have less (read articles by Andrew Coyne here and here). We have 1 regulator for basically the entire financial sector, and banking is a federal matter under the Constitution so there is 1 set of rules that are national. It makes for a more stable banking system, and it makes it really easy that I can go essentially anywhere in the country and find my bank.

Also, our regulator (the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, or OSFI), is concerned with 1 thing and 1 thing only: risk, or probably better put risk aversion. They are not bogged down with secondary concerns. That leads a bit to the second reason…

…Secondly, we’re not as stupid when it comes to housing. We don’t allow people to write-off mortgage interest on their income tax, because (as I’ve said before) that idea is asinine. It is also not a policy of the government to promote home ownership. The OSFI doesn’t care about how many people own homes. For that matter, neither does the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CHMC), which insures mortgages for the banks. They have a limited scope which again is related to risk (hence when the changed the maximum mortgage period down from 40 to 35 year, and again lowered it to 30 this year, and you must have 5% down).

Actually, when it comes to housing, the government is fairly laissez-faire (especially compared to the US). Sure, a government corporation insures mortgages and hence they do have quite a bit of control over maximum times and minimum down payments, but the policies in place are meant more to ensure stability of the banks over consumers. Banks are totally free to do greater lengths and lower down payments, but they’ll have to get private insurance and it’ll cost more, so the reality is that they don’t.

I guess there’s a third minor reason, and that’s that we’re obsessed with balancing the books. All 3 national parties (even the left-wing NDP) all promised to turn a surplus in less than 5 years. Maybe it’s another one of our “we’re not like America” things, but we don’t like to see deficits (and the only reason we’ve had one for the past few years is the recession and stimulus spending). Heck, Alberta paid down it’s entire deficit a few years ago (I think they’re back in the red due to low royalties on oil the past few years).
 
I can point out 2 out-front reasons.

One, we regulate our banks better. That doesn’t actually mean more regulation because we actually have less (read articles by Andrew Coyne here and here). We have 1 regulator for basically the entire financial sector, and banking is a federal matter under the Constitution so there is 1 set of rules that are national. It makes for a more stable banking system, and it makes it really easy that I can go essentially anywhere in the country and find my bank.

Also, our regulator (the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, or OSFI), is concerned with 1 thing and 1 thing only: risk, or probably better put risk aversion. They are not bogged down with secondary concerns. That leads a bit to the second reason…

…Secondly, we’re not as stupid when it comes to housing. We don’t allow people to write-off mortgage interest on their income tax, because (as I’ve said before) that idea is asinine. It is also not a policy of the government to promote home ownership. The OSFI doesn’t care about how many people own homes. For that matter, neither does the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CHMC), which insures mortgages for the banks. They have a limited scope which again is related to risk (hence when the changed the maximum mortgage period down from 40 to 35 year, and again lowered it to 30 this year, and you must have 5% down).

Actually, when it comes to housing, the government is fairly laissez-faire (especially compared to the US). Sure, a government corporation insures mortgages and hence they do have quite a bit of control over maximum times and minimum down payments, but the policies in place are meant more to ensure stability of the banks over consumers. Banks are totally free to do greater lengths and lower down payments, but they’ll have to get private insurance and it’ll cost more, so the reality is that they don’t.

I guess there’s a third minor reason, and that’s that we’re obsessed with balancing the books. All 3 national parties (even the left-wing NDP) all promised to turn a surplus in less than 5 years. Maybe it’s another one of our “we’re not like America” things, but we don’t like to see deficits (and the only reason we’ve had one for the past few years is the recession and stimulus spending). Heck, Alberta paid down it’s entire deficit a few years ago (I think they’re back in the red due to low royalties on oil the past few years).
👍

Couldn’t have said it better myself
 
I can point out 2 out-front reasons.

One, we regulate our banks better. That doesn’t actually mean more regulation because we actually have less (read articles by Andrew Coyne here and here). We have 1 regulator for basically the entire financial sector, and banking is a federal matter under the Constitution so there is 1 set of rules that are national. It makes for a more stable banking system, and it makes it really easy that I can go essentially anywhere in the country and find my bank.

Also, our regulator (the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, or OSFI), is concerned with 1 thing and 1 thing only: risk, or probably better put risk aversion. They are not bogged down with secondary concerns. That leads a bit to the second reason…

…Secondly, we’re not as stupid when it comes to housing. We don’t allow people to write-off mortgage interest on their income tax, because (as I’ve said before) that idea is asinine. It is also not a policy of the government to promote home ownership. The OSFI doesn’t care about how many people own homes. For that matter, neither does the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CHMC), which insures mortgages for the banks. They have a limited scope which again is related to risk (hence when the changed the maximum mortgage period down from 40 to 35 year, and again lowered it to 30 this year, and you must have 5% down).

