What a strange position for a Catholic. You state they have no responsibility that they do not take on themselves. Do you not consider the welfare of a billion souls a little responsibility? If you believe in God, don’t you realize that it is He that determines a man’s responsibility.
[Ezek 3:18](
http://bibledatabase.org/cgi-bin/bib_search/bible.cgi?BIBLE=48&BOOK=26&CHAP=3&SEARCH=jesus king lord&Read=Read&FIRST=OK&HV=18) When I say unto the wicked, Thou shalt surely die; and thou givest him not warning, nor speakest to warn the wicked from his wicked way, to save his life; the same wicked man shall die in his iniquity; but his blood will I require at thine hand.
If a Pope couldn’t care two straws for God or man, then from his POV God is for all practical purposes non-existent. Responsibility exists only if one regards it as doing so - a thoroughly worldly man has nothing to worry about, not as far as he is concerned. It is simply naive to imagine that such a man must needs be impressed by quotations from the Bible - a man who feared God would not commit the the sin of simony by bribing cardinals.
Some Popes have been throroughly worldly, & nothing is gained by saying they should not be - for that is not the point, if one is interested in what actually happened. How things
ought to be, &
how they were, don’t always coincide. Popes, like anyone else,
ought to be Saints, no doubt - it doesn’t follow for one moment that they were; a scoundrelly Pope is not an impossibility; merely a scandal. History can’t be derived from “what
ought to be” - moral obligation is no guide to what actually happened: if it were, then the history of the Church in both Testaments, & since, would be spotless. So would all of us. It is is not, & we aren’t. “Ought to be” does not equal " is" or “was” - not even in the history of the Papacy. To say otherwise, is to tell lies.
So God matters no more than people let Him do so - He can be explained away, as can anything said to be done by Him. Those who wish to be blind & deaf to Him can always find ways of ignoring Him. Why should Popes, any more than the rest of us, be exempt from this temptation ?
As for Papal responsibility: they have almost unlimited power over the Church, & they are not subject to any restraint from any source on earth. So they have a free hand, to interpret the texts as they wish - for there is nobody & nothing to stop them. Not Tradition, the Bible, the canons, councils, cardinals, theologians, bishops, episcopates, nor any combination of the faithful. They have no obligations to anyone. Because they get to say what the words of the texts mean in practice - so if the Pope wishes to ignore the recommendations of a cathedral chapter, he is free to do so; if he wishes to abolish prayers, he is free to do so. The words setting out their responsibilities mean just as much or as little as it pleases a Pope to let them. If they don’t like a law - they can abolish it.
That is what was meant by “they have no responsibility that they do not take on themselves” - because they say what’s what, & there are no longer any checks or balances in the Church to counter an immoral or dangerous or unwise or scandalous Papal decision. As the colossal fuss and bother over the Mass shows - the Pope has power over the Liturgy (as Pius XII points out in “Mediator Dei”);, so he can do anything he likes to it.
This unfettered “Papal omnipotence” is what bothers the Orthodox. Among us, the Pope is for all practical purposes above the Church - this means his position is in effect schismatic; he is divided from the Church by being so over-exalted. This is a very very *very *unhealthy development.
This book is directly relevant to this thread: