K
KyivAndrew
Guest
No, imho, with respect to the Cold War, I believe you are wrong. As someone who had family “enslaved” so to speak in the Soviet Union, the argument that the Soviet Union would have ultimately collapsed (a view shared by that dove Strobe Talbott) is a straw man. I am not sure if you are familiar with the works of Jean-Francois Revel, but he once coined the phrase that while the Soviet Union may be a corpse, it was a corpse that was more than willing to take the entire world down with it into the grave. Lenin himself promised that should the socialist experiment fail, the communists would close the door on the entire world.No, I do not believe the Cold War was necessary, and I feel that it has in fact damaged our pursuit of liberty and cultural growth, since it emphasized a backward-looking jingoism and authoritarian attitude which persists today. As William F. Buckley stated “We should accept a totalitarian beuracracy within our shores,” in order to win the Cold war. This attitude was and is tragically common, and we have unfortunately become beholden to the idea that America must not be America in order to win. We should see that this is a self-defeating attitude and we shall instead become the very enemy we despise.
I accept the analysis of Mises and Rothbard regarding the Cold War, that the Soviet system, being an economic basketcase and inherently weak and unworkable, would have inevitably failed. It is only because we fueled its flames, with our foreign aid directly, and through the UN indirectly, as well as through our foreign policy, that we kept the Soviet Union alive long past its due date and it expired long after the foundation of its system had started to fade.
Harvard historian Richard Pipes always stressed that the Soviet Union intrinsically sought world hegemony, powered by its belief in Marxist teleology and Russian imperialism. The fact was that in the years between the two World Wars, the U.S. did not seek any entanglement with the Soviet Union. It was only after the Second World War, when Stalin’s brutality (millions upon millions of deaths in the Gulag and the Ukrainian Famine), that the U.S. realized that the Soviet Union posed an existential threat to the U.S. and to the world. Recall the Soviet Union was an atheist state which believed in NO morality other than that which would advance its cause, no matter what the human cost.
With the attainment of nuclear weaponry, the Soviet Strategic Rocket Forces’ Command actually planned meticulously for a first-strike capability against the U.S. to take America out before an advance on Western Europe (the writings of Red Marshalls Sokolovskii and Grechko bear this out). I cannot stress enough that the Soviet Union was an existential threat to the U.S., to the U.K. (which you praised), and to the entire free world. The economic basketcase argument does not hold well, when in reading the memoirs of such Red luminaries as Marshall Ogarkov from the 1980s, one realizes that Gorbachev and the Red elite collapsed under the weight of attempting to keep up with Ronald Reagan’s SDI program, an external factor that caused its collapse. Without Reagan, the Soviet bear could have gone on threatening the world for at least two generations more with its military, perhaps to fatal effect, no matter the economic inefficiencies, a fact attested to by many Soviets themselves. Pope JP2 and Reagan were absolutely right on the nature of the Cold War, and I stand with them on this one.
The Soviet Union was truly an “evil empire” and the nemesis of all free peoples in the last century and could have easily have won the Cold War had the U.S. never entered the fray as you suggest. I am quite certain that the U.S. chose the right course and did God’s work in putting an end to that evil monstrosity and freeing hundreds of millions of Christians and others from the Red yoke.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0dd6/a0dd67a17ec8b6e6bcb45d7047f3d9bfe87084bb" alt="Slightly smiling face :slight_smile: 🙂"