Actually, when it comes to housing, the government is fairly laissez-faire (especially compared to the US). Sure, a government corporation insures mortgages and hence they do have quite a bit of control over maximum times and minimum down payments, but the policies in place are meant more to ensure stability of the banks over consumers. Banks are totally free to do greater lengths and lower down payments, but they’ll have to get private insurance and it’ll cost more, so the reality is that they don’t.

I guess there’s a third minor reason, and that’s that we’re obsessed with balancing the books. All 3 national parties (even the left-wing NDP) all promised to turn a surplus in less than 5 years. Maybe it’s another one of our “we’re not like America” things, but we don’t like to see deficits (and the only reason we’ve had one for the past few years is the recession and stimulus spending). Heck, Alberta paid down it’s entire deficit a few years ago (I think they’re back in the red due to low royalties on oil the past few years).
:thumbsup:Are you an economist or a banker?
 
:thumbsup:Are you an economist or a banker?
Neither actually. I just pay attention to the news and have been an on-again-off-again political junkie for a long time.

I should point out that a lot of the points I took from the columns by Andrew Coyne (he’s a columnist for Macleans magazine who I agree with 3/4 of the time and think he’s out to lunch the other 1/4 of the time :p). It’s really about knowing who does good in-depth analysis’.

Neither of these things I really knew before reading them. I didn’t know what sort of regulations our banks had (I honestly thought we had more than the US), and I didn’t know until the last few years that owning a house is such an “official” value in the US. Sure, people are encouraged to own homes here, but it’s not really pushed, and you’ll always hear advice like “look for something you can afford” or “try to save for a downpayment”. I’m in university, and you do hear people talking about getting homes, but it’s not a short-term goal for anyone (usually finding a job/career is the #1 goal, and some others decide to take some time off for a while first).
 
Neither actually. I just pay attention to the news and have been an on-again-off-again political junkie for a long time.

I should point out that a lot of the points I took from the columns by Andrew Coyne (he’s a columnist for Macleans magazine who I agree with 3/4 of the time and think he’s out to lunch the other 1/4 of the time :p). It’s really about knowing who does good in-depth analysis’.

Neither of these things I really knew before reading them. I didn’t know what sort of regulations our banks had (I honestly thought we had more than the US), and I didn’t know until the last few years that owning a house is such an “official” value in the US. Sure, people are encouraged to own homes here, but it’s not really pushed, and you’ll always hear advice like “look for something you can afford” or “try to save for a downpayment”. I’m in university, and you do hear people talking about getting homes, but it’s not a short-term goal for anyone (usually finding a job/career is the #1 goal, and some others decide to take some time off for a while first).
When Coyne is on he’s REALLY on other times I think his evil twin writes his stuff.I am dee-lighted that MacLean’s is kinda staggering to the right.
 
Neither actually. I just pay attention to the news and have been an on-again-off-again political junkie for a long time.

I should point out that a lot of the points I took from the columns by Andrew Coyne (he’s a columnist for Macleans magazine who I agree with 3/4 of the time and think he’s out to lunch the other 1/4 of the time :p). It’s really about knowing who does good in-depth analysis’.

Neither of these things I really knew before reading them. I didn’t know what sort of regulations our banks had (I honestly thought we had more than the US), and I didn’t know until the last few years that owning a house is such an “official” value in the US. Sure, people are encouraged to own homes here, but it’s not really pushed, and you’ll always hear advice like “look for something you can afford” or “try to save for a downpayment”. I’m in university, and you do hear people talking about getting homes, but it’s not a short-term goal for anyone (usually finding a job/career is the #1 goal, and some others decide to take some time off for a while first).
You hear people give that advice in the US as well.

Just not from American liberals. They act like we should all pretend we were born with a government issued silver spoon in our mouth. Some of them even advocate making home ownership a constitutional right.
 
A home is the biggest investment that most people will ever make.They slave for 25-30 years and then it is theirs.

Some wing nut leftwing pinko in Canada proposed a special “Wealth Tax” on home owners as it wasn’t fair that industrious people should own property while others could not(because they weren’t willing to bust their hump)

…Over the time they paid the bank back 2.5 times what they originally paid for it.They forgo vacations and fripperies and work their butts off and scramble if they get laid off.Usually it requires the husband and wife both to be working and can’t spend enough time with their kids.

