Burning Corn More Efficient Than Manufacturing Biofuels, Study Says

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
Yale Environment 360:

**
Burning Corn More Efficient Than Manufacturing Biofuels, Study Says
**

[well, DUH!]
The most efficient way to convert corn into energy is to burn the kernels to generate electricity, rather than processing the plant into biofuels, according to a study in the journal Science. Research by a scientist at the University of California, Merced, showed that burning corn to produce electricity for electric-powered vehicles produces 56 percent more energy per acre than converting the corn to biofuels. The combustion of corn to generate electricity for cars also produced about half the greenhouse gases as the conversion of corn to ethanol, according to the study.
Meanwhile, a study by the environmental groups Friends of the Earth and Earth Track projects that the continuing expansion of federal subsidies to produce ethanol from corn and cellulosic materials, such as cheatgrass, could cost taxpayers $420 billion through 2022. The Obama administration is calling for the rapid expansion of biofuel production from non-food crops, and anticipated federal subsidies for the program are likely to average $28 billion a year, according to the study.
 
No, Big Corn is funding the lobbyists who keep them in ethanol subsidies.

The green lie is just one more nail in the coffin of our economy.
 
:rotfl: Awesome. I must say, being from a large corn producing state (MN) the ethanol thing was not very well thought out. :shrug:They didn’t considered with the increased demand on corn, food prices would rise, nor did they consider that growing all that corn and producing ethanol take a considerable amount of water, helping to deplete the water tables.

I guess my mother’s family had it right when they had to burn corn husks to keep warm after they ran out of other fuel. :winter:
 
Midwest farmers have been burning corn for many, many years. A “corn stove” is similar to a pellet stove, with an auger feed system to the firebox. Many of these stoves/furnaces have been used in barns and other outbuildings on these farms. They have become somewhat popular for residential use too, a similar alternative to a pellet stove (which uses manufactured pellets).
These farmers grow their own corn, they plant a certain percentage above their required yield (for feedstock) for this fuel. They have the land, the equipment, etc so it becomes more economical for them the plant “extra” for heating use.
Direct combustion of corn is a good idea, it bypasses the expensive processing to make ethanol. But it is only good for “furnace heating” and not much else. It cannot be used for motive power in raw form. Plus the BTU content is more than wood but not too much higher. I think it rates higher than typical “pellets” because of the corn oil.
Nothing beats fossil fuels at this point in terms of energy density, and the energy in vs energy out dynamic. Sure there are obvious costs in terms of exploration, extraction, refining, transport, etc. But one unit of gasoline produces many times more work than similar units of other “green alternatives”. Which is why thus far, oil is hard to beat. Plus it’s apples to oranges comparisons with all fuels; if you want to power a car on corn you would need to install a boiler and use it to create steam. The Stanley Steamer was a innovative car at the time but it didn’t catch on then; I doubt it would catch on now 🙂 (although if “Smart Cars” can sell like they do I bet someone would buy a “steamer” too)
 
Someone needs to explain the government’s duplicity in all this biofuels nonsence. I Agree with others here that this is just another form of government subsidizing farmers to gain more political hay from favored constituents. I have to say “what a country” and laugh at the gullibility of fellow Americans for falling for the nonsensical idea of putting in 10% less energy into one’s car fuel tank (The energy density [BTU’s per gallon] is substantially lower in ethanol than in gasoline) for MORE expensive fuel that requires more refueling stops to go the same distance! Then we have to have the government explain why we impose a $.54/gallon tariff on imported ethanol from countries that can produce and supply ethanol much more efficiently and at lower costs from Sugar Cane. Sugar Cane grown on equatorial climates (Brazil) can produce double crops in the same growing season and yield much higher rates of ethanol. How ironic that the USA must talk out of both sides of its mouth on lowering carbon emissions while doubly subsidizing US corn growers at the same time it punishes and discourages importation of much cheaper supplies of ethanol from foreign sources. Who’s kidding who here? In the mean time the cost for livestock protein (corn fed swine and cow) escalates - seems people’s tastes and preferences tend to favor the conversion of vegetable protein (corn) to animal flesh forms of protein.

What a completely irrational and duplicitous thing we have going on here in the USA biofuels market. It’s really time to rethink our entire modus operandi in mass transportation. The personal automobile as an expression of personal freedom is a thing we as a nation can no longer afford or cope with. This mode of transportation is outdated and inefficient. It would be much more effective to cut down on all our roads and maintenance expenses and massive infrastructure support (insurance, police, repairs, litigation, manufacturing etc.) by simply phasing the auto out or by dramatically reducing its contribution to transportation modes. We could use more massive public transportation in large point to point interstate and intercity transportation networks using more efficient electrical system (power company turbine produced electric is MUCH more efficient than what smal IC engines can produce from gasoline). It is even more nonsensical to use lead-acid hybrid cars just to keep the single car trasnportation mode!

