Can the Pope be excommunicated?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mpartyka
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Could you provide the links?
Just look up either pope on Wikipedia. Or find a better source.
I guess I took your question to mean whether there is some ecclesiastical authority that can legitimately take away a pope’s spiritual office.
Correct. Could, for example, the College of Cardinals get together for an emergency conclave to depose the Pope?
 
It is impossible to forcably remove a pope from office. Even if you exile him to the salt mines, he is still pope unless he resigns of his own accord.

There is also no possible way that a pope could be excommunicated by another person or council.

My earlier comments were directed at the idea that the pope could excommunicate himself, which is something I argued could also not be done.
I’m not sure if this is in response to my last post or not. If so, I don’t disagree with you. If you kill a Pope then I suppose that gets it done every time. If you imprison a Pope or confine him to a monastery then you can effectively limit the exercise of his office. He’s still the Pope though.
 
Just look up either pope on Wikipedia. Or find a better source.
So you won’t provide them then even though it was your assertion? Here is the link to Pope Stephen VI: newadvent.org/cathen/14289d.htm

He was murdered by strangulation.

Here is the link to Pope Romanus:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Romanus

He was deposed by one of the political factions of Rome and presumably forced to live out his life as a monk, although the historical accounts about him are nearly non-existent.
Correct. Could, for example, the College of Cardinals get together for an emergency conclave to depose the Pope?
No. The Pope would have to call the synod and approve it or voluntarily resign.
 
So you won’t provide them then even though it was your assertion?
All I said was that Wikipedia used the term “deposed” in reference to the two popes, and I asked if their using that term was accurate, given that I don’t consider Wikipedia to be the most reliable of sources. I’m satisfied now that “deposed” in these instances means “forcibly removed,” not “canonically removed”.
 
Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?

–Mike

No. The Pope is the one member of the Church against whom there is no legal recourse of any kind whatever. Not even an Ecumenical Council could depose him, because he could counter that by declaring that action uncanonical, & by suspending the Council - Ecumenical Councils are ecumenical only if recognised as such by the Pope; otherwise, they are not. Only the Pope can call them, suspend them, conclude them, or decide which of their acts are of ecumenical force. At the end of the day, the Pope is the only member of the Church whose words count. Which is not a healthy state of affairs.​

Popes used to be subject to canon law - their position of total immunity is post-mediaeval, so it has developed bit by bit. Now, they are unassailable - autocrats, in fact; they have almost absolute power, with no responsibility that they do not take on themselves; but they cannot be compelled by law, for they are the supreme law-makers in the Church; & they decide what constitutes orthodoxy, Tradition, Liturgy. That’s pretty cushy IMO 😉
 
Both mean a defect in the succession of apostles the popes claim to have.
No, that’s not what Apostolic Succession means. Note that there is a period where there is no pope, right after his death, before election of a successor.
 
Interesting question.

I am afraid it is one we will have to trust the cardinals to select holy and orthodox men to be pope and the Holy Spirit to protect the popes from any conduct or teaching that might make this theoritical question a real problem.

Like Rodrigo Borgia, you mean ? 😛 He was a fornicator, adulterer, had bastards, bribed the cardinals to elect him Pope, & was a worthy Pope for an age of iron like that. His life as Pope was a disgrace. :eek: And he is by no means alone. 😦​

As noted by others, I would think it is theoritically possible for a pope to automatically excommunicate himself by cooperating in an abortion for example.

Not if he changed the law - which he could do 😉​

That being said, if the pope’s teaching or conduct is gravely in error, I think it is the duty of the Pope’s fellow bishops to call him to account as St. Paul did to St. Peter. How this would be done exactly, I don’t presume to know, but it should in line with Christian charity and respect for the truth.
 
Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?

–Mike
As long as certain things can bring about automatic excommunication anyone can excommunicate themself.

I’m not aware of a process to remove a Pope from their position other than what has been done in the past. That is to kill them and then take their corpse and declare them a heretic. But this process is morally flawed and as such, not a good idea.
 
