Can Your Child Be Too Religious?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SamH
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SamH

Guest
Therapists in private practice report that they are seeing children and teens across a range of faiths whose religious practice can be problematic. The amount of time they spend praying, or in other acts of spiritual practice, is not as important, they say, as the quality of this devotion, and whether it helps the children or instead isolates them and undermines their schoolwork and relationships. Children with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), for example, may rigidly repeat holy verses, say Hail Mary’s or focus on other rituals less out of a deeper sense of faith but more as an expression of their disorder. “It looks positive but could be negative,” says Stephanie Mihalas, a UCLA professor and licensed clinical psychologist.

Such ritualistic behavior, she says, may also reflect a child’s way of coping with anxiety, and in reality could be no more spiritual than fanatical hand washing or dreading to walk on cracks. “These kids fear that if they don’t obey their religious rules perfectly,” explains Carole Lierberman, MD, a psychiatrist in Beverly Hills, “God will punish them.”

(MORE: Religion’s Secret to Happiness: It’s Friends, Not Faith)

**Some children suffer from scrupulosity, a form of OCD that involves a feeling of guilt and shame. **
news.yahoo.com/child-too-religious-094552602.html
Lord knows we can’t have children feeling shame… And any overt religious act by a child must be due to mental health issues…

A more apt article would have covered “Can your child be too liberal”?
 
Lord knows we can’t have children feeling shame… And any overt religious act by a child must be due to mental health issues…

A more apt article would have covered “Can your child be too liberal”?
This isn’t an article about normal kids that go to church. This is an article about children that have mental health issues that are manifesting with religious actions. If a 14 year old child has crippling anxiety because he does not want to go to hell because he said something mean to someone and cannot think about anything else, then yes, the kid is “too religious.”

Religion and a bond with God should enrich your life. If it is causing serious anxiety and negatively effecting your happiness (as it does to many with OCD or other mental health issues) it would be best to stop these religious actions.
 
Lord knows we can’t have children feeling shame… And any overt religious act by a child must be due to mental health issues…

A more apt article would have covered “Can your child be too liberal”?
Actually Sam, you are not correct about this (or at least your attitude is quite dismissive of this debilitating condition). My dd is 8 and I believe suffers from this (even the priest has explained to her that all that she does is not necessary). If you have never seen what is being discussed you cannot begin to understand how emotional this is not just as a parent watching their child go through this but for the child too. My daughter cries and asks why she is like this because it really does bother her and she can’t begin to tell reality because her mind distorts things.
 
This isn’t an article about normal kids that go to church. This is an article about children that have mental health issues that are manifesting with religious actions. If a 14 year old child has crippling anxiety because he does not want to go to hell because he said something mean to someone and cannot think about anything else, then yes, the kid is “too religious.”
Well no, that would not mean he is “too religious”, just that he has mental issues that need to be addressed.
 
Well no, that would not mean he is “too religious”, just that he has mental issues that need to be addressed.
Well that is obviously what was meant in the article posted and the thread starter called it “too religious.”
 
Lord knows we can’t have children feeling shame… And any overt religious act by a child must be due to mental health issues…

A more apt article would have covered “Can your child be too liberal”?
It doesn’t say “any overtly religious act” – it’s quite clearly about children with mental health issues. OCD, in it’s more severe manifestations, can be a terrible thing to struggle with.
 
Well no, that would not mean he is “too religious”, just that he has mental issues that need to be addressed.
True. It is important to recognize that the problem with excessive anxiety or OCD motivating empty prayers or constant fear is not that the child is spending too much time on religion, but that they are spending time on religion incorrectly.

There is a problem that the article addresses (scrupulosity and the like are real issues), but these things are not “too religious,” they are “wrongly religious.” Calling these things being “too religious” is like saying that an overweight person who starts becoming bulimic is “too focused on health.” It’s not that the person is too focused on being healthy, it’s that they’re doing it wrong.
 
It doesn’t say “any overtly religious act” – it’s quite clearly about children with mental health issues. OCD, in it’s more severe manifestations, can be a terrible thing to struggle with.
Then perhaps a credible author would choose a title for their work that doesn’t somehow portray the religiousness as the problem?