As an alternative mode we could use a much smaller fleet of “rental”/metered semi automated tracked electric cars for personal inter-community services etc. when mass trasport does not meet the general needs.

The USA is a victim of Ford’s discovery of an efficient assembly line production mode of manufacturing. No one has gone back to re-look at if it was really wise to base the entire transportation mode on what is essentially a manufacturing process efficiency - that is now ironically produced off shore by foreign competitors anyway. This is an 'inside out" and irrational way to run the country. We should be producing what we need from a holistic and rational transportation policy and systemic design approach - not having “the tail wag the dog” as we currently do.

Getting off on tangents here - but this whole thing is just so much nonsence that I can’t take any of it serious anymore. “What a country” where we pay more to put essentially water in our fuel tank, pay more for it both in food and fuel costs then stop more often to refuel; all while preventing cheaper fuel from foreign suppliers! MADNESS…

BF
 
Ethanol is not a bad idea. Making it from corn is a terrible idea.

Brazil uses ethanol as a motor fuel and it is made from sugar cane. There is no waste product left over that cannot be used again. Of course, Brazil has a climate that is good for growing sugar cane, while much of the US does not have that climate.

Natural gas is a better fuel than anything else available today. Autos can easily be converted to run on natural gas and it should be possible to refuel a natural gas powered vehicle from one’s own home. A long distance drive would be problematic, but that would be the only real drawback.

Natural gas is superior to hybrids or electric powered vehicles that have to lug around a battery.
 
Does that mean there would be an abundance of popcorn?

I’m all for it.

Wonder if they can give it that kettle corn flavor…my favorite.
 
I must say, being from a large corn producing state (MN) the ethanol thing was not very well thought out. :shrug:They didn’t considered with the increased demand on corn, food prices would rise, nor did they consider that growing all that corn and producing ethanol take a considerable amount of water, helping to deplete the water tables.
These are good points but, of course, burning corn to generate electricity would still divert food stock for energy production. So the problem of food price increases would still be there.

However, burning corn for electricity may not be economically viable. Essentially, it would be a replacement for coal, which is (excuse me) dirt cheap. If corn were equally cheap, I think we would already be using it instead of using coal - which is well known for pollution.

So burning corn may be a more efficient way to some form of energy, but in terms of electrical production it likely is an economic non-starter… The same is true of burning biomass (switchgrass, cornstalks, etc) although for reasons of higher transportation and handling costs required to produce one unit of electricity, due to the much higher volumes of fuel necessary.

And then there is the matter of whether electric vehicles are viable. I have serious reservations that the cars being introduced this fall will do well, once people have experience with their lower performance compared to an internal combustion engine.

I think liquid fuels will be with us for some time, as they give the performance that is expected (at least by Americans.) Natural gas holds promise. My father mentioned once that in his youth, vehicles were sometimes powered by propane.

I agree that corn-based ethanol is a mistake. Certainly sugar cane based ethanol makes more sense, and perhaps even sugar beets. However, my understanding is that the use of food stock for ethanol was meant to be a temporary stepping stone to using biomass. I don’t think biomass is commercially feasible yet, but it still holds promise.
 
Does that mean there would be an abundance of popcorn?

I’m all for it.

Wonder if they can give it that kettle corn flavor…my favorite.
I’ve heard that vehicles running on biodiesel based on vegetable oil smell like french fries. I wonder if the ones based on corn smell like popcorn? That would be cool. :cool:
 
That’s why I’ve said MickeyDs should get into the biodiesel business. They sell their used fryer oil for biodiesel, and the use of it causes french fry cravings! They could increase their revenues by BILLIONS with that kind of circular generating stream.
 
Making popcorn at an open house, public event, even when selling house, creates a happy mood I’m told from realtors. It’s a pleasant aroma that most people like. With our world smelling like french fries and popped corn it may actually make it a happier place 🙂

Personally I don’t want a government subsidized micro-car that only takes me back and forth from work. Even if it burns corn 🙂

Personal ownership of a car is probably one of the most treasured purchases in America because it represents freedom, something that we often take for granted. Oil has made this happen. Oil and other fossil fuels have also improved the quality of our lives. Coal and wood burning stories from our fathers and grandfathers make the improvements provided by fossil fuels very evident. Turning off the “oil valve” is foolhardy without truly understanding the benefits to our quality of living. A rush to “alternatives” without fully understanding the quality of life benefits we all enjoy will only move us backwards.
 
