Catholic history is disturbing

  • Thread starter Thread starter suupah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Church does not clearly define what is infallible and what is not. The lines are purposely blurred as to accomodate the user when necessary. Under those conditions I or anyone else can be infallible.
** Hi Ron, 👋
Under your reasonngs about the church’s condition you believe you could be your own Pope? Could I recommend the named “Forrest I” If you use candy as communion and you will be a shoe in at the next annual protestant convention. Eeeerrr, you do have conventions don’t you? What about the ones you don’t believe are true churches? I think that would amount to the about 60,999 other protestant denominations wouldn’t it? **
 
I think we should pray for Catholics and the Catholic hierarchy to have more humility. This attitude that says we are right about everything and everyone else is wrong does not promote unity and I don’t think Jesus would approve of it either. If anyone had a right to be that way it was Jesus but he wasn’t that way at all.
**
Hi ron, 👋
The Bible says “Answer a fool according to his folly, lest he be wise in his own conceit”.Pro 26:5
Now take some time to mean the real Jesus: Jesus who showed anger in the synagogue of Capernaum. When the Pharisees refused to answer Jesus’ questions, “He . . . looked round about them with anger” Mark 3:5 says that His anger was attended by grief over the Pharisees’ lack of faith. Jesus’ anger stemmed from love for the Pharisees and concern for their spiritual condition. It had nothing to do with hatred or ill will. Now imagine Him being told “Master, someone insulted your Mother!” What would He do? I think: “And I will dash them one against another, even the fathers and the sons together, saith the LORD: I will not pity, nor spare, nor have mercy, but destroy them.” Jer13:14
How can we judge? “The spiritual man makes judgments about all things, but he himself is not subject to any man’s judgment:” 1 Cor 2:15 We are told not to argue with an unbeliever.TI 6:20, 2TI 2:14-16, 3:1-7 **
 
** Hi Ron, 👋
Under your reasonngs about the church’s condition you believe you could be your own Pope? Could I recommend the named “Forrest I” If you use candy as communion and you will be a shoe in at the next annual protestant convention. Eeeerrr, you do have conventions don’t you? What about the ones you don’t believe are true churches? I think that would amount to the about 60,999 other protestant denominations wouldn’t it? **
I am a Catholic (it’s on my profile) like many others who have had denominational struggles within my family. Don’t assume I am Protestant because I crticize Catholics. I also critcize Protestants, atheists: those who put their faith in Darwin and anyone else who does not make sense.
 
** Hi Ron, 👋
Under your reasonngs about the church’s condition you believe you could be your own Pope? Could I recommend the named “Forrest I” If you use candy as communion and you will be a shoe in at the next annual protestant convention. Eeeerrr, you do have conventions don’t you? What about the ones you don’t believe are true churches? I think that would amount to the about 60,999 other protestant denominations wouldn’t it? **
I’m one of you. I’m Catholic. If you have a problem with it tell the priest who baptized me.
Can you tell me what has been proclaimed as infallible or where I could find it?
 
I’m one of you. I’m Catholic. If you have a problem with it tell the priest who baptized me.
Can you tell me what has been proclaimed as infallible or where I could find it?
What has been decreed infallible are any ex-cathedra statements. As far as I know, there are only two: The Immaculate Conception and Assumption.
 
I am a Catholic (it’s on my profile) like many others who have had denominational struggles within my family. Don’t assume I am Protestant because I crticize Catholics. I also critcize Protestants, atheists: those who put their faith in Darwin and anyone else who does not make sense.
Hi Ron,

There is a good book called “Catholicism: Now I Get it by Claire Furia Smith.” It is a small book but surprisingly packed with information and a very easy and quite entertaining read.

I think sometimes our criticisms can come from not knowing exactly where the Church stands on issues and why she has taken that stand.

I am a cradle Catholic and have loved the faith ever since I can remember. And yet it is only now, from doing more reading that I am beginning to get a bretter grasp or the depth, richness and beauty of the Catholic Church.

Also, if you have the time, try to get a book called “Why Does God Permit Evil” by Dom Brunno Webb. It is another small book that is well worth the money and time spent. It gives us a glimpse of how our faith comes into play in the whole economy of salvation.
 
Hi Ron,

There is a good book called “Catholicism: Now I Get it by Claire Furia Smith.” It is a small book but surprisingly packed with information and a very easy and quite entertaining read.

I think sometimes our criticisms can come from not knowing exactly where the Church stands on issues and why she has taken that stand.

I am a cradle Catholic and have loved the faith ever since I can remember. And yet it is only now, from doing more reading that I am beginning to get a bretter grasp or the depth, richness and beauty of the Catholic Church.

Also, if you have the time, try to get a book called “Why Does God Permit Evil” by Dom Brunno Webb. It is another small book that is well worth the money and time spent. It gives us a glimpse of how our faith comes into play in the whole economy of salvation.
Thanks Benedictus. I agree with you. The Catholic Church is the true church and it has beauty and richness. My criticism does come from the inability to understand what the Church actually teaches. There have been more than 2 infallible decrees but no one knows what they are. Most Catholics don’t agree on that and many other teachings of the Church so where is the unity? Some Catholics on this forum are united in their hatred of Protestants. Go to Ireland. You can get a gun and kill them if that’s what you like. If there were no Protestants I suppose they would find inferior Catholics to pick on. Now back to the subject. Symux really hit the nail on the head. Power hungry leaders in the past abused that power and stole it from the true believers.
 
