Can/Should I get an annulment?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RetreatFan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

RetreatFan

Guest
I really need some help discerning what I need to do. I am at a crossroads regarding my life and how I want/should live it as a converted/returning catholic and it’s tearing me apart inside. Let me give you some background:

I returned to the Church 2 1/2 years ago after 30+ years of denying the faith. I was never very religious as a child and at around 15 years old I threw myself head first into the pleasures of the world (drugs, booze, you name it), in part to escape what at the time I considered God’s injustices (abandoned by father, overprotected and physically abused by mother, sexually abused by others). I cleaned up my act somewhat at about 30 (drugs and booze weren’t the center of my life anymore although I still did them occasionally) but was still spiritually empty. Spent 14 years in a dysfunctional relationship with someone up until about 3 years ago when I finally worked up the courage to end it. I’m originally from South America and it so happens that a couple of weeks after I had made the decision to leave I reconnected online with my very first girlfriend, someone whom I had always considered the love of my life (although we only spent less than a year together when I was 15 and she was 12). In any case, I saw this as a sign that I was making the right decision ending the prior relationship and promptly moved out. We initiated a long distance relationship mostly via Skype, and after a few months I traveled to SA to see her in person. I was down there about a week, sparks did fly like when we were younger and I promptly returned to the US planning to get married and bring her here.

Now, a church wedding was really an afterthought. I still had no spirituality (although she did) and absolutely no clue what the Sacrament of Matrimony really meant. Originally we were only going to get married civilly (which was all we needed for me to petition for an immigrant visa for her) but then decided on a church wedding at the same time just because of tradition and because we didn’t want to have to celebrate two anniversaries on different dates (now there’s a good reason for a catholic wedding!). I went back a couple of months later and got married. We had no pre-marriage counseling (except a couple of visits with a nun) since I arrived a week before the wedding. Although I was baptized catholic as a child I had never been confirmed so we lied to the church and drummed up a bogus Confirmation Certificate. To me the church wedding was just another event that had to happen before the reception. I received the Eucharist at the wedding ceremony just to keep appearances even though I hadn’t gone to confession and hadn’t even set foot on a church in many years. However, a few weeks after the wedding (at my now wife’s family’s prompting) I attended a three-day conversion retreat where a little flame lit up in my heart and I finally began my road back to the Lord.

Flash forward 2 1/2 years and now at 51 years old I try to follow Christ with all my heart in every thought and action. I’m an active member of the ecclesial movement where I did my retreat (where I even give conferences now) and I’m heavily involved in church activities every day of the week. Thanks to the extensive studying and catechesis of the last couple of years I now understand the sanctity of the Sacrament of Marriage and I can’t believe I made such a foolishly rushed decision based on sexual sparks and a childhood fantasy. After 2 1/2 years of a long distance marriage (due to some unexpected immigration complications), I can say that the initial infatuation has worn off and I’m only left with the overwhelming realization of spending the rest of my life with a woman I barely know and I’m no longer sure it’s the one the Lord had reserved for me.

I have been ruminating over this for a few months now but I won’t go forward with anything unless I know there’s some hope for success. What are my options at this point? Do you think I have grounds for an annulment based on my lack of knowledge and informed consent? Or is this a case where I have to simply deny myself, take up my cross and follow Him? Sorry for the long ramble but I’m rather overwhelmed by this prospect and would appreciate some guidance for this confused soul.
 
I think a serious/momentous question such as yours requires more guidance and discernment then an online forum can offer. I would urge you to book a spiritual guidance session with a priest whom you know to be faithful to the teachings of the Church, wise, practical, holy and discerning, and discuss the matter with him.
 
This^^^

Oh dear. Where to begin?
Go see a priest. As soon as possible. Don’t leave anything out. Print your post out if you need to…
Only he can give you advice. On so many levels…
Praying for you and your wife.
 
Only a priest can guide you with this. Call the office and make appointment to speak to one ASAP. Leave nothing out and then rely on his advice to see you through.
 
