M
mardukm
Guest
I am officially impressed, brother.Typically when one bishop excommunicates another bishop, even if that bishop is the Pope, this simply means that they are no longer in communion with each other. However since you also say “depose the Pope and elect a new one”, that’s a much different matter. Since 1423, under Pope Martin V (1417-1431), the only authority great enough to depose a Pope is the Pope himself. But before that time there were actual cases where popes were deposed by Synod of Bishops in Rome. Benedict IX (1047-1048), for example, served three separate terms as Pope and was deposed two times as well, by the Council of Sutri. After his last deposition this Pope was also “excommunicated” by the Council of Sutri! Here is the chronology of Pope Benedict IX:
John XIX (1024-1032)
Benedict IX (1032-1044, 1st of 3 terms, resigned for financial reward.)
Silvester III (1045, Illegally elected, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)
Benedict IX (1045-1046, 2nd of 3 terms, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)
Gregory VI (1045-1046, Deposed by the Council of Sutri.)
Clement II (1046-1047)
Benedict IX (1047-1048, 3rd of 3 terms, deposed and excommunicated.)
Damasus II (1048)
If you are thinking of another jurisdiction deposing the Pope, I do not think that this is possible, the Latin Church is autocephalous, and as such the only thing that other autocephalous churches can do is break communion.
I hope this helps answer the question!
Blessings,
Marduk