Bush warns against Armenia bill

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think the President may be coming in on the wrong side here. Calling a spade a spade is important.

His concern is not with truth in this case, but with political expediency. He wants to fight al Qaeda. The problem is he has not identified the real enemy. His focus is too narrow.

Turkey is not really our friend and never will be. Neither is Turkey Europe’s friend, nor will it ever be.

Did Turkish Muslims systematically kill a million-and-a-half Armenian Christians. Yes. Possibly more. It also forced the emigration of many others.

If that were not true why does the Moslem dominated “secular” Turkish government go to such great lengths to suppress this. Do not forget it is illegal in Turkey to describe the Armenian genocide as anything other than separate and unrelated incidents of collateral damage during war and the separate and unrelated individual decisions of various people to emigrate. Currently, several people (5? 10?) are serving time in Turkish prisons for claiming that there was a genocide.
 
:confused: Why In heaven’s name is this coming up now?
Is it because of the war?
Maybe the Turks are afraid that not only the Armenians but Romanians,Hungarians,Moldavians and others will want compensation for what the Turks did to their ancestors 500 or 600 years ago when they invaded these countries. Wouldn’t mind a little turkish money for what they did to my mother’s ancestors in Hungary all those years ago,but it ain’t gonna happen.

Really curious what is behind this.
 
:confused: Why In heaven’s name is this coming up now?.
My guess is because congressional elections are next year and there is a Democratic representative pushing the bill who needs it to pass and now we have a Democratic controlled House and Senate: From the WP:
House Resolution 106, officially the Affirmation of the United States Record on the Armenian Genocide, has been pushed doggedly by a congressman whose Southern California district contains the largest concentration of Armenian Americans in the country. Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D) won his seat in 2000 after his Republican predecessor was sandbagged when then-House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert reneged on a pledge and pulled the bill from the floor after a last-minute plea from President Bill Clinton.

washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/10/AR2007101001280.html?hpid=topnews
 
**A bill recognising the killing of Armenians in Ottoman times as genocide has cleared its first hurdle in the US Congress despite Turkish warnings. **

It passed through the House Foreign Affairs Committee by 27 votes to 21 - the first step towards holding a vote in the House of Representatives.
Turkish PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan had warned the bill’s success would “significantly weaken” relations.
President George W Bush had urged US legislators not to pass it.
A spokesperson for the National Security Council told the BBC that the White House was “very disappointed” by the outcome of the vote. Turkey is a regional operational hub for the US military, which uses its airspace to supply US forces in Iraq.

news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/7038762.stm
 
If that were not true why does the Moslem dominated “secular” Turkish government go to such great lengths to suppress this.
The efforts a government makes to refute an idea is not necessarily evidence of the idea’s truth. If that were the case, we could also conclude that there really were aliens at Roswell, a second gunman at the JFK assassination was a sure thing, and the US staged the 9-11 attacks.

gilliam’s explanation seems pretty reasonable. Incidentally, while I’ve never noticed evidence of a large Armenian population in the cities I’ve visited, I did notice that in the movie “Sideways” that the lead character was married in an Armenian church, and the filmmakers obviously tried to make the wedding and reception true to the Armenian tradition, although the wedding itself was only a brief part of the movie - kind of an unusual effort for a Hollywood film.
 
As long as congress consults historians on this issue there should not be a problem with the resolution. Wasn’t it Adolf Hitler who said " Who today remembers the armenian genocide"?
 
I think the President may be coming in on the wrong side here. Calling a spade a spade is important.

His concern is not with truth in this case, but with political expediency. He wants to fight al Qaeda. The problem is he has not identified the real enemy. His focus is too narrow.

Turkey is not really our friend and never will be. Neither is Turkey Europe’s friend, nor will it ever be.

Did Turkish Muslims systematically kill a million-and-a-half Armenian Christians. Yes. Possibly more. It also forced the emigration of many others.

