Can the Pope be excommunicated?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mpartyka
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Typically when one bishop excommunicates another bishop, even if that bishop is the Pope, this simply means that they are no longer in communion with each other. However since you also say “depose the Pope and elect a new one”, that’s a much different matter. Since 1423, under Pope Martin V (1417-1431), the only authority great enough to depose a Pope is the Pope himself. But before that time there were actual cases where popes were deposed by Synod of Bishops in Rome. Benedict IX (1047-1048), for example, served three separate terms as Pope and was deposed two times as well, by the Council of Sutri. After his last deposition this Pope was also “excommunicated” by the Council of Sutri! Here is the chronology of Pope Benedict IX:

John XIX (1024-1032)

Benedict IX (1032-1044, 1st of 3 terms, resigned for financial reward.)

Silvester III (1045, Illegally elected, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Benedict IX (1045-1046, 2nd of 3 terms, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Gregory VI (1045-1046, Deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Clement II (1046-1047)

Benedict IX (1047-1048, 3rd of 3 terms, deposed and excommunicated.)

Damasus II (1048)

If you are thinking of another jurisdiction deposing the Pope, I do not think that this is possible, the Latin Church is autocephalous, and as such the only thing that other autocephalous churches can do is break communion.

I hope this helps answer the question!
I am officially impressed, brother.😃

Blessings,
Marduk
 
So I guess the question now is, has there been any decree by the competent authority that has cancelled the contents of the bull (encyclical(?)) mentioned above? If not, then it is still valid, and it states that a Pope falling into heresy no longer possesses the office.

I know Canon law says the Pope cannot be judged by anyone, but that is far from removing the validity of the aforementioned Bull/encyclical.
Doesn’t this bull date from before the first codification of canon law? Even if not, my guess is that a canon lawyer would say that canon law formally supersedes the relevant part of the bull and any canon law that may have been in effect then.
 
Doesn’t this bull date from before the first codification of canon law? Even if not, my guess is that a canon lawyer would say that canon law formally supersedes the relevant part of the bull and any canon law that may have been in effect then.
I don’t think the Canon law supersedes ANYTHING unless it explicitly states so. Doesn’t that make sense? I don’t see how the formalization of the Canon law would somehow automatically supersede EVERYTHING that went before it.

Besides, the closest thing we have in canon law related to the matter in that bull is the statement that the Pope cannot be judged by any person. But the latae sententiae excommunication contained in that bull would not be considered a judgment by a person.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
I suspect that there is within the rite of proclamation of pope a vow or solem oath that surely is used in the installation and formal investment of the original papal authority passed down to the new pope. I have never seen the words nor know if they are canon or tradition. But something just tells me that that oath has provisions for automatic anathemas or disinterment (pre-agreed excommunication through Peter’s authority itself perhaps?) in the event the power and authority is ever maligned or misused. If it doesn’t it should. In fact a swearing in rite with such a provision could also be used as a parliamentary mechanism to automatically and instantly nullify a misspoken ex-cathedra proclamation to not let it become binding on the faithful if the statement was stuttered or misspoken in error or just slipped through the checking systems (an “auto-retraction of sorts” that applies “papal” white out by instantly vacating the authority of the seat to preempt the occasion of an ex-cathedra snafu). The cardinals could then reinstall the office in short order with the same person through quick vote of confidence if the statement or behavior was recanted or declare the seat vacant by reason of papal-self-excommunication and call a new election.

Such a provision if it existed woud preempt a lot of potential problem scenarios and be a good safety valve. The down side is a poor and fragile aging pontiff who stuttered a lot or got a little foggy headed might get in the cross hairs of some trigger happy cardinals. 😃

At any rate, I am just tossing out the idea as another possible thing worthy of looking into. I really am curious now what the actual papal installation rites are that are apart from the coronation mass (no longer done I believe).

