Believe everything or get out

  • Thread starter Thread starter GrandeChartreus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you. But actually, I’m not looking for a church at all, much less one that conforms to any particular beliefs. I simply don’t believe the claims that the Catholic Church makes for itself.
Hi TedDC,
May I respectfully point out that the Catholic Church does not trade in claims which it “makes for itself”. It teaches us the ways to Salvation.
I have discussed similar views of the Church with non-believers and each time my response is the same: you must be fully conversant with the rudiments of Catholicism in order to understand the reasoning behind it’s precepts. Such understanding leads to joyous celebration. I do not state that in a triumphalist manner.
I truly believe in the power of the Holy Spirit to guide us all.
God Bless,
Colmcille.
 
There is a form of “contraception” which the Church has no problem with. It’s called abstinence, and it’s nearly 100% effective. And there’s only been one exception, which won’t be repeated again.

So that’s a perfectly valid option.
 
:banghead:

This image should come to mind every time you take up argument on this subject.

The teaching will not change.

That said, why would you believe your postion on the subject to be the correct one?

First, why do you believe that there is some group of Catholics out there that for some unknown reason religiously follows the churches teaching on contraception but ignores its teachings on abortion?

In any case, for your hypothesis to be proven correct, you would expect that there would be a dramatically higher abortion rate [and/or unwanted pregnancy rate] among Catholics than non-Catholics [since the teaching would presumably only be followed by Catholics.]

In a 2008 study, where non-believers constituted only 17.3% of the respondents they accounted for 27.5% of all abortions. In the same study Catholic women accounted for 26.9% of the population and 28.1% of all abortions.

Though disapointing statistics in all regards, does the data support your conclusion?

Chuck
I am not for abortion but believe that this will not be reduced until contraception is promoted.
 
Guarantee you, even if you put identical twins who’ve been brought up as similarly as possible in the same situation, and are as alike as possible in every other way too, they won’t necessarily react the same. They at least at times will make different choices and react in different ways to the same stimuli.
And what accounts for this? It is, obviously, impossible to raise two twins exactly the same, but, if you did, you would see even less deviation from one another. If they had exactly the same interior life as well – the same graces, the same crosses, the same events in the intellect, the same random flukes of interior matter – then, I suggest, there would be no deviation at all. Your example of identical twins does not support the position that human autonomy (or independence, if you like) exists. If only shows that no two people have ever reacted to identical internal and external stimuli.

Explaining away differences in action with a mysterious, unaccountable power called “freedom,” whose mechanism is unknowable and whose relationship to the human to which it is attached is tenuous at best (since “freedom” is being added into the model as an independent entity with no relationship to the individual’s identity, intellect, experiences, talents, memories, gifts, habits, or failings, but as some separate faculty divorced from the person it empowers), seems like a sizable cheat. Especially when there are stimuli that can account for the differences in action quite a bit more completely and simply.
Just because God CAN do anything and everything doesn’t mean He DOES do everything or anything - creatures do act on their own!
Well, for me, there’s the rub: I don’t see that happening, and I can’t even conceive how free action would be possible in a universe where we are not each God.
Of course you DO believe that we are responsible for our actions - to say otherwise is totally hypocritical. I’m sure if you worked for 8 hours digging a ditch for your city council you’d demand just pay for it and wouldn’t say ‘oh well, God did it, not me, so don’t pay me!’ So you of course believe that you are sufficiently responsible for that work to deserve payment for it!
Actually, no, my sense is that I would have not have earned that money. My sense is also that criminals have not earned their punishments.

Now, I know that this sense of my conscience is contrary to Church teaching. More importantly, I trust the Church’s teaching more than I trust my individual sense of the question. So I willingly submit to the Church’s teaching on free will… but I have never understood it.

Thanks for the attempted explanation, though!
 
Wowbagger;7083377 said:

have earned that money. My sense is also that criminals have not earned their punishments.