Thanks Benedictus. I agree with you. The Catholic Church is the true church and it has beauty and richness. My criticism does come from the inability to understand what the Church actually teaches. There have been more than 2 infallible decrees but no one knows what they are. Most Catholics don’t agree on that and many other teachings of the Church so where is the unity? Some Catholics on this forum are united in their hatred of Protestants. Go to Ireland. You can get a gun and kill them if that’s what you like. If there were no Protestants I suppose they would find inferior Catholics to pick on. Now back to the subject. Symux really hit the nail on the head. Power hungry leaders in the past abused that power and stole it from the true believers.
I do not agree with that statement one bit and can refute it but i am so tired and it is very late so I will leave the answer for tomorrow.

That statement is actually a dangerous statement with no merit in it whatsoever. But I will explain tomorrow.
 
I am a Catholic (it’s on my profile) like many others who have had denominational struggles within my family. Don’t assume I am Protestant because I crticize Catholics. I also critcize Protestants, atheists: those who put their faith in Darwin and anyone else who does not make sense.

Hi Ron,👋
Don’t pretend, Be honest. You don’t believe doctrines of the Catholic church. You want to do it “your way” You have no faith in the Cathathic church and the infallability of the Pope. that sounds Protestant to me. We teach that all christians are “Catholic”. They just don’t agree with our teachings or realize it. Sound familiar? Sso lets think about changing your profile to “non-denominational christian”. :rolleyes: The Protestants may already use that title they need 61,000 different names to attempt to keep their denominations straight. Some even are using Catholic in their names. That will help add confusion. The devil must love that.
I apologize for thinking you were a Protestant, it was the old “If it walk and looks like a Duck…’” Catholics are “permited” to put our “faith” in Darwin also and from reading the last line of your post I must say: “Please don’t be so critical of YOURSELF!”

God Bless ****
 

Hi Ron,👋
Don’t pretend, Be honest. You don’t believe doctrines of the Catholic church. You want to do it “your way” You have no faith in the Cathathic church and the infallability of the Pope. that sounds Protestant to me. We teach that all christians are “Catholic”. They just don’t agree with our teachings or realize it. Sound familiar? Sso lets think about changing your profile to “non-denominational christian”. :rolleyes: The Protestants may already use that title they need 61,000 different names to attempt to keep their denominations straight. Some even are using Catholic in their names. That will help add confusion. The devil must love that.
I apologize for thinking you were a Protestant, it was the old “If it walk and looks like a Duck…’” Catholics are “permited” to put our “faith” in Darwin also and from reading the last line of your post I must say: “Please don’t be so critical of YOURSELF!”

God Bless ****
Before you find fault with me you should speak to Catholics in your own parish and then expand from there and find out what they really believe. Concern yourself with baptized Catholics who don’t believe in the death, burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ, those who believe there is nothing wrong woth pre-marital sex and those who believe in reincarnation, numerology, astrology, horoscopes and psychics.
 
I’m one of you. I’m Catholic. If you have a problem with it tell the priest who baptized me.
Can you tell me what has been proclaimed as infallible or where I could find it?
**Hi ron,👋

Trust me on this one old buddy. You are not one of us. We take our religious beliefs on faith. We do not allow the devil to attempt to pull us away from the church through doubt or the “quest for knowledge” He did that ti Adam and Eve remember? They wasnted to have more Knowledge. I blame your lack of Faith on your desire to understand Our faith rather thaen live our Faith.

I happen to love our protestant brethren. I have “physically” defended them and their churches from attack. I would lay down my life to defend their right to worship freely. And not just christians. This is no idle boast. I have the scars to prove it!
We are all children of God. The Catholic church is right. They are wrong! It is that simple. They are members of corrupted, twisted, distorted, counterfeit denominations and that is just the way it is. Our Church is 2,000 years old we have remaind true to Jesus’ teachings. In only 500 years the protestants have developed 1,375 doctrines of their own. In 2,000 years if they could ever last that long theree would be 1244,000 denominations teaching 4500 doctrines and dogma, we would still be teaching the exact same thing e have for the past 2,000 years.

“Faith is to believe what you do not see; the reward of this faith is to see what you believe.”- Saint Augustine

“Seek not to understand that you may believe, but believe that you may understand.” - Saint Augustine

As Ben said: What has been decreed infallible are any ex-cathedra statements. So far there has been only two: The Immaculate Conception and Assumption.

Talk to a priest. Pray and remember Jesus loves all of us!

God Bless **
 
What has been decreed infallible are any ex-cathedra statements. As far as I know, there are only two: The Immaculate Conception and Assumption.
There have been more than 2 infallible decrees but no one knows what they are.
“As far as I know” is a strange way to put it, but the opinion that benedictus2 expressed is actually quite common, even among conservative Catholics. (Don’t ask me why.)
Some Catholics on this forum are united in their hatred of Protestants.
Sad. But true.