James
 
I don’t think the Canon law supersedes ANYTHING unless it explicitly states so. Doesn’t that make sense? I don’t see how the formalization of the Canon law would somehow automatically supersede EVERYTHING that went before it.
Agreed. Sorry, I wasn’t clear. I didn’t mean that it would be automatic, but that somewhere in the sequence of canon law revisions, it probably contained verbiage that would cover this provision.

Even if deposition of a pope isn’t addressed in current canon law, it could have been superseded by an earlier version, itself superseded. Of course, I don’t know whether that happened – just considering logical possibilities.
Besides, the closest thing we have in canon law related to the matter in that bull is the statement that the Pope cannot be judged by any person. But the latae sententiae excommunication contained in that bull would not be considered a judgment by a person.
Also agreed, and latae sententiae excommunication for heresy is in current canon law.
 
A valid Pope can never be excommunicated.

Excommunication can be given in two ways:
  1. ferendæ sententiæ
This is a judgment brought by one who has authority in the Church over the one being judged. But no one on earth in the Church has authority over the Pope to judge him, therefore this type of excommunicaion () cannot affect the Pope.
  1. latæ sententiæ
This is also called automatic excommunication, and it applies to persons who commit certain offenses, especially apostasy, heresy, or schism. The Pope is protected and prevented by God from falling into apostasy, heresy, or schism; this is due to the indefectibility of the Church and the fact that the Pope is the seat of the Magisterium and the head of the Church. The Church would not be indefectible if the Pope could commit apostasy, heresy, or schism.

It is merely hypothetical to consider what would happen if the Pope committed a sin that carried a latæ sententiæ excommunication, other than for apostasy, heresy, or schism. But in such a case, if Canon Law prescribed excommunication, and even if the Pope committed the requisite offense, he would still not be excommunicated, since the Pope is above Canon Law.
 
It is merely hypothetical to consider what would happen if the Pope committed a sin that carried a latæ sententiæ excommunication, other than for apostasy, heresy, or schism. But in such a case, if Canon Law prescribed excommunication, and even if the Pope committed the requisite offense, he would still not be excommunicated, since the Pope is above Canon Law.
Canon law is ALWAYS enacted with papal approval. So its prescriptions have the authority to apply to a Pope. I know that the Pope is considered bound by Canon law as a legislator is bound by his own law, but he is bound by it nevertheless.

If a canon law, approved by a Pope has a latae sententiae excommunication imposed for whatever act, then if the Pope commits that act, he has acquired latae sententiae excommunication and no longer has the authority to change that law to accomodate his sinfulness.

Blessings
 
Mardukm,

I just now had a chance to respond to the issues you raise. With respect, I do not agree that a latae sententiae excommunication necessarily carries with it a penalty of deprivation of office under canon law, particularly a deprivation of valid jurisdiction and exercise of the office. It certainly does not under the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

With regard to Cum Ex Apostolatus Officio, to the extent it provides for certain ipso facto penalties, they are positive ecclesiastical laws that can and have been changed numerous times throughout the history of the Roman Catholic Church. If one could show that they constitute immutable divine law, then that would be a different case.
 
Here’s a thought I’d like someone to comment on:

Since “excommunication” by one Bishop to another Bishop, or by a council of bishops to another Bishop, or to a Council of Bishops, essentially constitutes the same thing as the breaking of inter-communion between bishops, and since the Council of Bishops did in fact excommunicate a Pope in Rome (namely Benedict IX in 1048 AD), did the bishops in Rome who did this break themselves off from the See of St. Peter in the person of the Pope of Rome? How would these Latin bishops who excommunicated Benedict IX be any different than the Churches of the East when they broke communion with the Pope of Rome only six years after this time?!!
 
A valid Pope can never be excommunicated.

[A]utomatic excommunication . . . applies to persons who commit certain offenses, especially apostasy, heresy, or schism. The Pope is protected and prevented by God from falling into apostasy, heresy, or schism; this is due to the indefectibility of the Church and the fact that the Pope is the seat of the Magisterium and the head of the Church. The Church would not be indefectible if the Pope could commit apostasy, heresy, or schism.