Wow - come over and work for me 12 hours a day every day then. At your own expense, of course. I’m more than happy to give you absolutely nothing at all in return for your labours, and if you really believe what you say then you’ll be every bit as happy to enter that arrangement with me as any form of paid employment. So go ahead, put your money where your mouth is.

Your view is not just contrary to Church teaching - it’s contrary to God’s word. He tells us in scripture ‘the labourer is worthy of his hire’ and it tells us that sinners are damned.

Someone who is colour blind and cannot see green, for example, has no recourse, at least not until science figures out a way to eliminate the physical defect. You do - pray to God as hard as you can for enlightenment and understanding. And until then, recognise that your conscience is severely malformed and work as well as pray for understanding.
 
Good evening everyone,

I am sorry to disturb you on this wonderful night but I have a question with regards to arguments and divergent opinions inside the Church.

There are some things that I don’t really like in how the Church is heading right now. I have been raised in a christian household where it was important to say what you think. Arguments have to be rational, founded on logic, reason and (most important) God’s message of love and understanding.

I believe that I am a devout Christian. I pray daily, rosary and the liturgy of the hours, go to mass etc … I am a strong believer in almost everything the Church says.

Nevertheless, I have some issues with the Church policy on contraception. I am not for abortion but believe that this will not be reduced until contraception is promoted.

I sometimes get into discussion with other catholics and often write on my archbishop blog. I take the liberty to argue against some of his post that I find inaccurate or that voluntary forget to mention certain things (like for example he often forget to mention or talk about the the Sex scandals that is hurting our Chuch in Canada and he often omits this as a cause to why our Church is emptying itself in Canada … he often accuse the secularist as being the cause but forget that our Church has it’s part of the blame … ).

I always try to write in a thoughtful manner to people … stating my argument agreeing and opposing some posts etc …

I often get people to emotionally respond that I should quit the Church … I don’t like that and I feel that my faith threatened every time someone say that to me.

Many people in our Church (past and present) agreed / opposed and proposed certain aspects about the Church. I feel this is normal (and important) in a living and breathing institution.

As such is it normal for someone to be strong opinionated inside the Church ? Should I leave the Church because I believe we are not heading the right way on certain issues ?

Thank you for your help.
Essentially what you’re saying is that generally you believe in most of the Church’s teachings, but disagree with a few areas. Like you I disagree with the contraceptive ruling (I’m still waiting for the pro-contraceptive people to tell me what to tell the Chinese what their policy should be on population growth, bearing in mind we’d need four planet earths for everyone to have the same lifestyle as American citizens, and that includes conservative American Catholics, if we allow for their environmental “footprint”).

But you don’t leave the Church because there’s a few who can’t see outside the box and who state we must slavishly follow the Church’s rulings. The Moslems say exactly the same thing, and for the same reason - they think they can’t be wrong. I’ve seen the same attitude at work in the Presbyterian Church, due to their “infallible” Election. I know of a certain pastor who used lies and conspiracy leading to stress breakdown, to get rid of around eight other Presbyterian pastors because they didn’t have quite the same “infallible” opinion he did.

Hang in there, and reserve the right to think for yourself. God gave you a brain for a reason. But stay in the Catholic Church. It is, after all, “closest” to the truth.
 
Wow - come over and work for me 12 hours a day every day then. At your own expense, of course. I’m more than happy to give you absolutely nothing at all in return for your labours, and if you really believe what you say then you’ll be every bit as happy to enter that arrangement with me as any form of paid employment. So go ahead, put your money where your mouth is.
This analogy does not work. We are talking about the existence of moral responsibility, which is only possible if we have libertarian free will. Moral responsibility allows for us evaluate an individual, and see how well he lived up to the truth, to what extent he fulfilled his responsibility. So likely some individuals will choose good, and others will choose evil.

So the moral actions we make our objective, it doesn’t matter how we feel about them, they either are right or they are wrong.

