Biology / science / ressurrection

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rogerteder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You except the resurrection even though science says it can’t happen. Science says Fatima couldnt have happened. Science is wrong even though from their vantage point they seem to have all the answers.
With evolution their “answers” are disputed by other scientists(I’ll admit it is a very small minority, but they still exist). You said it yourself you reject Church teaching on polygenism. We have clear teaching from Pope Pius XII that we cannot believe in polygenism. Unless you have an official statement from another Pope overiding (official meaning an encyclical, a council, etc… not a speech, a book, an interview, a cardinal who supposedly has coffee with the Pope, etc) Pius XII, Pius X, Leo XIII, almost all the Fathers who took Genesis literally, etc how can you justify taking science over the Church?
Also, Phil the Fathers of the Church were creationists based on scripture. Not the science of the day. All Fathers took Genesis literally accept Augustine (Augustine even conceded he could be wrong on this point) and Origen (who took almost all of scripture allegorically) All the rest of the Fathers and subsequent Popes took Genesis literally. There is nothing in the text that suggests a figurative interpretation. None that is backed up by Catholic Tradition. YET BECAUSE SCIENTISTS SAY EVOLUTION MUST BE CORRECT YOU KISS AND BOW AND TAKE GENESIS SYMBOLICALLY. MERRY CHRISTMAS.
 
Roger << Ok Phil so you believe that JESUS actually bodily rose from the dead after he was dead for three days. SCIENCE says it is impossible for a man to do that. >>

OK once more, here is my response.

I believe Jesus actually bodily rose from the dead. Why? Not only does the Church affirm this, but there is evidence to support this. The best explanation in the historical context at the time Jesus lived is that “God raised Jesus from the dead.” The other “natural” explanations (hallucination, conspiracy, theft, deceivers, wrong tomb, swoon, myth, etc) fail to explain: (a) the death of Jesus on the cross, (b) His empty tomb, (c) his appearances alive to various witnesses in various places, (d) the origin and spread of the Christian faith.

Science does not speak to miracles. History speaks to (a), (b), (c), (d) and we can reasonably conclude these facts about Jesus and Christianity leads to the conclusion he rose from the dead.

Roger << You accept the resurrection even though science says it can’t happen. >>

Again, science has no opinion on miracles. Generally, science says people do not rise because we do not see resurrections every day. The resurrection of Jesus was a one-time, rare event (hence miracle) that science cannot speak to. The miracle itself only entails one assumption that science also does not speak to: God exists.

Science doesn’t say “it can’t happen.” Science says “I have no opinion on the matter.”

Roger << Science says Fatima couldn’t have happened. Science is wrong even though from their vantage point they seem to have all the answers. >>

Science only has answers on material things that are testable, repeatable, directly observable, where things can be verified by experiment, mathematics, and/or theoretical explanations based on evidence, etc. Science does not have answers on the meaning of life, whether there is purpose in the universe, morality, consciousness/mind (although they are working on this), and/or whether there is a creator God behind the universe (outside of space and time).

Fatima is like the resurrection of Jesus. It was a one-time event, witnessed by 70,000 (some sources have 100,000) people (skeptics and believers alike). There is a question why people OUTSIDE Fatima standing outdoors looking up ALSO did not see the sun dance and whirl. This can be explained by the people at that local area in Fatima all given a vision or hallucination by God. Either way, it was a miracle. Science does not speak to such miracles.

Science doesn’t say “Fatima couldn’t have happened.” Science says “I don’t know how to explain the 70,000+ people who witnessed the sun’s movement.” Science is not wrong, science has no strong opinion on the matter.

Roger << With evolution their “answers” are disputed by other scientists (I’ll admit it is a very small minority, but they still exist). >>

Evolution is disputed by creationists, but disputed wrongly and dishonestly. I can say this since I have read pretty extensive in their literature. I have the book In Six Days and others. They distort the writings of other scientists, taking quotes out of context. They do not publish in peer-reviewed literature, etc. That is not proper scientific “disputing.”

Roger << All the rest of the Fathers and subsequent Popes took Genesis literally. There is nothing in the text that suggests a figurative interpretation. None that is backed up by Catholic Tradition. YET BECAUSE SCIENTISTS SAY EVOLUTION MUST BE CORRECT YOU KISS AND BOW AND TAKE GENESIS SYMBOLICALLY. MERRY CHRISTMAS. >>

Scientists say evolution is correct based on the scientific evidence. That evidence is good, strong, overwhelming, and affirmed by various scientists cross-checked from various disciplines, published in peer-reviewed journals, etc. We’ve known the earth is very old for 200+ years, we’ve known we evolved since the time of Darwin, etc.