Popes used to be subject to canon law - their position of total immunity is post-mediaeval, so it has developed bit by bit. Now, they are unassailable - autocrats, in fact; they have almost absolute power, with no responsibility that they do not take on themselves; but they cannot be compelled by law, for they are the supreme law-makers in the Church; & they decide what constitutes orthodoxy, Tradition, Liturgy. That’s pretty cushy IMO 😉
Yeah what a wonderful job full of job benefits - position for life, abstinence from sex, one of the highest rates of assassination and assassination attempts for any high level office in the world, having to hold one’s tongue in public for fear that speaking one’s personal mind or conveying a joke could be taken as ex-cathedra if not careful, having to put up with aides following you around everywhere you go, having to shake hands or bless thousands of strange people daily, having fatwas and contracts for murder issued by enemies of God for being a guest speaker at a university, having to keep the peace between militant woman who want the “power” of the ecclesial office as another career advancement option and constantly reeling in liberal bishops and rouge priests who want to remake the church in their own image and become more Anglican and accommodating to every fringe special-interest group known to man. 😉

James
 
Yeah what a wonderful job full of job benefits - position for life, abstinence from sex, one of the highest rates of assassination and assassination attempts for any high level office in the world, having to hold one’s tongue in public for fear that speaking one’s personal mind or conveying a joke could be taken as ex-cathedra if not careful, having to put up with aides following you around everywhere you go, having to shake hands or bless thousands of strange people daily, having fatwas and contracts for murder issued by enemies of God for being a guest speaker at a university, having to keep the peace between militant woman who want the “power” of the ecclesial office as another career advancement option and constantly reeling in liberal bishops and rouge priests who want to remake the church in their own image and become more Anglican and accommodating to every fringe special-interest group known to man. 😉

James
Pretty much sums up my own opinion too. Thanks James!

IMO, it takes a pretty holy man to take up his cross daily and follow Him as Pope.
 
Now, they are unassailable - autocrats, in fact; they have almost absolute power, with no responsibility that they do not take on themselves; but they cannot be compelled by law, for they are the supreme law-makers in the Church;
What a strange position for a Catholic. You state they have no responsibility that they do not take on themselves. Do you not consider the welfare of a billion souls a little responsibility? If you believe in God, don’t you realize that it is He that determines a man’s responsibility.

[Ezek 3:18](http://bibledatabase.org/cgi-bin/bib_search/bible.cgi?BIBLE=48&BOOK=26&CHAP=3&SEARCH=jesus king lord&Read=Read&FIRST=OK&HV=18) When I say unto the wicked, Thou shalt surely die; and thou givest him not warning, nor speakest to warn the wicked from his wicked way, to save his life; the same wicked man shall die in his iniquity; but his blood will I require at thine hand.
 
As long as certain things can bring about automatic excommunication anyone can excommunicate themself.

I’m not aware of a process to remove a Pope from their position other than what has been done in the past. That is to kill them and then take their corpse and declare them a heretic. But this process is morally flawed and as such, not a good idea.
I had argued earlier that it was not possible for the pope to automatically excommunicate himself–that he is protected by the Holy Spirit from leaving the Church as part of the “gift of unfailing faith” granted to the successors of St. Peter defined by the First Vatican Council. I would be interested if you had a counter argument.
 
What a strange position for a Catholic. You state they have no responsibility that they do not take on themselves. Do you not consider the welfare of a billion souls a little responsibility? If you believe in God, don’t you realize that it is He that determines a man’s responsibility.

[Ezek 3:18](http://bibledatabase.org/cgi-bin/bib_search/bible.cgi?BIBLE=48&BOOK=26&CHAP=3&SEARCH=jesus king lord&Read=Read&FIRST=OK&HV=18) When I say unto the wicked, Thou shalt surely die; and thou givest him not warning, nor speakest to warn the wicked from his wicked way, to save his life; the same wicked man shall die in his iniquity; but his blood will I require at thine hand.

