Beto Proposes "War Tax"

  • Thread starter Thread starter ChuckB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

ChuckB

Guest

I can’t say that I’m a big Beto fan, and I dislike paying taxes as much as the next guy, but I think the concept of a war tax has merit.

Recently I’ve been reading articles about how the U.S. has been at war in Iraq and Afghanistan for over 18 years. While we read/hear about these wars in the news, I would argue that the vast majority of us have not been affected in the least. Rather, it is military members and their families who have shouldered the entire burden. Many have been killed or horribly injured. The lucky ones who make it back alive get to take a break before being sent back again for multiple deployments. Once discharged from service, many of our veterans are often at the mercy of the grossly mismanaged VA, waiting months for badly needed medical care - if they’re lucky. Often it never materializes at all. All the while the rest of us just go about our merry way, blissfully ignorant of what’s really going on - or worse yet, not even caring.

Next in the pain-line is our future generations who are going to burdened with the huge deficits we have accumulated by simply borrowing the money to pay for prosecuting these military misadventures.

While Beto’s proposed tax would be a small start at caring for veterans, I would propose a more aggressive course of action. I would propose a constitutional amendment calling for all wars to be paid for as they are prosecuted - not shifted to future generations. Under my proposal, anyone who is not an active duty member of the military, or the parent, spouse, or child of a military member who is on active duty during a time of war, would pay a war tax. Wars are expensive. So this tax would, out of necessity, be a tax that “stings.” If our political leaders, in their great wisdom (cough, cough), feel that a situation is so grave that it is necessary to send our military to war, then we should all share the burden. We should all feel it.

My guess is that if we are all shouldering a painful part of the burden, we might just wake up and take a bit of interest in what’s really happening. At the same time, while being subjected to the increasing scrutiny of the electorate, our political leaders just might fine-tune their great wisdom a bit and think twice before maneuvering our nation into another seemingly endless war.
 
Okay, so an elderly lady has to pay this tax because O’Rourke imagines that somehow she should. A man who lost a leg in an auto accident that wasn’t his fault, has to pay the tax notwithstanding that his prostheses are expensive, and again, because O’Rourke thinks he’s less deserving than a man who worked on helicopters on a ship in the Persian Gulf.

Likely, he doesn’t have anything quite that stupid in mind. Probably he thinks somehow that will prevent the nation ever going to war.
 
So Beto wants to tax everybody to turn them into peaceniks, not because they have an actual problem with foreign policy but because they don’t want to pay a tax?

Sounds pretty coercive to me.
 
My guess is that if we are all shouldering a painful part of the burden, we might just wake up and take a bit of interest in what’s really happening. At the same time, while being subjected to the increasing scrutiny of the electorate, our political leaders just might fine-tune their great wisdom a bit and think twice before maneuvering our nation into another seemingly endless war.
What’s needed is a nice cold draft to cool off the war fervor. Guaranteed to work. 🙂
 
I’m willing to look at it when:
  1. other taxes intended for a particular function (FICA and others) are protected from being used in the general fund.
  2. the budget is balanced without additional taxes.
 
I think a “War Tax” is a terrible idea. First off, I don’t even think it is constitutional. It is basically a fine for not being in the military. And not well thought out. I mean, do military spouses have to pay a “war tax”? What about their working kids? Most veteran programs apply to the non-serving children too. But most importantly, it further creates two classes of citizens. The military, and everyone else. Our military is already 100% volunteers. Which is cool, but since the implementation of the all-volunteer force we have found that military service runs heavily in family circles. If a parent served, the children are much more likely to serve. The higher in rank the parent, the more likely this is. So we have already developed a kind of sub-class of citizens, and taxing others for not participating just increases that. And yes these families deal with multiple deployments every few years, which sucks. But this proposal is very starship trooper-y “federal service” type stuff. If Beto cared about all Americans sharing the load, he would propose reimplementing the draft. That way all able-bodied male citizens would at least have a dog in the fight. The all-volunteer force allows for a very professional military but also one that most Americans don’t think too much about having in multiple low-intensity wars and so they drag on in perpetuity. The threat of a draft would immediately get people involved and hold politicians much more accountable than they currently are for wars, and it equalizes citizenship instead of elevating one above the other. But that is exactly why Beto isn’t proposing that idea. A draft would be massively more unpopular than a tax.

Also, your idea that a war has to be paid for up front is just not realistic. We could not have fought one single war for this country if it had to be immediately revenue neutral. Not WWII, WWI, Vietnam, Desert Shield/Storm, the Civil War, the American Revolution, none of it. That is just not how the cookie crumbles.
 
Last edited:
They imposed a 10% surtax to pay for the Vietnam War and that put pressure to get out of there fast.
 
ProVobis . . . .
They imposed a 10% surtax to pay for the Vietnam War and that put pressure to get out of there fast.
When did the Democrats 6% Vietnam War tax end?
THIS DAY IN POLITICS

LBJ asks Congress to pass war tax, Jan. 10, 1967​

By ANDREW GLASS

01/10/2019 12:08 AM EST

With some 485,000 American troops in Vietnam — a number that would peak in 1968 at 536,000 — President Lyndon B. Johnson, on this day in 1967, asked Congress in his annual State of the Union message to enact a 6 percent surcharge on personal and corporate income taxes to help finance the Vietnam War for the next two years, or “for as long as the unusual expenditures associated with our efforts continue.”

Congress delayed acting for nearly a year, but ultimately approved the surcharge. U.S. Treasury outlays for Vietnam in fiscal year 1967 came to some $123 billion in current dollars.

The president had to deal with a Congress that was less friendly to him than the one which had been elected in 1964. In the 1966 midterm elections, the Republicans gained 47 House seats. The Democrats also lost three Senate seats. Despite their losses, the Democrats still retained control of both chambers of Congress. . . . .
 
Last edited:
They imposed a 10% surtax to pay for the Vietnam War and that put pressure to get out of there fast.
I could be wrong but I am pretty sure people weren’t protesting the Vietnam War because of taxes.
 
This is like something from Starship Troopers. Totally absurd, nearing fascist. The United States needs to cut its military spending and stop its imperialist activities across the world, not punish most of its population for choosing not to kill civilians in the Middle East.
 
This is like something from Starship Troopers. Totally absurd, nearing fascist. The United States needs to cut its military spending and stop its imperialist activities across the world, not punish most of its population for choosing not to kill civilians in the Middle East.
Let’s remember that fascism is statist socialism. So, I’m not sure how this is fascist.
I think it is a great idea to cut military and extra-constitutional domestic spending. Maybe it is time to be selective about which countries we spend foreign aid on, too. If we send money to a given Central American country and they continue to send their citizens to our border, it seems we should remove the aid and use it at the border.

There is no reason that these countries can’t be as prosperous as Costa Rica. Adopt a limited government that values individual rights and free markets.
 
Well, it certainly didn’t work then. We didn’t get out of Vietnam “fast”.
 
I can’t say that I’m a big Beto fan, and I dislike paying taxes as much as the next guy, but I think the concept of a war tax has merit.
While Beto’s proposed tax would be a small start at caring for veterans, I would propose a more aggressive course of action. I would propose a constitutional amendment calling for all wars to be paid for as they are prosecuted - not shifted to future generations.
Every war the US has been involved in, including the American Revolution, was paid for, at least in part, by borrowing.
 
This is like something from Starship Troopers. Totally absurd, nearing fascist. The United States needs to cut its military spending and stop its imperialist activities across the world, not punish most of its population for choosing not to kill civilians in the Middle East.
Nice little slander you slipped in there. I see you are on the “soldier=murderous war criminal” train. Thanks for that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top