Not only the Fathers, but all primitive peoples (all “scientists” included) took the earth as young, the center of the universe, and sometimes flat (see Cosmology in Antiquity). It was indeed science “based on the Bible” but it was also the science of the day. It can be argued the Bible itself teaches or at least assumes a flat earth.

Phil P
 
Roger << Ok Phil so you believe that JESUS actually bodily rose from the dead after he was dead for three days. SCIENCE says it is impossible for a man to do that. >>

OK once more, here is my response.

I believe Jesus actually bodily rose from the dead. Why? Not only does the Church affirm this, but there is evidence to support this. The best explanation in the historical context at the time Jesus lived is that “God raised Jesus from the dead.” The other “natural” explanations (hallucination, conspiracy, theft, deceivers, wrong tomb, swoon, myth, etc) fail to explain: (a) the death of Jesus on the cross, (b) His empty tomb, (c) his appearances alive to various witnesses in various places, (d) the origin and spread of the Christian faith.

Science does not speak to miracles. History speaks to (a), (b), (c), (d) and we can reasonably conclude these facts about Jesus and Christianity leads to the conclusion he rose from the dead.

Roger << You accept the resurrection even though science says it can’t happen. >>

Again, science has no opinion on miracles. Generally, science says people do not rise because we do not see resurrections every day. The resurrection of Jesus was a one-time, rare event (hence miracle) that science cannot speak to. The miracle itself only entails one assumption that science also does not speak to: God exists.

Science doesn’t say “it can’t happen.” Science says “I have no opinion on the matter.”

Roger << Science says Fatima couldn’t have happened. Science is wrong even though from their vantage point they seem to have all the answers. >>

Science only has answers on material things that are testable, repeatable, directly observable, where things can be verified by experiment, mathematics, and/or theoretical explanations based on evidence, etc. Science does not have answers on the meaning of life, whether there is purpose in the universe, morality, consciousness/mind (although they are working on this), and/or whether there is a creator God behind the universe (outside of space and time).

Fatima is like the resurrection of Jesus. It was a one-time event, witnessed by 70,000 (some sources have 100,000) people (skeptics and believers alike). There is a question why people OUTSIDE Fatima standing outdoors looking up ALSO did not see the sun dance and whirl. This can be explained by the people at that local area in Fatima all given a vision or hallucination by God. Either way, it was a miracle. Science does not speak to such miracles.

Science doesn’t say “Fatima couldn’t have happened.” Science says “I don’t know how to explain the 70,000+ people who witnessed the sun’s movement.” Science is not wrong, science has no strong opinion on the matter.

Roger << With evolution their “answers” are disputed by other scientists (I’ll admit it is a very small minority, but they still exist). >>

Evolution is disputed by creationists, but disputed wrongly and dishonestly. I can say this since I have read pretty extensive in their literature. I have the book In Six Days and others. They distort the writings of other scientists, taking quotes out of context. They do not publish in peer-reviewed literature, etc. That is not proper scientific “disputing.”

Roger << All the rest of the Fathers and subsequent Popes took Genesis literally. There is nothing in the text that suggests a figurative interpretation. None that is backed up by Catholic Tradition. YET BECAUSE SCIENTISTS SAY EVOLUTION MUST BE CORRECT YOU KISS AND BOW AND TAKE GENESIS SYMBOLICALLY. MERRY CHRISTMAS. >>

Scientists say evolution is correct based on the scientific evidence. That evidence is good, strong, overwhelming, and affirmed by various scientists cross-checked from various disciplines, published in peer-reviewed journals, etc. We’ve known the earth is very old for 200+ years, we’ve known we evolved since the time of Darwin, etc.

Not only the Fathers, but all primitive peoples (all “scientists” included) took the earth as young, the center of the universe, and sometimes flat (see Cosmology in Antiquity). It was indeed science “based on the Bible” but it was also the science of the day. It can be argued the Bible itself teaches or at least assumes a flat earth.

