Biden's Reference During Abortion Comments

  • Thread starter Thread starter William777
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

William777

Guest
When Biden asked about his pro-death stance on abortion during the vice presidential debate, he cited some kind of Catholic doctrine, which he used to justify his thinking that he didn’t want to impose his Catholic faith on the rights of non-Catholics. What did he reference?

Not knowing about this doctrine, I obviously haven’t read it, but I find Biden’s argument hard to believe. I don’t know of any Bishops, Cardinals or Pope’s (the policy setting figures of the church), who would in any way agree; as a matter of fact, they have come out and openly and repeatedly to say they don’t agree, and that the church’s stand against abortion is, has and always will be completely non-negotiable. So he was wrong somehow.

But why did he cite that specific doctrine, and where did he go wrong in his interpretation and application of it to abortion?

Thanks.
 
I am long accepting of the idea that the Church does not and cannot set democratic policy; she can only advise. If the majority wishes gay marriage, assisted suicide or abortion the Church can only tell us not to, like the wealthy young man in the gospel who is advised to sell his worldly goods and join the Lord if he wishes to be complete:
Then someone came to him and said, “Teacher, what good deed must I do to have eternal life?” And he said to him, “Why do you ask me about what is good? There is only one who is good. If you wish to enter into life, keep the commandments.” He said to him, “Which ones?” And Jesus said, “You shall not murder; You shall not commit adultery; You shall not steal; You shall not bear false witness; Honor your father and mother; also, You shall love your neighbor as yourself.” The young man said to him, “I have kept all these; what do I still lack?” Jesus said to him, “If you wish to be perfect, go, sell your possessions, and give the money to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; then come, follow me.” When the young man heard this word, he went away grieving, for he had many possessions.
Matthew 19: 16-21
I feel as though the same occurs for those who wish abortion, same-sex marriage or physician assisted suicide. The answer is no but there is no force involved. You are allowed to do any of these things but the reply varies as above:
  1. She went away grieving for she could imagine no way to bear the child and be with the Lord…
  2. He/She went away grieving for he/she could not abandon the embraces of his/her lover and be with the Lord…
  3. He/She went away grieving for he/she could not bear the cross of sickness any longer and be with the Lord…
 
That’s not what he said.

He used some sort of doctrinal reference. He called it by name. “Dei Fidei” or something… but I don’t think Dei Fidei was it… I just cannot recall what he said verbatim…

I’m not looking for editorials here. I’m looking for what he actually said.
 
BTW, I would look for it myself in videos of the debate, but the man makes me physically sick, so I appreciate any help one can give to spare me that cross.
 
ncregister.com/blog/pat-archbold/joe-biden-and-the-abortion-question
My religion defines who I am, and I’ve been a practicing Catholic my whole life. And has particularly informed my social doctrine. The Catholic social doctrine talks about taking care of those who – who can’t take care of themselves, people who need help. With regard to – with regard to abortion, I accept my church’s position on abortion as a – what we call a de fide doctrine. Life begins at conception in the church’s judgment. I accept it in my personal life.
But I refuse to impose it on equally devout Christians and Muslims and Jews, and I just refuse to impose that on others, unlike my friend here, the – the congressman. I – I do not believe that we have a right to tell other people that – women they can’t control their body. It’s a decision between them and their doctor. In my view and the Supreme Court, I’m not going to interfere with that.
So Joe Biden accepts as a “de fide” tenet of the faith that life begins at conception, but that it is perfectly ok to take that innocent life. Yet Biden would take myriad other positions that do not rise to the level of ‘de fide’ pronouncements and happily impose them on everybody.
Joe Biden’s position is as disingenuous as his smile.
You cannot possibly really believe that life, innocent human life begins at conception and support abortion on demand. It is not possible. Paul Ryan tried to undercut this ridiculous duplicity before Biden even answered but it skittered right off his teflon intellect and bounced right off his kevlar conscience. It is the worst of lies, but the once pro-life Biden does not care, after all he is the same man who danced for joy when his support for Justice Souter resulted in the Supreme Court upholding abortion in Casey. You do not dance for joy if your personal belief is that life begins at conception.
One thing is true, however. Joe Biden does not want to impose the tenets of Catholicism on anyone, especially himself.
Fr Zuhlsdorf said

