Can people choose to be spriritual and live a loving life?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Serap
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s assuming the truth of the Catholic Church’s claim that its teachings are God’s revelations.
If you don’t assent to the truths of the Catholic Church, then how do you know what God has revealed?

Remember, it was the Church which discerned and codified the Sacred Scriptures, so without the Church you would not know what is inspired.

It was the Catholic Church, which decided for you, that the Gospel of Thomas is not *theopneustos, *but that the Gospel of Mark is.

[SIGN1]You would not know what God has revealed without the Church.[/SIGN1]
 
My point is made - you go to Church, and you don’t sin. The correlation stands. 🙂
Bah…some of the meanest and rudest people I have ever met have been church goers and they justify their behaviour in the name of religion.
 
I tend to agree with this. Many here state that someone is in mortal sin if they are given the truth (grew up a Catholic) and then choose not to be a Catholic anymore. They are in mortal sin for various reasons like being openly gay, cohabitating, etc., despite how kind hearted and giving they are as a person.

I just don’t buy it.
Yes, and to add to those reasons, spiritual laziness. Many people just don’t want to take the time to honor and worship God but still want to feel good about themselves.

Personally, I see it as self-delusion. One cannot stay spiritually strong for ever even when tied to the Church. But, trying to stay spiritually healthy without the benefit of the Body of Christ is virtually impossible.

Doing good works is an outgrowth of an understanding of one’s place in creation. It is not a spirituality unto itself. IMO, one cannot be spiritually strong without hearing the Word and sharing the Eucharist…
 
Yes, and to add to those reasons, spiritual laziness. Many people just don’t want to take the time to honor and worship God but still want to feel good about themselves.

Personally, I see it as self-delusion. One cannot stay spiritually strong for ever even when tied to the Church. But, trying to stay spiritually healthy without the benefit of the Body of Christ is virtually impossible.

Doing good works is an outgrowth of an understanding of one’s place in creation. It is not a spirituality unto itself. IMO, one cannot be spiritually strong without hearing the Word and sharing the Eucharist…
Tell this to the Dalhi Lama. Would he agree with you?
 
Tell this to the Dalhi Lama. Would he agree with you?
The Dalai Lama, is Buddhist, and does the best with what he has. I understand Buddhists spend a great deal of time in prayer and meditation.

But…he isn’t a lapsed Catholic who gave up full communion with the Church in order to be “spritual”.

When I was “spiritual” prayer was for me quite self centered. “God please do this for me… God please help me…”
 
If you don’t assent to the truths of the Catholic Church, then how do you know what God has revealed?
Maybe read as Paul instructed the Bereans to do with their Scripture at the time to see if what they were subsequently being told was true. And as spiritual people do our best to discern God’s Spirit to the best of our understanding. That’s faith.
 
Maybe read as Paul instructed the Bereans to do with their Scripture at the time to see if what they were subsequently being told was true. And as spiritual people do our best to discern God’s Spirit to the best of our understanding. That’s faith.
Except that Christ did not tell us to read the scriptures and do our best to understand them. He started a Church to guide us into the truth so that we would not be left with only our understanding. Paul was uncovering the truth hidden in the Old Testament and inviting the Bereans to verify this truth, revealed to the Church, for themselves.
 
Except that Christ did not tell us to read the scriptures and do our best to understand them. He started a Church to guide us into the truth so that we would not be left with only our understanding. Paul was uncovering the truth hidden in the Old Testament and inviting the Bereans to verify this truth, revealed to the Church, for themselves.
Yes, this is what Catholics believe.
 
Except that Christ did not tell us to read the scriptures and do our best to understand them. He started a Church to guide us into the truth so that we would not be left with only our understanding. Paul was uncovering the truth hidden in the Old Testament and inviting the Bereans to verify this truth, revealed to the Church, for themselves.
Jesus did say to “Search the scriptures” (Jn 5:39 Douay-Rheims). And I understand it is your faith understanding after doing so that the Church He founded has always been and remains the Catholic Church. God bless!
 
Jesus did say to “Search the scriptures” (Jn 5:39 Douay-Rheims). And I understand it is your faith understanding after doing so that the Church He founded has always been and remains the Catholic Church. God bless!
See this is the fundamental difference between Catholicism and other Protestant denominations and other religions. Catholics believe that they have the whole truth and that all the other religions are lacking and only have a piece of the truth.

Catholics also believe that if one is exposed to the “truth” and does not accept it, then that person is culpable for turning away from the “whole truth”. They are often referred to as dissenters, Cafeteria Catholics, etc. Catholics believe that these people are either in mortal sin or will have a very long journey in Purgatory.

I know first hand, Catholics that left the church to join a Protestant church and they are on fire for Christ. Catholics still insist that this person has turned away from God.

It’s very complicated and not easy to understand.
 
See this is the fundamental difference between Catholicism and other Protestant denominations and other religions. Catholics believe that they have the whole truth and that all the other religions are lacking and only have a piece of the truth.
You don’t believe Christ founded one Church? One Truth?

