Wow - come over and work for me 12 hours a day every day then. At your own expense, of course. I’m more than happy to give you absolutely nothing at all in return for your labours, and if you really believe what you say then you’ll be every bit as happy to enter that arrangement with me as any form of paid employment. So go ahead, put your money where your mouth is.
Not correct. You have provided no stimulus to the collection of conflicting impulses you refer to as my free will that would trigger the response you desire. The mere stipulation that nothing I do is originally or finally or responsibly willed by me does
not imply that I do not have desires, nor that one choice will satisfy my desires as well as any other. I suggest only that my power of will is not independent of external and influences which dictate the choice my will is always going to make.
For yourself, you still have not accounted for freedom of the will, nor explained how it can be separated from the million impulses that seem to make up the human faculty of decision while still bearing some relationship to its possessor that somehow renders that person morally responsible for its motions. You merely look at the stimuli, look at the responses, wave your hand at it, and say, “Stimulus and response are not sufficient explanations!” Alright, fine, but you’ve got to argue. You can’t just assert, and you cannot (as I am about to argue) build your entire case
solely on Scriptural passages and Church teaching. The doctrine of free will
must also conform to reason..
He tells us in scripture … that sinners are damned.
Although, you’ll note, only in the hypothetical and the general. We have no guarantee that anyone is actually in Hell other than Satan and his demons. (Which, going back to
your earlier post, renders premise (b) questionable at best - it is not impossible that all men are saved.) But this is largely irrelevant to the question at hand. Back to the point!
Your view is not just contrary to Church teaching - it’s contrary to God’s word.
I don’t see the difference, but fair enough.
You are citing
revelatory claim here (Scripture, teaching, tradition - revealed directly by God). I accept those claims, but my problem is with an
intellectual claim (deduced from the powers of natural reason). According to the Church, the claims of faith and the claims of reason can never contradict. My problem is that there is a – to me – clear contradiction between faith and reason. I need to
reconcile the claims.
Citing more and more and more Bible quotes isn’t going to help. All it does is make clearer the divide between my faith and my intellect. I need an
intellectual proof of free will – an argument from pure reason.
This, of course, is why I spend so much time reading Aquinas.
Incidentally, I wasn’t going to bring this up, because I thought I was bringing this conversation to a graceful end in my last post… but I think you need to
seriously reread some Catholic thought on predestination, starting with St. Thomas at I.Q23.A3. If we don’t preach what you term “negative predestination,” we come awfully close. Some are predestined to heaven by a gift of positive grace which allows them to respond to God’s call; from others, that grace is deliberately withheld, sealing the fates of these unfortunate “reprobates.”
I wouldn’t want to win you over to my view, which we both know is wrong (even if neither of us can explain that without resorting to revelation), but I think you would benefit from a deeper and more complex understanding of a question which, frankly, has vexed Catholic thinkers from Augustine to Molina.
You do - pray to God as hard as you can for enlightenment and understanding. And until then, recognise that your conscience is severely malformed and work as well as pray for understanding.
Haven’t I said several times that I do this already?
Honestly,
LilyM, I know you from around the threads and I like you, but it feels like you’re freaking out a little bit here. As good Catholics, we can and should entertain – and hopefully defeat! – objections to our religious claims, as part of the great Catholic intellectual project. Just look at the
Summa, where Thomas encountered, absorbed, wrestled with, and ultimately dispatched thousands and thousands of objections just like the one I have. I’m not exiting the Church, I’m not calling for the Church to accept my argument, I’m just trying to figure it out. So calm the heck down, yeah?
Smiles and all that!