If the focus was on children having mental health issues, why ask about religiousness? That is one of MANY ways they manifest.
 
Then perhaps a credible author would choose a title for their work that doesn’t somehow portray the religiousness as the problem?
I do have to say, in a lot of places the author doesn’t choose the title their piece is displayed under. I have often enough seen the same piece displayed under multiple headlines - I believe the editor often chooses those.
If the focus was on children having mental health issues, why ask about religiousness? That is one of MANY ways they manifest.
Because I think the point was that religiousness is a way they manifest that people often miss. Improper and excessive religious devotion might not be seen as a problem in someone who isn’t used to it, because it could appear pious rather than problematic. And many religious people might worry about having the problem treated, because they don’t want their kid to become “less religious.”
 
True. It is important to recognize that the problem with excessive anxiety or OCD motivating empty prayers or constant fear is not that the child is spending too much time on religion, but that they are spending time on religion incorrectly.
Then address it as an OCD issue instead of a “too” religious issue. :rolleyes:
 
Then address it as an OCD issue instead of a “too” religious issue. :rolleyes:
Agreed. The title of the piece was not good. I only skimmed the actual article, it seemed less bad, if not terribly great either.
 
I do have to say, in a lot of places the author doesn’t choose the title their piece is displayed under. I have often enough seen the same piece displayed under multiple headlines - I believe the editor often chooses those.
So instead of a single writer we have a media outlet choosing to act that way. If anything that makes it worse.
 
The catechism says that superstition is being too religious. You start attributing power to things that don’t have it.
 
See, I think this is EXACTLY what the article is saying. I didn’t see it saying that you should treat the religiousness instead of the OCD. What I saw it saying was that certain kinds of religious behaviors can be symptoms of OCD, and that many people don’t understand this - resulting in children not getting any treatment at all. The article in fact suggested that part of the treatment be teaching the child a proper understanding of religion, rather than pushing them away from it altogether.
 
Then address it as an OCD issue instead of a “too” religious issue. :rolleyes:
Oh, but then you would miss the opportunity to get in a subtle dig against religion and religious people. :rolleyes:

I was a scrupulous kid from the time of my First Communion prep (learning about Hell, also my grandpa had died a few months prior). Anxiety disorders run in my family on both sides so I was a sitting duck for it. It got really bad in young adulthood. Thanks to finding a helpful priest most of the time I know how to handle it now on my own or can ask a priest “Am I being scrupulous about (whatever) or what?”

It is something that needs to be addressed by parents with children who have it but I wish this writer had been more thoughtful in the choice of a title for the article.

Have to say, it’s amazing to see it in a regular news venue because back when I was struggling with it, it took some searching to find the information I needed - and the priest God directed me to, I have no doubt. 😉 My parents and other parents of scrupulous kids wouldn’t have known exactly what I was suffering. (No one who hasn’t experienced true anxiety and OCD really could.)

One final thought - could it be that scrupulosity is on the rise because the world provides plenty of things that cause us all an undercurrent of anxiety? :ouch: We all need to be praying about the state of the world :signofcross: Maybe these young souls are picking up on some of that because they are already by nature sensitive to it? Food for thought. :twocents:
 
To simply put it.Ofcourse your child can’t be too religous!
 
The catechism says that superstition is being too religious. You start attributing power to things that don’t have it.
Er, not exactly, or at least not without qualification. “2110…Superstition in some sense represents a perverse excess of religion; irreligion is the vice contrary by defect to the virtue of religion.”

Superstition is a perversion, and excess of perverted religion, not an excess of religion how it’s supposed to be.

Immediately after, we see: 2111 Superstition is the deviation of religious feeling and of the practices this feeling imposes. It can even affect the worship we offer the true God, e.g., when one attributes an importance in some way magical to certain practices otherwise lawful or necessary. To attribute the efficacy of prayers or of sacramental signs to their mere external performance, apart from the interior dispositions that they demand, is to fall into superstition.

Again, it’s not a matter of doing too much of what is good, but of doing bad things that may outwardly look similar to what is good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top