Catholic OB/GYN?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MrsATurner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve had PCOS for years since I was a Freshman in college and never took Birth Control Pills to protect my uterine lining. **Occasionally I was given Provera (progesterone) to shed my lining, but it was infrequent over the years. ** I’m 42 years old now, never been married, have no children and am open to life and marriage and children. However, I am now faced with uterine hyperplasia. Although I’ve been praying for a miracle and going the conservative route to treat this condition, hysterectomy is a real viable treatment unfortunately for what I’m experieincing because although Megase (a synthetic progesterone) treatment has helped eradicate the hyerplasia (thickened endometrium), atypical cells were found in my latest biopsy at the beginning of July. The pathologists did a stain for cancer on them, and a small foci of atypical cells that did not strongly diffuse for carcinoma but contained some that had with some/ weak diffusion. ?? Because is was non-diagnostic but still concerning, the gynocological oncologist who is treating me is concerned with the atypical cells and had to in his professional opinion suggest a hysterectomy or another D&C (I’ve had 2 already this year). The atypical cells in the biopsy are a precancerous condition and could also be an indication of an occult cancer. This is very scary, and I’m struggling with decision making because every fiber of my being wants to save my fertility and still be open to life but worries about the uncertainty of it all. ??? I’m struggling with trusting God although I know that He is capable of miracles and capable of everything. So…as of right now, I’ve decided to go in for a 3rd D&C (in two weeks July 24th) so that the doctor will have a larger sample to send to the pathologist for better evaluation and characterization of the atypical cells (hopefully there won’t be any is my prayer), and I’ll still have the opportunity to be treated conservatively. Why am I writing all this in detail…??? Perhaps I am sharing because I need prayers and prayers and more prayers. And also because this current condition of mine is the result of years of irregular, very irregular and often absent for months and months at a time, periods. **Had I taken birth control pills, which I didn’t, I might not be in the current health situation I’m in with possible uterine cancer and/or precancerous uterine cells that might make having to remove my uterus in a hysterectomy my only option. ** And…had I taken birth control pills in my younger years, it wouldn’t have been for the intent of preventing conception but for the health of my uterine lining over the long term. Had I known what I know now, I might have asked to be put on birth control pills…??? I don’t know???..I’m just saying that I did things right and was never on the pill, but because of PCOS and not regularly shedding a lining like I would have, had I been on birth control pills, I might not now be facing the potential loss of my uterus when I’m so desiring marriage, children and a family. It’s stressful and heart breaking. Any and all prayers for my situation would be appreciated. I’m trying to be open to life still and God’s will but also responsible to the care of my temple as I traverse these uncertain and rough waters with having to deal with my health situation in the near future.😦
Thank you for sharing and I’m sorry you are going through this. 😦

This is a sobering reminder that you cannot ignore PCOS or simply stay away from the “bad contraceptives.” The uterine lining should be shed at minimum 4x per year (every three months) to prevent hyperplasia. Whether using provera every 3 months or OCPs monthly, please use something to shed the lining.
 
I would love to have a Catholic OB/GYN myself but I am afraid Medicaid wouldn’t cover the ones that don’t prescribe birth control.
That isn’t true. I know for a fact that my OBGYN has medicaid patients.
 
I got my NaPro OBGYN from a list given to me by my Creighton Model instructor. My instructor works out of an office one of the local Catholic hospitals, so I imagine that I could have gotten the same list from that hospital.
 
Not sure if this is the place to put this, If its not feel free to move it.

Is there anyway to find a Catholic or pro-catholic OB/GYN. I love the one I have right now but he really pushes Birth Control and since becoming a Catholic again I do not want to be on BC. He claims that since I have PCOS that BC is the best option but the more I am researching it the more I have realized it is far from it.
Keep in mind that PCOS can be treated with hormones. While the doctor may refer to them as “birth control” pills, that is not what they are actually being used for, and thus are a valid, acceptable, and moral treatment.

I would recommend a more natural treatment. Losing weight and exercising is also an accepted treatment, but as always, seek advice from a medical professional.
 