But in such a case, if Canon Law prescribed excommunication, and even if the Pope committed the requisite offense, he would still not be excommunicated, since the Pope is above Canon Law.
The reasoning in this article first cited by tdgesq in #55 is, I think, persuasive:

catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0103fea1.asp

The pope could excommunicate himself, by virtue of committing heresy, for instance. I don’t see any basis for saying that the pope is prevented from holding heretical beliefs or professing them as his personal opinions; there is no doctrine of even limited ‘papal impeccability’. His subsequent acts would be valid but illicit. Not only does the Church’s indefectibility (her stability until the end of time as the institution of salvation founded by Christ) not prevent the pope from being a heretic, because his heresy could be occult it’s precisely the validity of his subsequent illicit acts that ensures the Church’s indefectibility. The charism of infallibility assures us that, even if the pope held heretical beliefs, the Holy Spirit would prevent him from making an ex cathedra declaration that those beliefs were orthodox.

I’m not aware of anything that puts the pope above canon law, nor do I see any mechanism whereby he could be deposed.
 
What about when there were 2 popes and they excommunicated each other? And then there was a 3rd pope that not everyone acknowledged…Crazy times, man. You ever hear of that joke with the Soviet Reversal?

In Soviet Russia, YOU excommunicate the POPE!
Because that’s what HAPPENED!

Good times. In general, though, the pope is kind of like a king.
 
  1. The Pope is prevented by God from even the possibility of falling into apostasy, heresy, or schism.
  2. The Pope can never be excommunicated under Canon Law.
Argument to support 1:

If any Pope in history could fall into heresy, and if he then would cease to be the head of the Church, then all his acts and teachings would not be valid, including his exercise of papal infallibility and his approval of the decrees of Councils. But heresy can be occult (hidden; not openly expressed). So the faithful would have no way of knowing which Popes were valid and which teachings and decision of which Popes were valid. Now the rules for electing subsequent Popes are often written or changed by previous Popes. But if any Pope could fall into heresy, and lose his authority, then we would have no way of knowing which rules made for a valid subsequent election. The entire papacy and each successive Pope’s authority would then be in doubt.

But God is not foolish. He did not build the Church in such a manner that it would be a house of cards, easily falling apart, losing its authority, because of the sin of one man, or a few men. Therefore, as part of the indefectibility of the Church, God prevents every Pope from even the possibility of falling into apostasy, heresy, or schism.

Argument to support 2:

The same argument applies to the claim that the Pope could be excommunicated under Canon Law. We would have no way of knowing if the Pope had broken a law that had the penalty of automatic excommunication. So then we would have no way of knowing which Popes had lost their authority, and the whole Magisterium, in effect, would be placed in doubt.

But God did not build the Church on sand. It cannot be the case that any Pope can be excommunicated, no matter what he does, because then the Church would lose its indefectibility, which is impossible.
 
  1. The Pope is prevented by God from even the possibility of falling into apostasy, heresy, or schism.
Where do we find this in authoritative Church teaching? E.g. a document of an ecumenical council, a papal encyclical, even one of the catechisms?
  1. The Pope can never be excommunicated under Canon Law.
Where does canon law exempt the pope either from the provisions of canon law in general or from the provisions relating to automatic excommunication specifically?
 
Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?

–Mike
Sure!
If he was a Heretic:
St. Robert Bellarmine, De Romano Pontifice, II, 30:
"This principle is most certain. The non-Christian cannot in any way be Pope, as Cajetan himself admits (ib. c. 26). The reason for this is that he cannot be head of what he is not a member; now he who is not a Christian is not a member of the Church, and a manifest heretic is not a Christian, as is clearly taught by St. Cyprian (lib. 4, epist. 2), St. Athanasius (Scr. 2 cont. Arian.), St. Augustine (lib. De great. Christ. Cap. 20), St. Jerome (contra Lucifer.) and others; therefore the manifest heretic cannot be Pope."