Personal ownership of a car is probably one of the most treasured purchases in America because it represents freedom, something that we often take for granted. Oil has made this happen. Oil and other fossil fuels have also improved the quality of our lives. Coal and wood burning stories from our fathers and grandfathers make the improvements provided by fossil fuels very evident. Turning off the “oil valve” is foolhardy without truly understanding the benefits to our quality of living. A rush to “alternatives” without fully understanding the quality of life benefits we all enjoy will only move us backwards.
The fish who takes the bait with hook and is then let to run with an open spool of line to keep the larger school close to the boat imagines it is free until the drag is set and he’s reeled in.

We are slaves to our oil dependency and our own freedom. We have depleted our own vast oil reserves long ago. The personal auto under a guise of freedom has become the very instrument by which we are all losing our freedom. The cost of that freedom is endless wars in the middle east and rising economic clout among anti-Christian countries who are more than happy to take its vig from the blessings of Christianity as a symbolic jezza tax of submission to finance our own eventual takeover or assimilation. Allowing ourselves to become slaves to an illusional and maliciously presented faux freedom is both stupid and deserved.

Just because we have a long rope to freely walk around the gallows don’t think for a moment that it can’t be reeled in and shorted at any time and used to hang our own fatted bodies more lethally. I never saw much sense in a condemned man adding to his own ballast by cooperating to eat a large last meal on the eve of his execution…

BF
 
Ethanol is not a bad idea. Making it from corn is a terrible idea.

Brazil uses ethanol as a motor fuel and it is made from sugar cane. There is no waste product left over that cannot be used again. Of course, Brazil has a climate that is good for growing sugar cane, while much of the US does not have that climate.

Natural gas is a better fuel than anything else available today. Autos can easily be converted to run on natural gas and it should be possible to refuel a natural gas powered vehicle from one’s own home. A long distance drive would be problematic, but that would be the only real drawback.

Natural gas is superior to hybrids or electric powered vehicles that have to lug around a battery.
I lost ya at the natural gas. It does burn “clean” which is a relative term anyway but the process of getting that gas is so destructive I can’t believe it’s actually legal to do. It completely poisons the ground water in the area it’s being extracted and that’s pretty unacceptable to me. I know we need energy but not energy at any cost of poisoning ourselves.
 
I lost ya at the natural gas. It does burn “clean” which is a relative term anyway but the process of getting that gas is so destructive I can’t believe it’s actually legal to do. It completely poisons the ground water in the area it’s being extracted and that’s pretty unacceptable to me. I know we need energy but not energy at any cost of poisoning ourselves.
Poisons the ground water in the area?

Be interested in learning how that takes place.

I know we are surrounded by oil fields down here, and we sometimes help the companies test local fresh water wells at peoples homes to make sure water floods are not injecting or leaking water into those zones. So far I’ve never heard of anyone’s water being poisoned.
 
The fish who takes the bait with hook and is then let to run with an open spool of line to keep the larger school close to the boat imagines it is free until the drag is set and he’s reeled in.

We are slaves to our oil dependency and our own freedom. We have depleted our own vast oil reserves long ago. The personal auto under a guise of freedom has become the very instrument by which we are all losing our freedom. The cost of that freedom is endless wars in the middle east and rising economic clout among anti-Christian countries who are more than happy to take its vig from the blessings of Christianity as a symbolic jezza tax of submission to finance our own eventual takeover or assimilation. Allowing ourselves to become slaves to an illusional and maliciously presented faux freedom is both stupid and deserved.

Just because we have a long rope to freely walk around the gallows don’t think for a moment that it can’t be reeled in and shorted at any time and used to hang our own fatted bodies more lethally. I never saw much sense in a condemned man adding to his own ballast by cooperating to eat a large last meal on the eve of his execution…

BF
It does need to be remembered, though, that all money spent on foreign goods has to come home eventually. It may be through other parties, it may be purchase of debt, it may be to buy goods or services. But it absolutely has to come home.

Seems to me, the worst part of the situation is not that, e.g., Saudi Arabia sells us oil, it’s that our government doesn’t live within our means. If we weren’t borrowing so much money from foreigners, those who sell us oil would be forced to “return the money” in the form of purchases or investments.

Regardless, it is my impression that our biggest sources of oil are actually Mexico and Canada, and I see no reason why reasonable balances of payments could not be arranged with them. Our biggest trade deficit is with China.

Finally, I am not sure we have exhausted our petroleum resources. Certainly, we have not exhausted coal reserves. What we have exhausted is our will to utilize the resources we have, and are chasing after fantasy resources for the sake of lobbyists for those fantasies.
 
It does need to be remembered, though, that all money spent on foreign goods has to come home eventually. It may be through other parties, it may be purchase of debt, it may be to buy goods or services. But it absolutely has to come home.