Oh my Gosh thank you so much! I have tried the fertilitycare.org website but it told me that my nearest Doctor was 3 hours away from me. I live in a small community and accept that I may have to travel an hour to a larger city.

I was able to find one an hour away. But he is listed under Family Practice. Will they still do OB/GYN stuff?
My daughter found a NaPro family practitioner who treated her fertility issues; she went to a Catholic OB-GYN when she became pregnant, and the combination worked well.
 
Keep in mind that PCOS can be treated with hormones. While the doctor may refer to them as “birth control” pills, that is not what they are actually being used for, and thus are a valid, acceptable, and moral treatment.

I would recommend a more natural treatment. Losing weight and exercising is also an accepted treatment, but as always, seek advice from a medical professional.
hormones don’t “treat” PCOS. they mask the symptoms and make it worse.
 
hormones don’t “treat” PCOS. they mask the symptoms and make it worse.
For some people, yes. For others, no. It depends on what the underlying cause of the problem is.

Personally, I believe in natural healing, and take no drugs, and encourage others to do the same. The general treatment should start with healthy eating, exercise, and weight loss, plus whatever guidance the osteopath/nutritionist/etc. recommends.

I’m just answering the question regarding “birth control” pills. The are not being used as artificial birth control in this case, but as medicine, thus their use is considered licit.
 
I have PCOS and my OB is one of the ones listed from the poster who linked to the St. Louis Review. After my marriage, when I began focusing on my cycles more closely, I noticed some major irregularities with long cycles and frequent spotting. I was treated with progesterone during the second part of my cycle, which helped regulate some problems. I was able to conceive twice and carried to term both times with progesterone support.

I know my situation isn’t the same as everyone else’s. I was fortunate to have normal blood sugars and not require Metformin. Some cases are much more severe, and can require additional procedures and medication. There were times I wanted to go on birth control, just to get some normalcy in that part of my life. I’m glad I stuck with my OB and the Creighton model. I don’t think I would have my sons without them.
 
I have PCOS and my OB is one of the ones listed from the poster who linked to the St. Louis Review. After my marriage, when I began focusing on my cycles more closely, I noticed some major irregularities with long cycles and frequent spotting. I was treated with progesterone during the second part of my cycle, which helped regulate some problems. I was able to conceive twice and carried to term both times with progesterone support.

I know my situation isn’t the same as everyone else’s. I was fortunate to have normal blood sugars and not require Metformin. Some cases are much more severe, and can require additional procedures and medication. There were times I wanted to go on birth control, just to get some normalcy in that part of my life. I’m glad I stuck with my OB and the Creighton model. I don’t think I would have my sons without them.
Dr G, Dr D, or Dr. B?
 
Code:
As a medical professional I develop a twitch when reading what people write on here and pass off as being “educated”.
We’ll twitch away. I cant tell you how many stories I hear of so called “educated” doctors that actually aren’t educated at all on the workings of napro, or who think nfp doesn’t work.
 
You can drop the snark.

Creighton Napro teaching is medical training.
Yes it is but it does not make you a medical professional.
-reading the insert of the “hormones”

-Beginning training to teach Creighton/NAPRO method

-and repeated from many Napro doctors.
And the fact that you are in the beginning of the training means that you are not, as yet, even a trained napro tech or teacher. 🤷

Simply because you don’t agree with doctors that give hormones to treat PCOS, doesn’t mean that it isn’t a viable treatment. And it doesn’t mean that they don’t know anything about NFP. 🤷

True they may not know about Napro, but they don’t need to know that to treat PCOS.
 
True they may not know about Napro, but they don’t need to know that to treat PCOS.
I didn’t say they did— you missed my whole point.

I was saying MANY doctors say “Oh, NFP— that doesn’t work”. Yet, according to the Pp, they are “educated” and by that very fact I am discredited and they aren’t.

That isn’t logical.

Those so called “educated” people change the definitions of words like “pregnancy” in medical journals. Those so called “educated” people say that birth control pills don’t cause abortions.

Don’t trust me, Fine. Go to www.omsoul.com and consult with the hundreds of doctors over there and they will repeat what I said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top