Bin Laden kill may reopen CIA interrogation debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1

1holycatholic

Guest
Bin Laden kill may reopen CIA interrogation debate
(Reuters) - The possibility that U.S. spies located Osama bin Laden with help from detainees who’d been subjected to “enhanced interrogation” techniques seems certain to reopen the debate over practices that many have equated with torture, security experts said on Monday.

One of the key sources for initial information about an al Qaeda “courier” who led U.S. authorities to bin Laden’s Pakistani hide-out was Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the al Qaeda operative said to have masterminded the September 11, 2001 attacks, a former U.S. national security official said.

KSM, as he was known to U.S. officials, was subjected to “waterboarding” 183 times, the U.S. government has acknowledged.
…
 
Bin Laden kill may reopen CIA interrogation debate
(Reuters) - The possibility that U.S. spies located Osama bin Laden with help from detainees who’d been subjected to “enhanced interrogation” techniques seems certain to reopen the debate over practices that many have equated with torture, security experts said on Monday.

One of the key sources for initial information about an al Qaeda “courier” who led U.S. authorities to bin Laden’s Pakistani hide-out was Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the al Qaeda operative said to have masterminded the September 11, 2001 attacks, a former U.S. national security official said.

KSM, as he was known to U.S. officials, was subjected to “waterboarding” 183 times, the U.S. government has acknowledged.
…
There are always those who believe that the ends justify the means.
 
There are always those who believe that the ends justify the means.
I agree, but in this case there is not even a connection between the end and the means they are trying to justify. A few Bush cheerleaders have opined from the sidelines that waterboarding may have had some connection to the operation, but everyone that is actually in a position to know has said that it did not. Even Don Rumsfeld has said that the information did not come from “enhanced interrogation” of KSM. This is nothing more than a last gasp attempt to defend the indefensible. Torture is not only immoral, it does not even produce good intelligence.
 
A few Bush cheerleaders have opined from the sidelines that waterboarding may have had some connection to the operation, but everyone that is actually in a position to know has said that it did not.
Leon Panetta explicitly said that it (waterboarding) did. I hardly think he’s a “Bush cheerleader.”
 
The information did not come directly from waterboarding. Only three terrorists were EVER waterboarded, and that was to break them down for future, less severe interrogation techniques. The information gathered which lead to this assault was not directly from waterboarding or other such techniques, but it some say that past use of waterboarding did contribute to the later information gathered by virtue of the weakened mental state of the prisoners.
 
Leon Panetta explicitly said that it (waterboarding) did. I hardly think he’s a “Bush cheerleader.”
No he did not. The quote you provided was cherrypicked and out of context, and even in that quote the most he said that some of the sources that provided information may have been subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques at some time in the past. If he has said that vital information for this raid was developed from waterboarding I have not seen it and you certainly haven’t posted it. All of the officials to comment on this have said that enhanced interrogation techniques were not a significant source of information for the raid.

Of course, it goes without saying (or should) that even if waterboarding or other torture techniques did prove useful in finding OBL, that would not justify their use. Torture is inherently evil and never justified.
 
No he did not. The quote you provided was cherrypicked and out of context, and even in that quote the most he said that some of the sources that provided information may have been subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques at some time in the past. If he has said that vital information for this raid was developed from waterboarding I have not seen it and you certainly haven’t posted it. All of the officials to comment on this have said that enhanced interrogation techniques were not a significant source of information for the raid.

Of course, it goes without saying (or should) that even if waterboarding or other torture techniques did prove useful in finding OBL, that would not justify their use. Torture is inherently evil and never justified.
It’s not cherry picked. Leon Panetta admitted to it on NBC.

clicker.com/tv/nightly-news/panetta–enhanced-interrogation-included-water-boarding-1736525/
 
I agree, but in this case there is not even a connection between the end and the means they are trying to justify. A few Bush cheerleaders have opined from the sidelines that waterboarding may have had some connection to the operation, but everyone that is actually in a position to know has said that it did not. Even Don Rumsfeld has said that the information did not come from “enhanced interrogation” of KSM. This is nothing more than a last gasp attempt to defend the indefensible. Torture is not only immoral, it does not even produce good intelligence.
No torture is not defensible, but simply repeating that point every time enhanced interrogation is discussed adds little, if anything, to the conversation, since it it not the real issue being debated. Supporters of various forms of “enhanced interrogation” generally do not argue that torture is acceptable. Both international law and Catholic teaching are clear on this point. Torture is illegal and morally wrong.

The real issue that profitably could be debated is when do physical forms of pressure become torture. This is a question not easily answered. If a prisoner is denied food for ten minutes during an interrogation few, if any, would claim it is torture. Conversely, if we deny a prisoner food for two days during an interrogation, most would say it is torture. The question on which consensus is not easily reached is at what point do forms of physical and psychological pressure become torture? Is it 15 minutes, 30 minutes, and hour, or 5 hours without food. Similarly, should prisoner be able to escape simply by saying they are tired? If not, how many hours without sleep becomes torture? Certainly that depends on one’s normal sleep habits, needs, etc…

Similarly guidelines are necessary for psychological pressure. Telling one prisoner another has already confessed, even if a lie, is common practice in US police stations. Conversely, a doctored film that falsely portrays someone’s children being killed, most would call psychological torture. But at what point does such deceit become torture?

For political rhetoric most of us like to pretend that what is and is not torture is readily known and well understood. In reality it is more like pornography, we seem to know it when we see it, but cultural and personal standards differ. Thus if you wish to have a conversation about when physical pressure, such as waterboarding, become torture, this would be interesting and is an important policy discussion. But if you wish to merely condemn the other side by using clearly vitriolic rhetoric, then it isn’t a discussion for the forum, it is simply a form of name calling.