wdtprs.com/blog/2012/10/vp-biden-planned-parenthood-under-law-cannot-perform-any-abortions
Biden says he is “personally opposed” to abortion but won’t impose his views on others. Uh huh. That’s the old Kennedy-Cuomo pro-abortion catholic dodge. When you spin that out to others issues the position is exposed as a fraud. “I’m personally opposed to someone knocking you out, cutting you open, and selling your kidneys on the black market, but I don’t want to impose my views on others.” “I’m personally opposed to putting 68 year-olds with Crohn’s Disease to death because they will drain system under Obamatax, but I don’t want to impose my views.” “I’m personally opposed to rape, but I won’t vote for any law against it. That would mean imposing my views on people who think rape is okay.”
Can. 915!
 
Here’s what Biden said:

"My religion defines who I am, and I’ve been a practicing Catholic my whole life. And has particularly informed my social doctrine. The Catholic social doctrine talks about taking care of those who – who can’t take care of themselves, people who need help. With regard to – with regard to abortion, I accept my church’s position on abortion as a – what we call a de fide doctrine. Life begins at conception in the church’s judgment. I accept it in my personal life.

But I refuse to impose it on equally devout Christians and Muslims and Jews, and I just refuse to impose that on others, unlike my friend here, the – the congressman. I – I do not believe that we have a right to tell other people that – women they can’t control their body. It’s a decision between them and their doctor. In my view and the Supreme Court, I’m not going to interfere with that." (Emphasis added by me.)

So, he wasn’t quoting a specific Church document. Rather, he was saying that, as a Catholic, it’s an article of faith (de fide means “of the faith”) that he has to assent to. Denying a de fide doctrine leads to the sin of heresy.

However, he then adopts the secular viewpoint that “he cannot force his religious beliefs on others”, which is gobbledygook. Faith without works, as St. James reminds us, is dead. By claiming that his faith and his work are two separate things, he is making both a logical and a theological error.

Far from quoting any Church document justifying abortion (God forbid!), he is actually accepting that the Church condemns abortion, but then saying “I won’t follow that viewpoint in my political life, because the world has already stated otherwise, and who am I to argue with them?” 🤷

ncregister.com/blog/pat-archbold/joe-biden-and-the-abortion-question

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_fide

newadvent.org/cathen/05089a.htm
 
When Biden asked about his pro-death stance on abortion during the vice presidential debate, he cited some kind of Catholic doctrine, which he used to justify his thinking that he didn’t want to impose his Catholic faith on the rights of non-Catholics. What did he reference?

Not knowing about this doctrine, I obviously haven’t read it, but I find Biden’s argument hard to believe. I don’t know of any Bishops, Cardinals or Pope’s (the policy setting figures of the church), who would in any way agree; as a matter of fact, they have come out and openly and repeatedly to say they don’t agree, and that the church’s stand against abortion is, has and always will be completely non-negotiable. So he was wrong somehow.

But why did he cite that specific doctrine, and where did he go wrong in his interpretation and application of it to abortion?

Thanks.
Most of us here aren’t parrticularly interested in what Mr. Biden says about his beliefs. But it is the general practice of those who " pick and choose " to misintrepret the the Doctrines of the Church to rationalize their positions. No one here is interested in analyzing Mr. Biden’s position to explain where he went wrong. But if you Google " Vice Presidential Debate, " you may find it. 👍
 
I’m curious if he would vote for a bill defining life as beginning at conception and if not, why not.

The guy is a fraud. His response was certainly not very Catholic and was about as illogical as you can imagine.
 
I am certainly not a Joe Biden fan, but when you spewed this comment…
BTW, I would look for it myself in videos of the debate, but the man makes me physically sick, so I appreciate any help one can give to spare me that cross.
…any credibility you might have had flew right out the window.