Phil P
Phil how can you say that ALL CREATIONISTS are dishonest? C’mon Phil!!! How about the magisterium clearly saying you CAN’T BELIEVE IN POLYGENISM? CLEARLY!!!
Phil science basically says that miracles can’t happen. Sorry it is true. There are clear instances where science and the Church simply conflict. In the case of evolution many scientists do dispute it. True the vast majority of scientists do accept it, but there are those who do not. How about the scientist that was fired by NASA a few years back. He was dishonest? Google that one. The fact is we have clear teaching by Pius XII that contradicts evolution. CLEAR TEACHING!!! ON JUDGMENT DAY I’D WOULD RATHER BE WITH PIUS XII NOT SOME ATHIEST SCIENTISTS!!! THINK ABOUT THAT!!!
 
Science does not speak to miracles.
I’m not sure what that means precisely but science does speak “about” miracles. “Science” these days concludes that miracles are “outside” of science. That is a statement about miracles and therefore science does draw a conclusion about miracles.
Again, science has no opinion on miracles.
Science does have an “opinion” about miracles – namely, that science supposedly cannot talk about miracles. Science has concluded that miracles are not a subject of science, just making a judgement about miracles. So, it’s not true that science has no opinion about miracles.
Generally, science says people do not rise because we do not see resurrections every day.
This is a good example of science’s opinion about miracles.
The resurrection of Jesus was a one-time, rare event (hence miracle) that science cannot speak to.
Science judges (apparently) that Jesus’ resurrection was a “one-time rare event”. This is a judgement and opinion about miracles (which is false, by the way). If science had “no opinion” it wouldn’t judge if resurrections were one-time events or every day events.
The miracle itself only entails one assumption that science also does not speak to: God exists.
As above, science concludes that the question of God’s existence is “outside of the scope of science”. So science has a strong opinion about the existence of God, namely, that it is irrelevant to science (and this is a major error).
Science doesn’t say “it can’t happen.” Science says “I have no opinion on the matter.”
Science does claim “I have no opinion” and then proceeds to establish an opinion, as shown above.
Science only has answers on material things that are testable, repeatable, directly observable, where things can be verified by experiment,
The origin of the species in ages past cannot be verified by experiment.
Science does not have answers on the meaning of life, whether there is purpose in the universe, morality, consciousness/mind (although they are working on this),
You seem to be mixing up some concepts here. You’ve been arguing that science “can not” (apparently) have an opinion about God or miracles, and here you’re saying that science “does not yet” have answers on consciousness. Is that true for morality, purpose and meaning or are those unrelated concepts in the same sentence?
Science doesn’t say “Fatima couldn’t have happened.” Science says “I don’t know how to explain the 70,000+ people who witnessed the sun’s movement.” Science is not wrong, science has no strong opinion on the matter.
This is a judgement against the miracle of Fatima. To not have any opinion regarding this powerful miracle is to judge the miracle as irrelevant.
 
I’m not sure what that means precisely but science does speak “about” miracles. “Science” these days concludes that miracles are “outside” of science. That is a statement about miracles and therefore science does draw a conclusion about miracles.

Science does have an “opinion” about miracles – namely, that science supposedly cannot talk about miracles. Science has concluded that miracles are not a subject of science, just making a judgement about miracles. So, it’s not true that science has no opinion about miracles.

This is a good example of science’s opinion about miracles.

Science judges (apparently) that Jesus’ resurrection was a “one-time rare event”. This is a judgement and opinion about miracles (which is false, by the way). If science had “no opinion” it wouldn’t judge if resurrections were one-time events or every day events.

As above, science concludes that the question of God’s existence is “outside of the scope of science”. So science has a strong opinion about the existence of God, namely, that it is irrelevant to science (and this is a major error).

Science does claim “I have no opinion” and then proceeds to establish an opinion, as shown above.

The origin of the species in ages past cannot be verified by experiment.

You seem to be mixing up some concepts here. You’ve been arguing that science “can not” (apparently) have an opinion about God or miracles, and here you’re saying that science “does not yet” have answers on consciousness. Is that true for morality, purpose and meaning or are those unrelated concepts in the same sentence?