But i don’t believe we really have this free will which makes this determination between good and evil, That doesn’t mean I can’t act. I still know that I need money to pay my bills, and if you offer me a laborious job at no pay, I would refuse, and look for a job that did pay.

If on the other hand you offered me a job that did pay, and i did the work, I would expect you to pay me because that is the arrangement we had. I do work, I get paid. If we have been raised to respect contracts, you will pay me and I will accept that payment. It still could have ultimately been predetermiend, predestined that i woudl work for you and you would pay me, and all of the time up to the day I worked you was society instilling in you the values of paying your workers such. So you see, just the fact that you pay me or don’t pay me, isn’t neccesarily a moral good or bad action, it just is. It could have been otherwise.
40.png
LilyM:
Guarantee you, even if you put identical twins who’ve been brought up as similarly as possible in the same situation, and are as alike as possible in every other way too, they won’t necessarily react the same. They at least at times will make different choices and react in different ways to the same stimuli.
What if instead, the entire universe, all people,all events, up to the end of time, were repeated from the very beginning several hundred of times. A copy will each time be made of every person and every situation, and every freely willed action will have to happen again with each trial. think of the universe and all time, as a computer program, which outputs the results of the number in heaven and the number in hell at the end of time. Will we get the same result every time (the same number in heaven, the same number in hell)?? If not, why is it different??? shouldn’t God have created an iteration of the universe where no one chooses hell??? or did God write human nature such that some would ALWAYS choose hell, even after millions of trials, they still choose the same thing in every iteration. Can we really say they have free will, if they never choose otherwise, it would sure seem they were predestined. And if their choices do change with each iteration again, if God could choose any universe, from the infinite number of possible universes to create, why not create one where everyone eventually makes it to heaven???
 
This analogy does not work. We are talking about the existence of moral responsibility, which is only possible if we have libertarian free will. Moral responsibility allows for us evaluate an individual, and see how well he lived up to the truth, to what extent he fulfilled his responsibility. So likely some individuals will choose good, and others will choose evil.

So the moral actions we make our objective, it doesn’t matter how we feel about them, they either are right or they are wrong.

But i don’t believe we really have this free will which makes this determination between good and evil, That doesn’t mean I can’t act. I still know that I need money to pay my bills, and if you offer me a laborious job at no pay, I would refuse, and look for a job that did pay.
No, because I’d get the money by stealing it. Look, if I really feel that I don’t deserve pay in return for a job and really feel that criminals don’t really deserve punishment for crime, then they’re both morally neutral and stealing is much easier than working (and the risks aren’t all that great compared to the rewards). So why not?
What if instead, the entire universe, all people,all events, up to the end of time, were repeated from the very beginning several hundred of times. A copy will each time be made of every person and every situation, and every freely willed action will have to happen again with each trial. think of the universe and all time, as a computer program, which outputs the results of the number in heaven and the number in hell at the end of time.
Of course it’s nothing like a computer game - a computer is a heartless soulless perfectly rational machine designed to do the same thing every time you push the same keys/buttons.

We’re talking about human (and Godly) action here, which is a different thing altogether. Think of it more like a poker machine where what YOU bring to the situation might always be the same (the same dollar to feed into the machine, and the same arm to pull that lever) but there are still a vast array of potential results that can happen when you do.
 
Not having read all the posts, I’d venture to say that the Catholic Church is never, will never nor should it ever be a democracy. We need to accept all it’s teachings exactly as pronounced and decreed without cherry picking the things we disagree with or those we do a agree with.
Whether it’s contraception, homosexuality, pedophilia within the church or many other issues we may have, for many of us this causes hardships or what we perceive as moral dilemmas yet we are all human and err at times, that’s the beauty of the confessional…and then we fall again until we eventually overcome our sinful nature.
Accept the Catholic Church and all it’s teachings, the alternative is the one of 30,000+ protestant beliefs.
Gerry
 
Wow - come over and work for me 12 hours a day every day then. At your own expense, of course. I’m more than happy to give you absolutely nothing at all in return for your labours, and if you really believe what you say then you’ll be every bit as happy to enter that arrangement with me as any form of paid employment. So go ahead, put your money where your mouth is.
Not correct. You have provided no stimulus to the collection of conflicting impulses you refer to as my free will that would trigger the response you desire. The mere stipulation that nothing I do is originally or finally or responsibly willed by me does not imply that I do not have desires, nor that one choice will satisfy my desires as well as any other. I suggest only that my power of will is not independent of external and influences which dictate the choice my will is always going to make.