I wonder if a video of you might make my physically sick? :rolleyes:
 
Sadly, too many Catholics voted for him. The only redeeming thing about Biden is that he seems to like to open his mouth a lot and stick his foot in it and show what is in his head which doesn’t amount to much. What is scary is that he is a heart beat away.
 
I am certainly not a Joe Biden fan, but when you spewed this comment…

…any credibility you might have had flew right out the window.

I wonder if a video of you might make my physically sick? :rolleyes:
Well, whether or not you think I lack credibility, doesn’t mean it isn’t true.

You think I am being judgmental?

I’ve been suffering with a disabling condition that has had me out of work and on SSI welfare for years. I turn to church constantly for healing - literally for the healing masses, repentance, a trusted community and the like. The progress has steadily improved over the years due to the church community. But the impact this election will have on our cherished values has left me sick and suffering anxiety attacks since Tuesday.

I voted my conscience in keeping with the church, and in the OP I spoke of it’s effects upon me. I’m sorry if my witness offends you.

The effects of the HHS mandate will kill a lot of innocent children, and it will enable vices that will cause far greater physical harm (for example, same sex marriages will result in increased STD’s, increased psychoses, etc…) to many, many more people than will ever participate in this post. And the list goes on.

The topic here was about wounded faith. What I mean by wounded faith has nothing to do with my judgement, or your approval of my personal perceptions, or personal attacks on anyone. Sin is death, and illness is only a natural consequence of what happens when we offend God in such a manner. We have a huge cross to carry over the next four years, and it’s going to be a long, long painful haul.
 
Well, whether or not you think I lack credibility, doesn’t mean it isn’t true.

You think I am being judgmental?

I’ve been suffering with a disabling condition that has had me out of work and on SSI welfare for years. I turn to church constantly for healing - literally for the healing masses, repentance, a trusted community and the like. The progress has steadily improved over the years due to the church community. But the impact this election will have on our cherished values has left me sick and suffering anxiety attacks since Tuesday.

I voted my conscience in keeping with the church, and in the OP I spoke of it’s effects upon me. I’m sorry if my witness offends you.

The effects of the HHS mandate will kill a lot of innocent children, and it will enable vices that will cause far greater physical harm (for example, same sex marriages will result in increased STD’s, increased psychoses, etc…) to many, many more people than will ever participate in this post. And the list goes on.

The topic here was about wounded faith. What I mean by wounded faith has nothing to do with my judgement, or your approval of my personal perceptions, or personal attacks on anyone. Sin is death, and illness is only a natural consequence of what happens when we offend God in such a manner. We have a huge cross to carry over the next four years, and it’s going to be a long, long painful haul.
Most us feel the way you do William. God Bless you in all your struggles. Even though sick, you seems to have a contemplative gift and I am wondering if you have thought about a religious order like the Carmelites? Take care.
 
I am certainly not a Joe Biden fan, but when you spewed this comment…

" BTW, I would look for it myself in videos of the debate, but the man makes me physically sick, so I appreciate any help one can give to spare me that cross."

…any credibility you might have had flew right out the window.

I wonder if a video of you might make my physically sick? :rolleyes:
William said this made HIM physically sick… who are you
to argue with him and say that this now makes HIS words
not credible ?

A video of me might might make you physically sick and vice versa, so what ?

William has a right to his OWN opinion.

( He makes me sick too William… )
 
Actually, Joe didn’t even get Catholic doctrine right.

“De Fide” means “of the Faith” or “essential to the Faith.” But as far as I know, the Church has no official doctrine that human life begins at conception. What is “de fide” is that abortion is always intrinsically evil. That human life begins at conception is a biolgical fact, not a moral doctrine. So maybe Joe just needs to study his biology a little more.
 
I wonder how he feels about forcing his political views on others?
Granted that through elections views/opinions of one kind or another may become law, but how is that “forcing it on others”? Should we all not vote in the first place? Could anyone translate the liberal speak for me?

dj
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top