St. Francis De Sales (17th century), Doctor of the Church, The Catholic Controversy, pp. 305-306: “Now when he [the Pope] is explicitly a heretic, he falls ipso facto from his dignity and out of the Church…”

For Heretics are outside of The Church:
Pope Eugene IV, Council of Florence, “Cantate Domino,” 1441:
“The Holy Roman Church firmly believes, professes and preaches that all those who are outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans but also Jews or heretics and schismatics, cannot share in eternal life and will go into the everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless they are joined to the Church before the end of their lives…”

Pope Leo XIII, Satis Cognitum (# 9), June 29, 1896:
“The practice of the Church has always been the same, as is shown by the unanimous teaching of the Fathers, who were wont to hold as outside Catholic communion, and alien to the Church, whoever would recede in the least degree from any point of
doctrine proposed by her authoritative Magisterium.”

That is the only reason a Pope can be Excommunicated: Heresy and Apostasy.
 
That is the only reason a Pope can be Excommunicated: Heresy and Apostasy.
And yet Pope Benedict IX was deposed and excommunicated in 1048 by Council of Sutri. Someone please tell me if I got my facts wrong! As I read it Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated for reasons other than Heresy or Apostasy. And once again, if I am correct about the history of Pope Benedict IX being excommunicated in Rome by Roman authority; the split between the Eastern and Western Churches was only 6 years after Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated (in 1054), so if bishops in Rome can break communion with the Pope via excommunicating him, how much different is that from the Eastern Churches breaking communion with the Pope?
 
And yet Pope Benedict IX was deposed and excommunicated in 1048 by Council of Sutri. Someone please tell me if I got my facts wrong! As I read it Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated for reasons other than Heresy or Apostasy. And once again, if I am correct about the history of Pope Benedict IX being excommunicated in Rome by Roman authority; the split between the Eastern and Western Churches was only 6 years after Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated (in 1054), so if bishops in Rome can break communion with the Pope via excommunicating him, how much different is that from the Eastern Churches breaking communion with the Pope?
I’m far from the best person to comment on all the murk surrounding Benedict IX, so I hope someone knowledgeable will step forward.

First, it’s important to understand that these events occurred in the absence of clearly defined procedures. Wasn’t all this about 500 years before the first code of canon law? There was a degree of improvisation in how things were done.

From what I’ve seen, there were three men claiming to be the pope and no one could determine for sure who the rightful claimant was. One of them called a local synod to resolve the situation. He resigned and the council deposed the other two. The emperor nominated the new pope, one of the last instances of that procedure. I haven’t seen any indication that the synod excommunicated anyone.
 
Dear brother JohnVIII,
And yet Pope Benedict IX was deposed and excommunicated in 1048 by Council of Sutri. Someone please tell me if I got my facts wrong! As I read it Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated for reasons other than Heresy or Apostasy. And once again, if I am correct about the history of Pope Benedict IX being excommunicated in Rome by Roman authority; the split between the Eastern and Western Churches was only 6 years after Pope Benedict IX was excommunicated (in 1054), so if bishops in Rome can break communion with the Pope via excommunicating him, how much different is that from the Eastern Churches breaking communion with the Pope?
Thank you for your honest question and permitting us to clear up the matter. The Council of Sutri was called by Henry III to settle the disorder in the Church of Rome. At the time, the true holder of the office was Pope Gregory VI. He was not deposed, but abdicated. The “deposition” of Benedict IX and Sylvester III - the other two claimants to the sedes - was a mere formality because they were not actually the Popes at the time. So no Pope was actually deposed by the Council of Sutri.

