Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
1holycatholic:
You’re flailing about like a just caught fish tossed onto a hot pier.

Your criteria:
What on earth are you talking about? Are seriously implying that because there are no Church documents condemning support for deregulating the insurtance industry, that to oppose deregulating the insurance industry is against Chutch teaching?

It was you who said that on cannot possibly be a democrat and a Catholic, not even if they were perfectly pro-life, basically because of guilt by association. Ok, so what’s a Catholic to do, who disagrees with some Republican policies (I never said they disagree with them because the Church told them to, you just assumed I did for some reason). Well can they be a Republican? According to you, apparently not, because even to disagree with other Republican policies is against Church teaching. Even if a pro gun-control, pro healthcare reform, pro-realist foreign policy Catholic did run for office as a Republican *because *he was pro-life and put that first, you and all the others would just call him a RINO and toss him out anyway.

The only logical option you leave me to deduce from this, is that it isn’t just voting for pro-choice candidates that is against Church teacching, it is the very act of being ideologically opposed to other Republican party policies is somehow against Church teaching. I have to force myself to believe that the Department of Education should be abolished and that everyone should be allowed to carry an AK-47 with them wherever they go, or I’m just not a real Catholic.

I have a few more important things to do right now, so I think I’m done listening to this asininity.
 
What on earth are you talking about? Are seriously implying that because there are no Church documents condemning support for deregulating the insurtance industry, that to oppose deregulating the insurance industry is against Chutch teaching?

It was you who said that on cannot possibly be a democrat and a Catholic, not even if they were perfectly pro-life, basically because of guilt by association. Ok, so what’s a Catholic to do, who disagrees with some Republican policies (I never said they disagree with them because the Church told them to, you just assumed I did for some reason). Well can they be a Republican? According to you, apparently not, because even to disagree with other Republican policies is against Church teaching. Even if a pro gun-control, pro healthcare reform, pro-realist foreign policy Catholic did run for office as a Republican *because *he was pro-life and put that first, you and all the others would just call him a RINO and toss him out anyway.

The only logical option you leave me to deduce from this, is that it isn’t just voting for pro-choice candidates that is against Church teacching, it is the very act of being ideologically opposed to other Republican party policies is somehow against Church teaching. I have to force myself to believe that the Department of Education should be abolished and that everyone should be allowed to carry an AK-47 with them wherever they go, or I’m just not a real Catholic.

I have a few more important things to do right now, so I think I’m done listening to this asininity.
What you can deduce is the Church is neutral on these issues As Catholics we are free to form or own opinion about them. The same is not true for abortion
 
What on earth are you talking about? Are seriously implying that because there are no Church documents condemning support for deregulating the insurtance industry, that to oppose deregulating the insurance industry is against Chutch teaching?

It was you who said that on cannot possibly be a democrat and a Catholic, not even if they were perfectly pro-life, basically because of guilt by association. Ok, so what’s a Catholic to do, who disagrees with some Republican policies (I never said they disagree with them because the Church told them to, you just assumed I did for some reason). Well can they be a Republican? According to you, apparently not, because even to disagree with other Republican policies is against Church teaching. Even if a pro gun-control, pro healthcare reform, pro-realist foreign policy Catholic did run for office as a Republican *because *he was pro-life and put that first, you and all the others would just call him a RINO and toss him out anyway.

The only logical option you leave me to deduce from this, is that it isn’t just voting for pro-choice candidates that is against Church teacching, it is the very act of being ideologically opposed to other Republican party policies is somehow against Church teaching. I have to force myself to believe that the Department of Education should be abolished and that everyone should be allowed to carry an AK-47 with them wherever they go, or I’m just not a real Catholic.

I have a few more important things to do right now, so I think I’m done listening to this asininity.
Most of the stated positions of the Democratic party are explicitly contrary to the teaching of the Catholic Church. It is not possible to exonerate the intrinsically evil positions of the Democratic party.

I never said you have to be a Republican, that’s your false dilemma. A faithful Catholic can’t support the Democratic party in good conscience.
 
I guess so. I can handle the argument that abortion outweighs other issues. But when people start arguing this nonsense about how Republican economic policy is reflected in Church teaching, I don’t know whether to laugh or cry, or both.

And what’s more, you can’t even be a dissenting Republican! Because the second you question a particular Republican party policy, estesbob will come on and call you babykiller. Does this attitude sway Catholics to support “the party of life?” Absolutely not. I’m a moderate, but after a little while on these threads I feel tempted to become a democratic socialist just to get as far away from the extreme right as possible. But if it gives some people a chance to be self-righteous, then I guess that’s what matters.

I’d thank God that I’m pessimistic enough that I don’t even vote, and so it’s not such a dilemma for me, but I’ve already been told once on these boards that even not voting is enough to get me sent to hell.
That’s why I don’t respond to certain posters anymore. I’d rather not be someone’s entertainment for the day.
 