For yourself, you still have not accounted for freedom of the will, nor explained how it can be separated from the million impulses that seem to make up the human faculty of decision while still bearing some relationship to its possessor that somehow renders that person morally responsible for its motions. You merely look at the stimuli, look at the responses, wave your hand at it, and say, “Stimulus and response are not sufficient explanations!” Alright, fine, but you’ve got to argue. You can’t just assert, and you cannot (as I am about to argue) build your entire case solely on Scriptural passages and Church teaching. The doctrine of free will must also conform to reason..
He tells us in scripture … that sinners are damned.
Although, you’ll note, only in the hypothetical and the general. We have no guarantee that anyone is actually in Hell other than Satan and his demons. (Which, going back to your earlier post, renders premise (b) questionable at best - it is not impossible that all men are saved.) But this is largely irrelevant to the question at hand. Back to the point!
Your view is not just contrary to Church teaching - it’s contrary to God’s word.
I don’t see the difference, but fair enough.

You are citing revelatory claim here (Scripture, teaching, tradition - revealed directly by God). I accept those claims, but my problem is with an intellectual claim (deduced from the powers of natural reason). According to the Church, the claims of faith and the claims of reason can never contradict. My problem is that there is a – to me – clear contradiction between faith and reason. I need to reconcile the claims.

Citing more and more and more Bible quotes isn’t going to help. All it does is make clearer the divide between my faith and my intellect. I need an intellectual proof of free will – an argument from pure reason.

This, of course, is why I spend so much time reading Aquinas.

Incidentally, I wasn’t going to bring this up, because I thought I was bringing this conversation to a graceful end in my last post… but I think you need to seriously reread some Catholic thought on predestination, starting with St. Thomas at I.Q23.A3. If we don’t preach what you term “negative predestination,” we come awfully close. Some are predestined to heaven by a gift of positive grace which allows them to respond to God’s call; from others, that grace is deliberately withheld, sealing the fates of these unfortunate “reprobates.”

I wouldn’t want to win you over to my view, which we both know is wrong (even if neither of us can explain that without resorting to revelation), but I think you would benefit from a deeper and more complex understanding of a question which, frankly, has vexed Catholic thinkers from Augustine to Molina.
You do - pray to God as hard as you can for enlightenment and understanding. And until then, recognise that your conscience is severely malformed and work as well as pray for understanding.
Haven’t I said several times that I do this already?

Honestly, LilyM, I know you from around the threads and I like you, but it feels like you’re freaking out a little bit here. As good Catholics, we can and should entertain – and hopefully defeat! – objections to our religious claims, as part of the great Catholic intellectual project. Just look at the Summa, where Thomas encountered, absorbed, wrestled with, and ultimately dispatched thousands and thousands of objections just like the one I have. I’m not exiting the Church, I’m not calling for the Church to accept my argument, I’m just trying to figure it out. So calm the heck down, yeah?

Smiles and all that! 🙂 🙂 🙂
 
But you don’t leave the Church because there’s a few who can’t see outside the box and who state we must slavishly follow the Church’s rulings.
Umm… no, it’s true, you don’t leave the Church in these cases. You submit to the Church’s ruling despite your own pathetic, proud conclusions to the contrary, and pray for the enlightenment to eventually understand why you are wrong. This is what I am doing with free will (see my conversation with LilyM above), and this is what all Catholics do.