Given the facts, your ultimate question no longer seems to be relevant. If you feel it is, please explain, and we will try to respond.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother JohnVIII,

Thank you for your honest question and permitting us to clear up the matter. The Council of Sutri was called by Henry III to settle the disorder in the Church of Rome. At the time, the true holder of the office was Pope Gregory VI. He was not deposed, but abdicated. The “deposition” of Benedict IX and Sylvester III - the other two claimants to the sedes - was a mere formality because they were not actually the Popes at the time. So no Pope was actually deposed by the Council of Sutri.

Given the facts, your ultimate question no longer seems to be relevant. If you feel it is, please explain, and we will try to respond.

Blessings,
Marduk
Thanks for clearing that up, I was actually lost when I first read the question, it took me a bit to connect it with the Schism.
 
Sure!
If he was a Heretic:
St. Robert Bellarmine, De Romano Pontifice, II, 30:
"This principle is most certain. The non-Christian cannot in any way be Pope, as Cajetan himself admits (ib. c. 26). The reason for this is that he cannot be head of what he is not a member; now he who is not a Christian is not a member of the Church, and a manifest heretic is not a Christian, as is clearly taught by St. Cyprian (lib. 4, epist. 2), St. Athanasius (Scr. 2 cont. Arian.), St. Augustine (lib. De great. Christ. Cap. 20), St. Jerome (contra Lucifer.) and others; therefore the manifest heretic cannot be Pope."
While it is true that St. Bellarmine concludes in his fifth opinion that a manifest heretic cannot be Pope, in the very same chapter he states that there is no ecclesiastical authority within the Church that can depose a Pope:

“Besides that, the second affirmation of Cajetan, that the Pope heretic can be truly and authoritatively deposed by the Church, is no less false than the first. For if the Church deposes the Pope against his will it is certainly above the Pope . . . .” fisheaters.com/bellarmine.html

Bellarmine’s opinion is that if a Pope is a manifest heretic, he automatically ceases to be Pope because he is no longer part of the body of Christ. He does not cease to be Pope because of any declaration of the Church. Once the Pope loses his office by virtue of being a manifest heretic, only then may the Church act against him since he would no longer be Pope. But the real question this raises is: Can a Pope ever become a manifest heretic?

St. Bellarmine states in his first opinion that it is probable this cannot happen:

Book 4, chapter 6 of De Romano Pontifice:
Code:
Chapter 6. On the pontiff as he is a particular person.

Fourth Proposition: It is probable and can be piously believed that the highest pontiff, not only cannot err as pontiff, but also as a particular person cannot be a heretic by believing anything false contrary to the faith.

This is proved firstly because the sweet order of God's providence seems to require it. For the pontiff not only should not and cannot preach heresy, but also should always teach the truth, and he will certainly do this since the Lord commanded him to confirm his brothers, and therefore he added: I have asked for you that your faith not fail, i.e. that the preaching of the true faith not fail in your see. And how, I ask, will a heretical pontiff confirm his brothers in the faith and always preach the true faith? Surely God can force out a confession of the true faith from a heretical heart, as he once put words in the mouth of the *** Balaam; but it would be violent and not according to the custom of God's providence sweetly ordering all things.

Secondly it is proved from the result, for so far there has been no heretic, or certainly it cannot be proved of any that he was a heretic. Therefore it is a sign that this cannot happen.
This quotation from Bellarmine comes from itsjustdave’s excellent blog here: itsjustdave1988.blogspot.com/search?q=sedevacantism

In other words, although Bellarmine believes that a Pope would cease being Pope without any action of the Church upon becoming a manifest heretic, he also believes a Pope cannot become a manifest heretic by virtue of divine providence and the indefectability of the Church. This leads to the ultimate question: what is the criteria for determining a manifest heretic and who in the case of the Pope would have the authority to judge?

That is a question that theologians who follow Bellarmine have struggled with for centuries. Btw, St. Bellarmine would have had access to the decrees of the Council of Florence and the case of Honorius at the time he wrote De Romano Pontifice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top