Catholic practices that have no biblical basis

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pai_Nosso
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was referring to dogmas that in the words of articles on this website have “no direct or categorical and stringent proof of the dogma can be brought forward from Scripture”.
Biblical proof isn’t required to form new dogmas according to the church
 
Sometimes, The Bible just doesn’t give teachings on some issues.
 
Sometimes, The Bible just doesn’t give teachings on some issues.
That’s true. The bible was not intended to be either a catechism or an exhaustive elucidation of doctrine or moral theology. That’s why Jesus established his Church.
 
I am late to this thread and confess to not having read it all. But has anyone pointed out to the OP that the Bible has no Biblical basis?
“Bible” has no “biblical” basis…

Lots of truisms exist outside the Bible.

_
 
40.png
Taras_Bulba:
It’s a well known trope that the preacher’s kids are rebellious jerks with daddy issues.
That is not always true. I knew a girl in college who was the daughter of an Orthodox priest. And she was a very decent and wonderful person. Quite beautiful too. I don’t like people mouthing off on things they don’t know anything about.
So harsh! A trope is a trope, and doesn’t claim to be an always literal truism! We had a young lady such as you describe on our campus, but I don’t recall her name. Don’t you think it’s possible that the general conclusions might be subjective, therefore, true within the experiences of the writer, as @Taras_Bulba expressed?

For example, when I attended a Big Ten college in the 50s, PKs (Preachers’ Kids), both guys and gals, were notorious for being among the wildest on campus. Back then, they flouted most of the written and unwritten rules, and their clothing, speech, hair styles, makeup, and behavior were often a bit radical, or dramatic, compared to your average Joe or Jane College, sometimes to the point of being embarrassing to onlookers.

Residence buildings for female students were locked at 11:00 PM on Sundays, 10:30 PM on Mondays through Thursdays, and at 1:00 AM on Fridays and Sundays. There were at least 6 daughters of preachers in my freshman dormitory who frequently stayed out all night (risking expulsion), came in drunk (risking expulsion), and sneaked booze into the dormitory (risking expulsion); two of them had to quit school because of pregnancy without marriage.

There were, of course, good kids from preachers’ families, as well, but the hell-raisers are the ones whose names I recall 60 years later. Generally, the tighter the reigns had been back home, the wilder the kids. Sooooooo, in my college years, the rest of us were well aware of of the trope to which Taras referred.

In my opinion, neither Taras, nor I, are mouthing off, but are referring to a trend that often occurs when kids from strict families are allowed to be on their own, with very little adult supervision.
 
Last edited:
Heck one preachers son in the Lutheran church I went to as a kid wound up snorting cocaine and shooting up a day care center in the middle of the night.
Not only were others in the day care center wounded or traumatized, but so were his family members, because of his actions. How very tragic! I realize that it’s long after the incident occurred, but I’ve offered prayers for the employees and families who were involved with the daycare, and the shooter and his family. Thank you for telling us, @StudentMI.

Over the years, I’ve noticed two parenting extremes, in addition to middle-of-the-road parents: 1) terribly strict (and maybe dictatorial) parents either come from similar homes or were hell-raisers when they were young and know first-hand about the possible pitfalls that can snag their kids, or 2) easy-going parents who were good kids and THINK their kids will be the same. Those are generalities, of course, but both categories seem to have a lot of heartache.
 
Thank you for offering prayers. There was a child in the house next to the day care center. He was in bed and a bullet just missed his head. Such a sad case. The preacher, who anointed me when I was sick as a kid, later moved to be near the prison where his son was held.
 
Good summary of the biblical account of the Eucharist.

From Jesus Himself: THIS IS My body
THIS IS My blood
DO THIS in memory of me …

solves the mystery of HOW we are to eat His flesh and drink His blood as He affirms must be done for us to have life in us (John Ch. 6).

Nowhere is Jesus Himself more firm and repetitive, accented by Amen Amens, or Truly, truly I tell you’s than IN John 6. Where many in the throngs following Him stopped believing and walked away.

If you “believe in (the truth of) scripture” …

… test whether you believe in THE scriptures emphasized most firmly BY Jesus (He who is the way, the truth and the life).

Praying TO saints? They are part of the body of Christ. Any powers they have are not apart from Christ … even if He has delegated such to them and allows them to do their duties.

They will do the works I do and greater things … Jesus tells us.

Indulgences? Power of the keys included what the Church binded or loosed on Earth was so in heaven. But a post death place of judgement and punishment that did NOT end with eternal punishment but being “saved as through fire” or being released after “the utmost farthing was paid” are also in the Bible even if the word Purgatory isn’t (quite, though purge … is).

The Bible isn’t a law book that binds God nor disallows His delegation of powers to His Church.

And neither did the empowered Church, as it ruled upon the Canon of the Bible, divest itself of its earthly rule and leave a self-interpreting Bible as its new vicar of God, answering only to the whims or feelings its reader of the moment to establish ultimate truth, law < or freedom FROM them as they might seem fit.

Let’s 🙏 and seek Him.

😇 that we may be one, as He prayed for us to be.
 
Catholics believe God gave us a Church, not only scripture. While we strongly rely upon the Bible as our foundational written source, we also rely on history, tradition and interpretation passed down from Jesus to the apostles in an unbroken line through today’s priesthood. The Bible as we know it did not even exist at the time Jesus walked among us and most history of the day was oral.
 
foundational written source, we also rely on history, tradition and interpretation passed down from Jesus to the apostles in an unbroken line through today’s priesthood. The Bible as we know it did not even exist at the time Jesus walked among us and most history of the day was oral.
Yes… In the Chronology of God’s Revelation to Man, the Bible is a relative NewComer…

The Bible? Is the Word of God … It is not All of God…

God? Is in Heaven, In all Creation and in the Hearts of His Followers…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top