BP Duped the President

  • Thread starter Thread starter MugenOne
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MugenOne

Guest
Savannah (GA) Morning News
Letters to the editor
Thursday July 8, 2010

BP Duped the President

It seems a miracle that our beloved leader was able to convince BP to establish a $20 billion slush (oops, escrow) fund to compensate those hurt by the ongoing oil plume in the Gulf of Mexico . After all, he had no constitutional power to force them to do so; so he had to resort to Chicago-style negotiating.
But, let us take a closer look at the effect on BP’s finances:
  1. BP will establish a $20 billion fund, but will pay only $7 billion into it during 2010.
  2. BP is a British corporation, but has a very large operating entity in the U.S.
  3. By Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), BP must book the entire $20 billion expense in the year accrued. Therefore, they will book a $20 billion expense in 2010, reducing their U.S. tax liability by $7 billion.
  4. Our dear leader also convinced this massive corporation to show their concern for the “small people” by withholding dividends to their shareholders for the last three quarters of 2010. This reduces their outward cash flow by about $7.5 billion, including approximately 40 percent of that amount to U.S. citizens. Assuming the Bush tax cuts will survive through 2010, the U.S. Treasury will lose another $450 million in taxes on that amount. We won’t even discuss the effect on the U.S. economy.
Let’s review the results:

BP Cash Flow
Escrow funding ($7 billion)
Dividend saving $7.5 billion
Tax savings $7 billion
Net favorable cash flow: $7.5 billion

US Treasury Tax Receipts
BP Corporate income tax lost ($7.5 billion)
BP Shareholders’ income tax lost ($0.45 billion)
Net unfavorable tax receipts: ($7.95 billion)

savannahnow.com/opinion/2010-07-08/letters-editor-thursday

I guess we really should expect this. After all, our dear leader is the most inexperienced man in any room he walks into.
 
BP Cash Flow
Escrow funding ($7 billion)
Dividend saving $7.5 billion
Tax savings $7 billion
Net favorable cash flow: $7.5 billion
US Treasury Tax Receipts
BP Corporate income tax lost ($7.5 billion)
BP Shareholders’ income tax lost ($0.45 billion)
Net unfavorable tax receipts: ($7.95 billion)
So the US lost money (at least short term) from BP paying $20b.

I guess this shows that even compensation has a price…

One question though – why was the President let to discuss this matter with BP officials (one of the largest companies worldwide) - instead of whoever is in charge of US finances? Surely; leadership is as much about good delagation as it is leading.
 
So the US lost money (at least short term) from BP paying $20b.

I guess this shows that even compensation has a price…

One question though – why was the President let to discuss this matter with BP officials (one of the largest companies worldwide) - instead of whoever is in charge of US finances? Surely; leadership is as much about good delagation as it is leading.
It’s just cronyism. It wasn’t the President doing the negotiations, but his staff. If the finance staff had the same level of technical expertise as the “scientists” on the Obama team who work working on the clean-up, it’s no surprise. We have friends who work for BP and the meetings with the Obama people were excruciatingly slow because the so-called “experts” did not have science/engineering backgrounds. One had to have the weight of water explained to him. :eek:
 
Obama traded off cold hard cash for a few good sound bytes?

Win, win?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top