converted and learned the beauty and meaning of being married Catholics. NFP opened our hearts to more children. Each of their blessed little lives opened our hearts to a new brother or sister. The experience of the marital embrace totally changed for us.
The dynamics of a large family is not that of a small family. There is naturally some fighting, argueing, rough housing, laughing, sharing in joys and sorrows, supporting, etc and at a louder decible than a small family. Both large and small families can be dysfunctional or functional–it has nothing to do with family size and everything to do with parenting and personalities. If one of my daughters came to me with a need for privacy, I’d ask her what she wanted to do with privacy. Was it a need for quiet, for being alone, for thinking, for doing homework, to get into trouble? And then we’d solve the problem, though I doubt it would be with her own room.
Actually, I have an excellent concept of “authentic” Church teaching - as I am finishing my masters in ecclesiastical history and have also been studying to work with the DRE - and the people at this parish are well acquainted with my views. Honestly, I don’t think you understood what I meant when I mentioned that the kids “help out with the Duggar family”
When one “buddies” up with another sibling- that child isn’t just helping out with a couple of chores or the occaisional diaper change - that older child become the Responsible party for the younger child - in other words acts as a fill in mom for that child - carrying the child around, changing diapers or taking to the toilet, bathing, feeding etc. etc. - all the thing a mother should be doing, not a child. While I have no qualms with a nanny doing this, no child should be saddled with having to constantly change diapers, feed and take care of another child- I can’t imagine my parents ever having the audacity to expect something like that from me -persoanlly if my parents had ever tried something like that, chances are I would have resented them and very possibly the child I had been stuck with caring for. In my opinion, those kids are sheltered from the real world and basically convinced that this is what is “normal” in todays society.
As far as Japan goes- when you’ve been brought up in that society, let me know, until then, don’t even try to comprehend the social dynamics of a society with which you are not familiar. Having been brought up in that society, I can tell you that it is an EXTREME rarity for there to be more than 2-3 children per family and has been for years (actually the average number of children is 1.35 kids). Birth control is a norm for a very high percentage of the society and I hate to tell some people on here that think that birth control is causing much of the divorce rate, but if you take Japan as an example, the divorce rate is only 13% - (granted this is the high estimate) -The main reason Japanese say they don’t have more children is because they don’t feel they can provide well enough for more children. Granted, 100 years ago it was different as female infanticide was not uncommon. Mortgages in Japan are often passed down from father to son or even father to daughter (if there is no son) - if I currently lived in Japan and had 6 children as you do, I can garuntee you that I would be looked if not down upon than looked at if I had a problem being responsible (I am not saying that you are I’m just saying that this would be a large possibility if you were in Japan) -
As far as birth control goes, I have had to use it for medical reasons - and I must say that there was no difference in our marriage as far as closeness in the “marital embrace” goes when we use the birth control and when we went against our Doctor’s advice and tried NFP for quite sometime. (And we stuck to the method religiously and still got pregnant - twice and I became extremely ill both times - almost bled out to the point of death once) So clearly, NFP doesn’t work for every couple (just like the pill doesn’t work for every couple either) - Granted, there are some people on here that it works wonderfully for, and more power to them. I’m thrilled it worked for you and you felt you got more out of your marriage - I’m sorry the pill made you ill. It (NFP) isn’t something that is an option for us. I don’t feel used or under appreciated or like an object because we have to use birth control and I certainly don’t feel like my husband doesn’t “appreciate” my fertility or understand it. There is no form of birth control that is a “one size fits all” model.
I noticed that when you answered the question regarding privacy with one of your girls you said you’d ask them some questions - but you got down to wondering if she wanted privacy in order to possibly get into trouble. I’m not going to say anything else about that -
As far as IVF goes, it’s easy to say with 6 kids that you don’t agree with it - but I know plenty of Catholics who didn’t believe in it until they were unable to conceive on their own. Now they literally thank God they were able to have a child that way.
I’m not trying to be down on you or anything - I think it’s great that you’ve gotten what you decided you wanted as a family. But personally, that wouldn’t work for us - I’m glad that my kids won’t have to worry about sharing a room, having hand me downs, not being one of the only families who isn’t vacationing in whatever the neat place that year to vacation is or other things like that. And if it means having less children to be able to do that then my husband and I are o.k. with that. There are positives to be said about having children both ways - each way gives each child something different - perhaps with yours they would learn more patience or how to share better - perhaps with mine, I’ll be able to take each to Japan or Europe each summer and they’ll always have the most up to date devices to work with. It doesn’t have to be one way or the other each way has positive and negative parts.
As far as the comment about the muslims and what Quadafi said about not needing terrorists but needing more time (implying that eventually there would be so many more muslims that their “job” would be easier) - personally, that does scare me, but it doesn’ t make me want to go out and have as many children as possible.
Thanks for sharing your opinion -
God Bless-
Rye