If a Pope couldn’t care two straws for God or man, then from his POV God is for all practical purposes non-existent. Responsibility exists only if one regards it as doing so - a thoroughly worldly man has nothing to worry about, not as far as he is concerned. It is simply naive to imagine that such a man must needs be impressed by quotations from the Bible - a man who feared God would not commit the the sin of simony by bribing cardinals. 😦​

Some Popes have been throroughly worldly, & nothing is gained by saying they should not be - for that is not the point, if one is interested in what actually happened. How things ought to be, & how they were, don’t always coincide. Popes, like anyone else, ought to be Saints, no doubt - it doesn’t follow for one moment that they were; a scoundrelly Pope is not an impossibility; merely a scandal. History can’t be derived from “what ought to be” - moral obligation is no guide to what actually happened: if it were, then the history of the Church in both Testaments, & since, would be spotless. So would all of us. It is is not, & we aren’t. “Ought to be” does not equal " is" or “was” - not even in the history of the Papacy. To say otherwise, is to tell lies.

So God matters no more than people let Him do so - He can be explained away, as can anything said to be done by Him. Those who wish to be blind & deaf to Him can always find ways of ignoring Him. Why should Popes, any more than the rest of us, be exempt from this temptation ?

As for Papal responsibility: they have almost unlimited power over the Church, & they are not subject to any restraint from any source on earth. So they have a free hand, to interpret the texts as they wish - for there is nobody & nothing to stop them. Not Tradition, the Bible, the canons, councils, cardinals, theologians, bishops, episcopates, nor any combination of the faithful. They have no obligations to anyone. Because they get to say what the words of the texts mean in practice - so if the Pope wishes to ignore the recommendations of a cathedral chapter, he is free to do so; if he wishes to abolish prayers, he is free to do so. The words setting out their responsibilities mean just as much or as little as it pleases a Pope to let them. If they don’t like a law - they can abolish it.

That is what was meant by “they have no responsibility that they do not take on themselves” - because they say what’s what, & there are no longer any checks or balances in the Church to counter an immoral or dangerous or unwise or scandalous Papal decision. As the colossal fuss and bother over the Mass shows - the Pope has power over the Liturgy (as Pius XII points out in “Mediator Dei”);, so he can do anything he likes to it.

This unfettered “Papal omnipotence” is what bothers the Orthodox. Among us, the Pope is for all practical purposes above the Church - this means his position is in effect schismatic; he is divided from the Church by being so over-exalted. This is a very very *very *unhealthy development. 😦

This book is directly relevant to this thread:
 
The historical events of the Cadaver Synod might be of some interest.
Stephen had the previous pope, Formosus, dug up, put on trial for usurping the seat of the Roman see. Stephen stamped a big “defective” sticker on Formosus’ papacy by reburying him in a lay-mans cemetery, then digging him up again and throwing his remains in the Tiber river. Consequent popes had a hard time then deciding where they stood on the issue until Sergius III (he declared the original trial of the maggot pile valid).

heres somewhere to start
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadaver_Synod

This event does seem to throw the same monkey wrench into the papacy as an excommunication would. Both mean a defect in the succession of apostles the popes claim to have.
While the Cadaver Synod is a shameful blot on the Catholic Church’s history, it has absolutely no bearing on apostolic succession, as Formosus was a validly ordained bishop. Try again.

As for excommunicating a Pope, that’s not possible, since he is judged by no one.
 
The Pope’s claim to be judged by no on is of late invention, no earlier than Gregory the VII.

The Dictatus Papae was included in Pope’s register in the year 1075. Some argue that it was written by Pope Gregory VII (r. 1073-1085) himself, others argues that it had a much later different origin. In 1087 Cardinal Deusdedit published a collection of the laws of the Church which he drew from many sources. The Dictatus agrees so clearly and closely with this collection that some have argued the Dictatus must have been based on it. There is little doubt that the principals below do express the pope’s principals.