Hello everyone, thank you for your replies. I did have a spiritual guidance session this week with a priest I trust and he’s referring me for counseling on the annulment. I was hoping to hear opinions from everyday brothers and sisters about the situation. Does anyone think that someone with the background I have described would have been ready to make that kind of decision after meeting someone long distance for a only a few months? I mean, we Skype’d pretty much every night but could that kind of decision be made without actual face to face interaction? She is a good woman but I’m not sure anymore if she was really the one for me. I feel like I totally screwed up…
 
It may very well be the case…but…I wouldn’t hang my hat on the belief that an annulment is a get out of jail card. This is a serious matter. And they will undoubtedly want to hear your wife’s side of the story. Just trust your priest to advise you well.
 
Believe me, I’m painfully aware it’s a very serious matter. That’s why I’m losing sleep over it. I don’t quite get the “get out of jail card” thing, though. What do you mean?
 
I sounds like you have given up on the marriage. It sounds like you’d really like an annulment to make it all go away.
I hope I’m wrong, btw. But it sounds like a case of buyer’s remorse.
I hope everything works out well for you…especially with regard to your marriage. Marriage counseling would be a good place to start…rather than throwing in the towel.
Peace.
 
It may very well be buyer’s remorse, but is that wrong considering the circumstances? I feel like I robbed myself of the opportunity to make a sound spiritual decision on something I now know you only get one shot at. Yes, I did make my bed (although I really didn’t know how) but do I really have to lie in it? I’ve come to realize that I want other things, children among them (which she can’t have), so would someone in my shoes just suck it up and bear it? I mean, it may turn out I may have to do just that, but is it wrong to question it?
 
It may very well be buyer’s remorse, but is that wrong considering the circumstances? I feel like I robbed myself of the opportunity to make a sound spiritual decision on something I now know you only get one shot at. Yes, I did make my bed (although I really didn’t know how) but do I really have to lie in it? I’ve come to realize that I want other things, children among them (which she can’t have), so would someone in my shoes just suck it up and bear it? I mean, it may turn out I may have to do just that, but is it wrong to question it?
YES you do. You made vows! You said for richer for poorer, in sickness and in health. You said you would accept children lovingly from God. You’re telling me there are no orphan children in her home country that would be blessed to live here?
All I’m reading is I, I, I.
What about what she wants? What about the vows you made to her before God?
Forgive me, but if you are so concerned with screwing up your relationship with God…this may be the hill you die on. Fix your marriage from within, Don’t run away from it. Exhaust all possibilities. Your wife is your partner in life. She’s not a baby-maker only.
You want to make a sound spiritual decision? Start by trying your hardest to love your wife and repair the damage.
 
It may very well be buyer’s remorse, but is that wrong considering the circumstances? I feel like I robbed myself of the opportunity to make a sound spiritual decision on something I now know you only get one shot at. Yes, I did make my bed (although I really didn’t know how) but do I really have to lie in it? I’ve come to realize that I want other things, children among them (which she can’t have), so would someone in my shoes just suck it up and bear it? I mean, it may turn out I may have to do just that, but is it wrong to question it?
You haven’t said anything about how your wife feels about this. I find that very concerning. You were an adult, making your own decisions, and now you want to just toss her aside?
 
Thank you both, this is exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for.

Clare, yes I did make vows but I realize now I didn’t really understand what they truly meant or what the sacrament itself meant. Can someone with absolutely no religious formation (at the time) and for whom the church didn’t mean anything for so long really say he made those vows with full knowledge and consent? On the other hand, does that really matter to God? I married her and that’s that, right?

Agnes, my wife is fine. I haven’t told her how I feel, and I probably won’t. Even though we have seen each other only a couple of months’ worth in the last 2 1/2 years she still seems in love with me so in the end I will probably just offer it up and do my duty regardless of how I feel. Love is an act of the will, not a feeling. I need to remember that.
 
Thank you both, this is exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for.

Clare, yes I did make vows but I realize now I didn’t really understand what they truly meant or what the sacrament itself meant. Can someone with absolutely no religious formation (at the time) and for whom the church didn’t mean anything for so long really say he made those vows with full knowledge and consent? On the other hand, does that really matter to God? I married her and that’s that, right?