I see it as part of a larger trend, of Catholicism being “hijacked” on the internet.
 
Before you find fault with me you should speak to Catholics in your own parish and then expand from there and find out what they really believe. Concern yourself with baptized Catholics who don’t believe in the death, burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ, those who believe there is nothing wrong woth pre-marital sex and those who believe in reincarnation, numerology, astrology, horoscopes and psychics.
**Hi ron, 👋 **

**Why would I start with them? Am I to do an invertory of what they believe? How about I start with someone who professes to be catholic and doesn’t act like he can spell the word? I find fault with you because you speak faulty. If they did I would find fault with them. I concern myself with my Faith and i tell people all the time that there isant sucah a thing as “luck” If someone mentions numerology, astrology, horoscopes or psychics I ay I am catholic we don’t believe in magic. That usually stopes them in their tracks unless they are catholic and desire to debate the reason why their erronious thinking is correct. Hmmm, reminds me of someone else! :rolleyes: . Held thy self. Talk to a priest, Pray that is the best advise I can give you. Remember Jesus does love you… **


**Do you know what I would call a baptized Catholics who don’t believe in the death, burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ? A catholic that needs someone to pray for them and explain that their eternal soul depends on their accepting Jesus’ offer to be their personal savior. He died for our sins, We have the free will not to accept His sacarifice. **


God Bless
 
Can I be unbaptized? I don’t think so.
**No Ron, **

It left an indeliable mark on your soul. But, if you don’t realize what you are doing, and repent. The only use it might have is help Satan in his count of how many “christians” he was able to steal from Jesus’. However, you could just depend on the mercy of God, or that Protestant belief of OSAS. Now that is a funny concept. May have been made by someone with simular beliefs about our church as you, Do you think?

God Bless
 
**No Ron, **

It left an indeliable mark on your soul. But, if you don’t realize what you are doing, and repent. The only use it might have is help Satan in his count of how many “christians” he was able to steal from Jesus’. However, you could just depend on the mercy of God, or that Protestant belief of OSAS. Now that is a funny concept. May have been made by someone with simular beliefs about our church as you, Do you think?

God Bless
I don’t know exactly what you are trying to say but let me say this and relate it to church history in my life time to keep on the subject. I am very honest. If I were to change my profile it would say Catholic/Protestant because I believe in the real presence of Jesus in the eucharist. The Protestants don’t believe that so I’m not a real Protestant either. I’m very impressed with the faithful Catholics on this forum because they know what they believe and why they believe it. I can’t say that about myself because a lot of the stuff I learned was at a Catholic bible study given by a priest. My parish priest tells us to take the good that we can learn from the Protestants. Obviously what you guys have learned is very different from what I was taught. I don’t get on here to create conflict. I get on here to challenge people hoping they can meet the challenge and change my mind. Sorry if I offend anyone in the process. Sometimes things get rough when you talk about religion.
 
It seems that my comment about Catholicism being hijacked came at a good time. (sigh)

ron,

I don’t feel that I know you extremely well, but my impression is that you’re sincerely interested in dialogue – which is a very welcome characteristic, whether you’re Catholic, Protestant, or miscellaneous (to paraphrase Reverend Lovejoy).
 
It seems that my comment about Catholicism being hijacked came at a good time. (sigh)

ron,

I don’t feel that I know you extremely well, but my impression is that you’re sincerely interested in dialogue – which is a very welcome characteristic, whether you’re Catholic, Protestant, or miscellaneous (to paraphrase Reverend Lovejoy).
Catholics get very concerned when someone expresses the idea that another Catholic does not accept all the teachings of the Church. In reality many Catholics do not accept all the teachings of the Church because they don’t know what they are. I’m almost certain that if I asked any group of Catholics what they think is required by the Church as necessary for salvation they would not all be in agreement. On this thread alone there is disagreement about what has been declared as infallible doctrine. I want to dialogue but I think it leads to shadow boxing. If we could go back in time and put all believers in one big room I think we would see that we all disagree about something and Jesus knew before the world began whose name is written in the Lamb’s Book of Life.
 
I am a Catholic (it’s on my profile) like many others who have had denominational struggles within my family. Don’t assume I am Protestant because I crticize Catholics. I also critcize Protestants, atheists: those who put their faith in Darwin and anyone else who does not make sense.
Anybody who can type a profile can claim to be a ‘catholic’. The question should be: do you believe in what Catholicism stands for? If not, you’re as much of a Catholic as a black swan is what he thinks he is.
 
Catholics get very concerned when someone expresses the idea that another Catholic does not accept all the teachings of the Church. In reality many Catholics do not accept all the teachings of the Church because they don’t know what they are. I’m almost certain that if I asked any group of Catholics what they think is required by the Church as necessary for salvation they would not all be in agreement. On this thread alone there is disagreement about what has been declared as infallible doctrine. I want to dialogue but I think it leads to shadow boxing. If we could go back in time and put all believers in one big room I think we would see that we all disagree about something and Jesus knew before the world began whose name is written in the Lamb’s Book of Life.
Then you’re as catholic as other non-catholics think they are!😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top