Bush and Gas Prices

  • Thread starter Thread starter qmvsimp
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
2shelbys:
Oh please. It is a figurative term that is used all of the time to describe various forms of violation that have nothing to do with the specific act of violence. If I had a dollar for every time I have heard taxation referred to as rape (including on these forums) I could spend Christmas in Rome for free. I am sorry you are bothered by such references, and if I had made light of the act of violence I would understand your feelings but having such a huge problem with my using the term in the way I did is taking it just a little too far.
Having been raised Catholic, I was always taught to apologize, to atone, and to move on. However, having read your post and seeing that that is yet to be forthcoming, I’ll respond to your defense of the term “gang rape” for the payment of taxes.

I’ve been a member of this forum for 8 months and have apparently missed every last one of the “gang rape” references of which you speak. Actually, I’m shocked to hear that “gang rape” references may be commonplace here. As for your hearing it thousands of times, I can only wonder with whom you are conversing. Quite frankly, I don’t even allow my kids to use the “everybody else does it” rationale.

I find it interesting that I am the one who is “taking it just a little too far” when you are the one who likened the payment of taxes to the vile, humiliating crime of gang rape.
 
For the record, I think using gang rape analogies in this forum is inappropriate.

Also for the record, while it is inappropriate, Thekla’s level of offense to it is a little over the top.
 
40.png
qmvsimp:
Interesting thoughts. A couple of questions though:

Who decides whether a candidate or party gets equal coverage? If I start my own political party tomorrow, can I get equal coverage? If you develop a standard, then can I spend money to reach that standard? Should I get more since the deck is stacked against alternative parties to the Democrats and Republicans?

If I might run for president, and I’m owner of a large company, can I spend my own money advertising my company and splattering my face all over the media? For that matter, can I spend my own money on anything with regards to the election? If not, isn’t that a violation of my freedom of speech?
Generally there’s a certain minimum you have to get to receive funds (e.g 5% of the vote to receive funding next cycle, or a certain number of signutres on a petition to qualify). As far as the deck being stacked against alternative parties…that’s pretty much just a fact in a presidential system like ours. Third parties either die off or replace an existing party.

As far as the point on freedom of speech, that is a tricky question. For a concrete example, look no further than the recent NYC mayoral race. Bloomberg ran using his own money, and basically spent Ferrer into the ground. I’m not even sure I saw a single Ferrer ad the entire campaign, only read news stories about ads he had produces but couldn’t afford to run.

I think Bloomberg was the better candidate, but there’s still something disturbing about the fact that he spent something like $77 million on the election. It’s also distrubing because the NYC campaign finance system is often touted as a model, and by spending his own money Bloomberg may have just killed the system.
 
40.png
qmvsimp:
For the record, I think using gang rape analogies in this forum is inappropriate.

Also for the record, while it is inappropriate, Thekla’s level of offense to it is a little over the top.
Right on both counts and I apologize.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
I’ve heard tax called ‘legalised theft’ far too many times - but comparing it to gang rape? That is just silly. It doesn’t make sense, for starters.

Mike
Mike,
I was not “comparing it”. “Rape” is a term commonly used in the US in describing violation in many forms and very often in relation to the tax burden. The “gang” part is in reference to the fact that there are so many factions with their hands in our pockets.
 
People blame Bush because he didn’t cave in and take oil from the strategic reserves like Clinton did. (which are set aside for military use)

And, Bush refilled the strategic reserves to where they should have been due to Clinton lowering their levels.
 
40.png
qmvsimp:
For the record, I think using gang rape analogies in this forum is inappropriate.

Also for the record, while it is inappropriate, Thekla’s level of offense to it is a little over the top.
Why? Your level of offense is based upon principle, experience, or a combination of both. How do you know that my level of offense isn’t perfectly justified?
 
40.png
2shelbys:
I was not “comparing it”.
Then I do wonder what you were doing in mentioning rape at all.
“Rape” is a term commonly used in the US in describing violation in many forms and very often in relation to the tax burden.
I still fail to see why. It seems highly inappropriate to me.
The “gang” part is in reference to the fact that there are so many factions with their hands in our pockets.
That bit (the plural) makes sense, but comparing taxation to rape seems bizarre in the first place.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Then I do wonder what you were doing in mentioning rape at all.
Come on Mike, as a self-described liberal you can not tell me that you have never heard someone refer to developement as the rape of the land or rape of the earth. It is a commonly used term. Now, why don’t we get back on topic?
 
40.png
Thekla:
Why? Your level of offense is based upon principle, experience, or a combination of both. How do you know that my level of offense isn’t perfectly justified?
I don’t know. I was merely expressing an opinion. Based on the information we have (user profile) and the venue (political discussions in an online forum) your reaction was to take it personal instead of in an allegorical way.

Your reaction seemed to be coming from somebody who had actually been gang raped. Even if that was the case, knowing that none of us would know this, the reaction just seemed a little extreme to me.

I would have mentioned that it was inappropriate (I did) and not taken it personally.
 
40.png
2shelbys:
Come on Mike, as a self-described liberal you can not tell me that you have never heard someone refer to developement as the rape of the land or rape of the earth.
True, I’ve heard that. Doesn’t mean I agree with the description though 🙂
It is a commonly used term. Now, why don’t we get back on topic?
Ok, probably sensible.

Mike
 
40.png
qmvsimp:
Even if that was the case, knowing that none of us would know this, the reaction just seemed a little extreme to me.
“Even if that was the case”? You have got to be kidding. Are you an expert on the appropriate level of offense for people in that situation?

Why not simply say it is an inapproriate comparison and leave out all the qualifiers. Not every offense is equal.
 
Thekla said:
“Even if that was the case”? You have got to be kidding. Are you an expert on the appropriate level of offense for people in that situation?

No, I’m not an expert. Just a person giving his opinion. You are entitled to yours, am I not entitled to mine? I wasn’t mean or derisive in my opinions. You should therefore, not be offended.

Having friendly discourse is one of the pleasures of this forum. Having emotional outbursts over other people’s opinions is not.
40.png
Thekla:
Why not simply say it is an inapproriate comparison and leave out all the qualifiers. Not every offense is equal.
I did say it was inappropriate without any qualifiers regarding his posts. I then said the level of reaction at your apparent offense to it was over the top, also without any qualifiers to it.

I know that every offense is not equal. I’m sure you know that every reaction is also not equal.

I’ve gone out of my way to say that I respect your opinion. I still do. You don’t have to respect mine, but at least don’t get angry at me for having one that happens to be different from yours.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top