Someone who doesn’t submit in these cases may be right and may be wrong, but he certainly is not a Catholic – he is the very definition of a Protestant.
 
The older I get the “dummer” I get I guess.

I was sure I knew more than the Chruch on practically everything when I was 20, I thought the Church only had a few things wrong when I was 30, by the time I was 40 I realized that maybe if I disagreed with the Church I was the one that was wrong.

Life would have been so much simpler if I’d figured that out at 20.

Chuck
Umm… no, it’s true, you don’t leave the Church in these cases. You submit to the Church’s ruling despite your own pathetic, proud conclusions to the contrary, and pray for the enlightenment to eventually understand why you are wrong. This is what I am doing with free will (see my conversation with LilyM above), and this is what all Catholics do.

Someone who doesn’t submit in these cases may be right and may be wrong, but he certainly is not a Catholic – he is the very definition of a Protestant.
 
Alright, fine, but you’ve got to argue. You can’t just assert, and you cannot (as I am about to argue) build your entire case solely on Scriptural passages and Church teaching. The doctrine of free will must also conform to reason..
Wait a cotton-pickin’ minute. Nothing about the faith HAS to conform to reason. Certainly nothing about the faith will contradict properly applied reason, but it can and does go beyond it in many instances. A whole bunch of the most central tenets of our faith well and truly exceed any human capacity to completely reason them out.

Hence St Augustine, one of the greatest Catholic minds, said of the doctrine of the Trinity that trying to understand it on a logical level was ultimately as useless as trying to carry the ocean in a bucket.

And hence St Thomas Aquinas, expounding on the mystery of transubstantiation, wrote the beautifully poetic words that we still sing every Holy Thursday:

“Word-made-Flesh, the bread of nature
by His word to Flesh He turns;
wine into His Blood He changes;-
what though sense no change discerns?
Only be the heart in earnest,
faith her lesson quickly learns.
”

In other words ‘learning’ the faith is a matter ultimately of the heart, not the head - and can often be achieved quickly without overreliance on our feeble powers of cogitation. Which is why, towards the end of his life, the same brilliant thinker and writer Aquinas said that all he had ever written was straw.

More to the point, just because YOU can’t reason something doesn’t mean a rational case can’t be and hasn’t been made.

St Thomas did hold, and the Church teaches, that the existence of God (only a tiny part of our faith, but a critical one) can be perceptible to reason. Accordingly, he and other saints have put forth much evidence and many logical proofs on the subject. Yet many many people, very intelligent, don’t apply their reason properly, don’t see or accept the evidence and logical proofs, and so would say that the existence of God is NOT perceptible to reason. Of course it is - it’s just, for whatever reason, not perceptible to the reason of those particular individuals.
You are citing revelatory claim here (Scripture, teaching, tradition - revealed directly by God). I accept those claims, but my problem is with an intellectual claim (deduced from the powers of natural reason). According to the Church, the claims of faith and the claims of reason can never contradict. My problem is that there is a – to me – clear contradiction between faith and reason. I need to reconcile the claims.
See above - you don’t need to reconcile the claims of faith and reason - some of the claims of faith can not be encompassed by the powers of natural reason full stop. Still others will never be deducable by your particular powers of natural reason, with the flaws and blind spots peculiar to your mind (which all thinkers have).
Citing more and more and more Bible quotes isn’t going to help. All it does is make clearer the divide between my faith and my intellect. I need an intellectual proof of free will – an argument from pure reason.
This, of course, is why I spend so much time reading Aquinas.
Who, as I said above, freely acknoweldged the limits, in fact the woeful inadequacy, of those very writings that you’re reading as an explication of the faith! As I said, the aspects of our faith which are capable of being reasoned are but a subset of the whole.

