Biblical Reference to the Rapture

  • Thread starter Thread starter PatienceAndLove
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it my fault that the scripture makes you squimish? Are you mocking God’s prophetic word when He is telling us how the numbers pan out?
Your interpretation is what sickens me.

God is not a bigamist; he has only one people and those of us who are left at the tribulation will suffer together, Jew and Gentile alike.
 
Your interpretation is what sickens me.

God is not a bigamist; he has only one people and those of us who are left at the tribulation will suffer together, Jew and Gentile alike.
Does it sicken you because pre-millennialism teaches God will ultimately save hardened Israel from themselves and the satanic plans all nations have coming for Israel?

And while we are talking about being consistent, you say God is not a bigamist with Him only having one people. So why do you differentiate between the left-behind Jews and Gentiles after the tribulation?

Jews and Gentiles are one in Christ.

To sum up in short, the Church is caught up to the Lord before the tribulation. And at the end of the seven years of tribulation, hardened Israel will be saved by Jesus Christ at His second advent to Israel. Then the survivors of the nations are judged as sheep and goats, and the sheep are let into the 1000 year kingdom.
 
Does it sicken you because pre-millennialism teaches God will ultimately save hardened Israel from themselves and the satanic plans all nations have coming for Israel?
Amillennialism and preterism also both hold that this will occur. Albeit with no particular violence and punishment falling on the Jews alone.
And while we are talking about being consistent, you say God is not a bigamist with Him only having one people.
So why do you differentiate between the left-behind Jews and Gentiles after the tribulation?
I don’t.
Jews and Gentiles are one in Christ.
Then why are only the Gentiles supposedly raptured?
 
Lev23 said:
Along with your presumption is the thought that pre-millennialists consider Israel ethnically superior to other nations. Which is NOT the case. Scripture makes that clear. The importance of hardened ethnic Israel is scripturally prophetic and because-

**Romans 11:28-29
…but as far as election is concerned, they are loved on account of the patriarchs, for God’s gifts and his call are irrevocable. **

Israel will be all saved at Jesus’ second coming, and the survivors of the nations will be judged for their treatment of them. Scripture is so clear on this.
What is not clear is that Israel and the nations are separate after Calvary.

[BIBLEDRB]John 3:16[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Gal 3:28[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Col 3:11[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Romans 2:15[/BIBLEDRB]

To be clear, you have three choices:
  1. The Church displaced Israel (replacement theology). You may THINK this is what the Catholic Church teaches, but that is false.
  2. The Church is a continuation of Israel, with Gentiles grated onto the Jewish roots. (Olive Tree theology) This is the Catholic teaching. Please read this, especially the part that describes the Jews as “the people of God of the Old Covenant, which has never been revoked”.
  3. The Church and Israel are separate (dispensationalism). This is what you currently hold to and I advise you to change course, along with Paul:
[BIBLEDRB]Romans 11:7-23[/BIBLEDRB]
 
What is not clear is that Israel and the nations are separate after Calvary.

[BIBLEDRB]John 3:16[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Gal 3:28[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Col 3:11[/BIBLEDRB]
[BIBLEDRB]Romans 2:15[/BIBLEDRB]

To be clear, you have three choices:
  1. The Church displaced Israel (replacement theology). You may THINK this is what the Catholic Church teaches, but that is false.
  2. The Church is a continuation of Israel, with Gentiles grated onto the Jewish roots. (Olive Tree theology) This is the Catholic teaching. Please read this, especially the part that describes the Jews as “the people of God of the Old Covenant, which has never been revoked”.
  3. The Church and Israel are separate (dispensationalism). This is what you currently hold to and I advise you to change course, along with Paul:
[BIBLEDRB]Romans 11:7-23[/BIBLEDRB]
Let me jump in here and say something. I believe that Jesus will come in the clouds at the “rapture” and not touch the earth, and all those, regardless of nationality, if they are saved, that is born again, will be taken away to be with the Lord. He will come again in Great Power and Glory and put His feet down on the Mount of Olives as King. I look forward to His return. PTL. Blessings
 
It seems to me that all this Rapture discussion is rather foolish speculation. Catholic teaching is clear on this: there is no rapture. But even if there was to be a rapture, does it effect what a person needs to do for salvation in the least?
 