Agnes, my wife is fine. I haven’t told her how I feel, and I probably won’t. Even though we have seen each other only a couple of months’ worth in the last 2 1/2 years she still seems in love with me so in the end I will probably just offer it up and do my duty regardless of how I feel. Love is an act of the will, not a feeling. I need to remember that.
You were an adult. People who are un-churched get married all the time. ALL THE TIME.
you think atheists don’t fall in love with each other and understand what it is to get married? There are some atheists on this forum that would have a lot to say about that.
But I digress…
Why are you not living together? This seems to be the root of all the problem. You are married. Get her up here, or move there with her. It can be done. My husband is an immigrant from Ireland. It took 4 years, ( and a fair bit of money) but he is now a permanent resident. We love each other. I can’t imagine being married to someone in another country. This is a terrible situation. No wonder you feel the way you do! You place is with her, and hers with you.
Get on it! You can’t possible make a decision about your marriage when you are not experiencing one. And to drop the annulment on her like this, without any work by either of you? It likely will not be granted.
3 in a marriage my friend, YOU, YOUR WIFE, and CHRIST.
Good luck.
 
Well, I don’t think the atheists comparison is relevant to a catholic. Yes, they get married all the time but they certainly don’t see it as something that is made holy by virtue of the vows you take in front of God. For them divorce is always only a phone call away. We don’t believe in that option, therefore the discernment that must take place before you take those vows is (or should be) orders of magnitude greater. We didn’t have any of that, that’s all I’m saying.

As far as why she’s not here, we hit some unexpected immigration complications (which also prevent me from traveling) that are not scheduled to be resolved until the middle of next year, only then can my petition for her permanent residence move forward. So we’re looking at least 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 more years (if everything goes well) before we can actually begin to live as husband and wife and if my feelings for her have already cooled off in 2 1/2 years, where will they be in 4 or 5? The first 2 years were really tough but at least now she was granted a multiple-entry visitor’s visa after several denials, so now she can at least come visit from time to time. I just don’t know if that’s going to be enough to rekindle the flame we had (or thought we had), hence my current deep ambivalence.

And as far as me moving over there, that’s really not an option for me. Although I was born there I don’t really know anybody anymore. I’ve lived in the US for close to 30 years and never even traveled back down there until almost 3 years ago, when I first went to meet her. I don’t even know how I would earn a living down there. All my immediate family (mother and siblings) is here so I had no reason to travel until then. It’s just a really unusual situation that I now wish I hadn’t gotten into. I’m no longer sure if marrying her was really His will or mine run amok…
 
Well, I don’t think the atheists comparison is relevant to a catholic. Yes, they get married all the time but they certainly don’t see it as something that is made holy by virtue of the vows you take in front of God. For them divorce is always only a phone call away. We don’t believe in that option, therefore the discernment that must take place before you take those vows is (or should be) orders of magnitude greater. We didn’t have any of that, that’s all I’m saying.

As far as why she’s not here, we hit some unexpected immigration complications (which also prevent me from traveling) that are not scheduled to be resolved until the middle of next year, only then can my petition for her permanent residence move forward. So we’re looking at least 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 more years (if everything goes well) before we can actually begin to live as husband and wife and if my feelings for her have already cooled off in 2 1/2 years, where will they be in 4 or 5? The first 2 years were really tough but at least now she was granted a multiple-entry visitor’s visa after several denials, so now she can at least come visit from time to time. I just don’t know if that’s going to be enough to rekindle the flame we had (or thought we had), hence my current deep ambivalence.

And as far as me moving over there, that’s really not an option for me. Although I was born there I don’t really know anybody anymore. I’ve lived in the US for close to 30 years and never even traveled back down there until almost 3 years ago, when I first went to meet her. I don’t even know how I would earn a living down there. All my immediate family (mother and siblings) is here so I had no reason to travel until then. It’s just a really unusual situation that I now wish I hadn’t gotten into. I’m no longer sure if marrying her was really His will or mine run amok…
I think you’d need to define “cooled off” before you do anything. It’s NORMAL for the romance to die away a little bit after awhile. Love is a decision, it’s not a feeling. It’s NORMAL for you to have days when you don’t find your partner very sexy. Love is what takes over at that point.

