Can Catholics participate in yoga?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dcaputo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I did not admit yoga is “simple exercises” (I missed putting quotes on the first mention of “simple exercises”). That’s the excuse I hear from others, that’s why I put it in quotes.
Then neither you nor anyone else has provided adequate proof or explanation of why they are not just simple exercises.
Now I see why you are so upset. You do yoga, and you are unwilling to give it up. I will pray for you.
Get your vision checked. I do not do yoga at all in any way; my statement was meant more generally. I am an advocate against the force of irrationality and paranoia, whether that comes from an atheist or you.

I will pray that you learn to open your mind and that you understand what constitutes good reasoning.
 
Let me get this straight. You believe Johnette Benkovic is a copycat fundamentalist naysayer who is not worth listening to even though she has been on EWTN for about 23 years. Isn’t it strange that EWTN, whose founder received the Cross of Hope award from Pope Benedict XVI in 2009, has not thrown her off the air!?
Religious or not, it’s still a TV network. I doubt that care that they care much about the finer details of an individual show. I’ve watched EWTN and I’ve actually seen a fair amount of theological views that would be in opposition to the ones being espoused in Women of Grace.

Besides, as everyone else stated, a number of years is just a number years and a really dishonest attempt to divert attention from the questions at hand. I may not have watched their take on Yoga specifically but I have seen them comment on some… other things and said comments were in serious violation of both logic and anything I would call taste.
 
I was told it was wrong to but then again it was somone online.
I told my mom about the yoga thing and she said its just stretching and its fine and I agree.
I do not see how it’s bad I think people are looking into it to much and trying to find that in it.
 
I have heard yes and no from Clergy. I suppose it depends on depth of understanding of Eastern philosophy and religion with relation to what the Church teaches. Yoga did come to play around 100 to 200 years prior to Christ’s birth. My recommendation to those who don’t understand which way to go is to consider Tai Chi. I have had many students come over to Tai Chi from Yoga and have come to appreciate it and realize its greater potential. Tai Chi is ultimately an internal martial art, but focuses on one’s harmony of the body, mind, and spirit. Additionally it is a flowing art form that combines static and non static movement as opposed to stationary postures and promotes internal energy flow. It’s roots are not of any religious order, even though its forefathers were of Taoist practice. Easter Chinese Martial Arts originated from Buddhist practitioners who ultimately were committed to praying and meditating daily. The Buddhist teacher Bohdidarma found that they were of poor health and incorporated daily exercise, also known as the 18 fists of Lohan or 18 hands of shaolin to improve on their health. Eventually there was a split from some Buddhist Shaolin practitioners or monks to Taosim, then came the development of Tai Chi.

Within Tai Chi is the practice of Chi Gung, which combines breathing techniques that helps move positive energy within the body to promote better health. I do caution you that seek a good teacher that is or can trace their roots to a Master Level of Chinese decent, particular to the Shaolin Order or any of the Chen or Yang families. The practice of Chi Gung can open the body to evil if one doesn’t know how to protect themselves to it. Without the Chi Gung practice Tai Chi becomes an empty form. I myself learned from one of few Monks from Shaolin that studied under the Chen family. While he is Buddhist, never has he promoted Buddhism to his students nor taught how to tie in Buddhism or any religion to Tai Chi. Truly Tai Chi is great practice that can help you to harmonize your body with itself, promote health benefits, and quiet the mind. Better yet, it even promotes martial applications from a non violent way, something Yoga lacks. A good teacher will teach one how to heal the body before it inflicts damage to anyone. For one is responsible, even in self defense to bring aid to the other if one has inflicted bodily harm to them.

Wish you the best in discerning a better way to strengthen your body and promote good health, while staying faithful to the teachings of the Catholic Church through Christ our Lord.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top