This is a judgement against the miracle of Fatima. To not have any opinion regarding this powerful miracle is to judge the miracle as irrelevant.
GO REGGIE IT’S YOUR BIRTHDAY!!!
 
how can you say that ALL CREATIONISTS are dishonest? How about the magisterium clearly saying you CAN’T BELIEVE IN POLYGENISM?
I’m missing the logical connection between those two sentences… if there is one…
science basically says that miracles can’t happen. Sorry it is true.
No it’s not. You can find scientists who say that miracles can’t happen (and they’re wrong), but natural science as such has no official position on the matter (because it can’t have an official position on the matter).
In the case of evolution many scientists do dispute it. True the vast majority of scientists do accept it, but there are those who do not.
And your point that follows from this stunning observation is… what?
The fact is we have clear teaching by Pius XII that contradicts evolution. CLEAR TEACHING!!!
APPARENTLY NOT.
Your argument here is about as logical as: we have clear teaching from the Bible that contradicts heliocentrism. CLEAR TEACHING!!! (…or however many exclamation points)
ON JUDGMENT DAY I’D WOULD RATHER BE WITH PIUS XII NOT SOME ATHIEST SCIENTISTS!!! THINK ABOUT THAT!!!
…

…

You know, you’re really not winning any points here.

When you’re ready to have a calm, rational argument with your opponent, let me know. Until then, this is getting ridiculous. Oh, and you starting multiple (at my last count: 3) threads on the same basic question regarding the truth of evolution… you might want to consider giving that a break too, because that’s not helping either.
Science does have an “opinion” about miracles – namely, that science supposedly cannot talk about miracles. Science has concluded that miracles are not a subject of science, just making a judgement about miracles. So, it’s not true that science has no opinion about miracles.

Science judges (apparently) that Jesus’ resurrection was a “one-time rare event” … If science had “no opinion” it wouldn’t judge if resurrections were one-time events or every day events.

As above, science concludes that the question of God’s existence is “outside of the scope of science”. So science has a strong opinion about the existence of God, namely, that it is irrelevant to science (and this is a major error).
This is silly. If anyone is making judgments about anything, it’s the scientists, not science, doing the judging. Furthermore, the conclusion that “miracles are not a subject of science” is not a opinion or a judgment. It’s a conclusion that necessarily follows from the facts that (1) natural science by definition can only speak of natural things, and (2) miracles are by definition supernatural, resurrections are by definition miracles, and the existence of God is an inherently metaphysical question. Thus these things do not (and cannot) fall under the scope of natural science. Q.E.D.
To not have any opinion regarding [the miracle of Fatima] is to judge the miracle as irrelevant.
Um… no. Not having an opinion does not equal having an opinion that it is irrelevant. If you opine (or judge) that it’s irrelevant, then by definition you have an opinion. And we’ve already shown above how natural science cannot have any opinion regarding miracles, because miracles are supernatural.
 
I’m missing the logical connection between those two sentences… if there is one…

No it’s not. You can find scientists who say that miracles can’t happen (and they’re wrong), but natural science as such has no official position on the matter (because it can’t have an official position on the matter).

And your point that follows from this stunning observation is… what?

APPARENTLY NOT.
Your argument here is about as logical as: we have clear teaching from the Bible that contradicts heliocentrism. CLEAR TEACHING!!! (…or however many exclamation points)

…

…

You know, you’re really not winning any points here.

When you’re ready to have a calm, rational argument with your opponent, let me know. Until then, this is getting ridiculous. Oh, and you starting multiple (at my last count: 3) threads on the same basic question regarding the truth of evolution… you might want to consider giving that a break too, because that’s not helping either.

This is silly. If anyone is making judgments about anything, it’s the scientists, not science, doing the judging. Furthermore, the conclusion that “miracles are not a subject of science” is not a opinion or a judgment. It’s a conclusion that necessarily follows from the facts that (1) natural science by definition can only speak of natural things, and (2) miracles are by definition supernatural, resurrections are by definition miracles, and the existence of God is an inherently metaphysical question. Thus these things do not (and cannot) fall under the scope of natural science. Q.E.D.