By the way, I would tend to agree that water boarding was most likely torture. (If we begin that conversation, I will explain why). Conversely, many of the other forms of “enhanced interrogation”, most of which are still in regular use, are, in my opinion not torture. I also would suggest that while the Bush administration’s decisions to use water boarding, while likely torture, is probably more defensible, it is likely kinder than the Obama administration’s tendency to ship these folks back to their home countries where they are often treated far worse physically (but American hands are technically cleaner) and often they are then let go, thus worsening the threat.
 
Why don’t you provide the actual quote? It does not say what you suggest it does:
“We had multiple series of sources that provided information with regards to this situation… clearly some of it came from detainees [and] they used these enhanced interrogation techniques against some of those detainees,” Panetta told NBC News anchor Brian Williams.
He said that some information used in the raid came from detainees and that some of those detainees had been subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques. He did not say that the intelligence that lead to the was developed through waterboarding.
 
Why don’t you provide the actual quote? It does not say what you suggest it does:

He said that some information used in the raid came from detainees and that some of those detainees had been subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques. He did not say that the intelligence that lead to the was developed through waterboarding.
Watch This Episode Now
Season 511 Episode 0503 Date: May 03, 2011
In an interview with NBC’s Brian Williams, CIA Director Leon Panetta confirms that the intelligence needed to find Osama bin Laden was gained, in part, by interrogation techniques that included water-boarding.
I don’t have to suggest anything. Leon Panetta affirms that waterboarding played a part in the information that led to the demise of Bin Laden.
 
I don’t have to suggest anything. Leon Panetta affirms that waterboarding played a part in the information that led to the demise of Bin Laden.
I suppose you will continue to believe what you want, but you are relying on a misleading summary of his statement while I provided the direct quote which says nothing of the kind. If waterboarding were used here it would be a shame, but hardly the first or last time our government did something that was wrong. Are you suggesting that an inherent evil can be justified here?
 
I suppose you will continue to believe what you want, but you are relying on a misleading summary of his statement while I provided the direct quote which says nothing of the kind. If waterboarding were used here it would be a shame, but hardly the first or last time our government did something that was wrong. Are you suggesting that an inherent evil can be justified here?
I provided video footage of Leon Panetta’s admission. Are you implying that NBC News doctored the footage to make Mr. Panetta appear to have said something he didn’t say?
 
I provided video footage of Leon Panetta’s admission. Are you implying that NBC News doctored the footage to make Mr. Panetta appear to have said something he didn’t say?
I read the transcript of his remarks, I did not watch the video. From what I read I think you are reading too much into his statements. I may be wrong, but it would it does seem odd that everyone else involved in the operation is saying that no significant intelligence used in the operation came from enhanced interrogation techniques.

Can we agree that it would be a shame if true, and that torture is an inherent evil that is never justified?
 
Can we agree that it would be a shame if true, and that torture is an inherent evil that is never justified?
I don’t.

Agree that is. If someone had kidnapped my Daughter, locked her away somewhere without food and water - and I knew she would die if I couldn’t get to her - I would torture the poop out of someone. Period. No use arguing a Mother’s instinct you’d be hanging from your toenails.
 
Since this is coming up in a number of threads, I placed some resources up as a sticky for your use. If you have additional resources, feel free to add them. That thread is not meant to be an open discussion thread, but a resource listing thread:

Torture is a Moral Issue - Some Catholic Resources

Feel free to continue your discussion here.
 
And just how would me not wanting my Daughter to die be MY failing?

I would be failing her if I didn’t do any and everything I could to find her and help her.

I understand that the church teaches the death penalty is wrong, but we are free to make the decision for ourselves. I’m hoping it is the same case with this - because I absolutely disagree.
 
And just how would me not wanting my Daughter to die be MY failing?

I would be failing her if I didn’t do any and everything I could to find her and help her.

I understand that the church teaches the death penalty is wrong, but we are free to make the decision for ourselves. I’m hoping it is the same case with this - because I absolutely disagree.
The issue is that torture is intrinsically evil, and as I understood it, the basic precept of Catholic moral theology is means focused, not ends focused: I.e. the end can never justify the means. One cannot commit a morally evil act to bring about a good end.

I have to read further on Akin’s tentative hedging in the links provided later, but at the moment this looks to me very much like Akin playing a game of pick your favorite or least favorite papal encyclical. If I’m correct, doesn’t the veritas splendor of JPII state that torture is intrinsically (i.e. always) evil? How’s he getting around this?

I must read more when I can of his argument here to analyze it fully, but this, if an accurate understanding on my part, leads to an incredible moral theology for Akin indeed! I won’t put words in his mouth, but I am willing to bet he would as ascribe fully to the most obsessive specifics governing marital love and sexual expression set forth in the encyclical Humanae Vitae. So, is Akin saying essentially that torturing another human being is NOT intrinsically evil, but the free and willing giving of sexual intimacy in marriage that does not ALWAYS end in the one acceptable way IS intrinsically evil? In other words: a husband receiving oral sex from his wife freely given, or, using a condom, for instance, always, absolutely grave mortal sin, evil that is never justifiable no matter what. But someone torturing another human being, placing them in the rack, cutting off fingers or toes, for instance…maybe evil, maybe not. Think about that stance for a moment and the total absurdity of it will overwhelm you. Ridiculous on it’s face.

Not to mention that even if we allow this “exception” in torture for the ticking time bomb scenario, the exception would eat the rule whole. EVERY captured terrorist suspect COULD know about an imminent, catastrophic threat. We’d use the exception on every case, since by definition we have no idea what nefarious plans the captive might know about. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top