I agree, but in this case there is not even a connection between the end and the means they are trying to justify. A few Bush cheerleaders have opined from the sidelines that waterboarding may have had some connection to the operation, but everyone that is actually in a position to know has said that it did not. Even Don Rumsfeld has said that the information did not come from “enhanced interrogation” of KSM. This is nothing more than a last gasp attempt to defend the indefensible. Torture is not only immoral, it does not even produce good intelligence.
No torture is not defensible, but simply repeating that point every time enhanced interrogation is discussed adds little, if anything, to the conversation, since it it not the real issue being debated. Supporters of various forms of “enhanced interrogation” generally do not argue that torture is acceptable. Both international law and Catholic teaching are clear on this point. Torture is illegal and morally wrong.
The real issue that profitably could be debated is when do physical forms of pressure become torture. This is a question not easily answered. If a prisoner is denied food for ten minutes during an interrogation few, if any, would claim it is torture. Conversely, if we deny a prisoner food for two days during an interrogation, most would say it is torture. The question on which consensus is not easily reached is at what point do forms of physical and psychological pressure become torture? Is it 15 minutes, 30 minutes, and hour, or 5 hours without food. Similarly, should prisoner be able to escape simply by saying they are tired? If not, how many hours without sleep becomes torture? Certainly that depends on one’s normal sleep habits, needs, etc…
Similarly guidelines are necessary for psychological pressure. Telling one prisoner another has already confessed, even if a lie, is common practice in US police stations. Conversely, a doctored film that falsely portrays someone’s children being killed, most would call psychological torture. But at what point does such deceit become torture?
For political rhetoric most of us like to pretend that what is and is not torture is readily known and well understood. In reality it is more like pornography, we seem to know it when we see it, but cultural and personal standards differ. Thus if you wish to have a conversation about when physical pressure, such as waterboarding, become torture, this would be interesting and is an important policy discussion. But if you wish to merely condemn the other side by using clearly vitriolic rhetoric, then it isn’t a discussion for the forum, it is simply a form of name calling.
By the way, I would tend to agree that water boarding was most likely torture. (If we begin that conversation, I will explain why). Conversely, many of the other forms of “enhanced interrogation”, most of which are still in regular use, are, in my opinion not torture. I also would suggest that while the Bush administration’s decisions to use water boarding, while likely torture, is probably more defensible, it is likely kinder than the Obama administration’s tendency to ship these folks back to their home countries where they are often treated far worse physically (but American hands are technically cleaner) and often they are then let go, thus worsening the threat.