Um… no. Not having an opinion does not equal having an opinion that it is irrelevant. If you opine (or judge) that it’s irrelevant, then by definition you have an opinion. And we’ve already shown above how natural science cannot have any opinion regarding miracles, because miracles are supernatural.
calm down chief----They are related threads, but they arent the same threads. Ok question —are you saying Pius XII doesnt teach that polygenism can’t be held by Catholics? You said apparently not above.
How about (instead of alluding to it here) you go to the other threads and comment on, what I believe to be the clear teaching, that evolution is contradicted by the councils I quoted.
 
question —are you saying Pius XII doesnt teach that polygenism can’t be held by Catholics? You said apparently not above.
Nope, sorry if I was unclear. I was simply referring to your statement that we had “clear teaching by Pius XII that contradicts evolution”. Because condemning polygenism does not contradict evolution. Because evolution does not, strictly speaking, require that polygenism be true. Furthermore, the theory of evolution itself has virtually no bearing on whether or not all men are descended from a single set of parents (monogenism) – all that evolution is really concerned with is the material origin of the human body. Evolution and monogenism/polygenism are pretty much a completely separate (albeit related) questions.
 
This is silly. If anyone is making judgments about anything, it’s the scientists, not science, doing the judging.
Mr. Vaz was the one who stated that science was making the judgement.
Furthermore, the conclusion that “miracles are not a subject of science” is not a opinion or a judgment.
I disagree. It certainly is an opinion. It’s not a scientific conclusion at all.
It’s a conclusion that necessarily follows from the facts that (1) natural science by definition can only speak of natural things,
“By definition” assumes that there is one, correct definition of what science is. But there is no one certainly correct definition. Thus, you’re offering opinions about science and the supernatural.
Thus these things do not (and cannot) fall under the scope of natural science. Q.E.D.
Thus, you (or “scientists”) have rendered a judgement about God and the supernatural – namely, that science cannot speak about them (you’ve added the term “natural” to science for some reason).
Um… no. Not having an opinion does not equal having an opinion that it is irrelevant.
The decison to not have an opinion is based on an assessment of the relevance of God and the supernatural. That assessment, which is necessary to judge whether to have an opinion or not, is a judgement about God and the supernatural.
If you opine (or judge) that it’s irrelevant, then by definition you have an opinion. And we’ve already shown above how natural science cannot have any opinion regarding miracles, because miracles are supernatural.
Your second sentence is an opinion and a judgement about miracles. Where has science proven that miracles are supernatural?
 
– all that evolution is really concerned with is the material origin of the human body.
I find that to be a very strange opinion. I’m pretty sure you don’t mean what you said although I would like to see your justification for that statement.
 
Mr. Vaz was the one who stated that science was making the judgement.
Well… that definitely wasn’t how I read the discussion. PhilVaz said nothing more than that “science does not have an opinion”, and then you filled in all of the “judgment” language from there. Not that you were intentionally misinterpreting his position – but I didn’t think he was actually saying what you seemed to take from it.
I disagree. It certainly is an opinion. It’s not a scientific conclusion at all.
There’s more in this world than simply “opinion” and “scientific conclusions”. No, it’s not a scientific conclusion – at least not in the way you’re using the term scientific – but it is still a necessary conclusion, because it logically follows from the very definition of the terms.
“By definition” assumes that there is one, correct definition of what science is. But there is no one certainly correct definition.
I think there is… but regardless, that’s not the way in which I’m using the term “science”. I’m operating primarily off of the Aristotelian/Thomistic definition of the term science, which is simply knowledge (from Latin: scientia). A particular science is simply a particular body of knowledge, whether it be natural science, mathematical science, the science of Sacred Doctrine, or whatever other things you can have sciences of.

Our modern habit of replacing the term natural science with the simpler (but more ambiguous) term science is, I think, rather unfortunate, for this very reason. However, regardless of what we call it, it’s still the exact same thing that it always was. The natural sciences – otherwise known as our modern sciences – are fundamentally (by definition) concerned with only natural things, whether it be physics, biology, geology, meterology, or astronomy. But the supernatural can never be considered by the natural sciences, because the supernatural is (simply according to the meaning of the term) above the natural. The natural sciences are, just as modern science correctly claims to be, inherently incapable or adressing the concerns of metaphysics.
(you’ve added the term “natural” to science for some reason).
You caught me. 😃 …but if you’ve read the above response by now, hopefully you understand why I did this. It’s definitely a very important distinction here.
Thus, you (or “scientists”) have rendered a judgement about God and the supernatural – namely, that science cannot speak about them.