Isn’t there a line in ‘Adoro te Devote’ where Aquinas talks (again speaking of transubstantiation if memory serves) of simply accepting the words of Christ, Truth itself, in regard the Eucharist as true, because all human perception else can conclude wrongly about it? THAT is what I’m asking you to do - adopt the same attitude! ‘Truth Himself speaks truly, or there’s nothing true’.
Haven’t I said several times that I do this already?
Did you? I’m sorry if I’ve missed it. :o
Just look at the Summa, where Thomas encountered, absorbed, wrestled with, and ultimately dispatched thousands and thousands of objections just like the one I have.
Of course he did - so much so that nobody EVER disagrees with him :rolleyes: You’re making far far greater claims for St Thomas, and for the capacities of human reason, than are justified. And still further claims than he ever made for either.
I’m not exiting the Church, I’m not calling for the Church to accept my argument, I’m just trying to figure it out. So calm the heck down, yeah?
You’re trying to carry the ocean in a bucket, is what you’re doing - and I’m telling you to you’re better off not attempting the unachievable.
 
We need to accept all it’s teachings exactly as pronounced and decreed without cherry picking the things we disagree with or those we do a agree with…Accept the Catholic Church and all it’s teachings, the alternative is the one of 30,000+ protestant beliefs.
That’s right, as far as I know. What I have been taught is that Catholics have to assent to and accept fully all of the teachings of the Catholic Church. Catholics are expected to believe and to obey all of the infallible and authoritative teachings of the Roman Catholic Church without any exception.
If someone wants to have a watered down version of Catholicism where you can pick and choose on what to believe as far as contraception or divorce goes, but still want to attend a liturgy similar to a Catholic Mass, you can join the Episcopal Church. They will wecome you there. Of course, you should keep in mind that the RCC does not recognise some of the Sacraments and liturgy of the Episcopal Church although they maintain cordial ecumenical relations with them as is seen from the recent visit of the Pope to England.
 
Umm… no, it’s true, you don’t leave the Church in these cases. You submit to the Church’s ruling despite your own pathetic, proud conclusions to the contrary, and pray for the enlightenment to eventually understand why you are wrong. This is what I am doing with free will (see my conversation with LilyM above), and this is what all Catholics do.

Someone who doesn’t submit in these cases may be right and may be wrong, but he certainly is not a Catholic – he is the very definition of a Protestant.
Maybe because I’m an ex-Protestant I tend to be a bit jaundiced about Church infallibility - Inquiisition, Galileo, massacres of those who resisted the faith in Spanish and Portuguese colonies, the way the church worked hand in hand with generations of South American dictators, the pedophilia cover up, the cruel educational methods used in many Catholic schools (I remember a TV personality, now in his 80’s, quite a nice chap, who with his mates stood outside his Catholic school at the age of 12 and shouted, “That’s it with God!” They’d had enough of the brutality. Mind you I know of an Anglican outfit that was much the same.), the fact most Western Catholics today have smaller families than previously which tells me most of them don’t have much time for the contraceptive pill ruling, the devious way Vatican I was called, the 4th Crusade and the sack of Constantinople, the way one of the Pope Pius’s (?) went around chipping off all the private parts of statues in part of the Vatican, the Pope’s coronation of Napoleon, the way Peter himself nearly caved into the Judaisers, the church’s opposition to “modernism” for a hundred years, the close relations between the Vatican and Franco the butcher, the butchering of the French Huegenots (although they reciprocated in equally brutal fashion at times), the endemic corruption in the church which brought about the Reformation in the first place, the Borgia Popes, the Anti-Popes, and so on.

When you can explain the Church’s infallibility in the light of all this, then I’ll accept my opinion is pathetic and proud, just as for example your own attitude has an arrogant judgemental aspect to it.
 
Maybe because I’m an ex-Protestant I tend to be a bit jaundiced about Church infallibility - Inquiisition, Galileo, massacres of those who resisted the faith in Spanish and Portuguese colonies, the way the church worked hand in hand with generations of South American dictators, the pedophilia cover up, ---------When you can explain the Church’s infallibility in the light of all this, then I’ll accept my opinion is pathetic and proud, just as for example your own attitude has an arrogant judgemental aspect to it.
I didn’t quote the whole thing for shortness.