I’d thank God that I’m pessimistic enough that I don’t even vote, and so it’s not such a dilemma for me, but I’ve already been told once on these boards that even not voting is enough to get me sent to hell.
Not voting is contrary to what the Church teaches. 🤷

[CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH

DOCTRINAL NOTE
on some questions regarding
The Participation of Catholics in Political Life](http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/c...s/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20021124_politica_en.html)
…
By fulfilling their civic duties, «guided by a Christian conscience»,[7] in conformity with its values, the lay faithful exercise their proper task of infusing the temporal order with Christian values, all the while respecting the nature and rightful autonomy of that order,[8] and cooperating with other citizens according to their particular competence and responsibility.[9] The consequence of this fundamental teaching of the Second Vatican Council is that «the lay faithful are never to relinquish their participation in ‘public life’, that is, in the many different economic, social, legislative, administrative and cultural areas, which are intended to promote organically and institutionally the common good».[10] This would include the promotion and defence of goods such as public order and peace, freedom and equality, respect for human life and for the environment, justice and solidarity.
…
 
What on earth are you talking about? Are seriously implying that because there are no Church documents condemning support for deregulating the insurtance industry, that to oppose deregulating the insurance industry is against Chutch teaching?

It was you who said that on cannot possibly be a democrat and a Catholic, not even if they were perfectly pro-life, basically because of guilt by association. Ok, so what’s a Catholic to do, who disagrees with some Republican policies (I never said they disagree with them because the Church told them to, you just assumed I did for some reason). Well can they be a Republican? According to you, apparently not, because even to disagree with other Republican policies is against Church teaching. Even if a pro gun-control, pro healthcare reform, pro-realist foreign policy Catholic did run for office as a Republican *because *he was pro-life and put that first, you and all the others would just call him a RINO and toss him out anyway.
Yep. It’s not the pro-life that makes a Republican, it’s the core ideology. The core ideology has nothing to do whatsoever, in any manner, way, shape or form with pro-life or any other social/moral issue. One can be a Republican in good standing and be totally pro-abortion, pro-gay “marriage”, pro-stem-cells, pro-cloning and pro-euthanasia just so long as they adhere to the core ideology of the Republican party: socialism for the corporations/rich and bootstraps for the poor/middle class.

I wonder what people here would do with such a hypothetical Republican vs. an ordinary run of the mill Democrat. I have my thoughts about that…:hmmm:
The only logical option you leave me to deduce from this, is that it isn’t just voting for pro-choice candidates that is against Church teacching, it is the very act of being ideologically opposed to other Republican party policies is somehow against Church teaching. I have to force myself to believe that the Department of Education should be abolished and that everyone should be allowed to carry an AK-47 with them wherever they go, or I’m just not a real Catholic.
This would seem to be the case…

Remember, we must all vote in lockstep with the :bowdown2: One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Republican Party :bowdown2: without question or hesitation or we are not good Catholics and will burn in hell for our insolence. :rolleyes:
 
40.png
1holycatholic:
Not voting is contrary to what the Church teaches.
My conscious (Christian I think it is, though I’m certainly not perfect, so I won’t claim it is perfectly so) is precisely one of the things that deters me from voting; I feel that the Republicans are quite selective about their application of Christian principle and ignore them entirely on some issues, so they’re not a very good alternative to the Democrats. So I don’t see how that’s against Church teaching, certainly not anything in the paragraph you quote. Nothing in that states or implies that not voting for conscientious reasons is against Church teaching. I can promote “goods such as public order and peace, freedom and equality, respect for human life and for the environment, justice and solidarity” where options are in accord with my conscience (I was not entirely accurate to say that I never vote; I’ve voted in a local election and voted for whoever ran against my congressman last election; in national elections, again, I abstain).

But, if you choose to imbue your own political obsessions into you interpretation of Church teaching and tell me that I absolutely positively must vote Republican in every election, I can’t even abstain from voting, or I’m damned or whatever, then fine. You’re quite wrong, but fine. I may criticize Republican policies but at least I don’t condemn voters who support them. Now I know not to expect the same courtesy in return.
40.png
LCMS_No_More:
This would seem to be the case…

Remember, we must all vote in lockstep with the One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Republican Party without question or hesitation or we are not good Catholics and will burn in hell for our insolence.
I’m still wondering when we Americans are ever going to pull our heads out of our ***** and change to an open list multi-party system. Of course, that would mean admitting that the Europeans got something right. And I guess Americans are just comfortable keeping their heads right where they are.

Given that my father is an ultra-conservative and probably an atheist or agnostic, my mother is liberal and devout Church-going Catholic and my brother is an agnostic libertarian, I guess I don’t have the luxury of being able to share the utter antipathy some people have toward everyone outside their own little niche, because I’d have to disown my whole family. At any rate, I’d be an atheist and thoroughly pro-choice if it weren’t for my left wing mother, so I can hardly share in the sentiment of these forums.
 
