Can a Cardinal be demoted to a conventional Bishop, and a Bishop to a Priest?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yeoman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes a Bishop can be made a Priest. It doesn’t happen often, but it is possible. A Bishop could also be demoted to Acolyte or Thurifer, or grave digger if the Pope wanted, which at one time, was a real Office in the Church. One must distinguish between order and jurisdiction. Jurisdictionally, a Bishop can be made an Presbyter, yes, it is possible.
 
A bishop cannot have his rank as bishop taken away from him, but he can be relieved of his responsibilities. There are bishops who don’t have any diocesal responsibility.
There is an infamous example of Bishop Bonaventure Broderick, he was a bishop in Cuba at the turn of the 20th century. He fell out of favor with someone and ended up running a gas station for 30 years until Cardinal Spellman brought him back.
 
Yes a Bishop can be made a Priest. It doesn’t happen often, but it is possible. A Bishop could also be demoted to Acolyte or Thurifer, or grave digger if the Pope wanted, which at one time, was a real Office in the Church. One must distinguish between order and jurisdiction. Jurisdictionally, a Bishop can be made an Presbyter, yes, it is possible.
Actually, no.

Once ordained a bishop, he will always be a bishop.

His faculties to function as a bishop can be removed.
 
No Father David, that’s not true. Jurisdictionally, a Bishop can be made a preysbyter.
 
He will still remain a Bishop in Order. That much is also true.
 
But Jurisdictionally he could be anything, including being made a layman, up to Pope.
 
No Father David, that’s not true. Jurisdictionally, a Bishop can be made a preysbyter.
No.

You obviously have no idea what you’re writing about.

Ordination is an ontological change. It is a change in the soul. It cannot be un-done.

Once a man is ordained a bishop, he will remain a bishop forever.

He can be restricted to only exercising the offices (munera) of a presbyter, to the exclusion of those of a bishop; but he can never be un-ordained as a bishop and re-made a presbyter.

I don’t know where you’re getting your information, but it’s simply not accurate.
 
Father, I said that his order could not be removed. I also said that jurisdictionally he can be made presbyter.
 
And can a cardinal be demoted to Bishop, the answer is yes.
 
40.png
BartholomewB:
I would imagine that most ex-priests who get marrried wouldn’t particularly want a church wedding.
Why not? Most only seek to leave the ministry, NOT to leave the Church.

There was such a man in a parish that I used to belong to (when I lived in a different city). He petitioned for laicization, was granted it. He later got married and was married in the Church. He ahs remained a faithful Catholic, and even volunteered at the parish religious ed, preparing Confirmation candidates.
I imagine it depends on why and how they left.
 
Father, I said that his order could not be removed. I also said that jurisdictionally he can be made presbyter.
But it’s the wrong language. He could be assigned as an archpiriest or simply exist in retirement somewhere. But I doubt he would be assigned as a simple pastor at some parish (though it guess it’s possible).

But regardless, when he celebrates Mass, he would do so a bishop
 
No actually, if he were jurisdictionally a Priest, which is the correct term, he would offer Mass as Priest.
 
If he were stripped to Thurifer or layman, he would not offer Mass at all.
 
I imagine it depends on why and how they left.
Yes, I suppose so. I have only known personally two ex-priests who left the Church to get married. I didn’t know either of them well enough to interrogate them closely about the circumstances of their laicization, but one thing they had in common was a complete lack of interest in anything to do with the Church or the Catholic faith.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top