Case in point: Last night at about 7:15 I get a call from my husband. He’s a security guard and he works nights - he does roving patrol (drives around between different sites). Well, he had absentmindedly locked himself out of his car and needed some things out of it before he could start patrolling. He asked me to come down and bring my key so he could unlock the car. Did I mention that he works about an hour from where we live? Did I also mention that this is not the first time I had to go “rescue” him (he forgot his cell phone once and needed it for work)? Do you think I was thinking about how great he was at that point? Of course not! But I love him and I knew he needed me. So I went and brought him the key. This is where the love comes into it. Do you make a decision to love your partner that day or not?

That said, obviously there are certain behaviours, beliefs, and values where you have to draw a line. You need to be on the same page about SOME things. For example, if/when DH and I have children I’d like to homeschool them. Fortunately he feels the same way. That’s a line I would have had to draw. Consequently, my question is, what are you feeling for your wife right now? What exactly is going on that’s bothering you? Is it something that can be resolved? (Another example: I love cats. DH is okay with them, but not nearly as fond of them as I am. He agreed that we could have cats for me - though as it turns out we got nice ones that he likes too.) Is this just a natural point in your marriage where it will take work to love your partner? Or is this a question of fundamental differences in beliefs/values/behaviours that cannot be resolved? Before you start seriously considering ending the marriage, I strongly, strongly suggest that the two of you find a way to spend more time together and possibly consider counselling. From the sounds of it you’ve barely given this marriage a chance to get off the ground.
 
RetreatFan,

You can put your worries, fears, and dilemma to rest. The presumption is that your marriage is valid. Therefore, it cannot be undone, redone, or nullified. This isn’t just the Church’s presumption. It should also be yours. And knowing this is a gift, really, because it can help quiet the incessant voice, the devil trying to tempt you to leave your wife because, as he whispers to you: “C’mon, maybe it’s not valid. You could leave your wife, abandon her, and it’ll be good. You’d be able to start over, find someone else, have children. God wants you to be happy! This isn’t what you signed up for.”

The truth is, you weren’t pressured to marry your wife. You did have free consent. You knew she couldn’t have children and you chose to marry her anyway. You made vows till death do you part in front of the church. How do you know you are called to marry this woman? Because you did. How do you know you shouldn’t pursue an annulment? Because you are married and you assume your marriage is valid. Even if it’s not the choice you would make again today, God respects it and allows you to be in a valid marriage because He has given us free will to bind ourselves for life to another human being, which you have done.

Consider also that it is precisely because of your marriage to her that you have your new-found faith. It was the love of her family which prompted you to go on that retreat. Be thankful for that blessing. Be thankful for the wife who still loves you even though she doesn’t get the benefit of sleeping with and talking in person with her husband.

But you’re not destined for a lifetime of unhappiness, which is what the world would have you believe. My advice? Focus on getting you and your wife under the same roof and on making your marriage great. Write her long letters about your fears and struggles and desires. Go on retreats together. Commit to praying for her every day. Take the pre-cana classes or married encounters offered by your Archdiocese since you missed them the first time around. Sign up for marriage or individual counseling to learn how to deal with her infertility and the fact that you two spent the first several years of your marriage in different countries. Discuss whether you want and are able to adopt. Even people in arranged marriages can learn to love each other and you and your wife, though you didn’t know each other well beforehand, can also develop a strong, healthy and, yes, very happy marriage together.

God bless.
 
RetreatFan,

You can put your worries, fears, and dilemma to rest. The presumption is that your marriage is valid. Therefore, it cannot be undone, redone, or nullified. This isn’t just the Church’s presumption. It should also be yours. And knowing this is a gift, really, because it can help quiet the incessant voice, the devil trying to tempt you to leave your wife because, as he whispers to you: “C’mon, maybe it’s not valid. You could leave your wife, abandon her, and it’ll be good. You’d be able to start over, find someone else, have children. God wants you to be happy! This isn’t what you signed up for.”

The truth is, you weren’t pressured to marry your wife. You did have free consent. You knew she couldn’t have children and you chose to marry her anyway. You made vows till death do you part in front of the church. How do you know you are called to marry this woman? Because you did. How do you know you shouldn’t pursue an annulment? Because you are married and you assume your marriage is valid. Even if it’s not the choice you would make again today, God respects it and allows you to be in a valid marriage because He has given us free will to bind ourselves for life to another human being, which you have done.