BUT none of what you mention are tenants of the Church and a catholic in good conscience can support everything you oppose. Of course what you mention bear little or no realtionship to what the Party actaully stands for but even if they were true a Catholic could support them.

If you beleieve that the only way you can participate in politics is to support abortion by your vote then yes, you should stay the hell out of politics.
Really? The Church is silent about capitalism? I believe you are mistaken. From the Catechism of the Catholic Church 2425:
She has also refused to accept ‘capitalism,’ individualism, and the absolute primacy of law of the marketplace over human labor…regulating [the economy] solely by the law of the marketplace fails social justice, for “there are many human needs which cannot be satisfied by the market.” Reasonable regulation of the marketplace…is to be commended.
 
Really? The Church is silent about capitalism? I believe you are mistaken. From the Catechism of the Catholic Church 2425:
Uh when did I say the Church was silent on capitalism? And where does the Republican party call for no regulation of Capitalism?
 
Uh when did I say the Church was silent on capitalism? And where does the Republican party call for no regulation of Capitalism?
It has been the historic position of the Republican party that has called for dergulation of industry and has always opposed labor rights.
 
It has been the historic position of the Republican party that has called for dergulation of industry and has always opposed labor rights.
In your opinion in my opinion the Republican party has been opposed only to over regulation and believes a man has just as much right to not join a union as he does to join one But the point is the Church does not endorse either of our opinions. The same can not be said for the Democrat Party’s allegiance to the culture of death
 
In your opinion in my opinion the Republican party has been opposed only to over regulation and believes a man has just as much right to not join a union as he does to join one But the point is the Church does not endorse either of our opinions. The same can not be said for the Democrat Party’s allegiance to the culture of death
The history of the Republican Party pre-exists Reagan. The Republicans fought against the legalization of unions since and for the interest of business since its inception.
 
The history of the Republican Party pre-exists Reagan. The Republicans fought against the legalization of unions since and for the interest of business since its inception.
In your opinion. An opinion the Church neither endorses or opposes. However the Prohibition on directly or indirectly. Supporting an abortion is not an opinion.
 
In your opinion. An opinion the Church neither endorses or opposes. However the Prohibition on directly or indirectly. Supporting an abortion is not an opinion.
It is a fact that the Republican party has historically opposed labor rights. It is opinion based on historical fact, and not a mere emotional response.
 
In your opinion. An opinion the Church neither endorses or opposes. However the Prohibition on directly or indirectly. Supporting an abortion is not an opinion.
The fact that the Church has not elucidated a conclusive position on a particular issue does not mean that all positions on that issue are equally valid or equally in keeping with a Christian worldview. The fact that the Church has not specifically condemned, say, the general advocacy of a position by the Republicans does not mean that one could not cite particular examples of Republican policies that are, in fact, against Church teaching. Just because not all issues are as “simple” as abortion does not mean that all opinions are equally valid and equally in keeping with Catholic teaching.
 
It is a fact that the Republican party has historically opposed labor rights. It is opinion based on historical fact, and not a mere emotional response.
They have opposed your opinion of what Labor rights are. Even if what you say is correct it would not be a proportionate reason for a Catholic to vote for a pro-abortion canidate I know it is necessary for Catholic Democrats to demonize the Republican party beyond recognition. To not do so would force them to come face to face with tha abject evil they support
 
It has been the historic position of the Republican party that has called for dergulation of industry and has always opposed labor rights.
Jimmy Carter & Ted Kennedy deregulated the airline industry in 1978.

I had no idea they were Republicans.
 
They have opposed your opinion of what Labor rights are. Even if what you say is correct it would not be a proportionate reason for a Catholic to vote for a pro-abortion canidate I know it is necessary for Catholic Democrats to demonize the Republican party beyond recognition. To not do so would force them to come face to face with tha abject evil they support
Do not put words in my mouth. It is uncharitable. I am 100% pro-life. All I have been saying is that “Republican” is not equivalent to “Catholic”
 
The fact that the Church has not elucidated a conclusive position on a particular issue does not mean that all positions on that issue are equally valid or equally in keeping with a Christian worldview. The fact that the Church has not specifically condemned, say, the general advocacy of a position by the Republicans does not mean that one could not cite particular examples of Republican policies that are, in fact, against Church teaching. Just because not all issues are as “simple” as abortion does not mean that all opinions are equally valid and equally in keeping with Catholic teaching.
But my opinion is as valid as yours And barring the Church coming down on either side we are left with prudential judgement EXCEPT where the have given us clear guidance-as with abortion
 
They have opposed your opinion of what Labor rights are. Even if what you say is correct it would not be a proportionate reason for a Catholic to vote for a pro-abortion canidate I know it is necessary for Catholic Democrats to demonize the Republican party beyond recognition. To not do so would force them to come face to face with tha abject evil they support
👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top