The decision to not have an opinion is based on an assessment of the relevance of God and the supernatural. That assessment, which is necessary to judge whether to have an opinion or not, is a judgement about God and the supernatural.
It must be so, because the natural sciences simply cannot address metaphysical concerns. And it’s not like this is just something that we all happened to get together and agree upon – it can’t be otherwise, because you can’t just arbitrarily change what the proper object of natural science is – because if you changed the proper object of the science, it wouldn’t be the same science anymore… it would be a different science concerned with something else.
Where has science proven that miracles are supernatural?
You can’t “prove” definitions – you just have to take them up according to what we mean when we use the term. The supernatural character of miracles is simply part of what it is to be a miracle – if an event was not supernatural in origin (or at least thought to be supernatural in origin) then people wouldn’t every actually consider it to be a miracle.
masterjedi747 said:
-- all that evolution is really concerned with is the material origin of the human body.
I find that to be a very strange opinion. I’m pretty sure you don’t mean what you said although I would like to see your justification for that statement.

I’m pretty sure I did mean what I said… but maybe you’re reading my statement differently than I had intended. Why do you find this to be a strange opinion, exactly?

Humani Generis: “…the Teaching Authority of the Church does not forbid that, in conformity with the present state of human sciences and sacred theology, research and discussions, on the part of men experienced in both fields, take place with regard to the doctrine of evolution, in as far as it inquires into the origin of the human body as coming from pre-existent and living matter - for the Catholic faith obliges us to hold that souls are immediately created by God.”
 
As I quoted earlier the Church teaches God created the world “out of nothing” ------do you evolutionists agree with that??? HOW CAN MODERN SCIENCE REMOTELY SUPPORT THAT?

**What has **​

  • an unique Divine act “outside” creation
    **to do with **
  • **things accessible to science & other human knowledge **
    **They are not the same kind of thing. At this rate we’re going to be expected to find God’s DOB, place of domicile, & ID card 😦 God is not man - men have such things, because they exist within **creation, & not outside it. Unlike God. A God who could be evidenced or disproved by anything within creation, would be no God at all.
**As well might a character within a story conclude that because he cannot find any trace of the author the other characters believe to exist, the author is a fiction. Yet without the author, the denier would not exist, let alone make his denials. And the analogy is defective, because God is greater far than any human author: at best, human authors are “sub-creators”, rather like demiurges. God is God - He cannot be discovered from what is not God. Only God is able to make Himself known. To treat Him as though were no mere more than a man writ large, a sort of “giant in the sky”, is not to believe in God, but in a god. **
 
I know of no official magisteriul texts that talk about Genesis being symbolic. Like I said earlier, almost all the Church Fathers believed in a literal interpretation of Genesis. Numerous Popes have arned against evolution in official texts, Pius X being one of them. The new catechism mentions nothing about evolution. (despite Jimmy Akin’s attempts–see Sungenis’ rebutal to him–I love you Jimmy) You may have a speech or a publication that alludes to evolution, but none in official magisterial texts.
Let me ask you something Bob, er, Roger.😉 If the Church has infallibly opposed evolution and at least the current and previous popes support evolution (at least in some form), does that make them heretics? I know you reject anything other than encyclicals or councils as only personal opinion, but considering the weight people give the writings and personal opinions of popes, wouldn’t expressing a personal opinion that is contrary to an infallible Church teaching constitute a heresy, thereby making them heretics?
Also Vatican I taught infallibly that God created “out of nothing” that there was no pre-existing matter before God’s creation. Do you believe that? Or are you going to cower to science.
I accept that. See the “Big Bang”.

Peace

Tim
 
I answered Roger’s (rogerteder) post a while ago. He keeps bringing up the same things.

(1) Roger confuses science with miracles. The resurrection was a one-time or rare event – Jesus rose bodily from the dead. Science has nothing to say about such miracles. They are not testable, they are not repeatable.

**That is also why they cannot be found out by historical criteria: science, & history & every other form of non-supernatural knowledge, relies on analogies within creation. This Unique Event is untestable because it is Unique not in number only but in character: other resurrections are possible only because of this Unique Resurrection. To be testable, a second Calvary & a second Christ & a second God would be needed. 🙂 IOW, the Resurrection is not an historical event, any more than the Creation is. To call it that is to say far too little of it. 😦 **​

This one-time event wasn’t (directly) observed. True, bodies do not normally rise from the dead, says science and reason. But “God raised Jesus from the dead” is the best explanation of what happened given the historical context. (E.G. death of Jesus on the cross, His tomb was found empty, the appearances of Jesus alive to various witnesses after His death, and the origin of the Christian faith, etc). See all of William Lane Craig’s successful debates or the exhaustive The Resurrection of the Son of God by Anglican N.T. Wright or the video by Ignatius Press.