Consider also that it is precisely because of your marriage to her that you have your new-found faith. It was the love of her family which prompted you to go on that retreat. Be thankful for that blessing. Be thankful for the wife who still loves you even though she doesn’t get the benefit of sleeping with and talking in person with her husband.

But you’re not destined for a lifetime of unhappiness, which is what the world would have you believe. My advice? Focus on getting you and your wife under the same roof and on making your marriage great. Write her long letters about your fears and struggles and desires. Go on retreats together. Commit to praying for her every day. Take the pre-cana classes or married encounters offered by your Archdiocese since you missed them the first time around. Sign up for marriage or individual counseling to learn how to deal with her infertility and the fact that you two spent the first several years of your marriage in different countries. Discuss whether you want and are able to adopt. Even people in arranged marriages can learn to love each other and you and your wife, though you didn’t know each other well beforehand, can also develop a strong, healthy and, yes, very happy marriage together.

God bless.
Excellent advice.
thank you.
 
RetreatFan,

You can put your worries, fears, and dilemma to rest. The presumption is that your marriage is valid. Therefore, it cannot be undone, redone, or nullified. This isn’t just the Church’s presumption. It should also be yours. And knowing this is a gift, really, because it can help quiet the incessant voice, the devil trying to tempt you to leave your wife because, as he whispers to you: “C’mon, maybe it’s not valid. You could leave your wife, abandon her, and it’ll be good. You’d be able to start over, find someone else, have children. God wants you to be happy! This isn’t what you signed up for.”

The truth is, you weren’t pressured to marry your wife. You did have free consent. You knew she couldn’t have children and you chose to marry her anyway. You made vows till death do you part in front of the church. How do you know you are called to marry this woman? Because you did. How do you know you shouldn’t pursue an annulment? Because you are married and you assume your marriage is valid. Even if it’s not the choice you would make again today, God respects it and allows you to be in a valid marriage because He has given us free will to bind ourselves for life to another human being, which you have done.

Consider also that it is precisely because of your marriage to her that you have your new-found faith. It was the love of her family which prompted you to go on that retreat. Be thankful for that blessing. Be thankful for the wife who still loves you even though she doesn’t get the benefit of sleeping with and talking in person with her husband.

But you’re not destined for a lifetime of unhappiness, which is what the world would have you believe. My advice? Focus on getting you and your wife under the same roof and on making your marriage great. Write her long letters about your fears and struggles and desires. Go on retreats together. Commit to praying for her every day. Take the pre-cana classes or married encounters offered by your Archdiocese since you missed them the first time around. Sign up for marriage or individual counseling to learn how to deal with her infertility and the fact that you two spent the first several years of your marriage in different countries. Discuss whether you want and are able to adopt. Even people in arranged marriages can learn to love each other and you and your wife, though you didn’t know each other well beforehand, can also develop a strong, healthy and, yes, very happy marriage together.

God bless.
Thank you so much! God bless you…
 
Could you have the marriage annulled? Probably. If you truly didn’t understand the nature of marriage as taught by the Church then your marriage may very well be invalid. You must understand a thing before you can consent to it, after all. You married in haste without really knowing your bride. You haven’t lived together to establish a true marital bond. Sure, I bet a Tribunal could see how this was never really a marriage. My own annulment lists similar grounds.

But here’s the thing…What difference does it make? So, you decide you want out. You file for divorce. You wait until the divorce is granted…maybe a few months or maybe a few years since your wife lives outside the U.S. Then you apply for annulment and wait 1-3 years (average in the U.S.) for a decision.

Anywhere from 1-6 years after you start the process you know your status. If the Tribunal decides the marriage was invalid, you’re free to date and marry. If not, you’re a divorced man who is bound by his faith to behave like a married man until either he or his wife dies. And, remember, even if the marriage is declared null there is no guarantee you’ll meet another woman who is suitable wife material. You could end up a single free to marry man of a certain age who can’t find a good woman willing to put up with him!

Or you could work to fix the marriage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top