If that were not true why does the Moslem dominated “secular” Turkish government go to such great lengths to suppress this. Do not forget it is illegal in Turkey to describe the Armenian genocide as anything other than separate and unrelated incidents of collateral damage during war and the separate and unrelated individual decisions of various people to emigrate. Currently, several people (5? 10?) are serving time in Turkish prisons for claiming that there was a genocide.
It does seem right to condemn the Armenian genocide. And by the way, when will Turkey give back the Hagia Sophia Church to the Orthodox Christians. It is disgraceful for Turkey to continue to deface this great Orthodox Church and use it as an Islamic museum.
 
:confused: Why In heaven’s name is this coming up now?
Is it because of the war?
Maybe the Turks are afraid that not only the Armenians but Romanians,Hungarians,Moldavians and others will want compensation for what the Turks did to their ancestors 500 or 600 years ago when they invaded these countries. Wouldn’t mind a little turkish money for what they did to my mother’s ancestors in Hungary all those years ago,but it ain’t gonna happen.

Really curious what is behind this.
First of all, the Armenians have been trying to get recognition for decades, maybe longer…Also, Some of the victims are still alive. What President Bush do business with a country that refused to recognize the Holocaust. In Turkey it’s a crime to call what happened to the Armenians genocide. And probably the living victims should get compensation.
 
Well, it is heating up.
House committee approves Armenian genocide resolution
Top Bush administration officials are shifting into damage-control mode after a House committee narrowly approved a resolution that labels the killings of Armenians in Turkey during World War I as “genocide.”
The House Foreign Affairs Committee passed the measure 27-21 Wednesday evening, even though President Bush and key figures lobbied hard against it.
The Web site of Turkish President Abdullah Gul carried a statement calling the decision “unacceptable,” saying it “doesn’t fit a major power like the United States.”
Full story

And Turkey responds immediately.
Turkey recalls ambassador over genocide resolution
Turkey has recalled its ambassador to the United States in response to a House resolution that would call the World War I massacre of Armenians by Turkish forces genocide, the Turkish Foreign Ministry said Thursday.
The House Committee on Foreign Affairs passed the measure 27-21 Wednesday, even though President Bush and key administration figures lobbied hard against it. The full House is expected to vote on it, possibly Friday.
A top Turkish official warned Thursday that consequences “won’t be pleasant” if the full House approves the resolution.
Full story

So if the Senate approves this resolution, will that mean the Turkey will terminate the treaty permitting the US to operate Incirlik Airbase? Will they drop out of NATO? Will they try to get the UN involved? What might the “unpleasant consequences” be?
 
:confused: Why In heaven’s name is this coming up now?
Is it because of the war?
Maybe the Turks are afraid that not only the Armenians but Romanians,Hungarians,Moldavians and others will want compensation for what the Turks did to their ancestors 500 or 600 years ago when they invaded these countries. Wouldn’t mind a little turkish money for what they did to my mother’s ancestors in Hungary all those years ago,but it ain’t gonna happen.

Really curious what is behind this.
It is not just coming up now!!! President Bush Jr. ran, partially, his first campaign, on promising to recognise the Genocide. 9/11 happened. Who knows if that has been a reason why he hasn’t made good on his promise. Second, for the past 40 years, I believe, all Presidents who have made it in to the office have promised to recognise it. All of them. Both parties. It may have little to do with the war, but, it seems as though it is portrayed as we can either recognise the Genocide as such or win the War on Terror. Not both. The Turks are afraid.
 
:confused: Why In heaven’s name is this coming up now?
Is it because of the war?
Maybe the Turks are afraid that not only the Armenians but Romanians,Hungarians,Moldavians and others will want compensation for what the Turks did to their ancestors 500 or 600 years ago when they invaded these countries. Wouldn’t mind a little turkish money for what they did to my mother’s ancestors in Hungary all those years ago,but it ain’t gonna happen.
The Armenian Massacre, or if you prefer, the “Supposed Unpleasantness in Armenia Falsely Implicating the Turks” is the only incident in question. And the Armenians are not seeking compensation, only recognition.
 
Incidentally, while I’ve never noticed evidence of a large Armenian population in the cities I’ve visited,
Try Fresno and Modesto and the San Joachim Valley of California. More names ending in “ian” than you’d imagine!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top