That’s what it all comes down to.
 
See this is the fundamental difference between Catholicism and other Protestant denominations and other religions. Catholics believe that they have the whole truth and that all the other religions are lacking and only have a piece of the truth.

Catholics also believe that if one is exposed to the “truth” and does not accept it, then that person is culpable for turning away from the “whole truth”. They are often referred to as dissenters, Cafeteria Catholics, etc. Catholics believe that these people are either in mortal sin or will have a very long journey in Purgatory.

I know first hand, Catholics that left the church to join a Protestant church and they are on fire for Christ. Catholics still insist that this person has turned away from God.

It’s very complicated and not easy to understand.
Serap, I know. It troubles me when I read in CCC 846 and Lumen Gentium, “Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.” Catholics will tell me the Church is only announcing what the outcome is going to be for such a person and it is the person condemning themselves. Maybe it’s just me. But that is getting a bit too close to judging salvation for me to be entirely comfortable with that idea at the moment. But like you said it can be very complicated and difficult to understand.
 
Serap, I know. It troubles me when I read in CCC 846 and Lumen Gentium, “Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.” Catholics will tell me the Church is only announcing what the outcome is going to be for such a person and it is the person condemning themselves. Maybe it’s just me. But that is getting a bit too close to judging salvation for me to be entirely comfortable with that idea at the moment. But like you said it can be very complicated and difficult to understand.
It’s extremely complicated. Catholics do not believe that anyone is on the road to perdition, per se, but they believe that the Church was instituted by Christ Himself and that the church evolved (rather imperfectly at times :o) through the Holy Spirit.

Protestants believed that Catholics began moving away from Christian values especially when they implemented (can’t remember the name of it) a process where a person could pay money to guarantee a spot in Purgatory. This has since been stopped and for a good reason.

The CC has never been perfect. It is like any large organized body…it can be filled with corruption and evil.

But, if you look at the big picture, the CC has performed very many wonderul acts throughout history. Just look at the work of our late Mother Theresa!!! She is an incredible inspiration to everyone, no matter their religion.

However imperfect the CC may be, it has created many beautiful works in the name of Christ. It really is a beautiful church despite its imperfections.

God bless!
 
You don’t believe Christ founded one Church? One Truth?

That’s what it all comes down to.
I know Protestants who believe Christ founded one Church. The difference is they define Christ’s Church as His body of believers. And He did say He was the Truth and to believe in Him for eternal life.
 
It’s extremely complicated. Catholics do not believe that anyone is on the road to perdition, per se, but they believe that the Church was instituted by Christ Himself and that the church evolved (rather imperfectly at times :o) through the Holy Spirit.

Protestants believed that Catholics began moving away from Christian values especially when they implemented (can’t remember the name of it) a process where a person could pay money to guarantee a spot in Purgatory. This has since been stopped and for a good reason.

The CC has never been perfect. It is like any large organized body…it can be filled with corruption and evil.

But, if you look at the big picture, the CC has performed very many wonderul acts throughout history. Just look at the work of our late Mother Theresa!!! She is an incredible inspiration to everyone, no matter their religion.

However imperfect the CC may be, it has created many beautiful works in the name of Christ. It really is a beautiful church despite its imperfections.

God bless!
Serap, maybe the word escaping you at the moment was the selling of indulgences. 🙂 Indeed the Church and Her members have performed much good in history. Protestants and persons of other faiths have as well I know you believe from your posts. But faithful Catholics believe the imperfections within do not apply to teaching and doctrine. Thank you for your kind words. God bless you too.
 
I know Protestants who believe Christ founded one Church. The difference is they define Christ’s Church as His body of believers. And He did say He was the Truth and to believe in Him for eternal life.
Which One is that CMatt25, the One Protestant Church? Which verse are you referring to?

Now Christ “actually” did say this about His church…

And Christ said: Simon Peter answered, “You are ther Christ the Son of the Living God” Jesus replied, Blessed are you Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to any man, but bt My father in Heaven. And I tell that you are Peter, and on this Rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall never prevail againt it. I will give you the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in Heaven… amd whatever you lose on Earth will be lossed in Heaven.

That was the catholic Church and the Apostolic Succession.

God Bless, Gary
 
Catholics believe the imperfections within do not apply to teaching and doctrine.
Maybe you could point out to us these corrupt teachings and doctrines. That is if you believe they exist?

God Bless, Gary
 
Jesus did say to “Search the scriptures” (Jn 5:39 Douay-Rheims). And I understand it is your faith understanding after doing so that the Church He founded has always been and remains the Catholic Church. God bless!
You are deflecting the point I am trying to make. Jesus very clearly founded a Church. Why did He do that? He founded a Church in order to remain with us (in His Eucharistic presence) and to guide His people into all truth through the Holy Spirit, thus spreading the kingdom of God to all the earth. He did not leave people on their own to figure it out for themselves. It isn’t just about me and God. There is something much bigger; the Church, the Body of Christ, of which we are invited to be a part.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top