The government-that’s YOU and ME don’t owe anybody anything.This culture of entitlement world wide has caused financial disaster-look at Europe.People have to be self-sufficient,study hard in school,work at ANYTHING till they can move up or create their own business and stop expecting the Nanny State to take care of everything.That is a sure way to lose your freedom and that’s the way the pinksters want it.LESS government-NO social engineering and keep your danged hand out of my pocket.
 
When Coyne is on he’s REALLY on other times I think his evil twin writes his stuff.I am dee-lighted that MacLean’s is kinda staggering to the right.
True that! Sometimes I wonder about the stuff Coyne writes.

I like the direction of Macleans too. I guess we’d call it Conservative for Canada.
 
I think that being taken to Kangaroo HRC Court by a bunch of Muslims who were unhappy with an article written in a magazine and were demanding eight pages(Free mind you)of rebuttal woke a lot of them up.Mark Steyn stiffened a lot of spines.He and Ezra Levant are my heroes.If i was rich I would have a giant statue of Ezra erected sort of like Brock’s monument right in front of the CHRC offices on land that I would purchase with his finger pointing at the building.
 
I think that being taken to Kangaroo HRC Court by a bunch of Muslims who were unhappy with an article written in a magazine and were demanding eight pages(Free mind you)of rebuttal woke a lot of them up.Mark Steyn stiffened a lot of spines.He and Ezra Levant are my heroes.If i was rich I would have a giant statue of Ezra erected sort of like Brock’s monument right in front of the CHRC offices on land that I would purchase with his finger pointing at the building.
I really wish Mark Steyn would write more.
 
I can point out 2 out-front reasons.

One, we regulate our banks better. That doesn’t actually mean more regulation because we actually have less (read articles by Andrew Coyne here and here). We have 1 regulator for basically the entire financial sector, and banking is a federal matter under the Constitution so there is 1 set of rules that are national. It makes for a more stable banking system, and it makes it really easy that I can go essentially anywhere in the country and find my bank.

Also, our regulator (the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, or OSFI), is concerned with 1 thing and 1 thing only: risk, or probably better put risk aversion. They are not bogged down with secondary concerns. That leads a bit to the second reason…

…Secondly, we’re not as stupid when it comes to housing. We don’t allow people to write-off mortgage interest on their income tax, because (as I’ve said before) that idea is asinine. It is also not a policy of the government to promote home ownership. The OSFI doesn’t care about how many people own homes. For that matter, neither does the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CHMC), which insures mortgages for the banks. They have a limited scope which again is related to risk (hence when the changed the maximum mortgage period down from 40 to 35 year, and again lowered it to 30 this year, and you must have 5% down).

Actually, when it comes to housing, the government is fairly laissez-faire (especially compared to the US). Sure, a government corporation insures mortgages and hence they do have quite a bit of control over maximum times and minimum down payments, but the policies in place are meant more to ensure stability of the banks over consumers. Banks are totally free to do greater lengths and lower down payments, but they’ll have to get private insurance and it’ll cost more, so the reality is that they don’t.

I guess there’s a third minor reason, and that’s that we’re obsessed with balancing the books. All 3 national parties (even the left-wing NDP) all promised to turn a surplus in less than 5 years. Maybe it’s another one of our “we’re not like America” things, but we don’t like to see deficits (and the only reason we’ve had one for the past few years is the recession and stimulus spending). Heck, Alberta paid down it’s entire deficit a few years ago (I think they’re back in the red due to low royalties on oil the past few years).
Excellent post. Let me add my own 👍 to the ones of others who have done so already.
 
Why would you EVER want to pay your mortgage off when the interest paid can be used as a tax deduction?Isn’t that why many people refinance their house?
 
Why would you EVER want to pay your mortgage off when the interest paid can be used as a tax deduction?Isn’t that why many people refinance their house?
That was my point about why it’s a stupid idea. It doesn’t encourage home ownership, it encourages people to hang onto debt (which is bad, you should only encourage people to take on debt when they have a suitable plan for paying it off in a reasonable amount of time. 30 years isn’t even reasonable).

It makes no sense in terms of economics. If you wanted to have something, have a credit that kicks in as a bonus for paying off a mortgage or something (I would disagree with that too). Don’t have something that encourages people to hold onto debt indefinitely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top