Seems to me, the worst part of the situation is not that, e.g., Saudi Arabia sells us oil, it’s that our government doesn’t live within our means. If we weren’t borrowing so much money from foreigners, those who sell us oil would be forced to “return the money” in the form of purchases or investments.

Regardless, it is my impression that our biggest sources of oil are actually Mexico and Canada, and I see no reason why reasonable balances of payments could not be arranged with them. Our biggest trade deficit is with China.

Finally, I am not sure we have exhausted our petroleum resources. Certainly, we have not exhausted coal reserves. What we have exhausted is our will to utilize the resources we have, and are chasing after fantasy resources for the sake of lobbyists for those fantasies.
The worst part is that our budget is completely untenable. We spend 80% of our budget on debt service and entitlements. That leaves precious little for anything productive or innovative. It’s time to jettison our entire system of government and start over if you ask me. We have reached the point where our debtors no longer think we are credible - and we aren’t. We can’t expand our GDP any further - we are strangled by too high of debt. There are not enough foreign dollars in the world available to buy our debt - so we print more and more paper currency and float the debt that no one wants to buy. We’d be better off giving our debt to our enemies rather than trying to sell it so they have a motive for not terrorizing us and causing collateral damage. The assumption being of course that our enemies are rational - but also they are not.

You are correct the US gets most of its oil from Canada and non-middle eastern countries. But it seems that the principals of the Monroe Doctrine have been abandoned and China is over here in our neighborhood selling long term contract deals with Canada and trying to drill oil off Cuba. We are under direct economic assault and being out capitalized by communists! You know that things are bad when a communist country calls the US on the carpet about improving our markets and economy if we don’t want them dumping trillions of dollars of us currency and debt on the market - making US bonds junk bonds and currency useless.

Coal will never be used in mass quantities - its too dirty and takes too much water and processing to make synthetic gasoline from it. Old coal fired electric plants are being demolished in favor of gas. We need nuclear as a stop gap till something better is found. Fusion is our current best hope - buts its a long ways off yet and its pretty much a boondoggle for the scientists to camp out and get a salary on it for a life of research.

The automobile is not so much an expression of freedom as it is a means to evade the precipitate that boils out of the “melting pot” lie/illusion. The classless society concept is a canard and does not work. No nation or people in all of history have ever managed to keep a classless society intact, Wealth and the motivation for achievement requires at least the illusion of power and privilege. No one works out of an altruistic motive. With a car people can bypass having to face the indigents, the gauche, the street-people and those “other people” that take buses and would do the mass transit programs. We are not as civilized nor as socially integrated and classless as we imagine. If the auto were reduced to less than 1 per household on average we would have either social chaos or else lots of people opting to stay home to work behind gated communities and secure apartment lobbies etc. Something will have to give socially-economically within the next 20-30 years, maybe sooner, IMHO.

BF
 
In terms of the automobile, there is no “guise of freedom”; it really is freedom.

“Somtimes the truth…is exactly what it appears to be”

The internal combustion engine, the main component of the automobile, is one of many innovative machines that has improved the quality of life in barely more than a century. It found initial use in industrial/agricultural uses; pumping water, sawing wood, and powering wash machines (go to a local fair and look for the Maytag wash machine engines).

A clothes washing machine is another great example of personal freedom, something we take for granted. While not engine-powered anymore, our quality of life, personal hygiene and health, etc. are improved by this often-taken-for-granted personal freedom. It is true that some people do not have their own washing machines; they cannot afford them and must go to laundromats. But is this also unfair? Should everyone be granted a wash machine, or those who can afford this personal freedom to give it up and use laundromats? Perhaps the answer to reducing our fuel consumptiom is that we abandon our personal freedoms and go to creeks and wash our clothes on rocks again. I’ll tell my wife that was your idea 🙂
 
Perhaps the answer to reducing our fuel consumptiom is that we abandon our personal freedoms and go to creeks and wash our clothes on rocks again. I’ll tell my wife that was your idea 🙂
When I was a kid, the area in which I live was extremely primitive. No electricity. My mother literally washed clothes on a big limestone slab in a creek. Tell your wife the practice has little with which to recommend itself, particularly in winter.
 
Heaven’s no, she does not want to be washing cloths on a rock in the dead of winter 🙂

Having been around many “green energy” types for more than a decade, I’m convinced that’s what they think we (as a nation) should do: go backwards. But they are usually the last to give up such creature comforts.

Calling oil an “addiction” is a bit short-sighted in my mind. What we are addicted to is a good quality of life and comforts. People are very much addicted to air conditioning, heat, personal transportation, abundant food, entertainment, health care, living farther from work, etc. It’s not wrong for a society to develop and use these things, which we have. My own personal opinion is that we have used oil for an amazing amount of good purpose!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top