Can a soul in hell pray for us?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JD27076
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JD27076

Guest
Interesting question if you ask me. Can prayers only be heard from Earth, Purgatory, and Heaven? Hell too? If a person who is eternally in hell pray for us?

Better question, can Demons pray for us? (I wouldn’t be praying to a demons, nor asking them TO Pray for me.)
 
No. To even offer up prayer requires grace, which is impossible in Hell.
 
Interesting question if you ask me. Can prayers only be heard from Earth, Purgatory, and Heaven? Hell too? If a person who is eternally in hell pray for us?

Better question, can Demons pray for us? (I wouldn’t be praying to a demons, nor asking them TO Pray for me.)
It’s not CAN a soul in hell pray for us. God is omniscient, and knows all, even the hearts of those in hell are not beyond His perception.

The question is WILL a soul in hell pray for us, or (for that matter) would a demon?

The answer to that is no… compassion is a charism of grace that is a product of our nature reflecting the perfect nature of God. When we are sent to hell, we are stripped of all beatific vision and the graces that go with it, we lose all sense of selflessness that would enable us to care about others enough to pray for them. The souls in hell, if they perceive others, would perceive them only as a means towards their own ends, and would not care to advance them out of a sense of intrinsic goodness.
 
I know the story isn’t taken literally, but what about the rich man and Lazarus? It’s clear that the rich man in hell was worried about his brothers and begging that they be warned.
 
I know the story isn’t taken literally, but what about the rich man and Lazarus? It’s clear that the rich man in hell was worried about his brothers and begging that they be warned.
It’s an exegetical puzzle, and is why some believe the RM is in fact in Purgatory.
 
Nope. Once in hell, you can’t do anything for good anymore.
I know the story isn’t taken literally, but what about the rich man and Lazarus? It’s clear that the rich man in hell was worried about his brothers and begging that they be warned.
I actually had a priest explain to me that the rich man may have been in purgatory, which was why he was able to actually talk and plead with Abraham. There is a great rift between heaven and hell. If he were in hell, he could not have done much of anything.

Of course, if you read about the saints and their experiences with purgatory, one saint said that a man had painted a “trashy” painting that caused people to go to hell because of the sin they committed with it. The painter ended up going to purgatory, but God allowed those who had been damned to hell because of it to come and yell at him for the picture he had done. He begged God that he may go down and plead with the museum owner to take the picture down.
 
Interesting question if you ask me. Can prayers only be heard from Earth, Purgatory, and Heaven? Hell too? If a person who is eternally in hell pray for us?

Better question, can Demons pray for us? (I wouldn’t be praying to a demons, nor asking them TO Pray for me.)
Once a soul is condemned to hell, it’s over. Our prayers can no longer help them and they are not able to pray and help us. They are forever cut off from God and all mankind.😦
 
I know the story isn’t taken literally, but what about the rich man and Lazarus? It’s clear that the rich man in hell was worried about his brothers and begging that they be warned.
Yes, but he had no hope of reaching them, and his message would have fallen on deaf ears. As well, notice that his message was one of desperation - which reflected his own state rather than that of his brothers. Abraham made it clear that their locations could not be changed or departed from. Notice also that only Abraham spoke, and no manifestation of the Lord was present. The rich man’s despair was only confirmed.
 
I know the story isn’t taken literally, but what about the rich man and Lazarus? It’s clear that the rich man in hell was worried about his brothers and begging that they be warned.
Yes, but he had no hope of reaching them, and his message would have fallen on deaf ears in any event. As well, notice that his message was one of desperation - which reflected his own state rather than that of his brothers. Abraham made it clear that their locations could not be changed or departed from. Notice also that only Abraham spoke, and no manifestation of the Lord was present. The rich man’s despair was only confirmed.
 
Yes, there is always hope, even for souls in hell and purgatory. They are unlikely though to pray for anyone except themselves.
 
**Of course, if you read about the saints and their experiences with purgatory, one saint said that a man had painted a “trashy” painting that caused people to go to hell because of the sin they committed with it. The painter ended up going to purgatory, but God allowed those who had been damned to hell because of it to come and yell at him for the picture he had done. He begged God that he may go down and plead with the museum owner to take the picture down. /B

Wow , so did the Saint say if God let him?**
 
I’m curious, how did anyone know the painter went to purgatory? Did anyone contact him there and on who’s authority was that contact made?

Dude
 
this was a cruel rich man. In full conscience he allowed a man to starve to death. And this richman went to Purgatory??? Really??? Is the bar to purgatory really that low??? What did jesus tell those, you saw me hungry and didnt feed me, Lord when did we see you hungry, and he said depart from me!!!

my two cents but I believe the richman was in hell, recall Lazarus could not see the Richman because of the divide, but the richman was able to see Lazarus, or atleast have knowledge of his whereabouts…

those that go to hell will see the glory of those whom they trampled while on earth. This is glory to the humble and punishment to the vile.
 
the parable is also an OT response to the Jews… Abraham was the father of Judism, so he was in the place of Jesus atleast in this parable…recall, when this parable was spoken Jesus was not crucified yet… Heaven as we know it was not opened yet, so Lazarus was in Abrahams Bosom, while the Richman was in a place of extreme torement.
 
The bar to Purgatory is low; all it requires is your last bodyful of breath, if you use it to call on our LORD. Remember HIS companion in death.

But don’t count on it, as none of us knows if we will have the use of our mind at that moment. Better get your penance up to date now.

ICXC NIKA
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top