Infallibility applies only when the Pope is teaching on faith and morals (or in certain cases, a group of Bishops).

It did not apply to the people who did those things. That is obvious because sins were commited there.
 
I have not read all of the posts here, but some of them are quite bitter. I do pray that you do not leave the Church despite being torn about artificial contraception. I also pray for you and hope you do as well for our Lord to give you the discernment to fully understand and accept the teachings He has given us to live within. They are not easy to follow by any means, but pray for the Holy Spirit to help you as well as others that carry this cross each day. The decision starts with you…not what others are doing regarding abortion. Pray for them, but focus on getting your mindset straight first, which can be done with God alone. I am very sorry to hear that people approach you so negatively on this subject. I understand that it is a very emotional topic, but please do not let anyone persuade you to leave the Church. Oftentimes, people post things on forums in a very inappropriate manner for various reasons, but do not let that get dissuade you from knowing, loving, and following the Magisterium. God Bless you and be with you!
 
In John chapter 6, when Jesus was telling His disciples about eating His flesh and drinking His blood, nobody understood what Jesus was talking about. One group said, “I don’t like this and I don’t understand this, so I’m leaving.” When asked by Jesus if they would also leave, the second group essentially said, “Nope. We don’t understand it, Jesus, and we really don’t even like it, but who else are we going to go to? You have the words of eternal life.”

Jesus gave His authority to the Church. That means the Church now has the words of eternal life. If we don’t understand or agree with the Church, we have two choices, just like those folks in John 6.

If you leave the Catholic Church, who else will you go to? You are really just making yourself the authority. There is no one else that has the words of eternal life.

As for those who struggle with all the “bad stuff” in the Catholic Church, I have this suggestion: never leave Peter because of Judas. We were told to expect wolves among the sheep! Don’t lose heart! Run the race! Fight the good fight! This is about spiritual warfare, folks! Pray for those wolves, but don’t let them run you off or devour you!

Peace.
 
I don’t think the question here is whether or not Jesus is King. The question is whether the Vatican is king. It is a question about whether or not the Church is right about what Jesus wants with respect to contraception. The OP has doubts about whether the Chruch knows the will of God.
Jesus is King…he is also the head of the Church…which happens to be in “The Vatican.” The Church, by the authority Christ gave it, the Church…being the body of which Christ is the head, gives a moral teaching on contraception. The OP as do I, as do you, has free will to accept or reject Christ, His Church in “The Vatican”, and His moral teaching on contraception through his Church. It’s a simple path to choose: Accept or reject, the choice is always ours because God gave us free will.

The world’s way of thinking of contraception is the world’s way. But God’s ways are different than the world’s. The world’s ways don’t work. Contraception has not decreased, STDs (rate higher than ever), out of wedlock births (rate higher than ever), divorce, (very high) or abortions (babies still being sacrificially murdered to the World’s god of “do it my way”).

Choose God, Choose Christ, Choose His Church (in “the Vatican”), choose Life. Obey God, Obey His Church…protestants have that old song “Trust and Obey.” It works better than anything this world has to offer. 😉
 
As good Catholics, we can and should entertain – and hopefully defeat! – objections to our religious claims, as part of the great Catholic intellectual project. Just look at the Summa, where Thomas encountered, absorbed, wrestled with, and ultimately dispatched thousands and thousands of objections just like the one I have. I’m not exiting the Church, I’m not calling for the Church to accept my argument, I’m just trying to figure it out. So calm the heck down, yeah?

Smiles and all that! 🙂 🙂 🙂
My position is that I NEED to resolve this issue in some way intellectually or otherwise (with the heart) or else I cannot proceed with my faith. I am obsessed with this issue as of late and it does not cease to trouble me. I just posted a big post discussing the same issue of free will in another thread here.

forum.catholic.com/showthread.php?p=7092249#post7092249
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top