Let me jump in here and say something. I believe that Jesus will come in the clouds at the “rapture” and not touch the earth, and all those, regardless of nationality, if they are saved, that is born again, will be taken away to be with the Lord. He will come again in Great Power and Glory and put His feet down on the Mount of Olives as King. I look forward to His return. PTL. Blessings
I don’t see anything in the Scriptures referring to a 1 and a 1/2 Coming or a 3rd Coming, or an inbetween coming. It’s the Second Coming.

Christ will come again only ONCE. Not twice.
 
Does it sicken you because pre-millennialism teaches God will ultimately save hardened Israel from themselves and the satanic plans all nations have coming for Israel?

And while we are talking about being consistent, you say God is not a bigamist with Him only having one people. So why do you differentiate between the left-behind Jews and Gentiles after the tribulation?

Jews and Gentiles are one in Christ.

To sum up in short, the Church is caught up to the Lord before the tribulation. And at the end of the seven years of tribulation, hardened Israel will be saved by Jesus Christ at His second advent to Israel. Then the survivors of the nations are judged as sheep and goats, and the sheep are let into the 1000 year kingdom.
I also find it sickening that you have been tricked into following a False Gospel (the Rapture). Christ comes back only once. Not twice.
 
I also find it sickening that you have been tricked into following a False Gospel (the Rapture). Christ comes back only once. Not twice.
Honestly, its an error, sure. But in reality, it doesn’t do much harm to speculate on the end times. Far more damaging to the evangelical’s soul is their lack of belief in the efficacy of the sacraments and their views that faith alone is sufficient for salvation and that sin doesn’t matter. Those that are doctrines that could lead to condemnation.
 
I don’t see anything in the Scriptures referring to a 1 and a 1/2 Coming or a 3rd Coming, or an inbetween coming. It’s the Second Coming.

Christ will come again only ONCE. Not twice.
I also find it sickening that you have been tricked into following a False Gospel (the Rapture). Christ comes back only once. Not twice.
Yes, there is one more coming of Christ, TO THE EARTH. Jesus’ 1st advent as well as His 2nd advent are to Israel. And yes, for the benefit of all peoples of all nations also. The pre-tribulation rapture is Christ’s catching away of His bride and hardened Israel will go through the last 7 years decreed for them in Daniel 9:24(the 144,000 Israelites are God’s servants, or remnant at that time). This is not “sickening” or a “false gospel”.

If some want to continue to call the pre-tribulation catching away of the Church a half coming, or 3 comings, then you must face the facts and admit amillennialism teaches the same thing.

Here is a link to an example of what I am talking about.

This is from this link-
If we can, lets get down to brass tacks.

By your reading and interpretation of Revelation, are you suggesting Jesus Christ came from heaven in the form of the Roman armies that destroyed the temple and the city?
The basic answer to your question is yes, but brb3 makes a good point. He did not come physically. Coming on a cloud is one of God’s ways of administering justice throughout the Old Testament, through a pagan army (otherwise known as the time of the Gentiles).
Count 'em up. By the critics of the pre-tribulation rapture, this is either 2-1/2 or 3 comings.
 
Yes, there is one more coming of Christ, TO THE EARTH. Jesus’ 1st advent as well as His 2nd advent are to Israel. And yes, for the benefit of all peoples of all nations also. The pre-tribulation rapture is Christ’s catching away of His bride and hardened Israel will go through the last 7 years decreed for them in Daniel 9:24
Again… don’t you see that there is anything wrong with positing that Jesus has two brides, two covenant people, as you are doing?

And there is Paul’s assertion that the People of God are one Body, one Olive Tree, with Hebrew and Gentile branches, both of which will be subject to pruning (suffering). Not two trees.

And Revelation 12 describes “those who keep the testimony of Jesus” suffering under war from the devil after the Tribulation begins… which is not possible if they had been raptured and those who are “left behind” are to be judged by works.
If some want to continue to call the pre-tribulation catching away of the Church a half coming, or 3 comings, then you must face the facts and admit amillennialism teaches the same thing.
Where do you get the idea that the Roman armies who sacked Jerusalem were a “coming” of Jesus Christ? Certainly not from amillennialism.

But anyway…

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 16:26-28[/BIBLEDRB]

Who that was standing there then is still alive today?
 
Again… don’t you see that there is anything wrong with positing that Jesus has two brides, two covenant people, as you are doing?

And there is Paul’s assertion that the People of God are one Body, one Olive Tree, with Hebrew and Gentile branches, both of which will be subject to pruning (suffering). Not two trees.

And Revelation 12 describes “those who keep the testimony of Jesus” suffering under war from the devil after the Tribulation begins… which is not possible if they had been raptured and those who are “left behind” are to be judged by works.