Another translation by G.A. Loud

The Dictates of the Pope

That the Roman church was founded by God alone.
That the Roman pontiff alone can with right be called universal.
That he alone can depose or reinstate bishops.
That, in a council his legate, even if a lower grade, is above all bishops, and can pass sentence of deposition against them.
That the pope may depose the absent.
That, among other things, we ought not to remain in the same house with those excommunicated by him.
That for him alone is it lawful, according to the needs of the time, to make new laws, to assemble together new congregations, to make an abbey of a canonry; and, on the other hand, to divide a rich bishopric and unite the poor ones.
That he alone may use the imperial insignia.
That of the pope alone all princes shall kiss the feet.
That his name alone shall be spoken in the churches.
That this is the only name in the world.
That it may be permitted to him to depose emperors.
That he may be permitted to transfer bishops if need be.
That he has power to ordain a clerk of any church he may wish.
That he who is ordained by him may preside over another church, but may not hold a subordinate position; and that such a one may not receive a higher grade from any bishop.
That no synod shall be called a general one without his order.
That no chapter and no book shall be considered canonical without his authority.
That a sentence passed by him may be retracted by no one; and that he himself, alone of all, may retract it.
That he himself may be judged by no one.
That no one shall dare to condemn one who appeals to the apostolic chair.
That to the latter should be referred the more important cases of every church.
That the Roman church has never erred; nor will it err to all eternity, the Scripture bearing witness.
That the Roman pontiff, if he have been canonically ordained, is undoubtedly made a saint by the merits of St. Peter; St. Ennodius, bishop of Pavia, bearing witness, and many holy fathers agreeing with him. As is contained in the decrees of St. Symmachus the pope.
That, by his command and consent, it may be lawful for subordinates to bring accusations.
That he may depose and reinstate bishops without assembling a synod.
That he who is not at peace with the Roman church shall not be considered catholic.
That he may absolve subjects from their fealty to wicked men.

translated in Ernest F. Henderson, Select Historical Documents of the Middle Ages, (London: George Bell and Sons, 1910), pp. 366-367
 
The Dictates of the Pope
…
That his name alone shall be spoken in the churches.
That this is the only name in the world.
…
That the Roman pontiff, if he have been canonically ordained, is undoubtedly made a saint by the merits of St. Peter; St. Ennodius, bishop of Pavia, bearing witness, and many holy fathers agreeing with him. As is contained in the decrees of St. Symmachus the pope.
Wow…
 
Fortunately, such documents are not infallible.

However, regardless of when it was “invented”, the principle that the First See (which includes its Bishop) is judged by no one is part of the current Canon Law. And since the Pope is the Bishop of the First See, there is no one with the authority to judge him, and no one therefore has the legal right to determine whether or not he has excommunicated himself.
 
As for Papal responsibility: they have almost unlimited power over the Church, & they are not subject to any restraint from any source on earth. So they have a free hand, to interpret the texts as they wish - for there is nobody & nothing to stop them. Not Tradition, the Bible, the canons, councils, cardinals, theologians, bishops, episcopates, nor any combination of the faithful. They have no obligations to anyone. Because they get to say what the words of the texts mean in practice - so if the Pope wishes to ignore the recommendations of a cathedral chapter, he is free to do so; if he wishes to abolish prayers, he is free to do so. The words setting out their responsibilities mean just as much or as little as it pleases a Pope to let them. If they don’t like a law - they can abolish it.

This unfettered “Papal omnipotence” is what bothers the Orthodox. Among us, the Pope is for all practical purposes above the Church - this means his position is in effect schismatic; he is divided from the Church by being so over-exalted. This is a very very *very *unhealthy development. 😦
So what has changed then? If the Pope was at one time subject to the Church, but now is not, when did that change?
 
What would the Church do then, if someone became Pope, but while he was Pope, he renounced theCathlic faith for Protestantism? If the Church has no power to excommunicate that pope, then what would happen if that pope made an Ex Cathedra pronouncement that say, Sola Scriptura is no longer a heresy, but a dogma, or the same about OSAS?
 
What would the Church do then, if someone became Pope, but while he was Pope, he renounced theCathlic faith for Protestantism? If the Church has no power to excommunicate that pope, then what would happen if that pope made an Ex Cathedra pronouncement that say, Sola Scriptura is no longer a heresy, but a dogma, or the same about OSAS?
Wait, maybe I know this. Wouldn’t this trigger (I’m gonna hose the latin) a Latae Senitanae (told you) excommunication just as if a pope showed up and presented himself for marriage?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top