bringyou.to/apologetics/IgnatiusResurrectionDVD.jpg

(2) Roger asks why can’t we reject science when it comes to creationism (a young earth in particular) ? Because it is not logical to do so. It is against reason. We’ve known the earth is millions of years old for at least 150 years, and precisely 4.5 billion years old for over fifty years. Science has confirmed these findings over and over. Even Pius XII acknowledges the ancient age of the earth (see John Paul II quote of Pius XII in "Cosmology and Fundamental Physics")

POPE JOHN PAUL II: “Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth – in a word, to know himself – so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves.” (Fides et Ratio [1998], cf. Ex 33:18; Ps 27:8-9; 63:2-3; Jn 14:8; 1 Jn 3:2).
  1. Faith and science: “…methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God. The humble and persevering investigator of the secrets of nature is being led, as it were, by the hand of God in spite of himself, for it is God, the conserver of all things, who made them what they are.” [Vatican II GS 36:1] (also 283-284)
CARDINAL SCHONBORN:…
“The Catholic position on this is clear. St. Thomas says that ‘one should not try to defend the Christian faith with arguments that are so patently opposed to reason that the faith is made to look ridiculous.’ It is simply nonsense to say that the world is only 6000 years old. To try to prove this scientifically is what St. Thomas calls provoking the irrisio infidelium, the scorn of the unbelievers. It is not right to use such false arguments and to expose the faith to the scorn of unbelievers. This should suffice on the subject of ‘creationism’ and ‘fundamentalism’ for the entire remainder of this catechesis; what we want to say about it should be so clear that we do not have to return to the subject.” (Christoph Cardinal Schonborn, Cat Lec for 11/13/2005)

Clear enough for you?

(3) Roger says all past theologians, the Church Fathers, and past Popes were all creationists (meaning young earth). What he doesn’t mention is that all SCIENTISTS were creationists as well. Up until Galileo, all scientists (and theologians, and churchmen) were geocentrists. The scientific evidence is what changed their mind. It wasn’t a conspiracy. The young earth became an old earth because of the scientific evidence. Read and learn about it. No need to hug or kiss it. 😛 Some of your most prominent geologists who discovered these truths were Catholics and Christians. The history is layed out in detail here. Read it, learn it, don’t kiss it. 😛

MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL.

Phil P

**And to you 🙂 **​

 
Nice Job Phil!!! Merry Christmas!! Here is my point. Scientists would say it is impossible for a man to be dead and rise from the dead. Yet you would reject that, and say with God all things are possible, correct?

**It depends what this means. Miracle is not whimsy. The sentence “God can become a Swiss cheese on Mars” is not made intelligible by starting with the words “God can…”. Otherwise, "God can uggle buggle ooger booger zippity zoo"would convey meaning. For now at least, it does not. **​

**The problem is that people try to defend words instead of things - IOW, they are Nominalists, not Realists. Instead of looking at words as primary, we need to look at things as primary. What things are, is not changed by their names; instead, “names are consequences of things”, & not vice versa. For a daisy to grow from the ground is not a miracle - that is how those two entities are related. For a human being to turn into a tree would be a monstrosity, not a miracle, because it is not within human nature, but contrary to it, to sprout leaves or grow bark or to take root in the earth. Miracles are not monstrosities. If anything could happen, nature would be unintelligible & unknowable, because anything would be possible: hemlock could be deadly poison one minute, & life-giving the next. Rocks might speak, trees vomit fire, & men turn into pigs. **

**If God can do anything, then he can turn the Ark into the Enterprise NCC-1701, & send it to Aldebaran for the duration of the Flood. “Anything” can mean, well, anything. If He can do anything, why did He not convert the world instead of drowning it ? Appeals to Divine Omnipotence as a deus ex machina are pointless, because nothing is ruled out on grounds of plausibility. It is not at all plausible that a monstrous fish devoured the waters of the Flood, but it explains how they vanished so soon, & sets the stage for Jonah to travel in said fish. And those who try to solve problems by appealing to Divine Omnipotence can, by their own argument, not rule the suggestion out. **
One of the reasons you would say this is because the Church teaches it. My assertion is that official Church statements support creationism, not evolution. Not to mention there are Catholics who (Bob Sungenis being one of them, Kolbe center etc.) who dispute evolution on a scientific basis.