Where do you get the idea that the Roman armies who sacked Jerusalem were a “coming” of Jesus Christ? Certainly not from amillennialism.

But anyway…

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 16:26-28[/BIBLEDRB]

Who that was standing there then is still alive today?
I was in the RCC for 43 years, and believed everything I was told without looking into God’s word to actually find out whether it was scriptural or not, in other words, whether it was “true” or not. When I looked in scripture, I found that about 85% of the RCC teaching was based on “tradition”, and therefore subject to changes as the years went by. On the other hand, whether you are RC or not, you will have to agree that the word of God, the Bible does not and will not change, so I base anything that I say, including the number of times Christ did and will come to earth, on the “bible”. I hope you understand where I am coming from. Blessings.
 
I was in the RCC for 43 years, and believed everything I was told without looking into God’s word to actually find out whether it was scriptural or not, in other words, whether it was “true” or not. When I looked in scripture, I found that about 85% of the RCC teaching was based on “tradition”, and therefore subject to changes as the years past. On the other hand, whether you are RC or not, you will have to agree that the word of God, the Bible does not and will not change, so I base anything that I say on the “bible”. I hope you understand where I am coming from. Blessings.
Hmm, I can see where you are coming from, but I don’t see where Sola/Solo Scriptura is found in the Bible either, or “everything a Christian MUST believe in is in the Bible.”
 
Yes, there is one more coming of Christ, TO THE EARTH. Jesus’ 1st advent as well as His 2nd advent are to Israel. And yes, for the benefit of all peoples of all nations also. The pre-tribulation rapture is Christ’s catching away of His bride and hardened Israel will go through the last 7 years decreed for them in Daniel 9:24(the 144,000 Israelites are God’s servants, or remnant at that time). This is not “sickening” or a “false gospel”.
I would urge you to look for the books The Rapture Trap and Will Catholics Be Left Behind?. The Rapture Trap is by Paul Thigpen, a former believer of this false gospel.

I will wait for Christ’s first and only return from Heaven, in his Second Coming.
 
I was in the RCC for 43 years, and believed everything I was told without looking into God’s word to actually find out whether it was scriptural or not, in other words, whether it was “true” or not. When I looked in scripture, I found that about 85% of the RCC teaching was based on “tradition”, and therefore subject to changes as the years went by. On the other hand, whether you are RC or not, you will have to agree that the word of God, the Bible does not and will not change, so I base anything that I say, including the number of times Christ did and will come to earth, on the “bible”. I hope you understand where I am coming from. Blessings.
All of the Catholic Church’s teachings are based on the Bible AND Tradition. There is not one dogma that does not have scriptural support. I will demonstrate this shortly.

Can you answer the question:

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 16:24-28[/BIBLEDRB]

Who has not tasted death?
 
Hmm, I can see where you are coming from, but I don’t see where Sola/Solo Scriptura is found in the Bible either, or “everything a Christian MUST believe in is in the Bible.”
May I suggest you take a look at John 12:44-50, and you will see how we will be judged in the last day. It does not say anything about “tradition”, but it does say’s that our judgment will come by the “word of God”. Blessings.
 
Again… don’t you see that there is anything wrong with positing that Jesus has two brides, two covenant people, as you are doing?

And there is Paul’s assertion that the People of God are one Body, one Olive Tree, with Hebrew and Gentile branches, both of which will be subject to pruning (suffering). Not two trees.

And Revelation 12 describes “those who keep the testimony of Jesus” suffering under war from the devil after the Tribulation begins… which is not possible if they had been raptured and those who are “left behind” are to be judged by works.

Where do you get the idea that the Roman armies who sacked Jerusalem were a “coming” of Jesus Christ? Certainly not from amillennialism.

But anyway…

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 16:26-28[/BIBLEDRB]

Who that was standing there then is still alive today?
There is a small Greek particle here [non-translatable] that indicates a contingency. There are four “tills” in Matthew where this particle appears. This is contingent upon Israel receiving her Messiah, The LORD Jesus Christ.
Hope this helps.
QC
 
There is a small Greek particle here [non-translatable] that indicates a contingency. There are four “tills” in Matthew where this particle appears. This is contingent upon Israel receiving her Messiah, The LORD Jesus Christ.
Hope this helps.
QC
Whether or not there is such a Greek “particle” is irrelevant because whatever the coming of Christ is contingent on is irrelevant. Jesus said that at least one person standing there would not die before it happened. So, who is it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top