QUESTION PHIL AND OTHERS: Do you believe Jesus actually physically rose from the dead or do you believe it was a spiritual resurrection?
  • **Are the two different, or even opposed ? **
  • "Physical" is ambiguous
 
There’s more in this world than simply “opinion” and “scientific conclusions”. No, it’s not a scientific conclusion – at least not in the way you’re using the term scientific – but it is still a necessary conclusion, because it logically follows from the very definition of the terms.
It’s an opinion based on how someone defines science.
I think there is… but regardless, that’s not the way in which I’m using the term “science”.
Ok, it’s a subjective decision on your part.
You caught me. 😃 …but if you’ve read the above response by now, hopefully you understand why I did this. It’s definitely a very important distinction here.
No, I found that to be dishonest, really.
It must be so, because the natural sciences simply cannot address metaphysical concerns. And it’s not like this is just something that we all happened to get together and agree upon – it can’t be otherwise, because you can’t just arbitrarily change what the proper object of natural science is – because if you changed the proper object of the science, it wouldn’t be the same science anymore… it would be a different science concerned with something else.
That is an excellent point. It certainly would make science different, but there’s no reason why it could not still be defined as science – since that definition just depends on what people agree on. But there’s no objective reason why science cannot have an opinion about God since science is based on a philosophical foundation – science could easily assert that it accepts that God exists and that studies of the natural world touch on the work that God has done in creation. Certainly that is true of the study of human beings.
I’m pretty sure I did mean what I said… but maybe you’re reading my statement differently than I had intended. Why do you find this to be a strange opinion, exactly?
As I read it …

– all that evolution is really concerned with is the material origin of the human body.

… I didn’t understand how you could say that. Evolution is concerned with much more than merely the material origin of the human body.
 
Tim science is clearly wrong about the resurrection. Why cant it be wrong about evolution? Pope Benedict XVI never said any such thing about monogenism. Even if he did his speeches and private interviews arent Church teaching. They are his private opinions. We have clear magisterial statements that Genesis is to be taken literally. Why can’t we say the resurrection was spiritual and not literal. Science indicates this is impossible.
Now, being both an engineer and someone who takes their Catholicism seriously, I would say that it looks like you’re trying to create an artificial barrier between science and religion. There is no reason at all why science and religion should be at odds with each other, when science does nothing more than to set-out to study God’s creation. Science, like religion, can be abused, and we have seen both in the past, but the Church is there to guide us on how to live a moral life, which pervades into science.

So, considering that science is only based off of the scientific method which is experimental and based off of man’s experience in the natural world, then I would say that scientifically speaking it is impossible to be resurrected, if you assume that God does not exist. Think of God as a mathematical axiom; you have to take for granted that certain mathematical principals just plain exist, and I tend to think of God’s existence as one such axiom.

As for evolution, the Church always has and always will maintain that there was at some point one set of parents, Adam and Eve. Evolution is, at most, a scientific theory, and it can at most, only account for a method that God used to create these two parents. However, we know that God infused Adam and Eve with an immortal soul and gave them free will, something that evolution cannot account for. Evolution could be flat out wrong, but one of the chief things to remember is that science does not profess to be fundamental truth, but to be explanations which have held up to certain scrutinies that best explain our experiences.
 
I’m a little confused as to what side Rogerteder is taking. It seems like he’s trolling for some inconsistency to cling onto and debate.

As for the original question, isn’t this more of a question of Does God Really exist? Because if you, Rogerteder, truly believe in the existence of an omnipotent God, why should resurrection be impossible? Why can’t science, mere laws of physics and biology, be wielded and manipulated by an omnipotent God to yield this ‘miracle’?
 
Does the supernatural overlap with the natural? Is matter entirely separate from the spiritual or supernatural aspect (especially of human beings)?

Those are questions that materialistic philosophy ignores (or wrongly concludes are false).

If the supernatural does intersect with the natural, then what effect does it have, especially on the development of man or animal species?

This is where evolutionism is incompatible with Catholicism.
 
If the supernatural does intersect with the natural, then what effect does it have, especially on the development of man or animal species?

This is where evolutionism is incompatible with Catholicism.
How?

God made man, gave him superior attributes that increased his chances of survival, he became the fittest and was naturally selected due to such favored attributes. And thus we live today. Where’s the incompatibility?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top